Classical Economics
Classical Economics
What It Means
“Classical economics” refers to the ideas of the first wave of modern economists, whose work spanned the late eighteenth century and much of the nineteenth century. The classical period of economic thought began with the publication in 1776 of the Scottish philosopher Adam Smith’s An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, the book whose theories gave rise to the modern study of economics. After Smith the most prominent figures generally included in the category of classical economists are David Ricardo, Thomas Malthus, John Stuart Mill, and Karl Marx.
The classical economists differed on many issues, but together they laid the foundation for all economic study to follow. Smith introduced the idea of analyzing the complicated processes involved in a nation’s production of goods and services, and the later classical theorists refined, added to, and reconsidered the picture of economic activity that he had drawn.
When Did It Begin
There was no systematic study of economic activity until after the Middle Ages (the period from about 500 to about 1500), when nation-states in Europe (such as England, France, Spain, and Portugal) began building power through wealth that was often amassed by traders. With the growing role of traders, economies were transitioning from being controlled by the nobility to being run by private individuals (a system that came to be called capitalism). This first phase of capitalism (which spanned the sixteenth through eighteenth centuries) was dominated by an economic theory called mercantilism. The mercantilists believed that a nation’s wealth equaled the amount of precious metals, such as gold and silver, that its government possessed. Therefore, the European nations attempted to establish a favorable balance of trade, which meant that they intentionally exported more goods than they imported, thus ensuring that they brought in more gold and silver than they sent to other countries.
Adam Smith (1723–90), writing in Scotland, formulated his book An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (published in 1776) as an argument against mercantilism. One of his chief goals was to show that a nation’s wealth was not simply equal to its stockpiles of precious metals. In Smith’s view, everything that a nation produced for sale should be taken into account when judging that nation’s wealth. Therefore, he said, it was healthy economic activity, and not gold stockpiling, that governments should worry about promoting.
More Detailed Information
Economic health, in Smith’s view, arose naturally from market activity (a market is any place where buyers and sellers come together). Self-interest led businesses to seek profits, which meant that they would naturally want to charge consumers as much as possible for their goods or services, while paying their workers as little as possible. The business owners’ desires for profits would be balanced, however, by the self-interest of consumers and workers, who wanted, respectively, to pay as little as possible for goods and services and to be paid as much as possible for their labor. When there were multiple businesses competing for customers as well as for workers, prices fell and wages rose until there was just enough profit to keep a business in operation. Thus, the market itself ensured that the goods and services people wanted were produced with maximum efficiency and at a fair price. Smith called this phenomenon the “invisible hand” that guided capitalism.
Smith revolutionized thinking about capitalism by showing that the public interest (the greatest good for all people in a society) could be promoted at the same time that individuals had no motive other than self-interest. He believed that the government should refrain from intervening in market processes as much as possible and should instead trust the invisible hand to guide the economy.
David Ricardo (1772–1823), writing in England during the early nineteenth century, developed some of his most important theories in response to the idea of government intervention in foreign trade; he specifically objected to Great Britain’s Corn Laws, which restricted imports of grain. Ricardo focused on the interaction of capitalists (those who used land for speculative business purposes), laborers, and landlords (those who owned land). The capitalists used some of their profits to pay rent to the landlords and some to pay the laborers their wages. When the government protected the profits of capitalists (in the instance of the Corn Laws, these were tenant farmers) through import restrictions on grain, it meant that more grain needed to be grown within England to feed the population. Because the amount of farmland was limited, it became more sought-after, and landlords were able to charge the farmers higher rents. Meanwhile, Ricardo argued, the laborers’ rates of pay were bound to be fixed at subsistence levels (allowing them to pay only for the bare necessities). The landlords therefore were the only ones making increased profits in this scenario, because the capitalists would be paying more rent and would still have to pay the same wages to workers. This would result in a decline in profits for capitalists and possible economic stagnation. Ricardo’s view was that, because of this process, economic expansion inevitably led to shrinking profits over time even without harmful trade restrictions.
Thomas Malthus (1766–1834), a friend of Ricardo, dealt extensively with the troubling side of economic activity. He first rose to prominence by theorizing that mass starvation would overtake England in the future as a result of overpopulation. Later he focused on the idea that an economy could collapse if there was a “general glut,” a situation in which there were more goods and services produced than people wanted to buy. Ricardo and subsequent economists dismissed this theory, but it came back into prominence in the twentieth century, when Malthus’s ideas seemed to be borne out by the Great Depression (the worldwide economic crisis that started in 1929 and lasted through the rest of the following decade).
The German political philosopher Karl Marx (1818–83) and the English philosopher John Stuart Mill (1803–73) both focused on the flaws in capitalism, but they came to very different conclusions. Marx built on Smith’s and Ricardo’s ideas to argue that capitalists derived their profits by exploiting workers, paying them less than they deserved given the amount of value they contributed to the goods and services that were produced. In Marx’s view competition and economic growth would inevitably cause capitalists’ profits to shrink, forcing them to exploit workers further. As shrinking profits forced more capitalists out of business, economic power would be concentrated in the hands of a few. Meanwhile, the working class would be larger and more dissatisfied than ever, so that revolution and the downfall of capitalism would become inevitable.
Mill, meanwhile, agreed that capitalism did not result in a fair distribution of rewards, but he did not prophesy the system’s collapse. Instead he argued that income could be redistributed without harm coming to the overall economy.
Recent Trends
One idea that united all of the classical theorists was a basic agreement on how the value of a good or service was created. Classical economists tended to view value as the sum of the labor that went into the production of a good or service. Beginning in the late 1800s economists started to reconsider this idea, called the labor theory of value. This reconsideration of value inaugurated a new school of thought called neoclassical economics, which continued, with certain major adjustments, to represent the views of mainstream economists through most of the twentieth century.
The neoclassicists viewed value not simply in terms of the amount of labor required to produce a good or service but also in terms of the amount of satisfaction a product gave the consumer. Consumers were seen as rational decision makers who took into account the satisfaction they would get out of buying one product versus another. The greater amount of satisfaction a product gave per unit of cost, the greater its value to consumers. While this issue marked an advancement over classical economists’ ideas, the neoclassical school continued to build on the basic ideas pioneered by the first modern economists.
Classical economic concepts were not, in fact, subjected to wholesale reevaluation until the Great Depression, which seemed to refute many of the assumptions that economists had long made. The ideas of the British economist John Maynard Keynes (1883–1946) departed greatly from classical theory and revolutionized economics in the 1930s and 1940s. In subsequent decades, however, the neoclassicists strove to integrate his ideas with their own. Thus, classical economics lives on.
