Westernizers

views updated

WESTERNIZERS

The Westernizers (zapadniki) were a loosely organized group of Russian intellectuals, who from the late 1830s to the mid-1850s engaged the Slavophiles (slavianofily) in a bitter debate about Russia's past, its national identity, and its probable future. The trigger for this debate was Petr Chaadayev's "First Philosophical Letter" (written 1828, published 1836), which charged that Russians, cut off from the Roman Catholic Church and therefore from the living source of European civilization, were "orphans with one foot in the air" who had contributed nothing to the world. Stung to the quick, the Slavophiles defended the Orthodox Church and Old Russian social forms and folk traditions as superior to the religious, social, and political institutions of the "rotten," "barbarous" West. In response, the Westernizers claimed either that Russia had always been a member of the European community of nations or that Russia, in spite of its peculiar origins, was gradually becoming Europeanized and would eventually join the West as an equal partner in the civilized community of nations. Aside from their role in this pivotal debate, the Westernizers were significant in another regard: they contributed to the birth of a distinctively Russian agrarian socialism—the genesis of Russian anarchism and liberalism. Their tiny group was the intellectual seedbed of progressive politics in mid-nineteenth-century Russia.

It is customary to divide the Westernizers into two smaller groups. The moderate Westernizers included the historians Timofei Granovsky (1813–1855) and Sergei Soloviev (1820–1879), the legal expert Konstantin Kavelin (1818–1885), and the jurist Boris Chicherin (1828–1904). Sometimes the literary critic Pavel Annenkov (1813–1887) and the novelist Ivan Turgenev (1818–1883) are also added to the list of moderates. The radical Westernizers included the literary critic Vissarion Belinsky (1811–1848), the great memoirist Alexander Herzen (1812–1870), and the future anarchist Mikhail Bakunin (1814–1876).

As a historian of medieval and early modern Europe, Granovsky traced the development of centralized states, representative governments, and educated civil societies in the West. His university lectures strongly implied that Russian history had belatedly followed the Western pattern of social evolution, so that contemporary Russians could see their future in Europe's immediate past. Soloviev's classical History of Russia from Ancient Times (published in twenty-eight volumes from 1851 to 1879) argued that Russia, like the West, had gradually moved from an association of tribes to a modern state, based on common religious and political values and ruled by an enlightened government. Although he thought that Peter the Great (r. 1682–1725) had contributed much to this development, Soloviev saw Peter and other Europeanizers as organic products of a Russian past that from time immemorial had begun slowly converging with the West. Kavelin emphasized the slow development in Russia of abstract ideas (such as duty to the state, citizenship, and the rule of law) crucial to the appearance of a modern Europeanized polity. In his 1847 essay "An Analysis of Juridical Life in Ancient Russia," he pointed to the complete development of the free individual (lichnost) as the final goal of Russian history. Chicherin, younger by a generation than other moderates, used their insights into Russian history and law as the basis of a liberal political program. In his essay "Contemporary Tasks of Russian Life" (1855), he made the case for the abolition of serfdom, freedom of conscience and the press, and an independent court system. Annenkov and Turgenev wrote memoirs chronicling the Westernizer–Slavophile debate from perspectives agreeable to the Westernizers. Turgenev's early fiction, especially A Sportsman's Sketches (1852), contributed to the abolition of serfdom by showing Russian serfs as sympathetic human beings. Russian contemporaries and subsequent scholars (including Isaiah Berlin and Leonard Schapiro) regarded Turgenev as a Westernizer and moderate liberal.

Among the radical Westernizers the leader was Belinsky, who contended in the article "Russia before Peter the Great" (1842) that only Peter's forceful intervention in backward, semibarbarous Russia had made it possible for Russia to join the community of civilized nations. According to Belinsky, Peter was "a god who breathed a living soul into the colossal, sleeping body of ancient Russia." Belinsky's "Letter to Gogol" (1847) lamented Russian religious oppression and the existence of serfdom, and pointed to Russian writers' moral responsibility to expose injustice. Belinsky had no patience with the Slavophiles' apologies for pre-Petrine Russia or for their religious "obscurantism." Bakunin's polemic against conservatism, "The Reaction in Germany" (1842), was a thinly veiled call for social revolution in the name of a "new religion of humanity." By the late 1840s both Bakunin and Herzen had come to believe that Russia might actually precede the West in inaugurating social justice, if only the peasant commune could be emancipated, peacefully or forcefully, from governmental interference. Herzen's "The Russian People and Socialism" (1851) made the case for the Russian commune as socialist ideal. Subsequently, Bakunin achieved fame as a revolutionary Pan-Slav and as the apostle of Russian anarchism in Europe. Herzen achieved renown as the "father of Russian socialism."

See alsoBakunin, Mikhail; Belinsky, Vissarion; Chaadayev, Peter; Herzen, Alexander; Intelligentsia; Russia; Slavophiles; Soloviev, Vladimir; Turgenev, Ivan.

bibliography

Berlin, Isaiah. Russian Thinkers. New York, 1978.

Copleston, Frederick C. Philosophy in Russia: From Herzen to Lenin and Berdyaev. Tunbridge Wells, U.K., 1986.

Edie, James M., James P. Scanlan, and Mary-Barbara Zeldin, eds. Russian Philosophy. Vol. 1: The Beginnings of Russian Philosophy: The Slavophiles; The Westernizers. Chicago, 1965.

Hamburg, G. M. Boris Chicherin and Early Russian Liberalism, 1828–1866. Stanford, Calif., 1992.

Walicki, Andrzej. A History of Russian Thought from the Enlightenment to Marxism. Translated by Hilda Andrews-Rusiecka. Stanford, Calif., 1979.

G. M. Hamburg

More From encyclopedia.com

About this article

Westernizers

Updated About encyclopedia.com content Print Article

Related Content

NEARBY TERMS

Westernizers