(b. Oberlin, Ohio, 28 September 1941; d. Princeton, New Jersey, 14 October 2001),
metaphysics, philosophy of language, philosophical logic, philosophy of mind, epistemology.
Lewis was one of the most important philosophers of the twentieth century, working in the Anglo-American analytic tradition. His corpus is extraordinary for its breadth of subject matter and for its systematicness. For both these reasons, it is difficult to do justice to his work in a short space—there are rich interconnections among his myriad writings and numerous possible entry points.
This article approaches Lewis and his work in three passes: first, a biographical tracing of his intellectual influences; second, a summary of his metaphilosophy; and third, a survey of his more specific philosophical views, mostly following their order of conceptual dependence.
Intellectual Biography . While Lewis was a strikingly original thinker, a number of others helped to shape his eventual intellectual outlook to varying degrees, as he acknowledged. He was born in Oberlin, Ohio, in 1941, the eldest child of John Donald Lewis, a professor of government at Oberlin College, and Ewart K. Lewis, a medieval historian. Shortly before his sixteenth birthday he entered Swarthmore College, where his teachers, Jerome Schaffer and Michael Scriven, and such fellow students as Gilbert Harman, Allan Gibbard, Barbara Hall (later Barbara Hall Partee), and Peter Unger, were early philosophical interlocutors and influences. Lewis initially planned to major in chemistry. That changed during a year in Oxford in 1959–1960, where he was tutored by Iris Murdoch and went to lectures by Gilbert Ryle, Peter Frederick Strawson, Paul Grice, and John Langshaw Austin. (Lewis returned to Oxford to deliver the John Locke Lectures in 1984.)
After graduating from Swarthmore in 1962, he went to Harvard University for his doctoral studies under Willard van Orman Quine. Lewis’s dissertation, revised to become his first book, Convention (1969), was partly a rehabilitation of the analytic-synthetic distinction in the face of Quine’s famous rejection of it. Lewis’s application of game theory to analyzing conventions, understood as coordination problems, was to some extent inspired by Thomas Schelling (a Harvard economics professor at the time), who had deployed game theory in his study of the strategy of conflict. Lewis was attracted to Nelson Goodman’s egalitarianism about properties and to Donald C. Williams’s four-dimensionalist approach to time, with its analogizing of time to space (and temporal parts to spatial parts). These figures were also fine philosophical writers, and as such they arguably served as models for Lewis, who went on to earn a reputation himself as a master of philosophical prose.
In 1963 Lewis befriended John J. C. Smart, who visited Harvard from Australia, consolidating Lewis as an “Australian materialist” regarding the mind, which meant that he believed that mental states are physical states— specifically, neurochemical states—that play certain causal roles. An argument for this position is expounded in his first publication, “An Argument for the Identity Theory” (1966). In Smart’s graduate seminar, Lewis met Stephanie Robinson, whom he married in 1965. Lewis’s friendship with Smart led to an ongoing connection with Australia and annual trips there for thirty years. David M.
Armstrong became a longtime friend and correspondent of Lewis’s, playing an important role in what Lewis later described as “a big turning point in my philosophical position”: recognizing the distinction between natural properties (such as “green”) and gerrymandered properties (such as “grue”).
Lewis was hired by the University of California at Los Angeles, working there from 1966 to 1970. The philosophy department was a hothouse for formal semantics, with colleagues such as Rudolf Carnap, Donald Kalish, Hans Kamp, Richard Montague, David Kaplan, and Barbara Hall Partee, whose collective influence can be discerned in some of Lewis’s early publications in the philosophy of language and philosophical logic. He began teaching at Princeton in 1971, where he was associate professor, then full professor from 1973, subsequently holding a series of endowed chairs. Richard Jeffrey’s Bayesian decision theory proved influential on Lewis, underpinning both his early work on interpretivism in the philosophy of mind and his later work on rational credence and decision.
Metaphilosophy . Lewis’s metaphilosophy is intertwined with his first-order philosophy. He takes seriously Quine’s maxim regarding ontological commitment—we should regard as existing everything over which we quantify in our best theories—and the pragmatism that underlies his related “indispensability” argument for mathematical objects. Shades of the indispensability argument are recognizable in the Lewisian doctrine that philosophical positions should be judged by how well their costs trade off against their benefits. Their costs are measured by the extent to which their consequences are unintuitive or in tension with our best science (including mathematics); their benefits are measured by their ability to systematize folk theory and the findings of science. But despite these fundamental regulative roles played by common sense and science, they are not to be deferred to unquestioningly. Like Carnapian explications, philosophical theories may not perfectly respect our pretheoretical judgments, and science itself (particularly quantum mechanics) may need further refinement. According to Lewis, then, philosophical analysis looks to folk theory, identifies the theoretical roles of target terms in this theory, and looks for the best “deservers” of those words—things in the world that best play the specified roles. To be sure, nothing may play these roles perfectly; but imperfect candidates may suffice for many philosophical purposes.
The best-systematization approach that Lewis exemplifies in his philosophical methodology resonates with some of his more specific philosophical positions. He analyzes laws of nature, for example, as the regularities that appear in the true theories of the universe that best balance simplicity and strength. Likewise, he contends that mental states should be attributed to others by balancing various standards for best interpreting their behavior.
The ghost of Carnapian positivism is found in Lewis’s thesis of Humean supervenience: “all there is to the world is a vast mosaic of local matters of particular fact.” The natural properties discovered by science (many familiar to common sense) are crucial here: everything is determined by the distribution of perfectly natural intrinsic properties of space-time points. Here again, Lewis’s metaphilosophy shades seamlessly into his philosophy proper.
Philosophical Positions . Lewis’s Quinean methodology yields some positions quite at odds with Quine’s. Applied to modality, it results in Lewis’s most notorious doctrine: his modal realism, as defended in On the Plurality of Worlds (1986). On this view, for each way that a world (universe) could be, there is a world that is that way—we may call these worlds concrete to emphasize that they are of a kind with our world, not merely abstract objects or linguistic entities. Our world is privileged only insofar as it is actual (for us); but worlds in which donkeys talk, or in which there are alien properties, are just as real as ours. Indeed, Lewis believes that gods exist in infinitely many worlds, even though our world happens to be godless! He argues that modal realism strikes the best overall balance of costs and benefits among philosophical accounts of modality. Its primary cost is its offense to common sense, enshrined in what he calls the “incredulous stare” objection. But this cost is more than offset by the manifold ways in which the doctrine is serviceable to philosophy, and that, Lewis insists, is a reason to believe that it is true. It provides elegant analyses of such philosophical bugbears as possibility and necessity, supervenience, counterfactuals, verisimilitude, mental content, and properties. Moreover, he maintains that these benefits cannot be realized as well by any rival philosophical theory—in particular, by any theory that offers some “ersatz” alternative to concrete possible worlds.
Many of Lewis’s specific philosophical positions can be fitted into a bravura chain of reductions or dependences. Several of them appeal to the notion of causation. For example, he regards things (objects, persons) that persist through time as consisting of temporal parts, typically united by causal continuity: later parts depend causally on earlier parts for their existence and nature. In the case of persisting persons, such causal dependence will be among psychological states. Psychological states underpin his analyses of conventions, as we find in languages—for example, semantic facts exist in virtue of the mutual expectations of members of a linguistic community. And psychological states, in turn, are definable as the occupants of certain causal roles. Beliefs and desires—or more generally, degrees of belief and degrees of desire, understood decision-theoretically—are analyzed in terms of their functional role. Perception is likewise defined in terms of appropriate causal relations between external scenes and an agent’s representations of them.
Causation, for its part, is analyzed by Lewis in terms of patterns of counterfactual dependence among events. Indeed, it was his concern to secure proper foundations for that analysis that prompted Lewis to write his book Counterfactuals (1973), a seminal work on the truth conditions and logic of conditionals that are typically expressed in the subjunctive mood—for example, “if kangaroos didn’t have tails, then they would topple over.” Lewis’s analysis of counterfactuals invokes relations of comparative similarity among possible worlds. Roughly, “if it were the case that X, it would be the case that Y” is true (at a given world “w”) if and only if there is a world in which X and Y are true that is more similar (to “w”) than any world in which X is true and Y false. Similarity of worlds is determined by closeness of match of matters of particular fact; the sharing of laws of nature is an important respect of such match, because they codify much information about what is true at the relevant worlds.
This brings us back to the worlds themselves. They are individuated by spatiotemporal connectedness: you and I are world-mates because we are spatiotemporally related to each other. But distinct possible worlds are isolated from each other, bearing no spatiotemporal relation to each other; likewise, parts of worlds, such as you and I, are isolated from parts of other worlds. Lewis infers from this that modal claims about individuals are made true by corresponding facts about counterparts of these individuals in other possible worlds, rather than by facts about the individuals themselves in these other worlds. “You could have been a movie star” is thus analyzed roughly as: There is a possible world in which a counterpart of yours— someone who plays a very similar role in that world to the one you play in the actual world—is a movie star.
Lewis’s views on other topics respect his broader philosophical commitments, especially to modal realism and to Humean supervenience. While his early work is concerned more with issues in the philosophy of language, philosophical logic, and the philosophy of mind, he moves in later work more towards metaphysics and (to a lesser extent) ethics-social philosophy, philosophy of mathematics, and epistemology. This essay closes with a quick overview of some further distinctive themes.
An integrated set of papers concerns probability and decision theory. Lewis regards opinion as coming in degrees—“credences”—and he follows Bayesians in modeling rational credences as subjective probabilities. These are constrained by the usual probability axioms, but Lewis adds a further principle that links one’s credences to one’s beliefs about corresponding objective chances. He provides a novel defense of a particular rule (conditionalization) for updating rational credences in the face of new evidence. He famously proves various “triviality results” against the equating of probabilities of conditionals with conditional probabilities. On the side of decision, Lewis offers a version of causal decision theory according to which rational decisions maximize expected utilities of actions, with probabilities and utilities assigned to various “dependency hypotheses” about how outcomes depend causally on one’s actions. He proves further “triviality results” against an anti-Humean thesis that decision-theoretically reduces “desires” to “beliefs” of a certain kind.
In metaethics, Lewis argues for a subjectivist position that portrays our values as those properties that we are disposed to desire to desire, when suitably apprehending them. He has a number of papers on more specific topics in social philosophy, including deterrence, punishment, and tolerance. Parts of Classes (1990) is an important contribution to the philosophy of mathematics, in which Lewis reduces set theory to mereology (the theory of the “part-whole” relation). In epistemology, his “Elusive Knowledge” (1996) is a groundbreaking work that gives a new analysis of “S knows that p,” accompanied by a detailed contextualist analysis of the pragmatics of knowledge ascriptions. And then there are many papers on sundry other topics: holes, properties, dispositions, truth, vagueness, fiction, quantum mechanics, and more.
Lewis’s work continues to be enormously influential, and often agenda-setting. He was renowned as a great teacher and supervisor. His sudden death in 2001, due to complications arising from many years of diabetes, ended a remarkable career.
The Lewis archive is in the care of his wife, and literary executor, Stephanie R. Lewis. There is a hope that the archive will be deposited someplace, but that has yet to be arranged. There is not much of Lewis’s work that is unpublished; efforts are in progress to see the remaining unpublished works into print. The major source of unpublished work by Lewis is in his correspondence—there are many hundreds of letters of philosophical import in his files. Ms. Lewis is working on publishing a series of volumes of Lewis’s correspondence.
WORKS BY LEWIS
“An Argument for the Identity Theory.” Journal of Philosophy 63 (1966): 17–25.
Convention: A Philosophical Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1969.
Counterfactuals. Oxford: Blackwell and Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1973.
On the Plurality of Worlds. Oxford and New York: Blackwell, 1986.
Parts of Classes. Oxford and New York: Blackwell, 1990.
“Elusive Knowledge.” Australasian Journal of Philosophy 74 (1996): 549–567.
Papers in Philosophical Logic. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Papers on Metaphysics and Epistemology. New York, and Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1999.
Papers in Ethics and Social Philosophy. New York, and Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
Jackson, Frank, and Graham Priest, eds. Lewisian Themes: The Philosophy of David K. Lewis. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2004.
Nolan, Daniel. David Lewis. Montreal: Acumen Publishing; and Kingston, Ontario: Chesham and McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2005.
O’Grady, Jane. “David Lewis: Princeton Philosopher Who Formulated Ground-Breaking Theories on Everything from Language to Identity to Alternative Worlds.” Guardian, 23 October 2001. Obituary. Available from http://books.guardian.co.uk/news/articles/0,6109,579258,00.html.
Career: Actor. Appeared in a print advertisement for Lincoln Financial Group, 2000.
Gimli manfolk and patient, Tales from the Gimli Hospital (also known as Gimli Saga and Pestilence), Circle Films, 1988.
Sissy Boy Slap Party, TVA Films, 1995.
Herb, Air Bud: Golden Receiver (also known as Air Bud 2 and Tobby 2: Receveur etoile), Dimension Films, 1998.
Stewart, Shoes Off! (short), AtomFilms, 1998.
Ian, Limp, 1999.
Walt Lawson, Lake Placid (also known as Lac Placid), Fox 2000, 1999.
Organist, MVP: Most Valuable Primate, Keystone Family Pictures, 2000.
Jeweler, D-Tox (also known as Eye See You and Im auge der angst), Universal, 2002.
Businessman, Liberty Stands Still (also known as Liberty stands still—Im visier des morders), Lions Gate Films, 2002.
Rick Cooper, Slap Shot 2: Breaking the Ice, Universal Home Entertainment, 2002.
Bob Green, Halloween: Resurrection, Miramax, 2002.
Jack Von Jarvis, K-9: P.I., Universal Home Video, 2002.
Andy, How It All Went Down, The Asylum, 2003.
Gerry, See Grace Fly, CineClix Distribution, 2003.
Mr. Ross, The Great Upstanding Member, Corus Entertainment, 2003.
Suit, Paycheck, Paramount, 2003.
Josh, White Chicks, Columbia, 2004.
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Warner Bros., 2004.
Mr. Crow, Edison, Nu Image, 2005.
Television Appearances; Series:
Kevin Mitchum, Hope Island, PAX, 1999.
Stu, John Doe, Fox, 2002–2003.
Television Appearances; Movies:
Marine pitcher, The Comrades of Summer, HBO, 1992.
Ranger, Love on the Run, NBC, 1994.
Frank Farr, Falling from the Sky: Flight 174 (also known as Freefall: Flight 174), ABC, 1995.
Officer, Beauty's Revenge (also known as Midwest Obsession), NBC, 1995.
Orderly, Abducted: A Father's Love (also known as Fugitive from Justice), NBC, 1996.
Dissident, Color Me Perfect, Lifetime, 1996.
Rick, A Child's Wish (also known as A Fight for Justice), CBS, 1997.
Officer number one, Breaking the Surface: The Greg Louganis Story, USA Network, 1997.
Ned Simon, Voyage of Terror (also known as Die schreckensfahrt der Orion Star and The Fourth Horseman), Family Channel, 1998.
Bruce, Every Mother's Worst Fear, USA Network, 1998.
Airplane security man number two, Loyal Opposition: Terror in the White House, Family Channel, 1998.
Ned Henderson, Fatal Error (also known as Reaper), TBS, 1999.
Danny Field, The Linda McCartney Story (also known as L'histoire de Linda McCartney), CBS, 2000.
Jack Beck, Special Delivery, Fox Family, 2000.
Joan's lawyer, The Wedding Dress, CBS, 2001.
Roger Sanderson, Jinnah—On Crime: Pizza 911, CBC, 2002.
Ira Denmark, Behind the Camera: The Unauthorized Story of "Three's Company," NBC, 2003.
Stan, Confessions of a Sociopathic Social Climber, Oxygen, 2005.
Behind the Camera: The Unauthorized Story of "Mork & Mindy," NBC, 2005.
Agent Johnson, Totally Awesome, VH1, 2006.
Television Appearances; Pilots:
Dave Romain, Dead Like Me, Showtime, 2003.
Television Appearances; Episodic:
Young officer, "The Jersey Devil," The X Files (also known as The X-Files), Fox, 1993.
"Roller Coaster!," Nova, PBS, 1993.
Vosberg, "Firewalker," The X Files (also known as The X-Files), Fox, 1994.
Young agent, "Oubliette," The X Files (also known as The X—Files), Fox, 1995.
Eric, "Can't Get No Satisfaction," Madison, Global, 1995.
Correspondent, Democracy in America '96, CNN, 1996.
Deputy, "Paradise," The Outer Limits (also known as The New Outer Limits), Showtime and syndicated, 1996.
Correspondent, Impact, CNN, 1997.
Billy, "Jump Vector," The Net, USA Network, 1998.
Oakridge, "Deja Vu," The Outer Limits (also known as The New Outer Limits), Showtime and syndicated, 1999.
FBI technician, "Collateral Damage," Millennium, Fox, 1999.
Red-headed man, "The Hunt," Da Vinci's Inquest, CBC, 1999.
Red-headed man, "The Capture," Da Vinci's Inquest, CBC, 1999.
Fruitcake, "Patches in the Sky," Lexx (also known as Lexx: The Series and Tales from a Parallel Universe), Sci-Fi Channel, 1999.
Arch Friggins, "A Just Reward," Dead Man's Gun, Showtime, 1999.
Justin Taylor, "A Price to Pay," Level 9, UPN, 2000.
"Judgement Day," Hollywood Off-Ramp, E! Entertainment Television, 2000.
Steve Carson, "Think Like a Dinosaur," The Outer Limits (also known as The New Outer Limits), Showtime and syndicated, 2001.
Derek, "Hostile Environment," Pasadena, Fox, 2001.
Dr. Marcus, "Calling," Smallville (also known as Smallville Beginnings and Smallville: Superman the Early Years), The WB, 2003.
Stemple, "Deja Voodoo," The Dead Zone (also known as Stephen King's "Dead Zone"), USA Network, 2003.
Officer Cooper, "Nine One One," Alienated, Space, 2003.
Curtis Connor, "Reunion," Tru Calling, Fox, 2004.
Dan, "Day 1,412," The Days, ABC, 2004.
Cameron Balinsky, "Heroes: Part 1," Stargate SG-1, Sci-Fi Channel, 2004.
Cameron Balinsky, "Moebius: Part 1," Stargate SG-1, Sci-Fi Channel, 2005 Woodland, Criminal Minds, CBS, 2005.
Also appeared as Derek, "The Truth Hurts," Pasadena, Fox.
LEWIS, DAVID (1909–1981), Canadian lawyer and socialist politician. Lewis was born in Svisloch, Belorussia. His father, Morris, was an active member of the *Bund and maintained his involvement after the family immigrated to Montreal in 1921. In 1931 Lewis earned a B.A. from McGill and won a Rhodes scholarship to Oxford, where he became president of the Oxford Union. On his return to Montreal he was admitted to the Quebec Bar and became a founder of the largely western-based social democratic Cooperative Commonwealth Federation (ccf). He became the party's national secretary in 1936 and for many years the party's sole paid employee. Through the 1940s he ran for a seat in the House of Commons but was defeated on each occasion. In a 1943 by-election in Montreal's Cartier riding he lost to Fred *Rose, who became Canada's first and only Communist member of Parliament.
Lewis resigned as national secretary of the ccf in 1950 and moved to Toronto to practice law. He became legal advisor to several major unions including the United Steel Workers of America's Canadian division, and assisted the union in its battles with the Communist-led Mine, Mill union. But he also remained active in the ccf. He was successively vice chairman, chairman, and president of the ccf. He also helped organize the New Democratic Party (ndp), the more urban-based successor to the ccf, and in 1962 won a seat in the House of Commons for the ndp in a Toronto riding and represented the ndp in Parliament from 1965 to 1974. In 1971 he was chosen leader of the ndp, the first Jewish leader of a major Canadian political party, and in the 1972 election became head of the 31-member ndp caucus which held the balance of power between the governing Liberals and the opposition Conservatives. He propped up the Liberals, holding them to a very progressive legislative agenda. Lewis was defeated in the 1974 election and stepped down as ndp leader and took up a teaching post at Carleton University in Ottawa.
Lewis was active in Jewish affairs and was vice president of the Jewish Labor Committee of Canada, sat on several Canadian Jewish Congress committees, and was on the board of the Canadian Council of Christians and Jews. Although raised in a Bundist home, Lewis warmed to Zionism and the State of Israel after the Holocaust. He helped forge good relations between the Canadian labour movement and Israel. Lewis was honored with the Order of Canada, Canada's highest civilian award.
D. Lewis, The Good Fight: Political Memoirs, 1909–1958 (1981); C. Smith, Unfinished Business: The Lewis Family (1989).
[Ben G. Kayfetz]