Negligence

views updated

NEGLIGENCE

Conduct that falls below the standards of behavior established by law for the protection of others against unreasonable risk of harm. A person has acted negligently if he or she has departed from the conduct expected of a reasonably prudent person acting under similar circumstance.

Ford Held Liable in Explorer Rollover Case

In June 2004, a jury ordered the Ford Motor Company to pay a California woman $369 million dollars in damages that she had sustained in a roll-over accident in her Ford Explorer. The verdict, one of the largest-ever awards of its kind, came from a San Diego County jury. The trial judge later reduced the amount of the award to $150 million.

This was the first loss for Ford after winning more than a dozen Explorer rollover cases. The company has settled many other such cases. Ford, the country's second largest automaker, has sold more than five million Explorers since 1990. The Explorer is the best-selling sport utility vehicle (SUV) in the United States.

The plaintiff, Benetta Buell-Wilson, was injured in an accident in January 2002 on the interstate near San Diego. She testified that a metal part flew off an RV in front of her, bounced on the road, and headed toward her windshield. When she swerved to avoid it, she lost control of her 1997 Explorer. The vehicle rolled 4 times and left Buell-Wilson hanging from the roof of her car, suspended by her seat belt. Rescuers initially had difficulty extracting Buell-Wilson from the vehicle. The accident left the 49-year-old paralyzed from the waist down.

In the lawsuit, Buell-Wilson contended that design defects on Explorers manufactured through 2001 made the vehicle unstable. She alleged that Ford had not followed recommendations from its engineers to widen the vehicle's wheel track or to lower its center of gravity, to make it less likely to roll over. Buell-Wilson also claimed that Ford had not sufficiently reinforced the vehicle's roof, leaving passengers more vulnerable in a rollover. She claimed that cost concerns had driven the automaker's decisions to refuse to make the design changes. Moreover, she alleged that weak support pillars were likely to collapse in rollover situations, which led to her instant paralysis when the roof buckled and broke her back. She testified at trial that the roof "crumpled like paper."

Her attorneys introduced internal Ford documents and testimony from former employees. This evidence demonstrated that Ford had repeatedly ignored engineering recommendations to change the design. Buell-Wilson's attorneys contended that Ford had known for more than 20 years about the rollover risks with SUVs.

At the trial, Ford asked to present evidence comparing the Explorer to other SUVs. The trial judge did not allow it.

The case went to trial in mid March 2004 and concluded with the jury decision in early June. The jury awarded more than $122.6 million in compensatory damages and $246 million in punitive damages . The verdict broke a string of victories in Ford's favor on Explorer rollover lawsuits.

At one point, Buell-Wilson's attorneys told Ford that they would be willing to settle the case for $5 million. Ford rejected the settlement offer. While the jury was deliberating, Ford reportedly offered to settle the lawsuit for the same amount but withdrew the offer before Buell-Wilson could respond.

The jury deliberated for four days before reaching its decision with regard to compensatory damages. It found that Ford had acted with malice , oppression , or fraud . That determination allowed the jury to consider punitive damages. Deliberation on the punitive damages issue lasted about one day.

The jury decision was 9 to 3. The jury was not required to reach a unanimous verdict.

After the verdict, Buell-Wilson offered to reduce the damage award by $100 million if Ford would agree to fix the design problems by recalling Explorers through 2001. Ford declined. The company continued to contend that the design was safe. Ford redesigned the Explorer in 2002.

In August 2004, the trial judge in the case upheld the jury's verdict but reduced the damages award. Judge Kevin A. Enright ruled that Ford had acted with "malice" and "conscious disregard" for drivers' safety. He ruled that punitive damages were appropriate because the company had known that the defects were potentially fatal, yet it had disregarded that information. However, he found that both the compensatory and punitive damages were excessive. He also determined that the jury had not acted with "prejudice or passion" in reaching its decision. He reduced the compensatory damages to $70 million for Buell-Wilson. He also reduced the compensatory damages from $13 million to $5 million for Buell-Wilson's husband, Barry Wilson. He further reduced the punitive damages to $75 million.

Judge Enright gave the Buell-Wilson a choice when he ordered the reduction of damages. She could accept the reduction, or he would grant Ford's motion for a new trial on the grounds of excessive damages. Ford filed a notice of appeal on September 15, 2004.

More From encyclopedia.com