Whistleblowing

views updated

WHISTLEBLOWING

The origin of the term whistleblowing is uncertain. It may refer to English policemen blowing whistles to alert others to an illegal act or to sports referees stopping a game due to a rule infraction. The term began to be used in a way relevant to science, technology, and ethics in the 1960s and became part of the common vocabulary as a result of Ralph Nader's investigative activities during the 1970s. The American Heritage Dictionary defines a whistleblower as "one who reveals wrongdoing within an organization to the public or to those in positions of authority," but a more detailed analysis of the term is appropriate.


Analysis of the Concept

Based on the above definition, it is possible to distinguish between internal and external whistleblowing. Internal whistleblowing occurs when the hierarchical chain of command within an organization is violated, so that one's immediate superiors are bypassed, perhaps because they have refused to act or are themselves involved in the wrongdoing. The whistleblowing is internal, however, because it stays within the organization. External whistleblowing refers to going outside the organization, possibly to a regulatory agency, the press, or directly to the public. The philosophical literature often restricts the use of the term to external whistle-blowing, but the media typically use it in both senses.

A further distinction may be made between open and anonymous whistleblowing. The former means that the identity of the whistleblower is known, while such identity remains unknown in the latter. Anonymous whistleblowing is generally considered to be less effective, because it is more easily ignored and because no follow-up with the whistleblower is possible. Organizations have also shown themselves willing to devote significant resources to discover the identity of anonymous whistleblowers, a task made easier by the limited number of individuals who typically have access to the information being revealed. At the same time, whistle-blowers often want to hide their identities because of possible reprisals from their organizations or colleagues.

The idea of wrongdoing also requires clarification. Generally not every wrongdoing is considered to be a legitimate subject for whistleblowing. The wrongdoing must entail serious harm, whether physical, psychological, or financial. Depending on the particular philosophical perspective, the notion of harm might be extended to situations where human beings are only indirectly affected, such as through damage to the environment. Serious harm is considered to be the appropriate criterion in that whistleblowing itself is an act which that tends to harm the parties involved and thus requires a balancing of outcomes.

Finally, although omitted in the popular definition, whistleblowers need to be insiders, that is, either currently or formerly associated with the organization on which they are blowing the whistle. Outsiders might be considered spies, investigative reporters, or moles, but not whistleblowers. Whistleblowing must involve a conflict of loyalties, between the duty of loyalty to an organization and duties to the public or to a principle. For an infiltrator, no such duty of loyalty to the organization exists. It should be noted, however, that whistleblowers often do not perceive themselves as being disloyal, especially in instances of internal whistleblowing, but believe they are working for the long-term organizational good.


Ethical Perspectives

From the perspective of ethics, whistleblowers are faced with deciding whether breaking the bond of loyalty is justified in a particular circumstance. The philosopher Richard DeGeorge proposed the classic criteria for justifying whistleblowing; most other criteria are a reaction to his formulation. DeGeorge argues that external whistleblowing is morally permissible if three conditions are met: (a) substantial harm will be done to persons; (b) the immediate superior is made aware of the problem; and (c) the chain of command of the organization is exhausted. DeGeorge contends that whistleblowing is morally obligatory if two additional conditions are met: (d) enough documented evidence is available to the whistleblower to convince an impartial individual; and (e) the whistleblower has a justified belief that the wrongdoing will be corrected as a result of going public.

A number of critiques have been leveled against DeGeorge's criteria, including questions about the extent to which a future rather than a past harm must be involved, immediacy of the harm, lack of consideration for the fate of the whistleblower, and importance of the motives governing the action. Fundamentally these debates reflect the divergence between consequentialist and deontological approaches to the issue. Consequentialist thinkers emphasize the costs to the institution and to the whistleblower and the detrimental results of mistaken or malicious whistleblowing, while deontological thinkers tend not to distinguish as significantly between degrees of harm and are more concerned with justice being done.

For engineering, in particular, the issue of whistle-blowing has been a major focus of ethical discussions because of the potential impact of engineering activities on public safety. Most codes of engineering ethics follow the lead of the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology (ABET) by emphasizing that "engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health and welfare of the public in the performance of their professional duties." Preventing physical harm to people is seen as a special professional responsibility of engineers based on their technical expertise. Many codes even obligate engineers to blow the whistle by requiring notification of the proper authority when public safety is endangered.

Whistleblowing in science generally has a different justification. Most often it is related to the research process and falsification of data, although research can also directly harm the human subjects involved or the public at large through the introduction of products based on falsified data. The difference in emphasis between science and engineering whistleblowing can be traced to the fundamental emphasis given to truth and accuracy in science, as opposed to the need to protect the public from harmful technologies in engineering.

Due to the serious consequences associated with whistleblowing, most analyses stress that it should be an avenue of last resort. Many discussions have emphasized ways that organizations can avoid whistleblowing, including creating an internal ethics office, fostering open door practices, having clear organizational policies, or appointing an ombudsperson. One reason to highlight such alternatives is that the whistleblower often becomes the target of subsequent investigations, directing attention away from the misconduct that was revealed.

In fact, the consequences for whistleblowers are so universally negative, including shunning by colleagues and organizational reprisals, that whistleblowing is legitimately an act of moral heroism. Commentators such as Kenneth Alpern argue that engineers, given their special responsibility for the public safety, should be required to be moral heroes. Others, such as Mike Martin, believe that whistleblowing is a supererogatory act whose obligatory nature must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, taking into account both professional duty and personal considerations. Whether certain individuals should be singled out and required to suffer grave consequences for the common good will continues to be a matter of debate.


HEINZ C. LUEGENBIEHL

SEE ALSO Engineering Ethics.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Alpern, Kenneth D. (1983). "Moral Responsibility for Engineers." Business and Professional Ethics Journal 2(2): 39–47. Argues that engineers have a higher duty than others to blow the whistle.

Davis, Michael. (1996). "Some Paradoxes of Whistleblowing." Business and Professional Ethics Journal 15(1): 3–19. Critiques DeGeorge's analysis of whistleblowing and substitutes a complicity theory.

DeGeorge, Richard T. (1999). Business Ethics, 5th edition. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Provides the most commonly cited treatment of whistleblowing. Also distinguishes between responsibilities of business people and professionals.

Johnson, Roberta Ann. (2003). Whistleblowing: When it Works—and Why. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner. Emphasizes the legal dimensions of whistleblowing.

Lubalin, James S., and Jennifer L. Matheson. (1999). "The Fallout: What Happens to Whistleblowers and Those Accused But Exonerated of Scientific Misconduct?" Science and Engineering Ethics 5(2): 229–250. An empirical study of consequences associated with whistleblowing in science.

Martin, Mike W. (1992). "Whistleblowing: Professionalism, Personal Life, and Shared Responsibility for Safety in Engineering," Business and Professional Ethics Journal 11(2): 21–37. Argues against DeGeorge that deciding whether whistleblowing is obligatory should be contextually determined based on an all-things-considered judgment.

Martin, Mike W., and Roland Schinzinger. (1996). Ethics in Engineering, 3rd edition. New York: McGraw-Hill. The most widely used text on engineering ethics. It extends DeGeorge's analysis of whistleblowing.

Whitbeck, Caroline. (1998). Ethics in Engineering Practice and Research. New York: Cambridge University Press. Focuses on ethical issues in scientific research.


INTERNET RESOURCE

National Society of Professional Engineers. "NSPE Code of Ethics for Engineers," rev. January 2003. Available at http://www.nspe.org/ethics/eh1-codepage.asp.

More From encyclopedia.com