Obesity

views updated

Obesity

bibliography

Although obesity, which indicates excessive accumulation of fat tissue with a corresponding increase in size, has been the focus of medical interest since antiquity, it has not been well defined. Moderate stores of fat are desirable and indicate normal nutrition. Since only an excess of the physiologically desirable is regarded as abnormal, a quantitative, even arbitrary, element enters into the definition. A clinician of the last century (Ebstein 1882) divided obesity into three stages: the enviable, the comical, and the pitiable. In contemporary American society no stage would be considered “enviable.” Even mild degrees of excess weight, or those that indicate abundant normal growth, are condemned.

During the past half century, obesity has customarily been equated with overweight in relation to an “average” figure for height, age, and sex. Since in Western society weight commonly increases with age, it was considered a further refinement to refer to the weight of the young adult person as the “ideal.” Life insurance companies, which need a statistical approach for quick evaluation of a large number of people, have branded any excess weight as undesirable. Clinically, it is doubtful whether such a statistical concept of “normal” or “ideal” weight is valid. A recent examination of the total population of a certain area in the south of Sweden, for example, revealed that as much as 70 per cent of the female population over 40 years of age were 10 kilograms “overweight” and 10 per cent were overweight by 30 kilograms or more (Bjurulf & Lindgren 1964).

Many other objections have been raised against a rigid statistical approach. It has been criticized as being based on the implicit assumption that all body weight is equivalent and that overweight is a measure of relative fatness. Keys and Brozek (1953), who first gathered extensive evidence against the blind use of statistics, particularly in regard to moderately overweight persons, considered some judicious pinches of various skin folds a more scientific way of estimating fatness. Refinements of this biological approach include the use of skin-fold calipers, soft-tissue roentgenograms, and estimates of the total body water through densitometry. These newer methods aid in obtaining more accurate measurements of the body fat in relation to the lean tissue (von Dobeln 1964).

There is increasing awareness that clinical obesity does not represent just an extreme on the normal distribution curve for weight, but that it is a symptom of true abnormalities, an expression of a variety of underlying clinical disturbances (MacBryde 1964). There is increasing recognition that the term refers to a variety of decidedly different clinical pictures. Obesity that develops early in life, in infancy or before puberty, has an entirely different course and significance from the gradual increase in weight in middle life (Bruch 1955).

Entirely different problems are encountered in (1) those whose weight is stable or who have arrived at the stationary stage of obesity and (2) those who are in the active phase of progressively increasing weight or who, with constant fluctuation, show dramatic weight losses during which the fat seems to melt away, only to be regained even more rapidly. The clinical picture and the pathological processes are different again in superobese people who achieve a tremendous size, with weight in excess of 300 pounds—reaching up to 700 or 800. At the present stage of our knowledge, or rather ignorance, it is not possible to differentiate between these different forms of obesity on the basis of any laboratory test; thus far it can be done only through evaluation of the whole development and reaction pattern (Bruch 1957a).

Economic and sociological factors . Regardless of the physiological and psychological aspects to be discussed later, external factors influence the occurrence of obesity to a conspicuous degree. In the United States, obesity has been called the number one health problem. Other affluent countries, too, express concern with overnutrition as a not altogether desirable by-product of increased and improved food consumption and labor-saving devices.

Human history has been determined to a large extent by the search for sufficient food. Malnutrition is still prevalent in underdeveloped countries with inadequate nutritional resources, and starvation is a specter that even today threatens large sections of mankind. Such abundance of food for large population groups is historically very recent, and geographically it is limited to a few overprivileged countries.

Yet the condition of obesity has been familiar to man since the dawn of history. The oldest representation of the human form, the “Venus of Wilendorf,” shows marked obesity, and so do other paleontological figurines. The taste for fat women persisted into the Neolithic period. It is not known whether these “Venuses” are realistic representations or whether they represent an artistic ideal, a dream of abundance and fertility.

In primitive society, a yearning for fatness persists. Cloete (1953, p. 119) describes the attitude of the typical South African who works for the white man: “. . . and what is his heart’s desire? Fat above all things. To be fat himself, to have a fat wife and children and fat cattle. This is the native’s dream, the Biblical dream of plenty in a starving land.”

A similar primitive desire for fatness was conspicuous during the 1930s among the mothers of a large group of obese children who were studied in New York City (Bruch 1940). Many of the women had been poor immigrants who had suffered hunger during their early lives. They did not understand why anyone should object to a child’s being big and fat, which to them indicated success and freedom from want.

Even in the United States, traditionally the country of abundance, nutritional deficiency diseases were the object of concern fifty years ago; today they have become quite rare. In the last fifty years, American children, both of native and foreign-born parents, have become 6-8 per cent taller and 1215 per cent heavier than their parents, and maturation and puberty occur at an earlier age. The same observation is being made in Japan, where the new generation, under the influence of improved nutrition, is outgrowing the short stature of the parents.

Adequate food supply is thus a prerequisite for optimum weight and physical development. Yet under the conditions of abundance, only a certain number of people become obese. A rich literature exists on the occurrence of obesity in different societies and eras, and on outstanding individuals who have been fat. Fascinating as these reports are, they have the value only of anecdotal contributions and are based on hearsay tales, old chronicles, and speculation (Bruch 1957a; Clauser & Spranger 1957).

In spite of the great public interest in obesity, systematic inquiries into its sociological aspects are conspicuously rare. Public health figures indicate a change in the weight of adult Americans: since 1912 the average weight of women has decreased by 5 pounds, whereas the average man is 5 pounds heavier. A detailed evaluation of a large unselected population sample—1,600 adults living in a central residential area of New York City—led to the discovery of a striking relationship between obesity and social class (Moore et al. 1962). Obesity occurred seven times more frequently among women of the lowest socioeconomic level than among those of the highest level; among men the same relationship existed, although to a lesser degree. As other studies also noted, obesity was found to increase with age.

Similar observations are reported in the south of Sweden, where the weight of women in the upper classes is lower and shows less variability than that of women of poorer economic background. However, men in the lower sociological group in Sweden do not tend to be overweight (Andersen & Esmann 1957).

A recent German study gives a different picture (Pflanz 1963). Information on social factors was obtained for 10,000 patients who were seen during one year at the medical clinic of the University of Giessen. A weight excess of 15 kilograms, indicating undisputed obesity, was observed in a sample of about 1,000 patients. This study revealed that the sociological factors associated with obesity were quite different in men and women. Conspicuously often, obesity occurred in men who had been only children. No such difference between the sexes was observed in those who came from a large sibling group. Single and divorced women and those living in cities were less obese than married and widowed women and those living in rural surroundings. Analysis according to social class revealed the greatest differences. In the group of independent farmers and small-business people, obesity was observed at approximately the same frequency in men and women. In the highest and lowest social class, the sex distributions went in opposite directions. Obesity was more frequent in women of the lowest class and in men of the highest class. It seems that under the special conditions of German culture, obesity in men has an entirely different sociological significance from that in women; in men it seems to add to their sense of power and prestige.

Physiological factors . The question of what causes obesity has challenged physicians since antiquity. Two lines of reasoning can be recognized throughout the medical literature: one suggests that obesity is due to some innate inherited factors and is therefore an unalterable fate; the other suggests that it is the result of deplorable personal habits—overeating and inactivity—that are morally condemned as greed and laziness. Scientific understanding has been delayed by the tendency to consider heredity and environmental factors as mutually exclusive. They are not only not opposed but interact and influence each other in many ways (Stern 1949). This clinical deduction now finds support from genetics, namely, from recent evidence that in the cells of higher organisms a large part of the genetic material remains inactive and that the level of activity of a gene depends on environmental factors. Changes in diet and hormonal secretion may serve to activate certain genes. They in turn are influenced by living conditions, climate, and the emotional state of the organism.

The case for heredity is easily made in regard to obesity. A high family incidence is reported by many different investigators (Bruch 1957a; Davenport 1923). Of course, it is just as easy to demonstrate that these families indulge in rich meals and tend to avoid physical activities.

Other evidence of inherent factors is the prevalence of certain constitutional types. In a group of 180 obese adolescent girls, there was an expected high proportion of endomorphic types, but also a high incidence of mesomorphic types (Seltzer & Mayer 1964). A group of 250 obese boys and girls tended to be taller and to mature earlier than their age peers of normal weight (Bruch 1939a). An anthropological study of adult obese women showed the prevalence of a certain body type, namely, juvenile proportions that are associated with early maturity [Ange] 1949; see also Psychology, article on Constitutional Psychology].

Micromorphologic study shows that fat tissue varies greatly in size and number of cells (Hirsch & Goldrick 1964). It appears that the size of the cell varies with nutritional factors, whereas the number of cells is determined by endogenous, probably genetic, factors. Individuals with the same thickness of subcutaneous fat may have different morphologic tissue structure. Coronary sclerosis appears to be associated with large fat cells but not with a high cell count (Bjurulf 1964).

Powerful support for the genetic view came from the discovery of certain strains of mice that grew fat under ordinary laboratory conditions. As many as 15 types of obesity, with different hereditary, metabolic, regulatory, eating, and activity disturbances, have been recognized in the mouse (Mayer 1963). It is questionable whether any of them has an equivalent in human obesity. The great merit of these extensive studies is the clarity with which they demonstrate the way multiple factors interact and how etiological and pathogenetic factors can and need to be separated.

Clinical investigations reflect this stimulus in the greater diversification of problems that are being studied. “Metabolism,” a generation ago, referred to the balance between caloric intake and output. Metabolic studies today are directed toward clarifying the transformation of various foodstuffs into the metabolites that are deposited in the tissues. There is increasing evidence that there are forms of human obesity that are characterized by the increased formation of fatty acids from glucose and other foodstuffs and their decreased release from fat deposits. Various pathways of the transfer and synthesis of fatty acids have been clarified (Elovson 1964; Gordon 1964). It has been recognized that the fat tissues themselves play a role in this process and that hormones enter into the delicate balance between lipogenesis and fat mobilization in various ways (Dole & Hirsch 1960). Once lipogenesis is increased, it cannot be reversed by simple dieting. The fat person’s claim, “Everything I eat turns into fat,” and his sad experience that the painfully lost weight is readily regained, now has some scientific support. Other metabolic work deals with disturbances in the carbohydrate metabolisms, with differences in the glucostatic regulations (Mayer 1953).

Another factor leading to disordered weight is found in disturbances in the regulatory mechanisms. Since the beginning of the century, it has been recognized that obesity may develop after midbrain lesions, in the presence of tumors, or following encephalitis (Bruch 1939b). Extensive animal studies with experimentally produced microscopic lesions in the hypothalamus and other midbrain regions have elucidated the importance of different cell groups in influencing appetite and the experience of satiation, and thus weight regulation. Here again, newer studies emphasize the complexity of the problem, namely, that not only the eating function is affected by these operations but also spontaneous activity and motivation (Kennedy 1964). Proven anatomical lesions are rare in humans, and there has been speculation about possible functional weakness of the regulatory “centers,” some aspects of which will be discussed in the section on psychological factors.

Furthermore, animal experimentation has also demonstrated that environmental factors alone can result in severe obesity. If young rats are allowed food only two hours per day, they become markedly obese, with increased lipid synthesis in the adipose tissue, in contrast to litter mates who have free access to food and grow into normal rats (Hollifield & Parson 1962). The gain in weight continues, with voracious eating, when the restricted rats are restored to normal feeding. However, the cycle is interrupted, with corresponding metabolic changes, after a period of fasting.

Psychological aspects . Throughout the ages, popular opinion has attributed definite, although contradictory, character traits to fat people that reflect changing concepts of obesity. Attention has been focused on the inherent temperament of the fat person, or on the consequences of being fat and the insults of a derogatory social climate. The contribution of psychological factors to the development of obesity has been recognized only recently.

Systematic psychological studies have led to better understanding and clinical management of obese people, and they have also revealed the complexity of the problem. Psychiatric observations first emphasized the need for differentiating among several types of human obesity and recognized overeating and inactivity as manifestations of underlying emotional and personality disturbances (Bruch 1957a).

The psychiatric problems of obesity are far from uniform (Bruch 1957b). It is not possible to speak of the psychodynamics of one basic personality type or even to describe one single psychological feature as characteristic of all obese people. Obesity may be associated with every conceivable psychiatric disorder, with neurosis as well as psychosis. Psychological problems can be recognized under two different conditions. In some patients with many signs of disturbed behavior and adaption, obesity is intrinsically interwoven with their whole development; others become obese as a reaction to some traumatic event. It is in the latter form that the significance of psychological factors was first recognized. Obesity seems to serve as an equivalent for a depressive reaction in people who in other respects have the capacity for adequate functioning.

The total picture is much more disturbed in the developmental obesity that occurs in children and adolescents who grow up in families in which they are treated as objects—precious or hated possessions that are overstuffed with food and shielded from, or not trusted with, the ordinary tasks of life. In many respects their behavior and psychological reactions resemble those of the preschizophrenic stage. Such patients may become overtly schizophrenic when the demands of life become too threatening. Enforced reducing at this time may precipitate the manifest psychosis. Overeating and inactivity appear as central symptoms in the patient’s whole development and often reflect severe intrafamilial pathology. Such patients parallel preschizophrenic development in their general immaturity, social withdrawal, and body image disturbances (Bruch 1958).

Psychological and psychiatric studies of obesity have become so numerous that it is impossible even to enumerate them in a brief review. Various investigators have focused on different traits in an effort at classification. Stunkard (1959a), for instance, differentiates various forms of obesity according to eating patterns. He has also studied the extent and psychodynamic aspects of inactivity (Dorris & Stunkard 1957).

Psychoanalytic thinking has played an important role in the psychological study of obesity and has helped to clarify the conflicts and motivations that underlie overeating. Food is symbolically equated with an insatiable desire for unattainable love, but also with inhibited destructive impulses. Food intake may reflect self-indulgence, the desire for sexual gratification, or, the wish to be pregnant; it also may represent punishment of forbidden impulses. Preoccupation with food may appear as helpless, dependent clinging to parents or as hostile rejection of them.

In recent years a skeptical note can be recognized in psychiatric writings. The question has been raised whether the observations made on selected patients undergoing extensive psychoanalysis could and should be generalized to apply to the enormous group of obese patients not so extensively studied and observed. There is also need to differentiate between the psychological forces that lead to obesity and the psychological suffering resulting from it. Monello and Mayer (1963) observed that the psychological responses of a group of obese adolescents were similar to those of a minority group. They also noted that the obese child came from a nonunified family with poor sociability and was afraid to leave home. In a sociological study in New York City, obese persons gave more pathological responses on nine measures of mental health (Moore et al. 1962). For three of these measures—immaturity, suspiciousness, and rigidity—the results were statistically significant. These observations suggest that serious emotional disturbances may be present in obese people other than those who were actually studied.

There has also been a decided change in the direction and emphasis of psychiatric inquiry. Instead of focusing exclusively on the symbolic meaning of the disturbed behavior, a more basic theoretical question has been raised: How does it happen that a body function becomes capable of being misused in the service of motivational conflicts and disturbed interpersonal relations? It has been recognized that deficits in perception and conceptualization are important factors in the psychopathology of obese patients. Inability to identify correctly hunger and satiation is conspicuous among many other indications of falsified awareness of bodily needs, emotional states, and interpersonal situations. Patients with such disturbances have difficulty in drawing correct conceptual conclusions about sensations and impulses arising from within and differentiating them from those impinging from the outside [Bruch 1961; see also Body Image].

This failure to develop an integrated and differentiated concept of a bodily self and psychological identity could be related to a deficit in earliest learning experiences, namely, the absence of confirmation of child-initiated impulses. The importance of disturbed family influences had been recognized much earlier (Bruch & Touraine 1940), but as long as the abnormal interaction was related entirely to emotional experiences, this basic disturbance in conceptual awareness remained unclear. The importance of conceptual awareness has been demonstrated experimentally. When measured amounts of food were introduced directly into the stomach, marked individual differences were observed in the accuracy of recognizing whether, and how much, food had been given. Some healthy, normal subjects were consistently accurate. Obese patients were significantly less accurate. Independently, Stunkard (1959b) observed that obese patients frequently failed to feel hungry in the presence of stomach contractions or to recognize such contractions.

A comprehensive review in a limited space of ongoing research on obesity offers severe, even unsurmountable difficulties. These very difficulties signify a desirable and much needed development. They indicate that extensive research on this topic is being performed by investigators in many different disciplines. The multitude of new findings may appear confusing and contradictory; yet there is slowly developing a convergence of opinion that, contrary to old concepts, obesity is not a uniform or simple condition but a symptom of multiple interaction of various factors, only a few of which have thus far been clearly recognized.

This whole line of work is still very much in the beginning stages, but it promises a better understanding of the problem through integrating findings in various fields of research. From the psychiatrist’s point of view, patients suffering from obesity go through life with inadequate guideposts for orienting themselves about their own functioning and their relationships with others. They develop inaccurate behavior that becomes more and more inappropriate as, with their increasing age, the demands of life become more and more complex.

Hilde Bruch

[See alsoFood, article onConsumption Patterns; Psychosomatic Illness.]

bibliography

Andersen, Knud; and Esmann, Viggo 1957 Survey of the Distribution of Weight in the Adult Population of Kjellerup, Denmark. Acta medica scandinavica 157: 185-198.

Angel, J. Lawrence 1949 Constitution in Female Obesity. American Journal of Physical Anthropology New Series 7:433-468.

Bjurulf, P. 1964 Micromorphologic Aspects of Variation in Human Body Fat. Pages 95-101 in Gunnar Blix (editor), Occurrences, Causes and Prevention of Overnutrition. Uppsala (Sweden): Almqvist & Wiksell.

Bjurulf, P.; and Lindgren, G. 1964 A Preliminary Study on Overweight in the South of Sweden. Pages 9-15 in Gunnar Blix (editor), Occurrences, Causes and Prevention of Overnutrition. Uppsala (Sweden): Almqvist & Wiksell.

Bruch, Hilde 1939a Obesity in Childhood. Part 1: Physical Growth and Development of Obese Children. American Journal of Diseases of Children 58:457-484.

Bruch, Hilde 1939b The Froehlich Syndrome. American Journal of Diseases of Children 58:1282-1289. BRUCH, HILDE 1940 Obesity in Childhood. Part 3: Physiologic and Psychologic Aspects of the Food Intake of Obese Children. American Journal of Diseases of Children 59:739-781.

Bruch, Hilde 1955 Fat Children Grown-up. American Journal of Diseases of Children 90:501 only.

Bruch, Hilde 1957a The Importance of Overweight. New York: Norton.

Bruch, Hilde 1957b Psychiatric Aspects of Obesity. Metabolism 6:461-465.

Bruch, Hilde 1958 Developmental Obesity and Schizophrenia. Psychiatry 21:65-70.

Bruch, Hilde 1961 Transformation of Oral Impulses in Eating Disorders: A Conceptual Approach. Psychiatric Quarterly 35:458-481.

Bruch, Hilde; and Touraine, Grace 1940 Obesity in Childhood. Part 5: The Family Frame of Obese Children. Psychosomatic Medicine 2:141-206.

Clauser, G.; and Spranger, J. 1957 Hinweise auf die Aetiologie der Fettund Magersucht aus Volkstum, Kunst, Medizingeschichte und Wissenschaft. Münchener medizinische Wochenschrift 99:53-58.

Cloete, Stuart 1953 I Speak for the African. Life 34, May 4:111-126.

Davenport, Charles B. 1923 Body-build and Its Inheritance. Carnegie Institution of Washington, Publication No. 329. Washington: The Institution.

Dole, Vincent P.; and Hirsch, Jules 1960 Effects of Hormones on Depot Fat. Volume 1, pages 551-557 in Edwin B. Astwood (editor), Clinical Endocrinology. New York: Grune.

Dorris, Ronald J.; and Stunkard, Albert J. 1957 Physical Activity: Performance and Attitudes of a Group of Obese Women. American Journal of the Medical Sciences 233:622-628.

Ebstein, Wilhelm 1882 Die Fettleibigkeit und ihre Behandlung. Wiesbaden (Germany): Bergmann.

Elovson, J. 1964 Metabolic Regulation of Lipogenesis. Pages 67-74 in Gunnar Blix (editor), Occurrences, Causes and Prevention of Overnutrition. Uppsala (Sweden): Almqvist & Wiksell.

Gordon, Edgar S. 1964 New Concepts of the Biochemistry and Physiology of Obesity. Medical Clinics of North America 48:1285-1305.

Hirsch, Jules; and GOLDRICK, R. B. 1964 Serial Studies on the Metabolism of Human Adipose Tissue. Part 1: Lipogenesis and Free Fatty Acid Uptake and Release in Small Aspirated Samples of Subcutaneous Fat. Journal of Clinical Investigation 43:1776-1792.

Hollifield, Guy; and Parson, William 1962 Metabolic Adaptations to a “Stuff and Starve” Feeding Program. Parts 1-2. Journal of Clinical Investigation 41 : 245-253. ? Part 1: “Studies of Adipose Tissue and Liver Glycogen in Rats Limited to a Short Daily Feeding Period.” Part 2: “Obesity and the Persistence of Adaptive Changes in Adipose Tissue and Liver Occurring in Rats Limited to a Short Daily Feeding Period.”

Kennedy, G. C. 1964 The Hypothalamic Control of Food Intake. Pages 56-64 in Gunnar Blix (editor), Occurrences, Causes and Prevention of Overnutrition. Uppsala (Sweden): Almqvist & Wiksell.

Keys, Ancel; and BroŽek, Josef 1953 Body Fat in Adult Man. Physiological Reviews 33:245-325.

Macbryde, Cyril M. 1964 The Diagnosis of Obesity.Medical Clinics of North America 48:1307-1316.

Mayer, Jean 1953 Genetic, Traumatic and Environmental Factors in the Etiology of Obesity. Physiological Reviews 33:472-508.

Mayer, Jean 1963 Obesity. Annual Review of Medicine 14:111-132.

Monello, Lenore F.; and Mayer, Jean 1963 Obese Adolescent Girls: An Unrecognized “Minority” Group?American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 13:35-39.

Moore, Mary E.; Stunkard, Albert; and Srole, Leo 1962 Obesity, Social Class, and Mental Illness. Journal of the American Medical Association 181:962966.

Pflanz, M. 1963 Medizinisch-soziologische Aspekte der Fettsucht. Psyche 16:579-591.

Seltzer, Carl C ; and Mayer, Jean 1964 Body Build and Obesity: Who Are the Obese? Journal of the American Medical Association 189:677-684.

Stern, Curt (1949) 1960 Principles of Human Genetics. 2d ed. San Francisco: Freeman.

Stunkard, Albert J. 1959a Eating Patterns and Obesity. Psychiatric Quarterly 33:284-295.

Stunkard, Albert J. 19592? Obesity and the Denial of Hunger. Psychosomatic Medicine 21:281-289.

Von DÖbeln, W. 1964 Determination of Body Constituents. Pages 103-106 in Gunnar Blix (editor), Occurrences, Causes and Prevention of Overnutrition. Uppsala (Sweden): Almqvist & Wiksell.

More From encyclopedia.com