Negligence
Negligence
Norfolk Southern Railway Company v. Sorrell
Working for a railroad in the early Twentieth Century was a very dangerous occupation. Workers injured on the job faced numerous legal hurdles if they attempted to sue railroads for negligence. A Nineteenth-Century legal doctrine called assumption of risk held that workers who knowingly went to work in a dangerous industry could not sue their employers for damages. Even if a court of law ignored the assumption of risk doctrine a worker could lose if the employer proved that the worker contributed to the negligent action. It did not matter if the employee was only 5 percent negligent because such a finding barred the worker from recovering any damages. Public concern over number and severity of railroad employee uncompensated injuries led Congress in 1908 to enact the Federal Employers' Liability Act (FELA), 45 U.S.C.A. §§51-60. FELA established a compensation scheme for railroad workplace injuries and pre-empted state tort remedies. The common-law assumption of risk doctrine was abolished and contributory negligence was replaced with comparative negli-gence. Workers who were negligent would have the damages award reduced by the proportion of their fault. FELA provisions have been litigated for almost one hundred years and the Supreme Court issued another FELA ruling in Norfolk Southern Railway Company v. Sorrell, ___U.S.___, 127 S.Ct. 799, 166 L.Ed.2d 638 (2007), holding that the state of Missouri had improperly provided a more lenient causation standard for railroad negligence than for employee comparative negligence. The Court ruled that the FELA causation standard must be the same for both categories of negligence.
Timothy Sorrell injured his back and neck while working as a trackman for the Norfolk Southern Railway Company. In 1999 Sorrell was working for Norfolk in Indiana, driving a dump truck filled with asphalt to be used to repair railroad crossings. While driving on a gravel road between crossings another Norfolk dump truck approached Sorrell's truck. Sorrell and the driver of the other truck gave different accounts of what happened next but Sorrell's truck veered off the road and tipped on it side. Sorrell testified that the other driver forced him off the road, while the other driver said Sorrell drove his truck into the ditch.
In 2002 Sorrell filed suit in Missouri state court under FELA, which makes railroads liable to their employees for injuries "resulting in whole or part from the negligence" of the railroad. Sorrell alleged that Norfolk had failed to provide him with a reasonably safe place to work and that its negligence caused his injuries. Norfolk countered by claiming Sorrell's own negligence caused his injuries. When the time came for the judge to issue jury instructions a legal controversy arose. Under Missouri law a jury was to apply two different standards of causation to railroad and employee contributory negligence. The instructions directed the jury to find an employee contributory negligent if the employee was negligent and his negligence "directly contributed to cause" the injury. The jury was also instructed to find the railroad negligent if the railroad was negligent and its negligence contributed "in whole or in part" to the injury. Norfolk objected to these instructions, arguing that the same causation standard should be applied to employee and employer, for the standard applied to the railroad was a "much more exacting" standard. The judge overruled the objection and Sorrell recovered $1.5 million in damages. Norfolk appealed but the Missouri Court of Appeals affirmed the dual causation standards. After the Missouri Supreme Court rejected Norfolk's petition to appeal Norfolk petitioned the U.S. Supreme Court. Norfolk argued that Missouri was the only jurisdiction to apply different standards. The Supreme Court granted review.
The Supreme Court, in a unanimous decision, overturned the Missouri appeals court decision. Chief Justice John Roberts, writing for the Court (four justices joined in concurring opinions), rejected Norfolk's attempt to broaden the question before the Court to include what the standard of causation under FELA should be. Norfolk not only sought to enlarge the question but it took a position that was contrary to the position it took in the Missouri courts. In the lower courts Norfolk urged that the less rigorous negligence standard applied to railroads be applied to employee negligence. Before the U.S. Supreme Court Norfolk urged the Court to apply the more rigorous contributory negligence standard to the railroad's negligence as well. Chief Roberts concluded that "we should stick to the question on which certiorari was sought and granted," for the Court is reluctant to let parties "smuggle additional questions into the case."
Turning to the issue of dual standards of negligence, Chief Justice Roberts agreed with Norfolk that Missouri was the only jurisdiction to apply differing causation standards in a FELA action. Though it was possible that "everyone is out of step except Missouri," Roberts found that Congress did not intend to allow disparate causation standards. Common-law principles that have not been expressly rejected under FELA are given "great weight" by the Court in analyzing issues. In this case the common law applied the same causation to defendant and plaintiff negligence and FELA "did not expressly depart from this approach." Roberts thought that allowing more than one standard of causation would have been a "peculiar approach for Congress to take in FELA." Moreover, as a practical matter it would be difficult to reduce damages "in proportion" to the employee's negligence if "the relevance of each party's negligence to the injury is measured by a different standard of causation." It would be simpler for the jury to apportion negligence if "the jury compares like with like-apples to apples." Other courts supported this position, leading the Supreme Court to reject Missouri's "idiosyncratic approach" that "unduly muddies what may, to a jury, be already murky waters."
