The Crowd

views updated


USA, 1928

Director: King Vidor

Production: Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer Pictures Corp.; black and white, 35mm, silent with music score; running time: about 93 minutes; length: 9 reels, 8538–8548 feet. Released 3 March 1928.

Producer: King Vidor; scenario: King Vidor, John V.A. Weaver and Harry Behn; titles: Joseph Farnham; photography: Henry Sharp;editor: Hugh Wynn; production designers: Cedric Gibbons and Arnold Gillespie.

Cast: Eleanor Boardman (Mary); James Murray (John); Bert Roach (Bert); Estelle Clark (Jane); Daniel G. Tomlinson (Jim); Dell Henderson (Dick); Lucy Beaumont (Mother); Freddie Burke Frederick (Junior); Alice Mildred Puter (Daughter).



Vidor, King, A Tree Is a Tree, New York, 1953; revised edition, 1977.

Brownlow, Kevin, The Parade's Gone By, New York, 1968.

Baxter, John, King Vidor, New York, 1976.

Comuzio, Ermanno, King Vidor, Florence, 1986.

Durgnat, Raymond, and Scott Simmon, King Vidor—American, Berkeley, 1988.

Vidor, King, King Vidor, Lanham, Maryland, 1988.


New York Times, 20 February 1928.

Variety (New York), 22 February 1928.

Cheatham, M., interview with Vidor, in Motion Picture Classic (New York), June 1928.

Mulligan, W. E., "Work of King Vidor," in National Review (New York), July 1928.

Troy, W., "Collectivism More or Less," in Nation (New York), 24 October 1934.

Brownlow, Kevin, "King Vidor," in Film (London), Winter 1962.

Thomas, John, in AFFS Newsletter (New York), November 1964.

Higham, Charles, "King Vidor," in Film Heritage (Dayton, Ohio), Summer 1966.

"King Vidor at NYU: Discussion," in Cineaste (New York), Spring 1968.

Schonert, Vernon, "James Murray," in Films in Review (New York), December 1968.

Luft, Herbert G., "A Career That Spans Half a Century," in Film Journal (New York), Summer 1971.

Durgnat, Raymond, in Film Comment (New York), July-August 1973.

"Vidor Issue" of Positif (Paris), September 1974.

Vidor, King, "L'Acteur," in Positif (Paris), December-January 1978.

Ellis, M., "Crowd Music," in Sight and Sound (London), Autumn 1981.

Allen, W., "King Vidor and The Crowd," in Stills (London), Winter 1982.

Cinema e Cinema (Venice), January-April 1985.

Bush, G. W., "Like 'A Drop of Water in the Stream of Life': Moving Images of Mass Man from Griffith to Vidor," in Journal of American Studies (New York), no. 2, 1991.

Rhodes, C., "Filling the Void: Work and the Modern Subject in King Vidor's The Crowd," in Studies in the Humanities, vol. 20, no. 2, 1993.

Klopcic, M., "Mnozica," in Ekran (Ljubljana) no. 3/4, 1993.

* * *

King Vidor's career wavered between the lure of romantic, erotic melodrama and the stricter morality of his Christian Science background. After three John Gilbert vehicles, including the popular The Big Parade, Vidor was able to sell MGM on a bleak, expressionist urban tragedy of the sort made fashionable by the novels of Sinclair Lewis, Theodore Dreiser, and John Dos Passos. Other studios, notably Fox, already enjoyed considerable success in this area due to their importation of German and Austrian directors like Murnau and Dupont. MGM, committed to a policy of mainly Scandinavian recruitment, lacked such experts in relentless art of the "city film." Vidor persuaded Irving Thalberg to permit this single excursion into the field by offering to produce "The Big Parade of peace"—clearly a strategem, since The Crowd is as cynical and relentless as his World War I romantic drama was soft-centered and sentimental.

The Crowd is a remarkable aberration to come from the optimistic, cheerful MGM machine, mocking as it does American fictions of self-advancement and ambition. John Sims's birth on July 4th, 1900, is greeted with elation by his father. "He's a little man the world's going to hear from," he crows. But social circumstances, Vidor points out, guide our life from childhood. John's schoolboy friends already have their careers mapped out for them, especially the black boy who boasts in comic minstrel patter of the time "I detend to be a preacher man. Hallelujah!"

No less a social stereotype, John is forced by his father's early death to join the crowd who fill the streets of New York. "You've got to be good in that town if you want to beat the crowd," remarks a gaunt stranger as John watches the skyline from a ferry. As a huge office building swallows up the young Sims, we realize he has become another victim of the city, subject to its whims, threatened by its pressures.

John's early enthusiasm for city life, fuelled by visits to Coney Island, an early marriage and the unexpected windfall of a $500 slogan-writing contest prize, is crushed by the random death of his child, then unemployment and a slide to the humiliation of selling vacuum cleaners door to door, until he becomes a juggling sandwich-board man—a character seen before and mocked by Sims, but who returns like the clown in The Blue Angel as a memento mori. Interfering relatives nearly destroy Sims's marriage, but the love of his son saves him from a suicide attempt and he's finally reunited with his wife. "The crowd laughs with you always," warns a title, "but it will cry with you for only a day."

Vidor tried seven endings before shooting one incorporating this bleak moral. Sims and his family visit a vaudeville show, and are last seen howling at the antics of two clowns, swallowed in a mindless laughing crowd.

Always attracted by expressionism and stylisation, Vidor exercised his penchant for both in The Crowd. Characters seem swallowed by their environment; the office building where John works (actually a model) is one of thousands in the city, and the camera zooms in through a window, apparently at random, to choose him, just another wage slave in an office of identical desks reaching in forced perspective to infinity. Earlier in the film, when John hears of his father's death, Vidor creates a vision of his threatened status by placing the boy on a staircase constructed against a distorted impression of a corridor actually painted on the back wall of the set. John, sustained by a relative, seems to hover between the inquisitive crowd huddled around the doorway and a threatening, unknown future.

James Murray, a minor featured performer (and not, as Vidor claimed, an extra) superbly conveys the feckless, ukelele-plucking John Sims mindlessly letting the world carry him along. (He was never to be offered work of this standard again, and drowned in the Hudson River in 1936; used to his gagging, watchers thought he was joking and failed to attempt a rescue.) Eleanor Boardman, later Vidor's wife, is an effective support.

But, as in all "city films," the individuals are dwarfed by an unfeeling capitalist society. Vidor emphasises this isolation in the film's most striking images; trying to quiet the crowd to soothe his dying child, Sims sets himself against the hurrying mob, hands thrust out, eyes blind; clocks dictate the coming and going of the city people with a relentless Langian power; even the couple's honeymoon is dwarfed by the torrent of Niagara plunging past the ledge on which they sit. A mis-step and it will carry them away.

Thalberg was alarmed at the bleak vision Vidor presented to him. The film was delayed for a year, and released to respectful reviews but little profit. Vidor went straight on to two Marion Davies comedies for William Randolph Hearst's Cosmopolitan Pictures, then based on the MGM lot. It was not until An American Romance that he had a chance to deal with the larger quasi-political issues he addressed in The Crowd, and by then the moment had passed.

—John Baxter