Samuel
SAMUEL
SAMUEL (twelfth century bce), or, in Hebrew, Shemuʾel, was a judge and prophet of Israel. The story of Samuel's birth and the account of his youth present him as a Nazirite, dedicated to God's service through his mother's vow and raised in the sanctuary at Shiloh to be a priest (1 Sm. 1–2). While still a youth in this priestly service he is called to be a prophet to deliver a message of judgment to the house of Eli, and in one scene (1 Sm. 19:18–24) he appears as the head of an ecstatic band of prophets and the protector of David in his flight from Saul. The prophetic role predominates in the rest of the narratives about him. In addition, however, Samuel is considered by the author of 1 Samuel to be a judge and is included in his scheme of a succession of judges—charismatic leaders—who ruled in Israel before the rise of the monarchy (1 Sm. 7:15–17, Jgs. 2:16–19). As such Samuel is depicted as a transitional figure, the last of the old order and the one who consecrates the new. This variety of roles in the tradition makes it difficult to reconstruct his historical role in early Israelite society.
The story of Samuel's birth follows a common folktale pattern of explaining a hero's name and future destiny from the circumstances of his birth. Yet because the story seems to involve a wordplay upon the name Saul (see Ackroyd, 1971 and McCarter, 1980) it has often been taken as a story about the birth of Saul that was later transferred to Samuel. The difficulty with this view is that none of the story's details fits with Saul's known origins, nor does the birth announcement presage a royal destiny. Instead, the announcement leads directly into the account of Samuel's youth, so that 1 Samuel 1–3 must be taken together. In this vita of Samuel's birth, dedication, and prophetic calling, the historian marks out Samuel as one of the major figures of his history.
In 1 Samuel 7, Samuel is a spokesman of religious reform, calling the people to repentance. At the same time, as judge he saves the people from their enemies, not by feats of military prowess but by intercessory prayer and sacrifice. When the people raise with Samuel their desire for a king to replace the institution of judgeship (1 Sm. 8), the author of the book uses the speeches of Samuel to express his own feelings of ambivalence about the monarchy, both as a source of social and religious sins (1 Sm. 8, 12) and as a divinely instituted political order (1 Sm. 10:17–27, 11:12–15).
In the folktale of Saul's search for his father's donkeys (1 Sm. 9–10:16) Samuel is only a local seer with clairvoyant powers. But the historian has transformed his role by adding an account of the secret anointment of Saul by Samuel, identifying him as the divinely chosen king in anticipation of his later public acclamation. In a similar fashion, Samuel anoints David (1 Sm. 16:1–13) and thus assures his destiny.
Samuel is also a prophet of judgment to Saul. The scene of Saul's secret anointment is linked directly to an act of disobedience in which Samuel announces God's rejection of Saul's kingship in favor of another, David (1 Sm. 13:8–15; cf. 1 Sm. 10:8). In a second episode (1 Sm. 15), in which Samuel commands Saul to exterminate the Amalekites, Samuel again declares God's rejection of Saul, this time for not completely carrying out all of the prophet's instructions; this episode leads directly to the account of the secret anointment of David as Saul's replacement. This rejection scene also anticipates the final episode of Samuel's appearance, as a ghost (1 Sm. 28), at which point rejection is reinforced and Saul's imminent death along with that of his sons is predicted.
Bibliography
Two important studies that deal with major parts of the Samuel tradition are Bruce C. Birch's The Rise of the Israelite Monarchy: The Growth and Development of 1 Samuel 7–15 (Missoula, Mont., 1976) and Artur Weiser's Samuel: Seine geschichtliche Aufgabe und religiöse Bedeutung (Göttingen, 1962). Two helpful commentaries are Peter R. Ackroyd's The First Book of Samuel, "The Cambridge Bible Commentary" (Cambridge, 1971), and P. Kyle McCarter, Jr.'s I Samuel, vol. 8 of the Anchor Bible (Garden City, N.Y., 1980). See also my book In Search of History: Historiography in the Ancient World and the Origins of Biblical History (New Haven, 1983).
New Sources
Brenner, Althalya, ed. Samuel and Kings. Sheffield, U.K., 2000.
Dietrich, Walter. Samuel. Neukirchen-Vluyen, 2003.
Evans, Mary J. 1 and 2 Samuel. Peabody, Mass., and Carlisle, U.K., 2000.
John van Seters (1987)
Revised Bibliography
