Compromise of 1850
Compromise of 1850
Wilmot Proviso. The crisis over the status of slavery in the territory acquired from Mexico grew out of the struggle for partisan advantage. A breach in the Democratic Party opened when James K. Polk defeated former president Martin Van Buren for the presidential nomination in 1844, and the split deepened over the next two years. When Polk guided the United States into a war with Mexico, planning to annex territory extending to the Pacific Ocean, the Van Burenites moved to exact their revenge. Representative David Wilmot of Pennsylvania proposed to add a clause, or proviso, to military appropriations for the war stipulating that slavery would not be permitted in any territory obtained from Mexico. Wilmot’s proposal imitated restrictions by which slavery had been barred from the Northwest Territory in 1787 and from the Louisiana Purchase Territory north of the 36° 30’ latitude in the Missouri Compromise of 1820. Congressional response to the Wilmot Proviso confirmed the Van Burenites’ calculations that the gambit would be received enthusiastically by Democrats and Whigs in the North. Bipartisan support enabled the proviso to pass in the House of Representatives, where the more populous Northern states enjoyed a commanding majority, but it was stymied in the Senate, where free and slave states were evenly divided.
Alternative Proposals. As the Mexican War ended with the cession of more than six hundred thousand square miles of land to the United States, Democratic and Whig leaders adjusted to the polarizing impact of the Wilmot Proviso by developing strategies for the 1848 presidential campaign that promised to restore the intersectional alliances on which the parties were based. The Democrats, led by Sen. Lewis Cass of Michigan, promoted a policy of “popular sovereignty” under which the residents in any territory would decide whether or not to permit slavery; this approach would effectively remove the issue of slavery in the federal territories from national politics and make the question a local matter. The Whigs nominated war hero Zachary Taylor, who remained non-committal about slavery in the territories but who appealed to both sections because he was a Louisiana slave owner with influential Northern advisers. Meanwhile, two other approaches to the question continued
to attack the intersectional pattern of politics. Martin Van Buren made the Wilmot Proviso the cornerstone of his campaign for the presidency on the Free Soil ticket. His strong showing divided Democratic voters and contributed to the victory of Taylor. Meanwhile, John C. Calhoun tried unsuccessfully to form a Southern coalition around the policy that slavery must be permitted throughout the federal territories. Perhaps more surprising was the collapse of the solution suggested by the Missouri Compromise, extension of the 36° 30’ line to the Pacific Ocean. The North’s rejection of this option
reflected an increasing tendency to treat the issue as a matter of principle that should not be compromised.
The Omnibus Bill. The situation in the Mexican cession assumed a new urgency when the California Gold Rush of 1849 produced a large population on the Pacific Coast that required the prompt organization of a government. Sen. Henry Clay of Kentucky, who had played a lead role in defusing the Missouri controversy during 1819–1821 and the Nullification controversy in 1833, took the legislative initiative by seeking to combine the settlement of the territorial problem with several other slavery issues. Clay proposed to admit California to the union as a free state, which was clearly the preference of the majority of inhabitants; to organize territorial governments for Utah and New Mexico without restrictions on slavery; to draw the Texas-New Mexico border in a way that made the slave state of Texas smaller than it might have been; to provide for the federal government to assume the debt contracted by Texas before annexation; to pass a new law governing the retrieval of fugitive slaves; to prohibit public slave auctions in the District of Columbia; and to forswear congressional interference with the legality of slavery in the District of Columbia or with the interstate slave trade. Because President Taylor favored the admission of California as a free state but opposed the provisions for the organization of New Mexico and Utah, Clay put the linked proposals together into one piece of legislation known as the “omnibus bill.”
The Great Debate. The congressional deliberations on the omnibus bill were among the most dramatic in American history. Clay, brandishing a fragment of George Washington’s coffin, led off by calling for each section to make concessions to preserve the Union. John C. Calhoun, who would be dead within a month, watched in enfeebled silence while a colleague read the South Carolinian’s speech opposing the compromise and calling for a restructuring of the federal government to protect Southern interests. Daniel Webster answered by supporting the compromise in his “Seventh of March address,” for which he was pilloried by his antislavery constituents in Massachusetts. The eloquent curtain calls of this triumvirate were matched by the rising generation. William Henry Seward of New York memorably appealed to a “higher law” than the Constitution to justify his opposition to a compromise that recognized slavery; Salmon P. Chase of Ohio took a similar position. Jefferson Davis of Mississippi in turn opposed the compromise on the ground that Congress had no authority to interfere with slavery.
Breakthrough. Although Clay had initially planned to present each proposal separately and had only adopted the omnibus strategy to counter the threat of a veto by Taylor, the compromise remained a single bill after the president died on 9 July 1850 of acute gastroenteritis caused by overindulgence in raw vegetables, cherries, and iced milk at Fourth of July ceremonies in Washington. The measure failed to pass in the omnibus format: most Northerners would not vote for the fugitive slave bill or for legislation that recognized the possibility of slavery in the territories, while most Southerners continued to oppose the admission of California as a free state and the reduction in the size of Texas. After the collapse of the omnibus, Clay left Washington for a vacation in Newport, Rhode Island, and Democrat Stephen A. Douglas of Illinois took charge of the measure. Douglas had already been working behind the scenes to cement intersectional harmony by sponsoring the first grant of federal land to promote railroad construction, for a line stretching from Chicago, Illinois, to Mobile, Alabama. The advance of other land grants similarly defused sectional tensions, and financier William Wilson Corcoran effectively promoted the compromise measures by interesting members of Congress in the Texas bonds that would stabilize in value once assumed by the United States government. When Douglas broke up the omnibus into a series of bills in September, all of Clay’s original proposals passed in a modified form. But different measures depended on the votes of different coalitions. Northerners from both parties and Whigs from the border states secured the admission of California, the abolition of the slave trade in Washington, and the adjustment of the Texas border. Southerners and Northern Democrats passed the Fugitive Slave Law and organized Utah and New Mexico without restrictions on slavery. The “compromise” had won no real concessions from either side, but supporters nonetheless hoped that it would achieve a final resolution of slavery disputes in national politics.
Northern Reactions . The limits of acquiescence in the compromise measures became apparent more immediately in the North. The Fugitive Slave Law had not been a primary focus of the congressional debates: the issue necessitating action had been the admission of California; the main collision of principle had been over the status of slavery in the territories; and the stickiest negotiating point had been the adjustment of the Texas border. But the new mechanisms for retrieving runaway slaves soon inflamed the North and sparked several highly publicized episodes of resistance. The Fugitive Slave Law also impelled Harriet Beecher Stowe to write one of the most politically important novels of American history, Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Published as a book in the spring of 1852 after appearing in installments in an antislavery newspaper, Stowe’s exploration of slavery and evangelical Christianity sold three hundred thousand copies within a year. By the end ofthat time, however, it seemed that the compromise might be taking hold. The federal government under Millard Fillmore had demonstrated its willingness to commit the resources necessary to subdue local resistance to the Fugitive Slave Law. Controversy also declined because the number of African Americans returned to the South fell by two-thirds in the second year under the law, in part because so many blacks had resettled in Canada. The Free Soil Party, which had received about 10 percent of the vote in the presidential election of 1848, received only about half as much in 1852.
Southern Reactions . The Southern response to the Compromise of 1850 was outwardly less volatile but in the end more dangerous to the Union than the Northern reactions. The immediate result of the compromise was to take the wind out of the sails of advocates of secession. The Nashville Convention, held in June 1850, which had agreed to meet after the compromise to decide policy, could muster only a handful of radicals in November 1850. Unionist candidates won the races for governor in Georgia and Mississippi, and supporters of the Compromise won fourteen of the nineteen congressional seats from Georgia, Mississippi, and Alabama. Even in South Carolina, by far the most aggressively disunionist state, voters overwhelmingly rejected an appeal for secession in a statewide referendum. Unionism in the lower South after the Compromise seemed stronger. Several states embraced the “Georgia Platform” of 1850, which threatened resistance and even secession if Congress enacted additional antislavery measures. Moreover, the Compromise left leading Whigs from the lower South estranged from their party. Northern Whigs like William Henry Seward had not only led the protest against permitting slavery in the Mexican cession but had seemed to control Whig president Zachary Taylor. Repairing the intersectional bonds of party politics would be crucial to cementing loyalty to the Union.
THE GEORGIA PLATFORM, 1850
To the end that the position of this State may be clearly apprehended by her Confederates of the South and of the North, and that she may be blameless of all future consequences—
Be it resolved by the people of Georgia in Convention assembled, First. That we hold the American Union secondary in importance only to the rights and principles it was designed to perpetuate. That past associations, present fruition, and future prospects, will bind us to it so long as it continues to the be the safe-guard of those rights and principles. . . .
Third. That in this spirit the State of Georgia as maturely considered the action of Congress . . . and whilst she does not wholly approve, will abide by it as a permanent adjustment of this sectional controversy.
Fourth. That the State of Georgia, in the judgment of this Convention, will and ought to resist, even (as a last resort) to a disruption of every tie which binds her to the Union, any future Act of Congress abolishing Slavery in the District of Columbia, without the consent and petition of the slaveholders thereof, or any Act abolishing Slavery in places within the slave-holding States, purchased by the United States for the erection of forts, magazines, arsenals, dock-yards, navy-yards, and other like purposes; or in any Act suppressing the slave-trade between slave-holding States; or in any refusal to admit as a State any Territory applying because of the existence of Slavery therein; or in any Act prohibiting the introduction of slaves into the Territories of Utah and New Mexico; or in any Act repealing or materially modifying the laws now in force for the recovery of fugitive slaves.
Fifth. That it is the deliberate opinion of this Convention, that upon the faithful execution of the Fugitive Slave Bill by the proper authorities, depends the preservation of our much loved Union.
Sources
William W. Freehling, The Road to Disunion (New York: Oxford University Press, 1990);
Holman Hamilton, Prologue to Conflict: The Crisis and Compromise of 1850 (Lexington: University of Kentucky Press, 1964).
