Sabbatarianism
SABBATARIANISM
Sabbatarianism, a movement devoted to preserving the sanctity of the Sunday Sabbath, emerged in the Anglo-American world in the seventeenth-century, but it gained force in the nineteenth century. Although multifaceted, Sabbatarians primarily focused their efforts on preventing the tumultuous and burgeoning worlds of recreation and leisure from interfering with the observance of Sunday in what they considered to be a biblically mandated manner, that is, as a day of rest. No single Protestant denomination accounted for all Sabbatarians. Rather, liberal Protestants tended to shy away from placing heavy restrictions on Sunday activity, a tendency that stood in striking contrast to traditionalists' (or orthodox) emphasis on prohibitions of all sorts. Sabbatarians dominated American religious and political approaches to Sunday through the nineteenth century, but with each decade of the twentieth century their power waned.
After the American Revolution, politicians wrote into state constitutions an array of Sunday laws that grew out of the Sabbatarian orientation that Puritan and Anglican colonists brought to North America; more important, however, a Sabbatarian bias against Sunday activity of any sort other than the religious had become customary by 1800. In the early decades of the nineteenth century, the Sabbatarian movement took institutional form, largely around the issue of transporting and delivering mail on Sunday. After the failure of their efforts to prevent the United States Post Office from functioning on Sunday, Sabbatarians turned to other depredations, mainly the unwillingness of many Americans to observe Sunday in such a manner that rest would be distinguished from work. They formed various organizations, sent petitions to elected officials, and published tracts urging the strict observance of Sunday as a day of rest. It is here that the pertinence of Sabbatarianism to the history of leisure and recreation comes into focus, for it was the inability of Americans to agree on what differentiated work from rest that animated controversies about not only Sunday observance but leisure and recreation in general.
Until the second half of the nineteenth century, dominant meanings for rest (that is, the meanings written into law and shaping custom) precluded all activity outside the home on Sunday except for attending divine services. It was believed that rest could be obtained only through prayer, church attendance, and meditation upon religious themes. But throughout the century, new theories about how to rest were developing. Unitarians and liberal Protestants embraced natural and man-made delights on all days of the week, and they argued that what refreshed the body and spirit at once provided rest and created opportunities for uplift that could lead to spiritual awakening. Additionally, German immigrants brought with them an expansive view of rest, as did other immigrants steeped in Catholic and European traditions. Within cities, churches, and homes, debates were waged over what was restful, with German Americans arguing that Sunday afternoons at beer gardens were in keeping with the spirit of the day of rest, ministers urging congregants to bicycle Sunday afternoons, and mothers admonishing children to put away their weekday playthings and devote their energies to biblical toys and games. But Sabbatarians resisted the creep of these views: in insisting on the closing of saloons, public libraries, and museums on Sundays, in petitioning in favor of stilling world's fairs each Sunday, or in lobbying behind the scenes to prevent Sunday afternoon baseball games—just to name a few instances of their work—they hewed closely to a circumscribed meaning for rest.
Additionally, Sabbatarians pointed to the incontestable fact that most recreation and leisure activities depended on the labor of railroad men, ticket takers, stage performers, star athletes, concession operators, and many others. To be sure, numerous Americans also toiled on Sundays, as well as the other six days of the week. Work without rest was nearly as troubling as rest without work, and with boom-and-bust characterizing the American economy none could be assured of steady work, but unemployment was hardly restful. Few Sabbatarian organizations took on the industrial giants of the period who ran their plants continuously. Instead, they focused their energies on reforming amusements and recreations.
In the meantime, the development of networks of commercial amusements and recreations further challenged the prohibition against Sunday work; picnic grounds, beer halls, saloons, beach resorts, amusement parks, concert halls, theaters, world's fairs, and such relied on the labor of many to operate. The vast majority of Americans were able to patronize these venues only on Sunday, for they were either working the other days of the week or broke. Indeed, attendance figures support such a contention: Sunday business exceeded that of all the other days of the week put together. And increasingly, as Americans argued that such diversions were restful, a concept of leisure developed that pivoted on commercialized opportunities for rest. Sunday soon became a day for leisure rather than a day of rest; by the 1920s, when this transformation was irreversible, Sabbatarianism lost its valence.
Despite the diminished political and theological potency of Sabbatarianism in the twentieth century, many Sunday laws remained on the books and many customs associated with proscribing the sphere of Sunday activity continued to hold sway. One of the first set of Sunday laws to disappear were those that banned theatrical shows. Oregon and California led the way in the nineteenth century, and, by 1910, most states allowed certain kinds of theaters to open on Sunday, though the content of the spectacles was censored so as to showcase material in keeping with the sanctity of the day. World War I was a turning point in the diminution of Sunday laws, in part because entrepreneurs opportunistically linked Sunday opening with patriotic fund-raisers and morale boosters. Before the war, all but six states prohibited the screening of movies on Sundays, but a campaign led by the National Association of the Motion Picture Industry led to the granting of local option for movie palaces to open on Sundays. By the mid-1920s, all large cities, with a few exceptions such as Knoxville, Tennessee, allowed movie theaters, dance halls, roller-skating rinks, bowling alleys, and other commercialized recreation venues to open Sunday afternoons and evenings. It was only in the 1970s that prohibitions against Sunday morning openings dissipated, and then it was because the Sabbatarian impulse was vestigial at best.
Sunday as a widespread day of rest helped to shape professional baseball and football during their formative periods. Self-imposed Sabbatarian regulations helped baseball become the sport of the middle classes. In banning Sunday contests and the sale of beer in 1878, the National League sought to foster a family-oriented, respectable image. By the 1890s, it was no longer necessary to avoid play on Sunday. In order to appease the sensibilities of Sabbatarians, however, baseball's managers sponsored sacred concerts and other such exercises before the first pitch. Some states where Sabbatarians held significant political power, notably Massachusetts and Pennsylvania, banned Sunday games; during World War I, owners of teams in these states held exhibition games to raise monies for the war effort. Still, through the 1930s, Sunday baseball was illegal in Boston, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, and most southern cities. In the 1920s, semiprofessional football games were held on Sundays, mostly because players were not available at other times. As the sport took shape, a distinct calendar solidified, whereby high schools played on Fridays, colleges on Saturdays, and the pros on Sunday. Ironically, until the 1990s, Sunday—a day idealized as separate from the quest for profit—was solely the province of professional sporting contests, with amateur contests held at other times.
Although Sabbatarianism as a movement was on the wane during the first third of the twentieth century, the commercial aspect of theater and sports bothered enough Americans that Sunday laws remained on the books. While Americans had accepted the existence of multiple and conflicting styles of rest, and sought to accommodate them, the majority was uncomfortable about making Sunday into a day of gain, or in the words of one critic, in "putting the dollar mark on it." However, by the 1960s, most Americans were no longer discomfited with the rampant commercialization of every day life, and thus Sunday laws came to seem antiquated and anachronistic. Although the Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of Sunday laws in 1961, state legislatures began to repeal such laws. Americans wanted to be able to shop, play, and even work according to the dictates of their own consciences and the demands of their schedules. Today, the only proscriptions that remain in effect across the nation are against the sale of alcohol on Sundays. And so, a long period of Sabbatarian hegemony over Sunday recreation and leisure gave way to an age when only private sentiment regulates Sunday observance.
See also: Church Socials, Regulation and Social Control of Leisure
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Evenson, Bruce J. "'Saving the City's Reputation': Philadelphia's Struggle over Self-Identity, Sabbath-Breaking, and Boxing in America's Sesquicentennial Year." Pennsylvania History 60 (1993): 6–34.
John, Richard R. "Taking Sabbatarianism Seriously." Journal of the Early Republic 10 (1990): 517–567.
McCrossen, Alexis. Holy Day, Holiday: The American Sunday. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press, 2000.
Marion, Forrest L. "Blue Laws, Knoxville, and the Second World War." Journal of East Tennessee History 68 (1996): 41–62.
Raucher, Alan. "Sunday Business and the Decline of Sunday Closing Laws: A Historical Overview." Journal of Church and State 36 (1994): 13–33.
Solberg, Winton. Redeem the Time: The Puritan Sabbath in Early America. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1977.
Alexis McCrossen
