Negligence

views updated

41. Negligence

Contributory Negligence

Comparative Fault

Contribution Among Tortfeasors

The State of the Law

Negligence is an actionable tort. This means that if one person’s carelessness causes another personal injury, the injured party may sue to recover damages (money) for his or her injuries. The idea that a person can sue for negligence is a relatively new phenomenon, only about a century old.

The reason for negligence’s late recognition is because common law traditionally recognized only intentional torts; that is, it held parties responsible for injuries that were the result of intentional acts. It was irrelevant that the actor did not intend to injure anyone, much less the injured party, but it only needed to be shown that the actor intended the action that caused the injury. In these cases, evidence of who caused what injury was affirmative, direct, and fairly objective.

The concept of permitting someone to recover damages for injuries caused by someone’s lack of action or failure to do something was a revolutionary concept. Since its recognition as an action in tort, negligence has become a major source of very large jury awards. It is the root of all product liability cases. When people complain about our legal system and the outrageous verdicts being awarded nowadays, they are speaking about negligence.

Originally, negligence was recognized by the courts as part of the common law. Over time, as causes of action became more numerous and as damages became larger, various efforts were undertaken to limit the appeal of negligence lawsuits.

Contributory Negligence

When contributory negligence first appeared in the repertoire of personal injury lawyers, the standards of proof needed to succeed were quite high and very severe. Originally, under the doctrine of contributory negligence if it were shown that the plaintiff contributed in any way to his injuries, he was barred from any recovery. This has been modified over time to permit the plaintiff to recover even if he contributed to his injuries, as long as his fault is under 50 percent. In these cases, recovery is relative to fault. For instance, if a jury finds a party’s injuries worth $100,000 and holds that the party was 25 percent at fault, the party’s recovery would be $75,000. On the other hand, if the jury found the party 60 percent at fault, the party would be barred from any recovery.

Comparative Fault

The doctrine of contributory negligence eventually evolved, in some states, into a system of comparative fault that permitted recovery on a completely relative scale. Thus, in an accident one could be 90 percent at fault for one’s own personal injury and still sue to recover the 10 percent of the damages suffered that were caused by the other party.

Contribution Among Tortfeasors

In the doctrine of joint and several liability among tortfeasors, when there are multiple tortfeasors (“guilty” parties), all parties are equally liable for the damages caused to the injured party. This doctrine is quite harsh. For example, if the driver of a truck hits a pedestrian at night and the jury holds that the city is 15 percent responsible because it did not properly maintain the lighting at that portion of the road and the truck driver, who is 85 percent at fault, is uninsured, unemployed, and without assets, the city can be made to pay 100 percent of the damages. Under the doctrine of contribution, one tortfeasor may sue a fellow tortfeasor to recover any damages paid in excess of the proportion of fault. In most comparative fault states liability is the proportionate responsibility of each party.

The State of the Law

As can be seen by looking at the table of negligence laws, there is great diversity among the states as to how negligence is handled. As the law of negligence continues to mature and change, courts have led the way in defining the laws and legislatures have in may cases responded with statutes that both recognize the cause of action and often limit it as well.

There have been many attempts over the years to have Congress or state legislatures pass laws that would specifically limit the amount of recovery available to plaintiffs in negligence actions. So far, none has met with much success. Under the general term “tort reform,” such acts promise to be proposed in the future.

Table 41: Negligence
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
ALABAMANoneNo Plaintiff’s negligence is a bar to recovery. Contributory negligence is an affirmative defense. (ARCP, Rule 8(c)) Jackson v. Waller, 410 So.2d 98 (1982); Williams v. Delta Int’l Machinery Corp., 619 So.2d 1330 (Ala.1993)NoNo. Gobble v. Bradford, 147 So. 619 (1933); But yes if executed instrument with joint payees or indorsers, §7-3-116
ALASKA23.25.010 (Employer’s liability for negligence)NoYes, §09.17.060 Contributory fault diminishes proportionately the award based on claimant’s fault, but does not bar recovery (“Pure” comparative negligence) Kaatz v.Alaska, 540 P.2d 1037 (1975); “Pure” form adopted and codified hereinYes; §09.17.080(d)
ARIZONA12-2505Yes; §12-2501, et seq.No right to comparative negligence if claimant intentionally, wilfully or wantonly caused/contributed to injury or wrongful death §12-2505(A)  Yes; §12-2501, et seq.
ARKANSAS16-64-122Yes; 16-61-201 to 212 If Plaintiff’s fault is of less degree than defendant’s, he may recover amount diminished in proportion to degree of his own fault; if plaintiff’s fault is equal to or greater than defendant, he may not recover at all (§16-64-122) Yes; §§16-61-201 to 212
CALIFORNIACiv. §1714No“Pure” form adopted by Li v. Yellow Cab Co., 532 P.2d 1226 (1975). Li v. Yellow Cab Co., 532 P.2d 1226 (1975).Yes; (Civ.§1431.2) liability of each defendant per non-economic damages shall be several only and not joint.
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
COLORADO13-21-111Yes. §§13-50.5-101 to 13.50.5-106 Contributory negligence does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence is not greater than defendant’s. But any damages allowed is diminished in proportion to claimant’s attributed negligence (13-21-111) Yes; §§13-50.5-101 to 13.50.5-106
CONNECTICUT52-572h  Comparative negligence does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence is not greater than combined negligence of defendant(s). However, damages are diminished in proportion to attributed negligence (§52-572h) Yes; §52-572e; also §52-572h. Must be brought within one year
DELAWARETit. 10 §8132Yes; Tit. 10 §§6301 to 6308 Claimant’s contributory negligence does not bar recovery if such negligence is not greater than the defendant(s) negligence. But any awarded are diminished in proportion to claimant’s attributed negligence (Tit. 10 §8132) Yes; Tit. 10 §§6301 to 6308
DISTRICT OF COLUMBIANone  Plaintiff’s negligence is a bar to recovery except the liability of common carriers for injuries to employees, when plaintiff’s negligence is slight and employer’s is gross. See §35-302 No
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
FLORIDA768.81Yes; §768.31Any contributory fault chargeable to claimant diminishes proportionately the amount awarded as economic or uneconomic damages; §768.81 Hoffman v. Jones, 280 So. 2d 431 (1973)Yes; §768.31
GEORGIA51-11-7No Claimant’s contributory does not bar recovery provided his fault is less than defendant’s and that by ordinary care claimant could not have avoided the consequences of defendant’s negligence. However claimant’s damages are diminished by amount in proportion to the amount of his fault. (§51-11-7) Yes; §51-12-32
HAWAII663-31Yes; §§663-11 to 663-17 Contributory negligence or comparative responsibility does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence or comparative responsibility is not as great as defendants, but any damages are diminished in proportion to the negligence or comparative responsibility attributable to claimant (§663-31) Yes; §§663-11 to 663-17
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
IDAHO6-801No Contributory negligence or comparative responsibility does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence or comparative responsibility is not as great as defendants, but any damages are diminished in proportion to the negligence or comparative responsibility attributable to claimant (§6-801) Yes; §6-803.
ILLINOIS735 ILCS 5/2-1116No Over 50% recovery barred; under 50% damages diminished in proportion to plaintiff’s percentage of fault Yes; 740 ILCS 100/0.01, et seq.
INDIANA34-51-2-5, et seq.No Recovery barred if contributory negligence was greater than defendant’s negligence, otherwise reduces recovery proportionately  
IOWA668.3; 668.5No Contributory fault does not bar recovery unless claimant’s fault is greater than defendant’s, but any damages diminished in proportion to attributable fault.Goetzman v. Wichern, 327 N.W. 2d 742 (1982)Yes, §668.5
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
KANSAS60-258aNo Contributory negligence not a bar to recovery if claimant’s negligence is less than causal negligence of defendants, but damages diminished in proportion to the amount of attributable negligence. (§60-258a)  
KENTUCKY411.182NoFailure to put child in safety restraint is statutorily not contributory negligence (§189.125). Percentage of fault of claimant is used to offset recovery by equal measure; “pure comparative negligence”Employee not guilty of contributory negligence where violation by carrier of state/federal safety statute contributed to injury or death. In the case were no safety statute has been violated, contributory negligence is not a bar to recovery, but damages diminished in proportion to the amount of attributable negligence. (277.320) Yes; §412.030
LOUISIANACiv. Code Art 2323NoPercentage of fault of all persons contributing is determined. If person who suffers as a result partly of his own negligence, the amount of damages reduced in proportion to% of attributable negligence.  No
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
MAINETit. 14 §156No. Claim in respect of death or damage not defeated by reason of fault the person suffering the damage, but damages reduced to extent jury thinks just and equitable. If plaintiff’s fault is 50% or more, recovery is barred. No
MARYLANDNone Not using seatbelt is not contributory negligence (Transp. §§22-412.3 & 4)  Yes; C & JP §3-1401
MASSACHUSETTSCh. 231 §85Ch. 231B §§1-4 Contributory negligence does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence is not greater than defendant’s. But any damages allowed is diminished in proportion to claimant’s attributed negligence Ch. 231B §§1-4
MICHIGAN600.2958, 600.2959 For economic damages, award is reduced proportionately to plaintiff’s negligence even if greater than 50%. For non-economic damages, negligence greater than 50% bars any recovery. (§600.2959)  Yes; 600.2925c
MINNESOTA604.01, et seq.  Plaintiff’s negligence reduces recovery proportionately, but if greater than 50%, recovery is barred No
MISSISSIPPI11-7-15NoContributory negligence no bar to recovery, but damages diminished in proportion to the amount of attributable negligence.  No.
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
MISSOURINone In products liability cases, comparative fault is an affirmative defense. Fault shall diminish damages proportionately but does not bar recovery (537.765)  Yes; §537.060
MONTANA27-1-702No Claimant’s negligence does not bar recovery if less than that of defendants. Damages diminished in proportion to the amount of negligence attributable. Yes; §27-1-703
NEBRASKA25-21, 185.07 to 185.12  Plaintiff’s award diminishes proportionally with negligence, but negligence equal to or greater than defendant’s is a total bar. (§25-21, 185.09) No; see §25-21, 185.10
NEVADA41.14117.225 to 17.305 When claimant’s negligence is greater than defendants, no recovery, otherwise proportionate to fault. Yes; §§17.225 to 17.305
NEW HAMPSHIRE507:7-dNo Contributory negligence does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence is not greater than defendant’s. But any damages allowed is diminished in proportion to claimant’s attributed negligence. Yes; §507.7-f
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
NEW JERSEY2A:15-5.1, et seq.  Contributory negligence cannot be greater than the negligence of defendants. Damages diminished by the percentage sustained of negligence attributable to claimant. Yes; 2A:15-5.3
NEW MEXICONone41-3-1 to 41-3-8“Pure” comparative negligence Scott v. Rizzo, 634 P.2d 1234 (1981)Yes; §§41-3-1 to 41-3-8
NEW YORKCiv. Prac. L. & R. §§1411, et seq. Contributory negligence does not bar recovery but damages are diminished in proportion to the attributable conduct.  Yes; Civ. Prac. L. & R. §§1401 et seq.
NORTH CAROLINANone§1B-1 to 1B-6 Not specified Yes; §§1B-1 to 1B-6
NORTH DAKOTANone32-38-01 to 04 Plaintiff’s negligence diminishes recovery in proportion to fault, but if greater then 50%, recovery is completely barred. Yes; §§32-38-01 to 04
OHIO2315.192307.31, 2307.33 Contributory negligence not a bar recovery if negligence was not greater than combined negligence of persons claimant seeks recovery and all other persons claimant does not seek recovery. Damages diminished in proportion to claimant’s fault. Yes; §§2307.31, 33
OKLAHOMATit. 23 §13-14Tit. 12 §832 Contributory negligence cannot be greater than negligence of defendants. Damages reduced in proportion to such person’s contributory negligence. Yes; Tit. 12 §832
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
OREGON31.600, 31.605No Contributory negligence not a bar if fault attributable claimant is less than combined fault of defendants. Yes; 31.800
PENNSYLVANIATit. 42 §7102Tit. 42 §§8321-8327 Contributory negligence does not bar recovery if claimant’s negligence is not greater than defendant’s. But any damages allowed is diminished in proportion to claimant’s attributed negligence. Yes; Tit. 42 §§8321-8327
RHODE ISLAND9-20-4§§10-6-1 to 11The fact that the claimant was not in the exercise of due care shall not bar recovery, but damages diminished in proportion to the amount of attributable negligence.  Yes; §§10-6-1 to 11
SOUTH CAROLINANone§§15-38-10 to 70Exists only for motor vehicle accidents (§15-1-300)Not specified. Yes; §§15-38-10 to 70
SOUTH DAKOTA20-9-215-8-11, et seq. Plaintiff’s negligence diminishes recovery proportionately, but if more than “slight,” recovery is completely barred (§20-9-2) Yes; §§15-8-11 to 22
TENNESSEENone29-11-101, et seq.Comparative negligence in reference to reviewing bank statements of accts. 47-4-406.See comparative negligence. Yes; §§29-11-101 to 106
TEXASCiv. Prac. & Rem. §33.001No Plaintiff’s negligence not greater than defendant’s; award diminished in proportion to negligence (Civ. Prac. & Rem.§33.001) Yes; Civ. Prac. & Rem. §33.012
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
UTAH78-27-37, et. seq.No If exceeds 50%, no recovery; otherwise diminished proportionately No; §78-27-40
VERMONTTit. 12 §1036  Contributory negligence not a bar if negligence was not greater that causal total negligence but damages diminished in proportion to the amount of attributable negligence. No
VIRGINIA8.01-58 (Contribu-tory negligence is no bar to recovery in certain employee-railroad disputes.)NoIn an action against a common carrier, comparative negligence will not bar recovery and if carrier violated a safety code, the injured party won’t be found comparatively negligent (8.01-58)  8.01-34; Contributory negligence may be applied when the wrong results from negligence and involves no moral turpitude
WASHINGTON4.22.005 to 925Yes; 4.22.005 to 925Contributory fault diminishes proportionately the amount of damages, but does not bar recovery.  Yes; §4.22.040
WEST VIRGINIANoneNoComparative negligence is reference to discovering and reporting unauthorized signature or alteration-bank statements (§46-4-406). Otherwise not specified.Not specified.Bradley v.Appalachian Power Co., 256 S.E.2d 879 (1979), at 885.Yes; §55-7-13
WISCONSIN895.045No Contributory negligence is not a bar if claimant’s negligence is not greater than defendants. Damages diminished in proportion to claimant’ attributable negligence. Yes; common law right based on equitable principles (State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. v.Continental Cas. Co., 59 N.W. 2d 425)
StateCode SectionUniform ActComparative NegligenceContributory Negligence—Limit to Plaintiff’s RecoveryJudicial Imposition ofComparative NegligenceContribution Among Tortfeasors
WYOMING1-1-109No Contributory fault shall not bar recovery if fault is not more than 50% of the total fault of all actors. Damages diminished in proportion to the amount of fault attributable to claimant. No

More From encyclopedia.com