Hate Crimes

views updated

Hate Crimes

The expanding definition of hate crimes often changes to include violations against specific groups based on race, sexuality, creed, and national origin and now protects persons with physical and mental disabilities in addition to the elderly. The history of antibias crime law begins with post-Civil War restrictions against groups such as the Ku Klux Klan (KKK). Although not termed hate-crime laws, these federal codes attempted to prevent and punish crimes motivated by racial hatred. An overview of hate-crime legislation, culminating in the civil rights era and garnering governmental support in the 1980s, provides a history of state and federal involvement in cataloging, preventing, and prosecuting hate crimes in America. Some of the more visible hate crimes, such as lynching and antigay violence, are examined more thoroughly in this entry. In addition, specific hate crimes, with names, dates, and descriptions, serve to catalog the range of crimes perpetrated against people based on group association. Finally, a summary of the debate between lawmakers and legal scholars outlines the opposition to hate-crime legislation on the grounds that it invalidates the First and Fourteenth Amendments.

To begin, the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), an organization created to fight anti-Semitism and racism, was the first to create hate-crime legislation in 1981. This legislation, while directed to anti-Jewish crimes, also covers hate crimes committed against any minority group. Every state except Indiana, Georgia, South Carolina, and Wyoming has enacted hate-crime laws that address crimes based on race, gender, or sexual orientation. Typically, the punishment for hate crimes is an enhanced sentence or increase in jail time. Hate crime laws also hold parents responsible for hate crimes their children perpetrate and allow for punitive damages for vandalism of churches, cemeteries, schools, religious centers, and community centers.

Congress passed the Hate Crimes Statistic Act on April 23, 1990, requiring the attorney general of the United States to compile statistics about hate crimes, or crimes committed because of bias or prejudice against a person because of race, ethnicity, sexual orientation, or religion. In conjunction with local and state law agencies, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) provided data to the Uniform Crime Reporting Program (UCR), which in turn created a database for recording and analyzing hate-crime statistics. The UCR's first publication of their findings, Hate Crime Statistics, 1990: A Sourcebook, contained data from eleven states but did not succeed in offering uniform data. By 1992 the UCR, in conjunction with law enforcement officials, developed their own means of collecting data, generating a comprehensive collection of hate-crime statistics. In 2004 more than 17,000 law enforcement agencies in all fifty states offered the UCR information and statistics on hate crimes. The collaborative efforts of the FBI, law enforcement agencies, and the UCR provides valuable information on the types and numbers of hate crimes being perpetrated in each state. The statistics not only help law officials track hate crimes but also provide valuable information to activist and advocacy groups who in turn educate communities, mobilize support, and lobby for hate-crime legislation.

HISTORY OF HATE-CRIME LEGISLATION

Early legislation that seeks to punish hate crimes can be traced to the close of the Civil War (1861–1865) and was created to combat renegade groups such as the KKK and their mob law. The first United States Federal Code made it unlawful to conspire against citizens with the aim of depriving them of their constitutional rights, but issues of race, religion, sexual orientation, or national origin are never mentioned:

If two or more persons conspire to injure, oppress, threaten, or intimidate an inhabitant of an State, Territory, or District in the free exercise of enjoyment of any right or privilege secured to him by the Constitution or laws of the United States, or because of his having so exercised the same; or If two or more persons go in disguise on the highway, or on the premises of another, with the intent to prevent or hinder his free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege so secured; They shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both; and if death results from the acts committed in violation of this section or if such acts include kidnapping or an attempt to kidnap, aggravated sexual abuse or an attempt to commit aggravated sexual abuse, or an attempt to kill, they shall be fined under this title or imprisoned for an term of years or for life, or both, or may be sentenced to death.

                               (18 U.S.C Section 241)

Hate Crime Statistics
YearTotal Hate CrimesDriven by Victim's Sexual Orientation
source: Federal Bureau of Investigation. Available online at http://www.fbi.gov/hq/cid/civilrights/hate.htm.
19957,9471,019
19968,7591,016
19978,0491,102
19987,7551,260
19997,8761,317
20008,0631,299
20019,7301,299
20027,4621,244
20037,4841,239
20047,6491,406

Not until decades later, when the Civil Rights Act of 1968 was enacted, would race become a factor in hate-crime legislation. Because the federal government was under constant pressure during the civil rights era to ensure and defend the rights of black Americans, the Civil Rights Act was created not only to ensure voting rights and access to juries, but also to protect students who attended public universities, safeguard travelers using public transportation or interstate highways, and desegregate restaurants, theaters, motels, and other public facilities where countless hate crimes occurred.

The Hate Crime Statistics Act outlines the specific responsibilities of law enforcement agencies in regards to hate-crime statistics. Agencies must compile statistics from crimes that manifest prejudice based on race, religion, sexual orientation, or ethnicity. This information must be summarized and published by the FBI in January of every year. The benefits of the act, according to the ADL, is that law enforcement agencies can trace certain patterns of hate crimes, anticipating new ones and bolstering authority in cities where hate crimes are most prevalent. The ADL also believes that publishing a report of hate crimes will make victims more apt to report crimes that happen to them.

In 1994 the Violence against Women Act confirmed that persons within the United States shall have the right to be free from crimes of violence motivated by gender. As part of this act rape crisis centers and domestic violence shelters received support and sentencing for crimes against women that included punitive and compensatory settlements.

Although rape is not considered a hate crime, some prosecutors and women's rights organizations, such as Hadassah, are lobbying to expand the definition to encompass sexual crimes against women. Those interested in reclassifying rape as a hate crime argue that the term sexual crime implies passion when, in fact, rape is about power and hatred of women. Certain cases of multiple or violent rapes have been tried as hate crimes in an effort to obtain lengthier prison sentences. Opponents of the reclassification argue that men accused of rape should not receive enhanced prison sentences simply because they target someone of a protected group.

LYNCHING

The term lynching is typically used to describe renegade punishments performed without the law's consent. Acting outside of justice in the role of judge and jury, lynch mobs arbitrarily deliver sentences and dispense violent retribution with little or no consideration of factual evidence or eyewitness testimony. Lynching black males for the alleged crime of raping white women became a widespread practice at the close of the Civil War during the period of Reconstruction. When Southern men were far away fighting the war, leaving their wives alone with scores of black males, the crime of rape was scarcely reported. But after slavery was abolished and black males were given citizenship, their free presence threatened the bedrock of white supremacy, and the accusation of rape was a common occurrence in many Southern towns. This racial threat, originating after emancipation, is linked to competition in the job market, infiltration of political spheres, and initiation of sexual relationships with white females. The Tuskegee Institute's records state that 3,446 African Americans were lynched from 1882 to 1968 and that 23.5 percent of these victims were lynched for supposedly raping white women. In almost every instance the crime of rape was never tried in a court of law; instead, violent crowds, in league with law enforcement officials, took matters in their own hands and wrestled prisoners from jail cells to administer mob justice.

The history of lynching, recorded in Without Sanctuary: Lynching Photography in America (2000) by Hilton Als, Jon Lewis, and Leon Litwak, shows a disturbing connection between violent punishment and eroticism, specifically voyeurism. This collection of photographic images is perhaps the most abject record of torture and punishment in America, offering visual evidence of eroticism, or more specifically, impressions of magnetism, fascination, attraction, fetishism, and desire. In the countless photographs of black males with their genitals exposed or mutilated, one must wonder how this form of punishment assumed such a sexualized nature. In lynching photographs of white males or Hispanic males included in the collection, only one photograph shows a man with his pants ripped from his body. In sharp contrast many photographs of African-American males reveal exposed upper or lower bodies, and some victims are stripped completely naked for a group of white onlookers. Many spectators took souvenirs from the bodies such as bone fragments, hair strands, and articles of clothing. The souvenirs once covering the genitals of young black males were turned into fetish objects as the crowd of fascinated onlookers took visual reminder of the lifeless naked bodies. These photographic records seem to verify that ritualized lynching fulfilled a sexual desire for the white voyeur. Black men are shown with their genitals mutilated or completely severed from their bodies, with a bloodied sheet covering the wounds. The practice of lynching black males, in combination with photographic evidence, bears witness to the psychosexual pathologies of white spectators and reveals a fascination with eroticized scenes of torture and death.

ANTIGAY VIOLENCE

Before 1990 and the passing of the Hate Crime Statistics Act, federal and state law simply ignored the problem of antigay violence. Only in the last few decades have violent crimes against lesbians and gays been referred to as hate crimes. In 1986 the U.S. House of Representatives Judiciary Subcommittee on Criminal Justice met to discuss antigay violence. At that meeting psychologists, physicians, sociologists, and other members of the medical community compiled evidence of antigay violence and shared testimony revealing a systemic national antigay sentiment that pervaded schools, churches, courtrooms, and other public spaces. In 1984 the National Gay and Lesbian Task Force compiled statistics from about 1,500 gay males and more than 650 lesbians to gather data on antigay violence. Nineteen percent of the participants described being physically assaulted as a result of their sexual orientation; 44 percent suffered verbal threats of violence, and 92 percent of those threatened admitted to persistent harassment.

When comparing governmental and law-enforcement statistics of antigay violence to those collected from private agencies, a striking trend is obvious; the figures reported from law enforcement agencies are drastically lower than those of advocacy groups and nonprofit agencies. Groups such as the National Coalition of Antiviolence Programs reported 2,212 crimes against gay men in 1995, whereas the FBI estimated only 1,266 offenses, pointing to either a gross miscalculation or a great deal of underreporting. Because lodging a formal complaint requires a police report with identification of the victim, some gays and lesbians choose to remain anonymous rather than call attention to their sexual orientation. In some cases homosexuals would rather suffer antigay violence than disclose sexual orientation to family members and the larger community.

Historically, the relationship between law officials and homosexuals has been volatile, culminating in a massive protest staged by gays, lesbians, and transvestites in 1969 called the Stonewall Riots or Stonewall Rebellion. In June 1969 police raided the Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village, a popular gay bar that served liquor without a license. Police and more than 1,000 protesters clashed in the streets, marking the first of many protests staged by gays and lesbians in the days to come. Most credit the Stonewall Riots as the beginning of the gay rights movement, the mobilization and organized protest rallies signaling a united front against homophobia and antigay violence. Gay Pride Week—typically held during the last week in June and marked by parades, costumes, marches, and rallies—celebrates gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgendered, and transvestite lifestyles while also commemorating the events at Stonewall and the struggle for gay rights.

SPECIFIC HATE CRIMES

What follows is a list and description of some of the more notable, or well-known, hate crimes that occurred in the United States between the years 1955 and 2006:

August 28, 1955: Emmett Till (b. 1941), an African-American male, disappeared from a small town in Mississippi while visiting relatives. Till, a native of Chicago, allegedly whistled at a white woman outside of a grocery store, infuriating the white citizens who witnessed the event. Allegedly, the white woman's husband and brother-in-law kidnapped Till from his family's home, beat him to death, tied a heavy metal fan blade around his neck, and threw his body in the Tallahatchie River. Till was only fourteen years old at the time of his death and his mother asked for an open casket so that the world could see what they did to her child. The trial gained national attention, with both accused men acquitted of the crime by a jury of all-white males. Many argue that Till's brutal murder generated a great deal of momentum for the civil rights movement.

June 12, 1963: Famed civil rights leader Medgar Evers (b. 1925) was shot and killed at his home in Jackson, Mississippi. The sniper shot Evers in his driveway, though Evers was able to crawl to his front steps before collapsing and later dying at a local hospital. Byron De La Beckwith (1920–2001), a KKK member, was charged with the murder, but two Jackson juries deadlocked on the decision to convict. It would be thirty years later, on February 5, 1994, when Beckwith would finally be convicted of Evers's death; he spent the rest of his life in prison. The film Ghosts of Mississippi (1996) tells the story of Beckwith's final trial and conviction.

June 21, 1964: Three civil rights workers were arrested for allegedly speeding in Philidelphia, Mississippi. Micheal Schwerner (b. 1939), James Chaney (b. 1943), and Andrew Goodman (b. 1943) were part of the Freedom Riders, a group of college students protesting segregation in the South. After the three men spent the day in jail, police officers released them in the evening, ignoring their requests to stay at the facility until morning. Waiting in the dark were several KKK members who systematically shot each man on a country road and hid their bodies in an earthen dam. The case pointed to a conspiracy between Klan members and police officials, and the trials reflected the segregationist leanings of judges and juries. Most of the men responsible for the attack escaped any punishment, and the strictest prison sentence for the murderers was six years. The motion picture Mississippi Burning (1988) chronicles the FBI search for the missing boys.

April 4, 1968: A sniper in Memphis, Tennessee, fatally shot Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr. (b. 1929) as he prepared for a scheduled demonstration. Riots broke out across the entire country in a wave of violence that left forty-six people dead, 2,600 injured, and 21,270 in prison. In the wake of mob violence estimated damage from vandalism and arson was more than $45 million.

October 19, 1973: A group of militant black Muslims called the Death Angels attacked two white victims, Richard and Quinta Hague, with machetes in San Francisco, California. Quinta Hague died from the attack and her husband was severely injured. By killing white men and women the Death Angels earned their wings and became prominent members of the gang. After six months and fourteen deaths, the Death Angels' killing spree finally ceased.

August 19, 1980: Notorious member of the KKK and American Nazi Party, Joseph Paul Franklin, shot two black joggers in Salt Lake City, Utah. The victims, David Martin (age twenty) and Theodore Fields (age eighteen), were allegedly shot for running beside two white women. Franklin was also charged with bombing the Beth Shalom synagogue in 1977 and in May 1980 of attempting to assassinate Vernon Jordan (b. 1935), the once National Urban League director. Franklin only targeted interracial couples or Jews and before his capture was responsible for killing twenty-one people.

August 7, 1998: James Byrd, a forty-nine-year-old African American, was dragged to death by two white supremacist members of the Aryan Nation. On an asphalt street in Jasper, Texas, Byrd was chained to a pickup truck and dragged for almost two miles. The men purportedly told Byrd: "We're starting the Turner Diaries early." A revered text amongst neo-Nazis, The Turner Diaries encourages the slaying of African Americans and Jews. One of the murderers, John William King (age twenty-four), was convicted of the murder and sentenced to death.

October 6, 1998: Matthew Shepard (b. 1976) left a local college bar in Laramie, Wyoming, with two men who claimed, as did Shepard, to be gay. After driving to a deserted rural area, the two men tied Shepard to a fence, severely beat him, and left him for dead. Almost eighteen hours later Shepard was discovered by a cyclist who found him unconscious and suffering from hypothermia. Shepard remained in a coma for five days before dying from massive head trauma that made it impossible for doctors to operate. In response to their son's death, the Shepard family created the Matthew Shepard Foundation to encourage diversity and support education and tolerance.

Friday July 28, 2006: Naveed Afzal Haq, a Muslim American claiming to be angry with Israel, walked into a Jewish community center in Seattle, Washington, and opened fire, killing one woman and wounding five others.

Critics of hate-crime legislation argue that people charged with hate crimes are essentially punished for holding certain opinions, something that tramples on the First and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution. Even though the First Amendment guarantees freedom of speech, some forms of personal expression, such as libel, obscenities, and language that either provokes violence or causes injury, are not sanctioned under the First Amendment. How to interpret whether some forms of hate speech fall under the protection of the First Amendment has some lawmakers uncertain. Legislators also cite the Fourteenth Amendment, which delineates equal protection under the law, as proof that enhanced penalty laws are unconstitutional.

Under the Fourteenth Amendment, each individual tried in court for a crime must be treated in the same manner as others tried for similar crimes. If a person charged with murder is given an enhanced penalty for a hate crime, critics argue that punishments are not assigned consistently or in line with equal protection. In addition, some argue that victims of hate crimes receive increased protection under the law simply because they meet the criteria of a protected group.

Susan Gellman, attorney in the Ohio public defender's office, writing in the UCLA Law Review, makes clear the positions of legal scholars against hate-crime laws:

Those who oppose ethnic intimidation laws, or at least who question them most vigorously, do not disagree that bigotry (and certainly bigotry-related crime) is a serious problem. On the contrary, they are also from the ranks of the most civil rights-conscious thinkers and activists. These critics focus on threats to constitutional liberties under the First and Fourteenth Amendments. Their concerns are that these laws tread dangerously close to criminalization of speech and thought, that they impermissibly distinguish among people based on their beliefs, and that they are frequently too vaguely drafted to provide adequate notice of prohibited conduct.

                              (1991, 30: pp. 333-396)

Although critics argue that hate-crime legislation might infringe on the rights of citizens and turn law enforcement officials into a thought police, many believe that strict deterrents—jail time, restitution for families, and community service, for instance—make perpetrators of hate crimes aware of the penalties for their actions.

see also Homophobia; Rape; Shepard, Matthew Wayne.

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Altschiller, Donald. 1999. Hate Crimes. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO.

Amnesty International. 2001. Crimes of Hate, Conspiracy of Silence: Torture and Ill Treatment Based on Sexual Identity. New York: Author.

Bureau of Justice Statistics. Available from http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/bjs/.

Civil Rights Act of 1968, 25 U.S.C. §§ 1301-03.

Gellman, Susan. 1991. "Sticks and Stones Can Put You in Jail, But Can Words Increase Your Sentence? Constitutional and Policy Dilemmas of Ethnic Intimidation Laws." UCLA Law Review 39: 333-396.

"Crimes in the United States 2004." Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. Available from http://www.fbi.gov/ucr/cius_04/offenses_reported/hate_crime/index.html.

Hate Crime Statistics Act of 1990, P.L. 101-275, 104 Stat. 140.

Lawrence, Frederick M. 1999. Punishing Hate: Bias Crimes under American Law. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Levin, Jack, and Jack McDevitt. 1993. Hate Crimes: The Rising Tide of Bigotry and Bloodshed. New York: Plenum Press.

Partner's Against Hate. Available from http://www.partnersagainsthate.org/law_enforcement/resources.html.

Sloan, Lacy M., and Nora S. Gustavsson, eds. 1998. Violence and Social Injustice against Lesbian, Gay, and Bisexual People. New York: Haworth Press.

Streissguth, Tom. 2003. Hate Crimes. New York: Facts on File.

Violence against Women Act of 1994, 42 U.S.C. § 13981.

                                              Melissa Fore

More From encyclopedia.com