Tawney, R. H.
Tawney, R. H.
R . H. Tawney (1880-1962), English social and economic historian, was the son of a distinguished Sanskrit scholar who was principal of the Presidency College in Calcutta. He was educated at Rugby, where he acquired a grounding in the classics and the Old Testament which profoundly affected his prose style, and where he struck up one of the most important friendships of his life— with William Temple, future archbishop of Canterbury. From Rugby he went to Balliol College, Oxford, where he came under the influence of the great tutor and master of Balliol, A. L. Smith, and also of Bishop Gore, whose theological and social doctrines provided the inspiration of his career. In 1903 he obtained a Second in Greats. “I grant you his mind was chaotic,” remarked the master of Balliol, “but his examiners ought to have seen that it was the chaos of a great mind.”
After graduating, Tawney worked first in the University Settlement in the east end of London, where he saw something of the horrors of slum landlordism, and then for the newly founded Workers’ Educational Association, which was to remain one of the chief interests of his career. Given the glaring inequalities of the existing educational system, this was work of the first importance, bringing an opportunity to men and women of lower-class origin to develop their latent intellectual interests.(One of Tawney’s first pupils was a future editor of the Manchester Guardian, A. P. Wadsworth.) In 1913 Tawney was appointed director of the Ratan Tata Foundation for the study of poverty at the London School of Economics, but two years later he enlisted in the infantry, characteristically in the ranks rather than as an officer, and was very severely wounded in 1916. One result of this terrible experience was a notable contribution to the literature of war called The Attack (1953).
In 1918 Tawney was elected fellow of Balliol, but within a year he moved to a readership in economic history at the London School of Economics. The next decade was the most fruitful of his career, as he threw himself into left-wing politics, educational propaganda, teaching, and research. He was involved in the general strike of 1926; he set out his passionate social and political convictions in two brilliant and immediately successful books, The Acquisitive Society (1920) and Equality (1931); he was joint editor of the newly founded Economic History Review for its first crucial seven years; and his output of scholarly works was at its height. From 1931 to 1949 he held the title of professor at the London School of Economics, where he instructed generation after generation of honors students in the social and economic history of Tudor and early Stuart England.
With the outbreak of World War n, Tawney’s services were enlisted as labor attache at the British embassy in Washington, but he was unhappy in this safe administrative backwater and soon returned to the perils and hardships of London. Between 1943 and 1948 he was an influential figure on the University Grants Committee at a time when it had a major role to play in the expansion of higher education.
Writings. The period from 1540 to 1640 is now familiarly known as “Tawney’s century,” a tribute paid by both friends and enemies to his towering position in English historiography. In 1912 he published The Agrarian Problem in the Sixteenth Century in which he tackled the problem of land use in an underdeveloped economy where old social and economic relationships were giving way under the impact of a price revolution and a demographic explosion. His ethical presuppositions may have made him too ready to see all landlords as the rapacious predators they often were, his solution to the problem—to turn customary tenures into freeholds—may have been an oversimplification, but the book opened a new era in historical studies in England and has formed the starting point for a huge amount of subsequent research. A year later he made a pioneer study (1913) of why the landed classes tried to regulate wages and of the practical results of their efforts. In 1924 the three volumes of Tudor Economic Documents were published, edited in collaboration with Eileen Power, which at once made the sixteenth century the best-documented period in the economic history of England. The next year Tawney wrote a long introduction to an edition of an Elizabethan tract, Thomas Wilson’s Discourse Upon Usury. It contains a brilliant analysis of the foreign exchange and internal credit problems of an under-capitalized economy dependent on precious metals for its circulating medium, a vivid description of the new monied classes ruthlessly exploiting their opportunities, and an account of the shifts of official policy towards usury in the light of changing economic circumstances and ideological theories.
In 1926 Tawney published his most popular work, Religion and the Rise of Capitalism, in which he used his great knowledge of early seventeenth-century English Puritan literature to reformulate a thesis previously put forward by Max Weber. Tawney argued that it was not so much Calvinist theological doctrines that, directly or indirectly, created the spirit of capitalism as it was individualism and the concomitant ethic of thrift and hard work that created an efficient labor force and a rational organization of industrial activity. The hypothesis was, and remains, controversial, but it has stimulated generations of students to think about the relationship between religion and economics.
The thirties were a fallow period in Tawney’s historical output: his only historical publication (1934) was an analysis of a unique occupational census for Gloucestershire in 1608. He was working on a comprehensive study of the sixteenth-century and early seventeenth-century social scene which in the end was never published, although the skeleton of the work was presented in his Ford lectures at Oxford in 1936.
In the meantime he traveled to China, and the result of his visit was a remarkable pioneer work (1932) on the problems of a country struggling to leap from the fifteenth century to the twentieth, and some concrete proposals for a democratic solution to those problems. Tawney applied to modern China his twenty years of study of preindustrial European societies, using this knowledge to illuminate and give depth to his analysis.
War had already broken out when Tawney published in two famous articles (194la; 1941b) his interpretation of the relationship between the political events of the 1640s and changes in the English social structure. He argued that in the century before the Civil War various factors, notably different capacities to adjust landed income to the price revolution and different habits of expenditure, caused a shift in the balance of property from the magnates to the medium-sized landlords, labeled respectively “peers” and “gentry”; and that, as James Harrington had pointed out at the time, it was this shift that caused the collapse of the anden regime in 1640 and so opened the way to Civil War and the subsequent abolition of monarchy, aristocracy, and episcopacy. [See Harrington.] Tawney saw the war in terms of a clash between the progressive, capitalist forces and the decaying semifeudal elements in the society. This thesis has since come under bitter criticism, and the truth of the concept of the rise of the gentry remains an open question (H. R. Trevor-Roper 1953; J. H. Hexter 1961). What Tawney certainly achieved, however, was to stimulate interest in the long-term sociological antecedents of the Civil War, and in doing so he provoked a mass of detailed research.
Finally in 1958 he published a study of Lionel Cranfield, the Jacobean cloth exporter and government speculator turned crown economic adviser, who eventually became lord treasurer of England. In this work Tawney once again broke new ground by forcing attention away from the parliamentary opposition, where it had rested for decades, and back to the deficiencies of the central government itself. Since he was a moralist as well as an economic historian, the corrosion of an aristocratic society under the acid of London finance capital was a theme admirably suited to his pen.
Assessment as a historian . The driving impulses of Tawney’s life were his individual brand of radical Christianity, his burning hatred of social injustice, and his profound suspicion of money. He was not merely indifferent to money, he actively disliked it. All his historical writings are deeply affected by these ethical and religious preoccupations. He was always, and unashamedly, concerned with making the world a better place to live in, as well as with advancing the frontiers of knowledge. As a professional scholar his technical equipment was far from ideal. His references were not always accurate; his grasp of statistical method was sometimes imperfect; his appreciation of impersonal economic forces like demographic growth and monetary inflation was obscured by his anxiety to identify personal or class responsibility for the ills of the world. Although he could be a dazzlingly brilliant stylist, there were times when his jewelled sentences tended to collapse under their own weight.
What, then, is Tawney’s claim to greatness? Historiography does not proceed in a smooth line but by a series of sudden jerks. Every now and then a genius emerges who shifts the emphasis of historical interpretation and directs attention to a new aspect of human affairs until then unnoticed and unappreciated. In English historiography there have been only five such giants—William Stubbs, F. W. Maitland, T. F. Tout, Namier, and Tawney. It is Tawney who directed attention to the close relationship between religious ideologies and ethical codes on the one hand and economic growth and government action on the other; Tawney who demonstrated the importance of economic relationships, such as those between landlord and tenant, employer and worker, in determining the character of a society; Tawney who formulated a sociological interpretation of one of the three great revolutions in modern European history; Tawney who published the documentary tools and generated the enthusiasm which has made his chosen period a standard subject of study in most English secondary schools and one of the most flourishing fields of graduate research in recent years. Tawney’s interpretations may ultimately prove to need revision, but it looks as if the problems to which he first drew attention will continue to preoccupy English historians for a long time to come.
Lawrence Stone
[Directly related is the entry History, articles on Economic Historyand Social History; other relevant material may be found in the biography of Weber, Max]
WORKS BY TAWNEY
(1912) 1963 The Agrarian Problem in the Sixteenth Century. New York: Franklin.
1913 The Assessment of Wages in England by the Justices of the Peace. Vierteljahrsschrift fur Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte 11:307-337, 533-564.
(1914) 1937 Bland, Alfred E.; BROWN, P. A.; and Tawney, R. H. (editors) English Economic History: Select Documents. London: Bell.
1920 The Acquisitive Society. New York: Harcourt. ? A paperback edition was published in 1948.
(1924) 1953 TAWNEY, R. H.; and Power, Eileen (editors) Tudor Economic Documents: Being Select Documents Illustrating the Economic and Social History of Tudor England. 3 vols. New York: Longmans. ? Volume 1: Agriculture and Industry. Volume 2: Commerce, Finance and Poor Law. Volume 3: Pamphlets, Memoranda and Literary Extracts.
(1926) 1963 Religion and the Rise of Capitalism: A Historical Study. Gloucester, Mass.: Smith.
(1931) 1952 Equality. 4th ed., rev. London: Allen & Un-win. ? A paperback edition was published in 1961 by Putnam.
(1932) 1964 Land and Labour in China. New York: Octagon Books.
1934 TAWNEY, A. J.; and Tawney, R. H. An Occupational Census of the Seventeenth Century. Economic History Review First Series 5:25-64.
1941a Harrington’s Interpretation of His Age. British Academy, London, Proceedings 27:199-223.
1941b The Rise of the Gentry: 1558-1640. Economic History Review First Series 11:1-38.
1953 The Attack, and Other Papers. London: Allen & Unwin; New York: Harcourt.
1954 The Rise of the Gentry: A Postscript. Economic History Review Second Series 7:91-97.
1958a Business and Politics Under James I: Lionel Cran-field as Merchant and Minister. Cambridge Univ. Press.
1958b Social History and Literature. Leicester (England) Univ. Press.
SUPPLEMENTARY BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ashton, Thomas S. 1962 Richard Henry Tawney, 1880-1962. British Academy, London, Proceedings 48:461-482.
Hexter, J. H. 1961 Reappraisals in History: New Views on History and Society in Early Modern Europe. Evanston, 111.: Northwestern Univ. Press. ? A paperback edition was published in 1963 by Harper. See especially the essay “Storm Over the Gentry,” first published in 1958 in Encounter.
Trevor-Roper, H. R. 1953 The Gentry: 1540-1640. London: Cambridge Univ. Press.
Wilson, Thomas (1572)1925 A Discourse Upon Usury by Way of Dialogue and Orations . . . With an historical introduction by R. H. Tawney. London: Bell; New York: Harcourt.
