Sectarianism

views updated

Sectarianism

Sources

Sectarian Impulse. The revolutionary era saw the beginnings of a more diverse religious society than America or Europe had ever known. The basis of the religious pluralism of the United States today lay in the new religious movements of the 1770s and 1780s. Even earlier, groups of revivalists had broken away from the established churches of New England and the Chesapeake Bay area to form new religious communities. But these groups of Virginia Baptists or New Light Congregationalists did not reject the basic Calvinist theology that most English settlers had brought with them to the New World. During the revolutionary years a few new groups made a more radical attack on those Calvinist premises. In doing this they exhibited one of the most common features of Protestantism, the tendency of some people to break away from the dominant church and form a new group, or sect. This sectarian impulse had its roots in the Protestant belief that all individuals are able to read and interpret the Bible for themselves. This belief made the formation of new, individualized religious groups possible. In addition the lack of central authority in Calvinism made it difficult to control the possibility of new, unorthodox

beliefs developing as people thought for themselves about religion. In colonial America religion was primarily congregational, even in the South, where Anglicanism was established, since there were no bishops or other strong central authorities. It is no surprise then, that sectarianism took hold.

Social Factors. Sectarianism is often linked to social disruption, something else that early America had in abundance. The revivals of the Great Awakening and the years after were just one sign of the social tensions that could be expressed in religious forms. Opponents of the revivals, such as Boston minister Charles Chauncy, complained about the disruptive forces let loose on society by the revivals, which they feared radically undermined the social order. In the 1770s, as the war spread through the colonies, there were other challenges to settled life, creating the conditions for new religious experiences and developments. One case occurred in rural New England. During the war years many people moved away from the coastal areas, where the danger of attack was great, into the relatively undeveloped interior areas of what is today Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, and western Massachusetts. Here they experienced the privations of life on a frontier, as they struggled to clear land, start farms, and build a new society. These unsettled people also experienced one of the periodic episodes of religious revival that marked eighteenth-century life. As early as 1778 western and northern New England began to exhibit the signs of a significant religious revival, which came to be known as the New Light Stir. The New Light Stir continued into the mid 1780s, as the Baptists came to dominate the area and displace the Congregationalists as the leading denomination.

New Sects. The Baptists were the main beneficiaries of the New Light Stir, which was thus part of that group’s longer-term growth across America. Yet some settlers in these areas developed even more-radical positions on religion, and at least three groups sprang up that had a lasting influence on American religion despite their relatively small size. In each case the unsettled conditions of life on the frontier led a visionary leader to develop a more radical view of religion and society. These groups rejected many traditional Christian beliefs in favor of a variety of new thoughts about the Bible, God, and the end of the world. In doing this they also reconsidered the way society should be organized, and in this respect they were participating in the main social project of the revolutionary era and helping to frame the new nation. Socially and politically this area became a hotbed of anti-Federalist feeling, home to the people most suspicious of schemes of big government and organized economic development. The religious parallel was a highly individualized spiritualism, emphasizing the direct access of believers to God. Many people considered this to be a clear challenge to more-traditional religious institutions and to the society those institutions upheld.

Shakers. Probably the best known today of these new groups was the Shakers, or the Believers in Christ’s Second Appearing, as they called themselves. The Shakers began in England as an enthusiastic offshoot of a group of Quakers. They got their name from the shaking they experienced when moved by the spirit during worship. The Shakers came to America in 1774, when a group led by Ann Lee arrived in New York. Lee’s spirituality had become increasingly intense over the course of a difficult life that included sickness, unhappy marriage, and even prison. She turned to increasingly radical ideas about God, ideas that she continued to develop in America. In 1776 Lee led her small group of followers to the village of Niskeyuna in the hill country north of Albany, New York. The group began to recruit converts from the area and from northern New England and slowly grew. Lee preached enthusiastically about the coming end of the world and encouraged her followers to establish a new society to prepare for the final judgment. That new society included sexual purity and the public confession of

sin and then the taking up of a reformed, simpler life. Eventually, Lee came to believe that the judgment day had already come and that Christ had returned to earth in her own body. The Shakers came to consider Lee the embodiment of sinless perfection and as Christ’s fulfillment in a female counterpart. As recruits arrived, Lee began to envision a community organized on her principles, where all members would be celibate and share their goods and lives equally and peacefully. Lee’s doctrine of pacifism combined with news of this radical lifestyle to get the attention of the authorities in Albany. In July 1780 she and six other Shakers were jailed as “enemies to the country.” Lee was released the following December and in 1781 started a tour of New England that extended over two years. By that time the Shakers were beginning to establish their first settlements where they could live apart from the world and pursue their lives in their distinctive style while they awaited the fulfillment of the millennial visions Lee had found inspiration for in the Bible. The first lasting Shaker village was in New Lebanon, New York, founded in 1785. It was the model for Shaker towns that would dot New England and New York in the coming decades and that can still be visited today.

Universalists. The Universalists did not take up celibacy or believe that the end of the world had already come, but their faith that God had saved all humans from damnation was just as radical, in the context of the time. Unlike other sects, the Universalists had a presence in urban areas as well as on the frontier. English revivalist John Murray arrived in New Jersey on 21 July 1770 after being awakened to God by revivals in his home country. He became an itinerant preacher and soon became well known in the coastal towns of the Middle colonies and in New England. In 1775, following the logic of his own reading of the Scripture and of the revivalists’ emphasis on the free acceptance of God that was potentially available to all, he publicly took up Universalism. In 1779 he established one of the earliest American Universalist congregations in Gloucester, Massachusetts. He persevered in his ministry despite being at times arrested, stoned by mobs, and threatened with deportation. His influence extended mainly to city dwellers, especially those already drawn to the ideas about human nature and the benevolent deity that were attractive to people there in touch with the latest European thinking.

Rural Growth. At the same time in the New England backcountry, a homegrown version of Universalism was taking hold, again as an outgrowth of the revivals. There three prophetic men led the way, Isaac Davis, Adams Streeter, and Caleb Rich. Davis preached in the Connecticut River valley, honing in on the story of how Christ’s suffering and death atoned for the sin of Adam once and for all. As early as 1775 a number of Davisonians withdrew to form a Universalist congregation in Oxford, Massachusetts. Adams may have been influenced by Davis, as he passed from being a Separate Congregationalist, then a Baptist, to finally a Universalist, taking over Davis’s leadership role. Rich had the widest influence of the three. Long-term religious conflict in his family in the 1760s and early 1770s led Rich to a series of visions, in which a “still small voice” led him to accept Universalist principles, and an angel presented him with biblical texts with which to instruct others. Rich was attacked as a heretic by his Baptist neighbors, but in 1773 he and a few others formed a separate religious society and started attracting new members. Further visions of angels and even of Christ himself in 1778 pushed Rich to an even more radical position, as he now came to preach about the imminent end of the world as well. Rich was also impressed by Christ’s easy manner with him during his vision, which emphasized the dignity of all humans since all had been saved equally, and he began to add a call for egalitarianism to his ministry as well.

Freewill Baptists. This group traced its start to the death of George Whitefield, the English evangelist of the Great Awakening. Whitefield’s death in 1770 greatly moved Benjamin Randel, who had heard Whitefield preach a week before and had found him a “worthless, noisy fellow.” Changing his first opinion while thinking of Whitefield in heaven and himself on the way to hell, Randel fell into a spiritual despair that ended with a profound experience of a new birth through the spirit. He continued to struggle with his faith, which he felt needed to be stricter, and in 1776 became a Baptist. He became an itinerant preacher and faced stonings, mobbings, and other abuses for his increasingly radical ideas. A failed attempt to settle at a church in New Hampshire led to another period of doubt and further revelations from God, who demanded even greater efforts to purity from Randel. The visions he had while praying in a cornfield in 1779 led him to reject family and congregation in favor of itinerant preaching. He spoke about the coming judgment day, about the need for Christian perfection, and most importantly about the free will humans had to accept Christ. This last point especially was a departure from the orthodox Calvinism of the Congregationalists and Baptists of the area. Randel faced down the opposition with a complete reliance on God. “I makes no odds with he who disowns me,” he said, “so long as I know the Lord owns me.” The first Randelite congregation formed in Strafford, New Hampshire, in August 1780, and the sect grew over the next two decades to become one of the largest groups on the Northern frontier, with more than 150 congregations by 1815.

NEWPORT’S SYNAGOGUE

There were probably only about 1,000 Jews in revolutionary America. Despite their small numbers, they were beginning to make their presence felt. They were also feeling the pressures of needing to acculturate to a Christian society, something that burdened the American Jewish community well into the twentieth century. One of the most important early communities was in Newport, Rhode Island. Drawn by the colony’s tradition of religious freedom, the first Jews arrived there in the 1680s. Most successfully participated in the shipping and commerce of this important port city. By 1763 Congregationalist Ezra Stiles counted 15 Jewish families, with about 80 individuals. That number had grown to about 125 by 1774. The Newport Jews mostly came from the Mediterranean area, although by the Revolution some had arrived from Germany. In 1763 the community dedicated their first permanent home, a building today called the Touro Synagogue, named in honor of Isaac Touro, the lay leader of the group. The synagogue was designed by Peter Harrison, who had earlier designed the home of Newport’s Redwood Library, one of America’s first private libraries. Harrison gave the community a synagogue in the Palladian style, then popular in England. The building was elegantly proportioned, symmetrically arranged, and detailed with classical elements. The interior was modeled after the synagogue of a wealthy London community and while arranged in the traditional form also conformed to the neoclassical style. The building captured the desire of this community to be true to their distinct heritage, as well as to conform to the standards of their Christian neighbors. The balance the Newport Jewish community tried to strike between their past and America’s future was precarious and short lived, however. Many of the Jews sided with the British during the war, drawn to them through the commercial connections of their families. The long British occupation of Newport and the eventual American victory were serious blows to the Jewish community. By the early 1800s the community had completely collapsed.

Source: Eli Faber, A Time for Planting: The First Migration, 1654–1820 (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992), pp. 84–88.

Shared Characteristics. None of these groups was ever large or long lived, although a few Shakers still survive today. Yet their experiences have been a model for many Americans of later times. The sectarian impulse has emerged repeatedly in American history, sometimes in tiny movements that soon disappear and sometimes in movements that result in huge new religions, such as the Mormons. All of these movements have some of the elements that were shared by these three original American sects. They were each founded by a charismatic leader, one who had visions and was able to translate them into preaching that excited others to follow them. The death of these leaders created problems in how to carry on the group, which in each case involved giving the sect a more carefully considered set of beliefs and practices that could be taught to others in an organized way. Other characteristics made stability hard to achieve. The sects placed no restrictions on lay preaching, which left them open to new ideas and influences that clergy trained in seminaries or colleges would never have entertained. Many of the people joining sects were people who moved from one religious group to another frequently throughout their lives, always searching for a more perfect expression of their ideas about God. Sects drew converts from all levels of society, although in the revolutionary period they were much less prominent in the coastal cities. The notion of a pure community and the emphasis on sin and repentance was often at the forefront of sectarianism. Because of this, such groups tended to withdraw from the wider world, as the Shakers did, and form communities of their own with limited exposure to the profane ways of others. In these separate places sectarians were free to pursue an ideal world that would be a heaven on earth. These perfectionist communities often brought larger social conflicts to the surface, as they divided existing churches and even families and challenged the existing social and religious order. Emotions often ran high in these communities, founded as they were on intensely personal experiences of God’s spirit. In this sense many sects had close ties to the evangelical Protestantism that was the heart of American religion in the nineteenth century even if many sects were extreme versions of tendencies within the larger denominations. Part of that extreme behavior was linked to a prevalent feeling in many sects that the end of the world was at hand. Such dire circumstances called for extreme expressions of reform and love and contributed as well to the willingness of many to reject the world.

Dissent. Finally sectarianism drew on at least one important aspect of American religion that has become a cherished part of our national identity. This is the tradition of religious dissent. Ann Lee, John Murray, Caleb Rich, and Benjamin Randel each departed from the mainstream of American religious thought and practice. Being an outsider was a basic part of their religious identity and of the identity of the groups they formed. Over the years since, strong individuals who stand up for what they believe is right against all opposition have become important symbols of American culture. Dissent is also an important means by which religion has developed in America, as freethinkers such as these sectarians have broken away from old traditions to start new ones with greater meaning for their own times. These people struggled against the opposition of their neighbors to find a way to express their ideas about God that were relevant to the unsettled conditions of life in revolutionary-era America. This process is so fundamental to American society that after the end of the Revolution, it became embedded in the First Amendment to the Constitution, which protected dissent by guaranteeing freedom of speech and freedom of religion.

Sources

Stephen A. Marini, Radical Sects of Revolutionary New England (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1982);

Sidney E. Mead, The Lively Experiment (New York: Harper & Row, 1963);

R. Laurence Moore, Religious Outsiders and the Making of Americans (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986);

Stephen J. Stein, The Shaker Experience in America (New Haven, Conn.: Yale University Press, 1992).

More From encyclopedia.com

About this article

Sectarianism

Updated About encyclopedia.com content Print Article

Related Content

NEARBY TERMS

Sectarianism