Federal Bureau of Investigation
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) is a division of the Department of Justice supervised by the attorney general. Although a cabinet officer since the 1790s, the attorney general did not oversee federal law enforcement and did not even head a federal department until congressional legislation of 1870 created the Department of Justice. The attorney general's responsibilities originally involved arguing major cases before the Supreme Court and advising the President on constitutional questions. The combination of the reconstruction experience with the enactment of legislation regulating interstate commerce in 1887 and preventing corporate mergers in 1890, however, led attorneys general to recognize the need for experienced investigators to secure evidence to prosecute violators of the antitrust and interstate commerce laws. Accordingly, in July 1908 Attorney General Charles Bonaparte, by executive order, created a special investigation division within the Department of Justice, the Bureau of Investigation, formally renamed the Federal Bureau of Investigation in 1935.
Thereafter, the FBI's investigative reponsibilities increased as new laws expanded the definition of interstate commerce crime (the mann act of 1910 and the Dyer Act of 1919) and law enforcement responsibilities (laws criminalizing kidnapping and bank robbing) and barred specified political activities that threatened the nation's internal security (the espionage act of 1917 and the Smith Act of 1940). Yet this expansion raised no unique constitutional question both because it was legislatively mandated and because the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of the Espionage and Smith Acts, which impinged on speech and association.
The FBI's activities have raised constitutional issues because of the Bureau's monitoring of "subversive" activities, particularly since 1936. In striking contrast even to the abusive palmer raids of 1920, which had been based on the 1918 Immigration Act's alien deportation provisions, after 1936 the FBI did not seek evidence to effect prosecution; and its "intelligence" investigations were authorized solely under secret executive directives (President franklin d. roosevelt's oral directive of August 1936) or public executive orders (President harry s. truman's March 1947 order establishing the Federal Employee Loyalty Program). In acquiring intelligence about dissident activities, the FBI's purposes became either to service White House interests and those of the increasingly powerful FBI director or, in the case of federal loyalty-security programs, to anticipate espionage by identifying "potentially disloyal" federal employees. In time, the FBI's dissemination activities extended beyond the executive branch—at first, during the 1940s, informally and then after the 1950s formally, to governors and to carefully selected reporters, columnists, prominent national leaders, and members of Congress. Rather than prosecuting individuals for violating federal laws, the FBI instead brought about the dismissal of "subversive" employees by disseminating information on state employees to state governors under a code-named Responsibilities Program and by exposing publicly other "subversives," often through covert assistance to the house committee on un-american activities, Senator Joseph McCarthy, and the Senate Internal Security Subcommittee. Adopting a more aggressive tack after 1956, FBI officials instituted two other formal programs, cointelpro and Mass Media, both having as their purpose the discrediting of targeted organizations and their adherents.
These programs were not subject to judicial review both because they had no law enforcement purpose and because they were conducted secretly. Furthermore, these covert efforts to "harass, disrupt and discredit" targeted organizations or to disseminate derogatory information about political activists to favored journalists, members of Congress, Presidents, governors, and prominent citizens were based on a commitment to contain political change.
The FBI's activities raised other constitutional questions in view of some of the Bureau's investigative techniques. Despite the legislative ban against wiretapping of the communications act of 1934 and the fourth amendment prohibition of unreasonable searches and seizures, from 1940 forward the FBI installed wiretaps and bugs and conducted break-ins when investigating "subversive" activities and at times during sensitive criminal investigations. These techniques were authorized under secret directives issued either by Presidents (Franklin Roosevelt's May 1940 authorization of wiretapping), the attorney general (Herbert Brownell's May 1954 authorization of bugging), or solely by the FBI director (j. edgar hoover's 1942 authorization of break-ins). Theoretically, information so obtained could not be used for prosecution. However, two individuals inadvertently uncovered the FBI's electronic eavesdropping at a time when they were the subjects of criminal inquiries. Intercepted messages included attorney-client conversations, and in both cases, the disclosures led the courts to overturn the defendants' convictions.
Contrary to the rationale that gained currency during the 1960s of inherent presidential powers, when FBI officials first employed these electronic surveillance techniques in the 1940s they privately conceded their illegality and accordingly sought to preclude public discovery of potentially controversial practices. For example, when outlining how requests for his approval to conduct breakins were to be submitted, FBI Director Hoover characterized this technique as "clearly illegal." Because break-ins offered the opportunity to acquire otherwise unobtainable information about "subversive" activities (membership and subscription lists, financial records, correspondence and memoranda), Hoover was willing to risk use of this technique. To avert discovery, however, the FBI director devised a special records procedure, "Do Not File," to ensure the undiscoverable destruction of such records and further to allow FBI officials to affirm, in response to congressional subpoenas or court-ordered discoverymotions, that a search of the fbi's "central records system" uncovered no evidence of illegal conduct. this fbi practice raised additional constitutional question insofar as, beginning in the late 1950s, break-ins were employed during some criminal investigations.
Athan Theoharis
(1992)
(see also: McCarthyism.)
Bibliography
Theoharis, Athan and Cox, John Stuart 1988 The Boss. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
Ungar, Sanford 1975 FBI. Boston: Atlantic/Little, Brown.
