Arnald of Villanova
Arnald of Villanova
(b. Aragon, Spain, ca. 1240; d. at sea off Genoa, Italy, 6 September 1311)
medical sciences.
The family of Arnald of Villanova may originally have been Provencal, but he himself was Catalan by birth, probably from Valencia. We have no information about his parents (except that they may have been converted Jews) and little about his professional education. It is certain only that he was a student at Montpellier ca. 1260; the ascription to him of training under John Casamicciola at the University of Naples between 1267 and 1276 rests on the doubtful authenticity of the Breviarium practice traditionally included among his works. By 1281 Arnald had become physician to Peter III of Aragon, and he subsequently served Peter’s son and heir, Alfonso III, in the same capacity. The death of the latter in 1291 and the succession of his brother as James II brought Arnald further into prominence.
By 1291 Arnald had taken up residence in Montpellier as a medical master at its newly chartered studium generale, but he was repeatedly called back to Spain during the next several years for professional consultations. Moreover, he seems to have been able to win considerable support from the royal family for his developing religious views. While Arnald’s teaching and writings at Montpellier were of the first importance in establishing the content of scholastic medicine there, his own commitment to medicine was gradually being replaced by a concern for theological matters. He studied for six months with the Montpellier Dominicans, but he seems to have been most strongly influenced by the Joachimite Peter John Olivi and the spiritual-Franciscans, a group of rigorists within that order. By 1299 Arnald had completed a number of mystical, prophetic works-notably the De adventu antichristi (begun in 1288), which announced that the world would end and the Antichrist appear in 1378 and insisted upon the need for a drastic reform of the Church. When in 1299 Arnald was sent by James II on a diplomatic mission to Philip IV of France, he took the opportunity to explain his beliefs to the Parisian theologians. The De adventu was condemned, however, and Arnald was spared imprisonment only through the intervention of Philip’s minister, William of Nogaret.
Arnald spent the next five years traveling between Provence and Rome. He continued to write while defending himself against his critics in the Church, Two popes, Boniface VIII and Benedict XI, were willing to tolerate him as a physician but were not receptive to his theology. With the accession in 1305 of Clement V, Arnald’s friend for some time, he finally had both papal and royal patronage and was repeatedly given the opportunity to express his views, in which his concern for Church reform soon became predominant over his interest in eschatology. Then, in 1309, before a large assembly at Avignon, Arnald made statements that called James II’s orthodoxy into question, thereby losing the king’s favor. Thereafter Arnald attached himself to James’s younger brother, Frederick I of Trinacria, a much more willing instrument for Arnald’s plans for the reform of Christian society. He died while on a mission for Frederick.
In his medical practice Arnald seems to have been remarkable only for his success. There are many striking testimonies to his abilities, two of which are James II’s demand that Arnald come from Montpellier to attend the queen’s second pregnancy (1297) and Boniface VIII’s delight at his relief from the stone (1301). From the various regimens and practical guides composed for such patients--for example, the Regimen sanitatis written for James II in 1307, and the Parabole medicationis dedicated to Philip IV (1300)—it is clear that his methods continued to be those in which he had been trained at Montpellier. His diagnostic and therapeutic principles appear quite conservative, with none of the dependence on uroscopy or extreme polypharmacy that marks the work of some of his colleagues. As a practicing physician, Arnald was evidently committed to experience rather than to theory or to authority.
Yet Arnald was also the principal figure in Montpellier’s fusion of the Western empirical tradition with the systematic medical philosophy of the Greeks and Arabs. He was well placed for this role. Living in Valencia shortly after its reconquest by James I, it was natural for him to learn Arabic, and at the Aragonese court in the 1280’s he translated, from Arabic into Latin, Avicenna’s De viribus cordis, which subsequently proved immensely popular, and Galen’s De rigore; he also translated a work on drugs by Albuzale and one on regimen by Avenzoar. There is very little in the choice of these texts to suggest any interest in the natural-philosophical aspects of medicine, but Arnald’s stay at Montpellier seems to have deepened his medical as well as his theological interests. One indication of this is the unusual number of different Hippocratic and Galenic works on which he is known to have lectured. The classical authors had been commented upon by earlier masters at Montpellier, notably Cardinalis, but apparently not so extensively; they had preferred to pursue the more purely empirical methods of such moderns as Gilbert the Englishman and Walter Agilon. By the fourteenth century, however, Arnald’s approach had become more widespread. The program of the university was unsettled in the 1290’s, and Arnald certainly encouraged its subsequent Scholasticism by his example; moreover, it was his advice that shaped the papal bull of 8 September 1309, which regularized medical education at Montpellier, defining a set of fifteen Greek and Arab texts as the basis for future study at the school.
Arnald himself went beyond commentary to try to develop a coherent, systematic science of medicine on the Galenic foundations. It is possible to trace the development of his ideas in a continuous series of works datable to Montpellier and the 1290’s, bound together by cross-references and a remarkably consistent interest in the philosophical aspects of medicine. In the earlier works (e.g., the De intentione medicorum) he is primarily concerned to defend pragmatically the presence of a rational element in medicine. Against his colleagues, Arnald holds that the physician can and should draw on theory insofar as it is meaningful to his practice; he requires simply that it save the medical phenomena, not that it be absolutely, philosophically true. Arnald repeatedly makes an analogy with the astronomers’ epicycles.
Gradually, however, Arnald became more preoccupied with problems of philosophy apart from any practical applications, and the later Montpellier treatises are highly technical discussions. of sophisticated medical theory. They most often treat the complexio (the set of sensible qualities, principally hot and cold, that characterizes a man’s state of health), which provides Arnald with a basis for both medical practice and theory. In the Aphorismi de gradibus he develops this qualitative medicine most fully: drawing on material from al-Kindi and Averroes, he establishes a mathematical pharmacy upon the empirical law that qualitative intensity increases arithmetically with a geometric increase in the ratio of the opposing forces that produce it. For medicinal qualities, the law would have the form (in modern terms) intensity = log2 hot/cold. The Aphorismi continued in use at Montpellier for over fifty years, and may have provided the stimulus for Bradwardine’s Law, the Merton College dynamic rule that, in local motion, velocity ?logn force/resistance. But this success was exceptional. For the most part, Arnald’s writings—even his final synthesis of medical theory, the Speculum medicine—were too elaborate and too abstract to have any vogue among professional physicians.
Arnald’s unusual attention to philosophical medicine coincided with the development of his theological position, and one concern may well have inspired the other. Certainly he should not be understood as a simple rationalist in medical matters. Although Boniface VIII once told him, “Occupy yourself with medicine and not with technology and we will honor you,” Arnald did not find it easy to make such a distinction, for to him the two disciplines were continually overlapping in subject matter. The outstanding instance of this is his De esu carnium (1304), a defense of the Carthusians’ abstension from meat, which gave equal weight to citations from Hippocrates and from St. Paul. More profoundly, his epistemology shows the same blurred dualism, for it is the mystical element in Arnald’s thought that restricts his rationalism. He believes that while all physical events may be natural and ordered, their causes are not all easily and directly accessible to the understanding and men wise in these more occult matters will prove to have been guided by chance—or, like himself, by divine illumination. This is the spirit behind his scientific writings on astrology and oneiromancy, as well as his prophetic works; it is also the rationale behind his acceptance of medical intuition as a tool complementary to reason, which was quite in agreement with the view of his more orthodox colleagues that medicine is an art as much as (or more than) a science. The scholastic writings by themselves do not make plain this complexity of his scientific thought, the coexistence in it of rationalism and mysticism.
Arnald’s heterodoxy made a great impression upon the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, and during that period his name became associated with a number of alchemical texts. Some of these, notably the Flos florum and the Rosarius philoso phorum, were until recently accepted as genuine. At present the authenticity of all appears doubtful, the more so because Arnald himself considered alchemists “ignorant” and “foolish.” More recently the empirical element in Arnald’s medicine has been emphasized by critics, who cite the Breviarium practice in support. But the authenticity of this work is dubious as well. From internal evidence, it seems that it must have been written in the first years of the fourteenth century, at just the time when Arnald was deeply concerned with medical theory and theology, and there is no hint of these subjects in the Breviarium. The most famous of the medical writings once attributed to him, the Commentum super regimen sanitatis Salernitanum, is now also thought to be apocryphal.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
I. Original Works. Virtually all of Arnald’s Latin medical works were collected in various sixteenth-century editions of his Opera (Lyons, 1504, 1509, 1520, 1532; Venice, 1505, 1527; Basel, 1585). In general, the later editions are the more complete, although the collection entitled (Praxis medicinalis (Lyones, 1586) omits his discussions of medical theory. None of these works has been published in a modern edition, but one not printed earlier, De conservatione virus, was published by P. Pansier in Collectio ophtalmologica veterum auctorum, I (Paris, 1903), 1-25.
Arnald’s translations from the Arabic are not included in his Opera. His versions of Aristotle and Galen were included with other writings of the same authors in editions of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries; his translation of the De medicinis simplicibus attributed to Albuzale or Albumasar (MSS Paris, Univ. 128, 165-168; Erfurt, Amplon, F. 237, 63-66; Q. 395, 138-160) and the translation of the De regimine sanitatis of Avenzoar less certainly ascribed to him (MS Oxford, Corpus Christi 177, 261-265v; cf. MS Paris, Univ, 131, 54v-59v [among others], where it is attributed to Profatius) have not been published. He has also been credited with two translations that are demonstrably not by him: Costa ben Luca’s De physicis ligaturis (which exists in a twelfth-century manuscript, MS Brit. Mus. Add. 22719. fol. 200v) and al-kindi’s treatise De gradibus (for which Arnald’s own Aphorismi de gradibus were mistaken).
A good bibliographical guide to the printed and manuscript sources is Juan Antonio Paniagua Arellano, “La obra médica de Arnau de Vilanova. Estudio I: Introducción y fuentes,” in Estudios y notas sobre Arnau de Vilanova (Madrid, 1962), pp. 1-51, reprinted from Archivo iberoamericano de historia de la medicina y antropologia médica,II (1959), 351-402.
A satisfactory bibliography of Arnald’s theological writings, indicating those that have been published in whole or in part, will be found in Joaquin Carreras y Artau, “Les obres teológiques d’Arnau de Vilanova,” in Analecta sacra Tarraconensia, 12 (1936), 217-231, although this is by now somewhat incomplete. The article by Paniagua cited above lists a number of more recent editions. It might also be mentioned that MSS Vat. Borg. 205 and Vat. Lat. 3824 are collections of Arnald’s theological writings made at his own direction, in 1302 and 1305, respectively; the former manuscript may be annotated in Arnald’s hand (see Anneliese Maier, “Handschriftliches zu Arnaldus de Villanova und Petrus Johannis Olivi,: in Analecta sacra Tarraconensia, 21 [1948], 53-74).
Arnald’s Catalan writings have been edited by Miguel Batllori as Obres catalanes (Barcelona, 1947) in two volumes, the first of which contains religious texts and the second, medical texts.
II. Secondary Literature. The Arnaldian literature up to 1947 is thoroughly covered in the bibliographies of the volumes edited by Batllori, cited above; of this early material, Paul Diepgen’s articles go most deeply into Arnald’s scientific work. Since then a few other important studies of Arnald’s science and medicine have appeared: Michael McVaugh, “Arnald of Villanova and Bradwardine’s Law,” in Isis, 58 (1967), 56-64. Juan Antonio Paniagua Arellano, “La patologia general en la obra de Arnaldo de Vilanova,” in Archivos iberoamericanos de historia de la medicina, 1 (1948), 49-119; Jacques Payen, “Flos florum et Semita semite, deux traités d’alchimie attribués à Arnaud de Villeneuve,” in Revue d’histoire des sciences. 12 (1959), 288-300; René Verrier, Études sur Arnaud de Villeneuve, 2 vols. (Leiden, 1947-1949). The many biographical and theological studies that have appeared since 1947 can best be found by following up the references given in Miguel Batllori, “Dos nous escrits espirituals d’Arnau de Vilanova,” in Analecta sacra Tarraconensia, 28 (1955), 45-70; or in Joaquin Carreras y Artau, Relactiones de Arnau de vilanova con los reyes de la casa de Aragón (Barcelona, 1955).
Michael McVaugh
