Disability

views updated

Disability

The presence of disability in popular culture has taken many forms; indeed, people with disabilities (PWDs) have appeared frequently across the pop-culture spectrum: movies, television, print media, dance, theater, music, and sports. Disability representations have never been in short supply, though many produced by the mainstream cultural industries remain questionable at best, hurtful and divisive at worst.

Images of disability have perhaps found their most frequent expression in movies, with the vast majority created from the perspective of able-bodied filmmakers and intended primarily for able-bodied audiences. The earliest silent movies, each only a few minutes long, tended to portray PWDs as comic figures given to pursuing others or being pursued themselves, as in The Legless Runner (1907), The Invalid's Adventure (1907), and Don't Pull My Leg (1908). As the medium matured, moviemakers borrowed heavily from such nineteenth-century literary fare as Moby Dick, A Christmas Carol, Notre Dame de Paris (The Hunchback of Notre Dame), Treasure Island, and The Two Orphans, to create more intricate narratives that portrayed disabled people either as innocent victims or incarnations of evil. The films in this tradition included Orphans of the Storm (1921), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1923, but many versions made since), The Sea Beast (1926), and numerous adaptations of A Christmas Carol. The 1930s saw a continuing interest in such stereotypical extremes—most notably in Moby Dick (1930), Charlie Chaplin's City Lights (1931), Todd Browning's famous gallery of grotesques, Freaks (1932), and a 1939 remake of Hunchback. Such images began fading during the World War II era in favor of relatively realistic and sensitive portraits of disabled veterans. Pride of the Marines (1945) and Bright Victory (1951) both dealt with blinded ex-servicemen; real-life veteran Harold Russell, whose service legacy was to lose his hands (replaced by metal hooks), played himself in The Best Years of Our Lives (1946), and Fred Zinnemann's The Men (1951), Marlon Brando's first film, dealt with paraplegics. These images, in turn, began giving way to famously larger-than-life civilians who "triumphed" over their disabilities: opera singer Marjorie Lawrence and Franklin D. Roosevelt, both polio victims, in Interrupted Melody (1955) and Sunrise at Campobello (1960) respectively, Helen Keller, deaf, dumb, and blind, in The Miracle Worker (1962). Stanley Kubrick's Dr. Strangelove (1964), however, mocked these latter types with its title character, and signaled their temporary demise.

With alarming regularity, Hollywood has continued churning out regressive disability movies such as Hook (1991), The Fugitive (1993), Speed (1994), and Forrest Gump (1994), reflecting the ageold practice of linking evil or innocence with disability, but an increasing number of films since the 1960s have offered positive images. Hollywood has often reserved the most resonant and poignant portrayals for disabled Vietnam veterans, as in Coming Home (1978), Cutter's Way (1981), and Born on the Fourth of July (1989). Other memorable, if not entirely progressive, films since the 1960s include The Other Side of the Mountain (1975), The Elephant Man (1980), Children of a Lesser God (1986), Rain Man (1988), and Scent of a Woman (1992), which range over a variety of afflictions and film styles.

Despite its relatively short history, the television industry has also demonstrated an interest in portraying the disabled experience, with a number of series presenting disabled characters in continuing roles. Gunsmoke's mobility-impaired sidekick Chester Goode, played by Dennis Weaver for nine seasons (1955-1964) during the program's 20-year run, competes with Raymond Burr's wheelchair-dependent police detective on Ironside (1967-1975), as television's most popular disabled character, while James Franciscus played a blind insurance investigator on Longstreet (1971-1972). Taking a different approach, nuclear-powered prostheses and implants turned disabled figures Steve Austin (Lee Majors) and Jaime Sommers (Lindsay Wagner) into the title characters of The Six Million Dollar Man (1974-1978) and The Bionic Woman (1976-1978), respectively. Later, LeVar Burton played the blind chief engineer Lt. Geordi LaForge in Star Trek: The Next Generation (1987-1994) and a string of follow-up movies.

Most of these films and TV programs featured able-bodied actors playing the disabled characters, a situation that some disability activists have likened to the now discontinued practice of white actors masquerading in blackface as African Americans or Shakespeare's Othello. Actors with actual disabilities have been employed only sporadically in the film and television industries, but their influence continues to rise. Some old-line actors, such as Sarah Bernhardt, Harold Lloyd, Herbert Marshall, and Lionel Barrymore, tended to mask their disabilities before the cameras (Barrymore's performance in the 1946 film It's a Wonderful Life is a notable exception), but for more recent actors, their disabilities became part of the characters they played. Harold Russell, whose hands were blown off in a demolition exercise, won two Oscars for his work in The Best Years of Our Lives, and Marlee Matlin, a hearing-impaired performer, won an Oscar for her role in Children of a Lesser God (1986) and went on to play bank-robber-turned-mayor Laurie Bey in the final years of the acclaimed TV series Picket Fences. Chris Burke, a developmentally disabled actor, co-starred as Corky Thatcher on the popular drama Life Goes On during its 1989-1993 run, and wheelchair-user Nancy Becker Kennedy played a sharp-tongued secretary on The Louie Show in 1996. Mitch Longley, a wheelchair-using heartthrob who once modeled shirts for Ralph Lauren, appeared as Byron Pierce on the soap opera Another World during the 1991/92 season and, beginning in 1997, played the double role of Dr. Matt Harmon and Eric Mancusi on the long-running soap opera, General Hospital, and its spin-off, Port Charles.

Longley is only one of several PWDs who have also made inroads into the modeling field. One of the most famous, wheelchair-user Ellen Stohl, posed nude for the July 1987 issue of Playboy, making her that magazine's first disabled centerfold, while runway models now have PWDs among their ranks, including Kitty Lunn and Kim Barreda. A number of American corporations, such as McDonald's and K-Mart, have begun using disabled performers in their commercials. A prime example is The Home Depot, which has featured disabled employees Henry Gibson and Dan Brady in its ads.

Since the latter decades of the twentieth century, PWDs have taken a more direct role in the creation of a pop-culture presence. Ron Kovic, a disabled Vietnam veteran who wrote the searing autobiography, Born on the Fourth of July, in 1976, also co-wrote the screenplay, in which he was played by Tom Cruise, for the like-titled movie in 1989. Three years later, Neil Jimenez wrote and co-directed The Waterdance, a film modeled largely on his own experiences as a newly disabled person. Billy Golfus, who suffered brain damage during a 1984 vehicular accident, eventually secured funding through the Independent Television Service to produce When Billy Broke His Head … and Other Tales of Wonder in 1995. This documentary film told not only his story but also the "tales" of other PWDs and their struggles for civil rights. Disabled journalist and poet Mark O'Brien collaborated with Jessica Yu on Breathing Lessons: The Life and Work of Mark O'Brien (1996), an Oscar-winning film for best short-subject documentary and a recipient of a special National Educational Media Network award. In 1992, Greg Smith founded On a Roll, a nationally syndicated radio talk show dedicated to disability issues, while John Hockenberry, a two-time Peabody Award-winning TV network correspondent, shared his perspectives about life as a disabled person in a 1995 memoir, Moving Violations, and in his oneman show, Spokesman, produced off-Broadway in 1996. Christopher Reeve, whose spinal cord was severed in a 1995 horseback-riding accident, directed a one-hour AIDS drama in 1997 titled In the Gloaming, and served as an executive producer for the 1998 TV remake of Hitchcock's Rear Window, in which he played the James Stewart role of a wheelchair-bound man who witnesses a murder across the courtyard of his apartment building.

Many other PWDs have contributed to the performing arts. Among the more notable are three singers who happen to be blind: Ray Charles and Stevie Wonder, who have enjoyed long careers as popular musicians; and Andrea Bocelli, who crossed over from opera to become something of a pop sensation. The National Theater of the Deaf, a mixed troupe of hearing and deaf actors founded in 1965, has performed across the country and on national TV. Mary Verdi-Fletcher, a wheelchair-user born with spina bifida, founded the Cleveland Ballet Dancing Wheels, a group of dancers with differing degrees of mobility that has given hundreds of performances on several continents.

PWDs have had their greatest successes in the literary field, with memoirs and poetry volumes. Nancy Mairs' Waist-High in the World (1996) and Kenny Fries' anthology Staring Back (1997) are prominent among the countless examples. The influence of the disability press has also grown appreciably, with New Mobility, The Ragged Edge (formerly The Disability Rag), and Mouth playing crucial roles.

In the world of sports, the Paralympic Games typically attracts thousands of amateur athletes and delegates from more than a hundred countries and are by far the most famous of competitions for PWDs. Among professional athletes, Monty Stratton pitched professional baseball for a few seasons in the 1940s despite having lost a leg in a 1938 hunting accident. He went on to supervise The Stratton Story (1949), a movie based on his life, which starred James Stewart. Despite a congenitally deformed hand, Jim Abbott enjoyed several seasons as a Major League pitcher and threw a no-hitter for the New York Yankees in 1993. In the National Football League, New Orleans Saints place kicker Tom Dempsey, born without a right hand and only half a right foot, used that foot to kick a 63-yard field goal against the Detroit Lions in 1970, a NFL record that stood unmatched for 28 years. Casey Martin, a professional golfer with a rare and painful birth defect in his right leg, made headlines in early 1998 by suing the PGA Tour and winning the right to ride in a cart while participating in the pro golf tour.

Of all pop-culture arenas, comic-strip art is decidedly the most problematic as regards the treatment of disability. Berke Breathed's syndicated cartoon strip Bloom County and its wheelchair-using Vietnam vet, Cutter John, are among the high points, but the field has generally been dominated by cartoonists such as Charles Addams and Gahan Wilson, long known for their "sick-humor" takes on such topics as blindness, deformity, and dismemberment. Their work arguably paved the way for John Callahan's repellent Hustler cartoon images and Gary Larson's skewed view of disabling conditions in his near-legendary strip, The Far Side.

Despite the excesses of comic-strip art and certain other media, however, the pop-culture representation of disability is constantly advancing. As more and more PWDs get involved in the creation of popular culture, the images can only improve.

—Martin F. Norden

Further Reading:

Cumberbatch, Guy, and Ralph Negrine. Images of Disability on Television. New York, Routledge, 1992.

Fries, Kenny, editor. Staring Back: The Disability Experience from the Inside Out. New York, Plume, 1997.

Gartner, Alan, and Tom Joe, editors. Images of the Disabled, Disabling Images. New York, Praeger, 1987.

Hockenberry, John. Moving Violations: War Zones, Wheelchairs, and Declarations of Independence. New York, Hyperion, 1995.

Klobas, Lauri E. Disability Drama in Television and Film. Jefferson, McFarland, 1988.

Mairs, Nancy. Waist-High in the World: A Life Among the Nondisabled. Boston, Beacon Press, 1996.

Norden, Martin F. The Cinema of Isolation: A History of Physical Disability in the Movies. New Brunswick, Rutgers University Press, 1994.

More From encyclopedia.com