Samuel

views updated

SAMUEL

An Old Testament figure whose story is recounted essentially in 1 Sm 1–16. His birth and early life are covered in 1 Sm 1–7; his involvement with Saul is told in 1 Sm 8–12 (Saul's anointment as king) and 1 Sm 13–15 (Saul's rejection); his involvement with David is limited to David's anointment (1 Sm 16) and a brief story of David, in flight from Saul, taking refuge with Samuel (19:18–24). Subsequent mentions recount his death (25:1), and Saul's desperate attempt to seek counsel from Samuel's ghost (28:3–25). Samuel is an important personage, but transitional: he represents the best of the old order of judgeship, which proved itself incapable of adequately governing Yahweh's people, and points forward to the new order of monarchy by anointing Saul and David, the first kings of Israel.

Narratively, the character of Samuel is complex. The account of his birth and early life culminates in his assumption of all the standard leadership offices in ancient Israel: he is a Nazirite (1:11); a prophet (3:19–4:1); a priest (7:9–10, 17), despite not being from the priestly tribe of Levi; and a judge (7:15–17). He, or Israelite forces under his leadership, subdue the Philistines (7:10–14, but contrast 13:5–15), but he cannot control his own sons (8:1–3). He is reluctant to anoint a king until Yahweh approves (8:4–9); he warns the people about royal abuses (8:11–18), then gives the king carte blanche (10:7); he condemns Saul when he takes decisions Samuel deems disobedient (13:8–14), and yet grieves when Yahweh rejects Saul from the kingship (15:35–16:1). He embodies the conflict of Israelite enthusiasm and hesitation before the irrevocable step of political transformation to autocracy, the ambivalence of cultic and charismatic leaders toward a dynast who will relieve them of both civil power and military responsibility, and even the obliquity of a deity whose motives are not always entirely clear (compare 1 Sm 10:23–24 with 16:7–8).

Historically, we can say unfortunately little about Samuel. With no external evidence about him from archaeology or non-biblical documents, we are restricted to conjectures based on the biblical text. That a transition from tribal confederacy to monarchy took place is virtually certain; that one or more individuals were pivotal in that transition is highly probable. That the artistically constructed narrative of those events has inherited and preserved, through several centuries of oral tradition and written elaboration and editing, authentic memories of one of those individuals is not impossible. But contemporary scholars' growing hesitation about the historical reliability of the biblical accounts of Israel's earliest days, and our increasing appreciation of the depth, richness, and sophistication of ancient Israel's genius for literary creativity, together urge caution about moving too readily from narrative characterization to historical reconstruction.

The Chronicler mentions "The Chronicles of Samuel the Seer" as one of several sources for the life of David (1 Chr 29:29), but no such book has come down to us. That remark may be the source of the later Jewish legend that gave the Books of Samuel their name and attributed them to his authorship, but the legend is certainly without historical foundation.

Bibliography: l. m. eslinger, Kingship of God in Crisis (Bible and Literature; Sheffield: 1985). g. w. ramsey, "Samuel," in The Anchor Bible Dictionary (New York 1992); 5:954–57. See also the commentaries on 1 Samuel under "Samuel, Book (s) of."

[j. t. walsh]

More From encyclopedia.com