USG Corporation
USG Corporation
101 South Wacker Drive
Chicago, Illinois 60606
U.S.A.
(312) 606-4000
Fax: (312) 606-4093
Public Company
Incorporated: 1901 as U.S.G. Company
Employees: 14,200
Sales: $2.19 billion
Stock Exchanges: New York Midwest Zürich Geneva Basel
Gypsum products are the principal goods manufactured by the USG Corporation. The manufacture of gypsum is a highly competitive and price-sensitive undertaking, with easy entry and exit from the field. As a result of these conditions USG Corporation—or the U.S.G. Company, as it was originally incorporated—has exerted substantial influence in the building-supplies field because of its market size.
Understanding gypsum production methods is essential to an understanding of USG’s corporate character. Gypsum, or hydrous calcium sulphate, is, in pure form, a white mineral commonly called alabaster. Large quantities of gypsum exist throughout North America. One of the first uses for gypsum was as a fertilizer. Gypsum is made suitable for commercial use by a process called calcination, which involves heating the mineral to remove approximately three-quarters of its water. Calcined gypsum, or plaster of Paris, can recrystallize into any shape with the simple addition of water. In the 1890s gypsum manufacturers perfected a method of strengthening plaster by adding a retarder, which controlled the setting time, thus creating a viable competitor to traditional lime plaster. Because gypsum was plentiful, and available at a relatively low price, and because the manufacturing process was so simple, new firms flooded the market and placed constant downward pressure on prices.
In the early years of the 20th century, several key businesses emerged as gypsum-product leaders. The English family of Nebraska; C.G. Root, Emil Durr, S.Q. Fulton, and Charles Pullen of Wisconsin; Waldo Avery and B.W. McCausland of Michigan; and, lastly, the largest manufacturer in the United States, J. B. King of New York, were all important gypsum processors. By 1901 several attempts to organize some of the industry’s producers into a corporate combination had failed. That year 35 gypsum companies consolidated into the U.S.G. Company. The participating firms traded their assets for securities and acquired a $200,000 loan. Directors of the new company, which controlled about 50% of U.S. gypsum output, chose B.W. McCausland as its first president. The company was based in Chicago.
Between 1901 and 1905 each director remained largely concerned with the success of his own plants. This polarization ended in 1905, when McCausland was replaced as president by Sewell Avery, his partner’s son. Avery’s tenure as president would extend 35 years, until November 12, 1936. Avery then served as chairman, between 1937 and 1951. He and his brother, Waldo Avery, were the company’s largest stockholders, controlling about 3.6% of the company’s stock. During Sewell Avery’s presidency, his character permeated the company’s culture. Avery was a conservative businessman who had the last word in virtually all matters. In 1931, when Montgomery Ward and Company was on the verge of financial collapse, Avery became chairman of the board of that company, a position which he held until 1955.
Avery had managed his father’s firm, the Alabaster Company, since 1894. When U.S.G. absorbed Alabaster, he became a U.S.G. director and its Buffalo, New York, sales manager. Avery built a strong research division after his promotion to president from his post as Cleveland sales manager. Staffed by engineers and chemists, the new division sought to find new uses for gypsum. The U.S.G. Company, reincorporated in 1920 as the United States Gypsum Company (US Gypsum), has maintained a market share ranging between 50% in 1901 and 34% in 1989. In 1909 Avery set out to diversify the company with one of his first acquisitions, the Sackett Plasterboard Company of New York. Augustine Sackett had invented gypsum wallboard and the specialized machinery to make it. This basic wallboard quickly became one of US Gypsum’s major products. Wallboard, a layer of gypsum plaster sandwiched between two pieces of paper, is a convenient building material with strong fire-proofing and insulating qualities.
US Gypsum improved on Sackett’s concept and patented a wallboard that had paper folded over its edges to seal in plaster residue, which often escaped during the wallboard’s installation. In 1927 CertainTeed Products Corporation introduced its own wallboard, which did not have enclosed edges, and challenged US Gypsum for market share. CertainTeed’s managers believed that their less expensive version had a good chance of success. The result was a price contest between the two companies, beginning in 1927 and ending in 1929. US Gypsum had a much larger market than CertainTeed. It, therefore, was able to sell wallboard at a loss only in those markets that CertainTeed also served. In all other markets US Gypsum kept prices up. CertainTeed, however, was forced to sell its product at a loss in all its markets. By 1929 CertainTeed was beaten. The smaller company was licensed to produce US Gypsum’s patented wallboard and was forced to sell the product at the price set by US Gypsum. This incident marked the start of US Gypsum’s unrivaled leadership in gypsum materials.
In 1928 Avery successfully predicted a recession which eventually became the Great Depression. Avery’s instinct for predicting business cycles helped US Gypsum get through the Depression without a single year of losses; this situation was quite unusual for a business involved in the cyclical building industry. Avery moved to protect the company, partly by ordering the construction of new plants closer to East Coast metropolitan centers. Since gypsum is a high-bulk, relatively low-value commodity, transportation costs have a large effect on pricing.
US Gypsum’s greatest advantage was size. The company was able to use its size to keep manufacturing and transportation costs down and to compete more effectively. Three specific policies, set by Avery, helped US Gypsum to counter the Depression and maintain its number-one position in the industry. According to Fortune, February 1936, diffusion of production facilities allowed US Gypsum to keep transportation costs, and thus total costs down. US Gypsum was also vertically integrated, from mine floor to retailer, and employed highly mechanized techniques when possible. The third element in US Gypsum’s success, according to Fortune, was a devotion to product diversification. US Gypsum marketed a broad cross section of building materials. Broken down into individual units these products would have been prohibitively expensive to transport. Combined, however, transportation costs were much more reasonable.
Avery took advantage of the company’s strong cash position at the beginning of the Depression to purchase nearly a dozen building-material firms weakened by the economic downturn. In 1930 US Gypsum bought into the insulation-board business with the purchase of the Greenville Insulating Board Corporation of Greenville, Mississippi. Also in 1930, it bought into the metal-lath business with the purchase of the Youngstown Pressed Steel Company of Warren, Ohio and the metal-lath division of Northwestern Expanded Metal Company. Avery also made US Gypsum, which had already been in the lime business for 15 years, a leading lime producer in 1930 with the acquisition of lime-producing firms such as the Farnam Cheshire Lime Company. Producers of mineral wool and asphalt roofing acquired in 1933, and asbestos-cement siding acquired in 1937, rounded out the Depression-era acquisitions. The company countered the downturn in new construction by exploiting the remodeling and industrial markets. During the Depression, 15% of sales were to industrial users. Glass-makers used gypsum as a packing material. Cement producers used it to retard setting, and moviemakers used flaked gypsum as snow.
In 1940, a new problem confronted the company’s management when the U.S. Justice Department filed suit against US Gypsum and six other wallboard manufacturers, charging them with price-fixing. The claim stemmed from US Gypsum’s 1929 cross-licensing of its patented wallboard. The agreement set prices at which the wallboard must be sold. In 1950 the Supreme Court forced US Gypsum and its six licensees—who produced all of the wallboard sold east of the Rocky Mountains—to cease setting prices, and US Gypsum was enjoined from exercising its patent-licensing privilege.
Between 1946 and 1949 US Gypsum invested over $51 million in expansion under the direction of William L. Keady, who had become president in 1942. In 1949, however, Chairman Avery predicted another depression—incorrectly—and began to rein in expansion. Keady resigned as a result of Avery’s intervention. Although there was a slight recession in 1949, the company did not step up capital spending again until 1954. In May 1951, when Sewell Avery resigned as US Gypsum’s chairman and CEO, his replacement, Clarence H. Shaver, inherited a company which had a capitalized value of $61 million and produced more than 75 commodities in 47 mines or factories. Avery’s imprint was an extreme conservatism marked by strong centralized control, rigid cost-cutting practices, and few benefits for employees.
Toward the end of the 1950s US Gypsum extended its expansion internationally. One of its principal discoveries during the decade was the gypsum deposit in Mexico’s San Luis Potosi State. This find, one of the world’s largest was conservatively estimated to contain at least 300 million tons of commercial deposits.
In the 1960s US Gypsum became the first major U.S. corporation to undertake privately funded housing renovation on a large scale. The highly publicized project began in 1964, when US Gypsum purchased six adjoining tenements in the East Harlem Section of New York City. US Gypsum paid $9,125 to renovate each unit; the cost of constructing new units averaged $22,500. US Gypsum’s president, Graham J. Morgan, saw these projects as an opportunity to get in on the ground floor of a potential $20 billion market. Morgan felt the renovation would open up because of the Federal Housing Administration’s willingness to provide financing for such projects. By 1969 the company had remodeled completely 32 buildings in New York, Cleveland, Chicago, and Detroit.
In 1973 US Gypsum settled a class-action civil antitrust suit brought against it by wallboard users and buyers. Settlement of those cases, which alleged price fixing, cost US Gypsum $28 million. This case led to a criminal indictment of US Gypsum and three competitors in 1973. The criminal trial eventually found its way to the Supreme Court, which ordered a new trial, and in 1980 US Gypsum settled the case, agreeing to pay $2.6 million in taxes on deductions from earlier civil antitrust judgements.
On January 1, 1985, the holding company, USG Corporation (USG), was created, and US Gypsum became the largest of the holding company’s nine operating subsidiaries. Chairman and CEO Edward W. Duffy formed the holding company to protect the bulk of company operations from asbestos litigation against US Gypsum. Asbestos had been a standard additive in wallboard manufacture for decades. US Gypsum had already begun to face property damage suits in 1984 with a $675,000 award to a South Carolina school district. The reorganization of the company was effective January 1, 1985.
In November 1986, the Belzberg brothers of Canada attempted a hostile takeover of USG. USG immediately instituted a plan to buy back 20% of its common stock in an effort to fend off the takeover. By December 1986, however, USG had purchased Samuel, William, and Hyman Belzberg’s 4.9% stake, for $139.6 million dollars. The Belzberg family’s profits on the transaction were in excess of $25 million dollars.
In October 1987 a partnership led by Texans Cyril Wagner Jr. and Jack E. Brown’s Desert Partners attempted to gain control of the company. Wagner and Brown’s main business venture was a Midland, Texas, oil and gas partnership with secondary real estate operations. They purchased their 9.83% stake in USG as USG tried to recover financially from the Belzberg takeover attempt. In April 1988 a federal court refused to block USG’s poison-pill antitakeover plan. In May 1988 USG announced a restructuring and recapitalization plan designed to block further the takeover attempt, and by June the plan had succeeded. The plan was expensive, however, and in October 1988 USG sold its Masonite Corporation subsidiary, purchased in 1984. International Paper Corporation paid $400 million for Masonite.
USG’s United States Gypsum Company subsidiary remains the largest gypsum producer in the world. The company is divided into four divisions. The gypsum-products division produces goods ranging from wallboard to agricultural and industrial gypsum, cements, and fillers. The interior-systems section produces tile and partition goods. The building-products-distribution section transports a variety of gypsum products and construction accessories throughout the United States, primarily through its L&W Supply Corporation subsidiary. The other-products division markets goods ranging from mineral-wood products to engineering-consulting services. The future of USG Corporation will be affected by the debt it has incurred during restructuring. The firm has an outstanding debt of $2.4 billion and has been forced to abandon Avery’s habit of maintaining large cash reserves.
Principal Subsidiaries
United States Gypsum Company; USG Interiors, Inc.; L&W Supply Corporation.; DAP Inc.; CGC Inc. (76%).
Further Reading
“Gyp,” Fortune, February 1936; “U.S. Gypsum: No Nonsense,” Fortune, September 1955.
—John C. Bishop
