Sweden

views updated

SWEDEN

Toward the end of the nineteenth century, the Swedish writer August Strindberg, wrote several plays, novels, and short stories dealing in a pertinent fashion with religion and doubt, the relations between men and women, the father and his position in the family. He described the hypocrisy and the destructive forces, the unconscious motivations, the representations and specific conflicts of man at the turn of the century. In 1893 the name of his contemporary, Sigmund Freud, was mentioned in Sweden for the first time in a medical review, along with those of Josef Breuer, Pierre Janet, and Jean Martin Charcot. The article, dealing with traumatic neuroses, was written by Frithiof Lennmalm, a professor of nervous pathology.

Freud wrote On the History of the Psychoanalytic Movement in 1914. Nine years later, in 1923, he felt obliged to specify in a note: "At the present time the Scandinavian countries are still the least receptive."

Psychoanalysis was introduced to Sweden in a manner that was at least unique. The two pioneers, Emanuel af Geijerstam, installed in Göteborg from 1898 to 1928, and Poul Bjerre, who worked in Stockholm and its surroundings for almost half a century, shared a similar attitude: they were both interested in psychoanalysis but were keenly critical of it. Geijerstam, a researcher and psychotherapist, approved of the theses of Alfred Adler and Carl Gustav Jung, without however being hostile to psychoanalysis. He wrote about Freud in 1902 but, from 1916 until his death, he persistently stressed that "anagogic analysis" constituted a progression on Freudian psychoanalysis. And when Geijerstam went on a study trip it was not to Vienna but to Zurich.

Poul Bjerre met Freud in December 1910. At a conference of the Swedish medical association the following year he introduced a part of Freudian theory. He went on to translate and in 1924 to publish some articles by Freud. From the time of his first encounter with the founder of psychoanalysis, and particularly after 1912, he was convinced that his own work was more important. For Bjerre, Freud had become bogged down in a mechanistic science that specifically prevented him from understanding the scope of psychosynthesis. Thus, for thirty years Freud was represented in Sweden by two physicians specializing in nervous diseases, having different points of view, but who shared their refusal to take on board the totality of Freud's theory.

In the bulletins of the Swedish medical association we find criticism of Freud as early as 1910. The tone was set by two eminent physicians, Bror Gadelius (1862-1938) and Olof Kinberg (1873-1960). Gadelius, a psychiatrist, adopted the following stance: "Freud has overestimated the importance of sexuality; this is because of the nature of his clientele who, in a cosmopolitan city like Vienna, have a particular propensity for exaggeration. We cannot never overstress the fact that alongside the sexual complexes—whose role in the appearance of hysteria I in no way wish to underestimate—there exist other complexes charged with affect that can give birth to neuroses and hysteria, and how much these complexes go hand in hand with the "Ich Triebe [ego-instincts]." However, this point of view did not prevent Gadelius from acknowledging the merits of Freud's theory. In his important work on psychiatry, Det mänskliga Själsivet (The Human Soul), he specifically wrote that "in recent years, largely thanks to Freud and his school, much more attention has been accorded than previously to the importance of the sexual instinct in psychic life." To sum up, Giejerstam and Bjerre, who are generally considered to have introduced psychoanalysis to Sweden, and Gadelius, the greatest critic and opponent of the discipline, adopted a similar position.

Simultaneous with the growing interest in psychoanalysis in Sweden at the end of the 1920s, we find the increasing hostility of several influential physicians and academics. This resistance had already made its appearance in 1911 when Poul Bjerre tried to publish his conference, "The Psychoanalytic Method," in which he gave the most positive presentation of psychoanalysis and met with what he considered to be unjustified criticism. Presentations delivered within the framework of the Swedish medical association were normally published in the review Hygiea. Bjerre's was refused on the pretext that it was too long. In addition, Gadelius indulged in a methodical criticism of psychoanalysis in his work Tro och helbrägdagörelse. Jämte en kritisk studie av psykoanalysen (Faith and Healing. A Critical Study of Psychoanalysis), published in 1934.

The review Clarté, which had socialist leanings, was a branch of the international Clarté movement and acted as a platform for psychoanalysis. In the latter half of the twenties it published the texts of the Swedish pioneers of Freudianism. A few intellectuals believed that psychoanalysis could perhaps be used to formulate a radical theory of society. Interest in psychoanalysis was essentially linked to this aspect and was marked by its pragmatism. In the thirties literary circles little by little began to take an interest in psychoanalysis. This interest took many forms, including the creation of the review Spektrum, which published modernist poetry and translations of psychoanalysts like Anna Freud, Erich Fromm, and Wilhelm Reich. One of the Swedish pioneers, Per Henrik Törngren, who went into analysis with Ludwig Jekels a few years later, was part of the editing committee and published his own texts in the review. During this same period Sweden saw the publication of considerable extracts from The Interpretation of Dreams, as well as, in their entirety, The Future of an Illusion and Civilization and Its Discontents.

In August 1931 the pioneers of psychoanalysis in the Scandinavian countries met to discuss for the first time the formation of a psychoanalytic society. Among the participants were Sigurd Naesgaard, a Dane; Harald Schjelderup, a Norwegian; Vriö Kulovesi, a Finn, and Alfhild Tamm, a Swede. Tamm, who organized the meeting, had international experience and had been a member since 1926 of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society. The Scandinavian group then split into two societies, a Danish-Norwegian society and a Finnish-Swedish society, for which she became the spokes-person. Tamm was the first woman psychiatrist in Sweden. Her theoretical work was of minimal importance. She invoked the tradition of the Enlightenment to combat prejudice with regard to masturbation and sought to understand the mechanisms of aphasia. Tamm was too much on her own for the first ten years to enable the society to become influential and the activities of the pioneers of psychoanalysis were somewhat limited.

The early thirties saw the arrival in Scandinavian countries of psychoanalysts who had been trained in Central Europe, particularly Vienna and Berlin. The Viennese Ludwig Jekels, a student of Freud's, settled in Sweden from 1934 to 1937. He saw his work as a training analyst in Stockholm as a difficult and thankless task and he finally left Sweden with the feeling that he had failed in his mission. As was common at the time, some Nordic pioneers made the journey to Vienna, Berlin, or Zurich to be analyzed by August Aichhorn, Helene Deutsch, Paul Federn, Eduard Hitschmann, Oskar Pfister, or Harald Schultz-Hencke.

The Nordic psychoanalysts were looking for more competent colleagues than themselves who would be capable of training them, and from 1926 onward they began to organize themselves along the lines of the model fixed by the International Psychoanalytic Association (IPA). Scandinavian countries simultaneously witnessed the creation of new psychotherapy societies based on an eclectic concept of psychotherapy and the exclusion of some of the bases of psychoanalysis, such as the theory of infantile sexuality and dream theory.

In 1932 Norway saw the formation of the Nordisk Psykoanalytisk Samfund (Nordic Psychoanalytic Society) under the presidency of Alfhild Tamm with, among its most notable members, Poul Bjerre and Sugurd Naesgaard. In Denmark the Psykoanalytisk Samfund was founded in December 1933, with Swedish Poul Bjerre, Danish Sigurd Naesgaard, and Norwegian Irgens Stromme playing the leading roles.

During World War II the Dutch psychoanalyst René de Moncy, a personal friend of Freud, went to live in Sweden as a result of his encounter in Vienna with the Jewish Swedish psychoanalyst Vera Palmstierna, who had been in analysis with Freud. The couple settled in Stockholm. René de Moncy had played a major role in the Dutch Society and was to play an equally important role in Sweden during the eight years that he lived there. He was psychoanalyst to Ola Andersson (1919-1990) and the Hungarian psychologist Lajos Székely (1904-1995) who was practicing in Sweden. Székely was a Jewishémigré who had arrived in 1944 with his wife Edith, a physician and psychoanalyst. He had trained as an analyst firstly in Hungary, then in Germany and Holland during the 1930s, and finally in Sweden. He was to play a major role in the 1950s by providing analytic training for Swedish physicians and psychologists. He wrote on a variety of subjects, among them the links between the unconscious and creativity. Székely spoke several languages and published articles in English, French, Swedish, German, and Hungarian.

Stefi Pedersen (1908-1980) began her analytic training in the Berlin Psychoanalytic Institute. She was first analyzed by Otto Fenichel in Berlin and later joined him in Oslo. In Sweden—where she arrived with a group of Jewish children after a stay in Norway—she worked in the Swedish Psychoanalytic Society (Svenska Psykoanalytiska Föreringen). She did a second analysis, this time as trainee, with René de Monchy. Her status as a member of the Society did not prevent her from adopting an independent and critical position. She was rather radical in her thinking and was attracted by Alexander Mitscherlich's theses. She wrote articles on vulnerability and the effects of the Nazi terror on psychoanalysts and clinical work. She published texts in English, German, Norwegian, and Swedish.

In August 1943, Tore Ekman (1887-1971) returned to Sweden after practicing for nearly twenty years in Berlin and Leipzig, as well as working as "Lektor " in Leipzig University. He trained under Therese Benedek, a close friend of Alfhild Tamm, and went on to play a role of capital importance in the Swedish Psychoanalytic Society, although he published very little. The psychoanalyst and theorist of science, Carl Lesche (1920-1993), a Finnishémigré in Sweden in the early 1950s, was also to occupy an important position in the Swedish Society between the 1960s and the 1980s. Among his influences were philosophers Wilhelm Dilthey, Edmund Husserl, and Karl-Otto Apel. The question of the classification of psychoanalysis was to take on a new dimension with him. He claimed that it was essential to define what made psychoanalysis more of a hermeneutic discipline than a natural science and to point out where it differed from psychotherapy. However, the influence of Lesche has not extended beyond the borders of Sweden.

Swedish psychoanalysts have done little research work and have made few important contributions to the history and theory of psychoanalysis. Ola Anders-son's thesis, "Freud before Freud. The Prehistory of Psychoanalysis" (1962) constitutes a remarkable exception, as does academic Gunnar Brandell's more substantial essay, "Freud a Child of his Century" (1961). Ola Andersson wrote an in-depth study of the context in the history of ideas that saw the birth and evolution of Freud's thinking up to 1896, the time when he formulated the concept of psychoanalysis. Andersson stressed the importance of the influence of Herbart on Freud and conducted original research into the true identity of Emmy von N. Andersson and Brandell. Both took part in Uppsala University seminars conducted by Wilhelm Sjöstrand, a pedagogue and history enthusiast who organized seminars at the end of the 1950s, during the time Michel Foucault was teaching at this university.

Few psychoanalysts in Sweden have taken an interest in philosophy, the theory of science, or the history of ideas, just as few Swedish philosophers and academics have studied Freudian theory, with one exception: researchers in the psychology department of Lund University have taken an interest in psychoanalysis since the 1940s.

The Swedish Psychoanalytic Society now numbers more than one hundred and ninety members and there is ever growing interest in its training program. Toward the middle of the 1960s, voices were nevertheless raised in criticism of this training. In 1963 one of the society's psychoanalysts, Margit Norell, secretary to the training group, founded a work group with some of the analysands. This work resulted in 1968 in the formal creation of the Swedish Society for Holistic Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis (SSHPP), which joined the International Federation of Psychoanalytic Societies (IFPS) in 1972. The SSHPP was initially supported by neo-Freudians, Erich Fromm, Frieda Fromm-Reichmann, and Harry Stack Sullivan. Harold Kelman, an American closely allied with Karen Horney, greatly contributed to its development. He organized seminars and was thesis director for many teachers. Toward the end of the 1970s, the SSHPP took an increasing interest in the theory of object relations, particularly in the work of theoreticians like Melanie Klein, Ronald Fairbairn, Donald Winnicott, and even Wilfred Bion. This same period saw intensified relations between the Swedish Psychoanalytic Society and the Swedish Society for Holistic Psychotherapy and Psychoanalysis, which began to study Freud more than ever. In May 1992 it was decided in agreement with the majority of the members to request affiliation with the IPA. Since then the IPA has never ceased to grow and it now numbers about seventy-five members.

In the 1970s, Swedes began to take an interest in Jacques Lacan and French psychoanalysis. This interest coincided with the publication in Swedish of the works of the French structuralists. A first translation of Lacan's work appeared, entitledÉcrits, but containing less than 15 percent of the French edition ofÉcrits, and was followed by pirate publications of other translations of texts by Lacan. Inspired by Lacan's work, a few rare researchers in human sciences were seduced by the idea of establishing links between psychoanalysis and modern linguistics. For a short period during the 1970s and 1980s, psychoanalysts from South America and the United States trained psychologists and physicians at Göteborg. In 1974 the Göteborg Institute for Psychotherapy (Göteborg Psykoterapi Institut) was founded, its founders, the Argentinean psychoanalysts Angel and Dora Fiasché, having been trained in their own country by the IPA. Dora Fiasché is a philosopher and still a member of the IPA. Angel Fiasché is a physician and has since left the IPA. The Fiaschés, who consider themselves to be socialists, are close to Kleinian psychoanalysis in terms of theory. They have worked with, among others, León Grinberg, Maria Langer, and Enrique Pichon-Rivière. They regularly return to Göte-borg and several members of the Institute have been to Buenos Aires for professional reasons. In terms of its orientation the Göteborg Institute for Psychotherapy is eclectic and pragmatic and adopts a radical position on social questions. It now has more than forty members. Just as in Göteborg, the interest in the theoretical works of Melanie Klein has also increased elsewhere.

In Sweden the dawn of the twenty-first century has seen renewed criticism of psychoanalysis, coming in equal parts from academic psychology and biological psychiatry. This has not prevented psychoanalysts and researchers from all quarters from taking part in a joint project: the publication in Swedish by a major publishing house of the complete works of Sigmund Freud. In 2002, the review Psykoanalytisk tid/Skrifr began publication in Göteborg; it is mainly orientated toward French psychoanalysis and thought.

Per Magnus Johansson, David Titelman

Bibliography

Gadelius, Bror. (1934). Tro och helbrägdagörelse jämte en kritisk studie av psykoanalysen. Stockholm: Hugo Gebers.

Johansson, Per Magnus. (1999). Freuds psykoanalys, utgângspunkter/arvtagare i Sverige. Göteborg: Daïdalos.

—— (2003). Freuds psykoanalys, arvtagare i Sverige. Göte-borg: Daïdalos.

Luttenberger, Franz. (1989). Freud i Sverige. Stockholm: Carlsson Bokförlag.

Törngren, Pehr Henrik. (1936). Striden om Freud. Stockholm: Albert Bonniers Förlag.

More From encyclopedia.com