Brain
Brain
The literature on brain, gender, and sexuality is subject to an array of interpretations. For example, it is known that individuals can be born with the "external parts" of one sex despite the fact that their cells contain the chromosomal pattern of the other sex or that those "external parts" can present ambiguously at birth as a result of genetic disorders, hormonal aberrations, or trauma, creating a condition called intersexual. However, even though technology continues to provide information with increasing degrees of precision, these matters often are confused because of the common misuse of the terms sex and gender as synonyms. David Haig chronicled this confusion in the academic literature and concluded that the increased use of the term gender "appears to be the result of well-meaning attempts to signal sympathy with the ideas and goals of feminism. This has had the paradoxical outcome of undercutting and blurring the distinction which feminists sought to emphasize by distinguishing sex from gender" (Haig 2000, p. 373).
SEX AND GENDER
Although gender controversies probably are as old as the human species, they were not labeled as such until John Money's 1955 adoption of the word gender from linguistics and grammar, where it was used to classify nouns. Money's graduate work was with intersexuals, or hermaphrodites as they were referred to at that time. Before he changed the lexicon, the only word or concept available was sex, and that created a dilemma in dealing with intersexuals. An example of that difficulty would be provided by a phenotypic male with the outward appearance of a male, including many male secondary sexual characteristics, and the genotype of a female, with ambiguous genitalia and therefore with no functioning male sex organ. Such an individual would not have a male sexual role in the sense of completing the act of penetration (Money used a new term for that role: sexuoerotic). However, that person would be able to present in public performing a male sexual (sociosexual) role consisting of masculine or manly attitudes, behaviors, interests, and actions.
Sex thus is the more restrictive term, tied to biology, and represents one's identification as a male, female, or intersexual on the basis of one's external genitalia. Gender is one's identification as male/man/masculine or female/woman/feminine on the basis of somatic and behavioral criteria. Gender thus is the more inclusive term and can be used to address genital sex, erotic sex, chromosomal sex, and gonadal sex and the expression of those factors as they are presented to society.
THE NUMBER OF SEXES
Anne Fausto-Sterling (2000) proposed, partly to be provocative, the concept of five sexes. Although the concept has caught on more than the terminology has, that terminology can be helpful in understanding the group—intersexuals themselves—that appears to be promoting the term intersexual. The five sexes are male and female, with the addition of herms, formerly called true hermaphrodites, who are born with both a testis and an ovary; merms, formerly called male pseudohermaphrodites, who are born with testes and some form of female genitalia; and ferms, formerly called female pseudohermaphrodites, who are born with ovaries combined with some form of male genitalia. Fausto-Sterling revised her earlier estimation of the prevalence of intersexuality down from 4 percent to 1.7 percent, or seventeen in every 1,000 live births. She agrees with Suzanne J. Kessler (1998) that her paradigm of five sexes still gives primacy to genitalia when in fact gender is attributed to individuals in their everyday lives without knowledge of what is underneath their clothing and is performed by those individuals regardless of the idiosyncratic configuration of their genitalia.
SCIENTIFIC STUDIES
The attempt to understand brain, gender, and sexuality has resulted in an enormous literature primarily involved in studying the differences between male and female biology and behavior. In the search for anatomical differences, gross and microscopic anatomical postmortem studies have given way to computerized axial tomography (CAT), positron emission tomography (PET), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), including functional MRI (fMRI), which allows increased spatial and temporal resolution.
In adults the male brain weighs 11 to 12 percent more than the female brain, and the male head is about 2 percent bigger than the female head. However, MRI demonstrates that in the frontal and parietal lobes the female brain has more folds; it is more convoluted and thus has a larger surface area. Neural and synaptic density is a function of surface area, not volume, and so the female brain has greater cortical complexity.
No area of the male brain is more complex than the female brain. MRI studies of adolescent brains have shown different sizes and maturation rates, with larger volumes found in the male cerebellum, putamen, and globus pallidus and a larger caudate nucleus found in the female. The corpus callosum in very early studies was said to have a greater surface area in the male brain; however, a 1982 study reported thicker fibers in the corpus callosum in female brains. MRI studies have found no differences in this structure in male and female brains. In the hypothalamus the preoptic area (POA), which is known to be involved in mating behavior in animals, is twice the size in the male and has twice as many cells. Functional imaging has demonstrated some different patterns of use of the parts of the brain.
Some research in brain and nervous-system function has involved the structures involved with sexual reproduction. The technical term for the differences between the two genders in the service of sexual reproduction is sexual dimorphism. Sexually dimorphic structures have been found in all parts of the neuraxis. Two that have been studied extensively are the sexually dimorphic nucleus, the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus muscle (SNB), and the sexually dimorphic nucleus of the preoptic area (SDN-POA). The peripheral SNB clearly influences sexual behavior. The SDN-POA has confused investigators because although the destruction of the entire POA impairs reproductive behavior, little effect results from selectively lesioning its SDN.
BEHAVIORAL AND COGNITIVE STUDIES
Studies in sex differences in human behavior have focused on social behaviors in children, especially play behavior; social behavior in adults, especially aggression and child rearing; cognitive abilities; and sexual behavior. The studies most pertinent to gender issues and the brain are those of juvenile play behavior, cognitive function, and sexual behavior.
Studies of juvenile play behavior in nonhuman animals show that sex differences can be modified by alterations in prenatal hormones. Rough-and-tumble play in males has been linked to prenatal or perinatal testosterone. The administration of androgens in female species such as the rat prenatally and/or postnatally results in more play fighting in juveniles. Early castration in the first week of life feminizes this behavior in male rats; later castration does not. In the brain the amygdala has been associated with this sexually differentiated play behavior. In primates only manipulations in the prenatal period can masculinize play behavior. In humans studies have reported boys displaying a higher level of play activity with more rough-and-tumble, as well as a preference for male playmates and transportation and construction toys versus dolls, kitchen supplies, and crayons. Such findings appear in many cultures. An experiment of nature involving females born with congenital adrenal hyperplasia has revealed similar changes, which often are referred to as tomboyism. In both animal experiments and human observations, psychosocial variables that include but are not limited to maternal care, expectations, and general environmental variables are acknowledged as influencing all the sex differences that have been reported.
In terms of cognitive function, although claims have been made in both directions, the question of which sex is more intelligent appears to have been declared a draw. There are, however, particular areas of cognition, thinking, and problem solving that garner much attention. Women most often are reported to perform better in tests of verbal abilities, especially verbal fluency, speech production, language decoding, and spelling; perceptual speed and accuracy; and fine-motor skills. Men do better on tests of spatial abilities, quantitative abilities, and motor strength. Virtually every study, regardless of its bias, includes some form of the same disclaimer, which is stated and then ignored: (1) the range of differences within each sex was usually larger than the average difference between the sexes; (2) sex differences are most marked at the extreme end of the range of ability, such as the most skilled; (3) differences often are found only at specific ages; and (4) the results may be affected by the measurement technique, such as multiple-choice questions, fill-in-the-blank prompts, or essay responses. Studies using meta-analysis have led many researchers to conclude that there are no significant differences between men and women in cognition; others report confirmation of some of the classically reported trends.
SEXUAL BEHAVIOR
Sexual behavior is one area where concrete findings would be expected and have been reported consistently. Although the fact is often forgotten, sex is not about reproduction but is the process by which DNA from two different members of the same species is exchanged and/or combined for purposes of repair and/or to achieve genetic variation. Sexual recombination of DNA involves differentiation into two genders: male and female. In fusion sex (as opposed to conjunction sex), in which two gametes fuse (as in humans), the female brings to the union nuclear DNA and cytoplasmic organelles such as mitochondria that contain DNA, and the male delivers only nuclear DNA.
All living things have sex, from viruses to multi-cellular eukaryotes, including humans. In humans but not in all species, sex and reproduction are obligatorily linked. Although the behavior necessary for procreation often is called having sex, technically, only the gametes have sex. Fusion takes place after the gametes have been released and the two bodies that produced them have separated. The body serves at the pleasure of the gametes, which are directed by genes. The genes live on, and the body dies. However, it is the body, directed by the brain, that performs the behaviors that allow sex to occur. Those behaviors are modified in each body (partner, gender) so that the bodies can find each other, join, release their gametes, and separate.
PET scans in human males and females have shed light on female orgasm. There is no convincing evidence of an evolutionary purpose for female orgasm. Evidence that shows the difficulty women have in achieving orgasm, especially during intercourse, has been replicated sufficiently to have strong credibility. The role of the clitoris, the homologue of the penis, became muddled by fruitless debates about the supremacy of vaginal versus clitoral orgasm dating back to Viennese psychiatrist Sigmund Freud (1856–1939); this line of argument continued long after data on vaginal insensitivity made it moot. Personal reporting and indirect psychophysiological recording have had to suffice as evidence of the occurrence of orgasm in human females.
However, G. Holstege et al. were successful in performing PET scans in both men and women during orgasm. It has been known for some time that orgasm is closely associated with a series of perineal-pelvic contractions. Holstege reported, "These results demonstrate that, similar to ejaculation and orgasm in men, during female orgasm activation occurs primarily in subcortical parts of the brain. The meso-diencephalic junction comprises the reward-related ventral tegmental area, which might produce the pleasure aspect of orgasm. The finding of involvement of the PAG [periaqueductal gray matter] is interesting, because this area has been shown to play a role in female cat, rat, and hamster sexual behavior. Faking an orgasm only activated parts of the voluntary motor system" (Holstege 2003).
Typical of media fascination with sex differences, this historical identification of a central marker localizing "orgasm in the lower brain stem" was ignored, and attention was concentrated on less dramatic, subtle cortical events as it was announced that women fall into a trance during orgasm.
REDUCTIONISM AND APPROPRIATENESS
Studies have demonstrated that differences in learning, cognition, and success in school can be influenced by simple things. For example, it has been shown that there are innate differences in the ways girls and boys see and hear. In his article titled "Six Degrees of Separation: What Teachers Need to Know about the Emerging Science of Sex Differences" (2006) Leonard Sax maintained that six degrees of separation between the sexes in ambient temperature produces dramatic effects, leading him to suggest more attention to same-sex schooling.
In regard to understanding gender and its multivariate influences, Money's work let the genie out of the bottle. Haig stated, "Although Money explicitly adopted an interactionist position … his work was implicitly read as lying at the nurture-end of the spectrum" (Haig 2004, p. 93). Although biologists, psychologists, and social scientists all know that the formation and expression of gender point toward the inadequacy of the term multivariate, they often yield to the temptation to bolster their viewpoint, discipline, or prejudice by blurring the boundaries of nature and nuture.
Societies have been rigid in their maintenance of appropriateness in regard to issues of sex and gender. For some—the transgendered/transsexuals—this has produced a conundrum that can be resolved only by what many consider mutilating solutions. Others—intersexuals—often have had to have Solomon-like decisions made for them concerning what has been felt to be corrective surgery. Others, whose sexual preferences come into conflict with an unaccepting world, seek legal solutions to establish their rights. At times the battle seems endless between visions that coalesce into opposing factions: the tyranny of the dichotomous versus the anarchy of the androgynous.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bleie, Tone. 2003. "Evolution, Brains and the Predicament of Sex in Human Cognition." Sexualities, Evolution and Gender 5(3): 149-189.
Fausto-Sterling, Anne. 2000. "The Five Sexes, Revisited." Sciences 40(4): 18.
Haig, David. 2000. "Of Sex and Gender." Nature Genetics 25: 373. Available from http://www.nature.com/.
Haig, D. 2004. "The Inexorable Rise of Gender and the Decline of Sex: Social Change in Academic Titles, 1945–2001." Archives of Sexual Behavior 33: 87-96.
Halpern, D. F. 2004. "A Cognitive-Process Taxonomy for Sex Differences in Cognitive Abilities." Current Directions in Psychological Science 13(4): 135-139.
Holstege, Gert; A. A. T. Reinders; A. M. J. Paans; L. C. Meiners; J. Pruim; and J.R. Georgiadis. 2003. "Brain Activation during Female Sexual Orgasm." Program No. 727.7. Abstract Viewer/Itinerary Planner. Washington, DC: Society for Neuroscience. Available from http://sfn.scholarone.com.
Hyde, Janet Shibley. 2005. "The Gender Similarities Hypothesis." American Psychologist 60(6): 581-592.
Kessler, Suzanne J. 1998. Lessons from the Intersexed. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.
Money, John. 1955. "Hermaphroditism, Gender and Precocity in Hyperadrenocorticism: Psychologic Findings." Bulletin of the Johns Hopkins Hospital 96: 253-264.
Sax, Leonard. 2006. "Six Degrees of Separation: What Teachers Need to Know about the Emerging Science of Sex Differences." Educational Horizons 84: 190-220.
Schuiling, G. A. 2002. "Sex, Gender and Reproduction." Journal of Psychosomatic Obstetrics and Gynecology 23: 83-88.
Benjamin Graber
