Cosmetics
Cosmetics
INDUSTRIAL CODES
NAICS: 32-5620 Toilet Preparation Manufacturing
SIC: 2844 Perfumes, Cosmetics, and Other Toilet Preparations Manufacturing
NAICS-Based Product Codes: 32-5620D111, 32-5620D121, 32-5620D141, 32-5620D241, 32-5620G111 through 32-5620G131, 32-5620G311 through 32-5620G331, 32-5620G351, and 32-5620G381 through 32-5620G3A1
PRODUCT OVERVIEW
Color cosmetics fall into five well-defined categories, depending on where they are used on the body—most often the female body: lips, eyes, face, nails, and cheeks. Because applying color cosmetics is part of what the French used to refer to as a woman's toilette, color cosmetics became known as toiletries. The French word toilette refers both to the room where the toilet is, and activities generally conducted in that room. As a result, the expression "to do one's toilette" emerged. This includes applying makeup, or applying color cosmetics.
The use of color cosmetics was historically associated with women of suspect morals. The advent of the cinema changed the perception of color cosmetics. Beautiful actresses appeared on the screen adorned with lush lips accentuated by red lipstick, color-shaded eyes, and thick black mascara. The emergence of the chain, or dime, store in the 1920s made color cosmetics available at the mass market level. After World War II, a number of cosmetic manufacturers emerged. For instance, Estée Lauder began operations in 1946 and with its Clinique brand became a pillar of prestige color cosmetics.
The major types of products associated with doing one's toilette are defined in a U.S. Census Bureau report titled "Toilet Preparation Manufacturing: 2002." The five major toilette product divisions, in order from largest to smallest based on 2002 market size, are:
- Cosmetics
- Hair preparations
- Creams, lotions, and oils
- Perfumes
- Shaving preparations
Figure 73 presents the size of each of these five major product divisions based on 2002 data. This essay focuses on a subset of the cosmetics division of the toilet preparation manufacturing industry.
MARKET
The market for all toilet preparation products in the United States was valued at almost $28 billion in 2002 according to the Census Bureau. Cosmetics accounted for $9.2 billion or 33 percent of the industry. Cosmetics are the largest and most profitable single division of toiletries.
The color cosmetics discussed in this essay are a subset of all cosmetics as defined by the Census Bureau. The subset covers five well-defined product classes, according to where they are used on the body: lips, eyes, face, nails, and cheeks. Figure 74 lists the products in the color cosmetic categopry which had shipments in 2002 of $5.1 billion.
Lips
Manufacturers' shipments of lip cosmetics—the largest product class within color cosmetics—almost tripled in size during the five-year period between 1997 and 2002, exploding in value from $1.0 billion to $2.7 billion, a growth of 157 percent. Lip cosmetics are a growing product class. In 1997 lip cosmetics represented 27 percent of the value of color cosmetics shipments. By 2002 lip cosmetics represented more than half (53%) of the total $5.1 billion color cosmetics shipment value.
This triple-digit growth may be seen by some as evidence of the 2001 recession because of an alleged economic indicator known as the lipstick effect. During a recession, consumers supposedly tend to spend more money on small, comforting items such as lipstick rather than large luxury items such as cars.
The triple-digit growth in lipsticks may also be evidence of innovations in lip care product formulations that resulted in a multi-functional product. Because lip skin is vulnerable to damage from sun, wind, and aging, reformulated lipsticks have been made to function as both color cosmetics and lip protection. Lipstick, lip glosses, and lip liners do double- or even triple-duty, functioning as colorants, sunscreens, moisturizers, and even plumpers. Other functions besides coloring include benefits such as gloss, long-lasting wear, and transfer resistance.
L'Oréal Paris, for instance, offers nine different lip cosmetic formulations: sheer gloss, moisturizing, zero-transfer, zero-transfer gloss, 8-hour, 8-hour liquid, shimmering 8-hour, plumping, and volumizing. Zero-transfer refers to zero-transfer when kissing. Even that old standby Chap Stick has been reformulated to be a skin protector with SPF 15.
Face
Manufacturers' shipments of face powder and foundation creams—the second largest product class within color cosmetics—were flat during the five-year period between 1997 and 2002, staying close to $925 million. This category combines two product classes: face powders and foundation creams. Face powders grew 22 percent in the five-year period between 1997 and 2002, from a total shipment value of $327 million to $400 million. Foundation creams dropped 12 percent in the same period, from a shipment value of $597 million down to $527 million. Even with the 12 percent drop in foundation creams, women still prefer cream foundation over face powder.
Overall, foundation's drop in shipments combined with powder's gain meant that face powder is becoming almost as popular as cream foundation. Face powder and foundation creams together remain a large and competitive color cosmetic product class. Makers tend to focus on face powder and foundation creams because for most women, face products remain a high loyalty category. America's Research Group reported that women have a penchant for buying brand name cosmetics; 35.2 percent reported that they were very loyal to a face cosmetic brand.
An article in Chain Drug Review summarized dollar sales of face powder and foundation creams for the year ending in January 2006 using data from Information Resources, Inc., for purchasing at drugstores, discounters, supercenters, supermarkets, warehouse clubs, and dollar stores. Such stores represent the mass market only, which is less than 50 percent of the total market and is commonly called masstige to characterize it as separate from the upscale prestige market. Prestige color cosmetic sales represent approximately 40 percent of the market. The top five face brands, with dollar sales and percent change over the prior 12-month period, were:
- Revlon Age Defying foundation—$34.8 million, up 88.9 percent
- Cover Girl Clean powder—$26.0 million, down 11 percent
- Cover Girl Clean powder—$21.40 million, down 12 percent
- L'Oréal True Match foundation—$19.6 million, down 13 percent
| Figures are in thousands of dollars unless otherwise specified. | |||||
| Product Class | 1997 Shipments | Percent of Total | 2002 Shipments | Percent of Total | Percentage Change 1997 to 2002 |
| Lipsticks, Lip Glosses, and Lip Pencils | 1,047,770 | 27.1 | 2,696,865 | 52.8 | 157.4 |
| Face Powder and Foundation Creams | 924,324 | 23.9 | 926,803 | 18.2 | 0.3 |
| Eye Cosmetics | 962,873 | 24.9 | 869,321 | 17.0 | ?9.7 |
| Nail Enamels, Polishes, and Polish Removers | 513,192 | 13.3 | 418,139 | 8.2 | ?18.5 |
| Blushers | 416,707 | 10.8 | 192,738 | 3.8 | ?53.7 |
| ? | ? | ? | |||
| Total | 3,864,866 | 5,103,866 | 32.1 | ||
- Maybelline Dream Matte foundation—$18.6 million, up 53 percent
Eyes
Manufacturers' shipments of eye cosmetics—the third largest product class within color cosmetics—declined 10 percent during the five-year period 1997 to 2002, from $963 million down to $869 million. Eye cosmetics generally consist of mascara, eye shadows, and eye liner. Part of the explanation behind the decline in eye makeup shipments is the more natural look that has been popular in Hollywood, with simple eyes and a focus on kissable lips.
Cosmetics manufacturers have not, however, lost interest in eye cosmetics. New products are regularly introduced, especially mascaras and eye liners. According to Chain Drug Review the following five masstige eye brands led U.S. sales in drugstores, discount stores, supercenters, supermarkets, warehouse clubs, and dollar stores for the year ending in January 2006. Those sales are listed as well as the percentage change over the prior 12-month period for all five leading products:
- Maybelline Great Lash mascara—$48.5 million, up 5 percent
- L'Oréal Voluminous mascara—$31.4 million, up 8 percent
- Maybelline XXL mascara—$28.3 million, up 153 percent
- Cover Girl Eye Enhancers mascara—$26.9 million, down 4 percent
- Revlon ColorStay eye liner—$22.7 million, up 15 percent
Of interest is the fact that bestselling brands are often produced by the same company so that manufacturers compete against themselves within some categories. L'Oréal, for example, owns both Maybelline and L'Oréal, and both brands have best selling mascara.
Nails
Nail polishes, enamels, and polish removers are the fourth largest color cosmetics class. Shipments of nail cosmetics declined 13 percent in the United States between 1997 and 2002, from a total of $513 million to $417 million. The use of nail polish appears to be on the decline. Long, brightly colored nails have been eclipsed by a natural look. Perhaps working women are too busy to apply color to their nails.
Cheeks
Blushers, the smallest color cosmetics classes, declined 54 percent in the five-year period between 1997 and 2002, from a U.S. shipment value of $417 million down to $193 million. This decline is likely the result of the 22 percent increase in face powder products that can be used to provide contour to the face but are not categorized as blushers.
The color cosmetics subset of the toilet products manufacturing industry grew 32 percent between 1997 and 2002, from industry shipments of $3.9 billion to $5.1 billion. Lip products, the largest group of color cosmetic products, saw the greatest growth while other product groups like those for cheeks and nails declined. Most manufacturers of color cosmetics have a full line of products, including items from each of the product categories. The toilet products manufacturing industry as a whole grew 23 percent in the five-year period from 1997 to 2002, from $23 billion in 1997 to $28 billion in 2002.
KEY PRODUCERS/MANUFACTURERS
Within the color cosmetics industry, some manufacturers have only top-drawer brands, and want to keep it that way. For instance, Chanel stays away from the masstige market fearing that association with the mass market will hurt, not help, sales. Other manufacturers such as L'Oréal have an impressive inventory of brands sold side-by-side at mass merchandisers such as Kmart and Target so that they have brands that compete with one another for sales.
A report by Citigroup Global Markets highlights the three top mass market color cosmetic makers who remained neck and neck over the period 2001 and 2004. In 2004 L'Oréal had a color cosmetic market share of 34 percent; Procter & Gamble (P&G) had a color cosmetic market share of 21 percent; and Revlon had a color cosmetic market share of 21 percent. Leading manufacturers are profiled in alphabetical order with note of popular brands.
Estée Lauder
The Estée Lauder portfolio consists of thousands of products across 26 brands, including Clinique. The Clinique franchise is a pillar of color cosmetics, so big it overshadows rival beauty brands. Lauder reported in August 2006 that Estée Lauder and Clinique are its fastest-growing prestige color cosmetic brands, as measured by same-store sales. Lauder also sells M-A-C and Bobbi Brown. It is committed to color cosmetics, where cream foundation tends to have the best margins. For most women, foundation is a high loyalty category. Once a person commits to Clinique or Bobbi Brown foundation, she or he rarely wants to change. Bobbi Brown planned to open 30 more U.S. doors in 2007. Lauder has 40,000 beauty consultants that helped make Clinique—and recently Bobbi Brown—pillars of color cosmetics. It renewed investment in training and educating its beauty consultants for one reason: consumers buy more under the auspices of a knowledgeable professional.
L'Oréal
Headquartered on Fifth Avenue in Manhattan, L'Oréal is the most successful mass market color cosmetic maker in the United States. L'Oréal is the U.S. color cosmetics leader with 34 percent of the mass market share. Its two strongest color cosmetics brands are Mabelline NY (taking 19% of mass color cosmetics market share) and L'Oréal Paris (with 15% of mass color cosmetics market share). L'Oréal grew both organically with its existing brands and through acquisitions such as Maybelline New York in 1996. L'Oréal is in a unique position in the color cosmetics market, selling both high-end products at department stores and low-end products at drugs stores and chain stores. Its Lancombe product line is more prestigious than Clinique and a longstanding color cosmetics brand.
Procter & Gamble
Cincinnati-based Procter & Gamble has been a giant in a wide range of consumer goods since its establishment in 1837. It produces nearly 300 brands in five segments: personal & beauty, house & home, health & wellness, baby & family, and pet nutrition & care. ICIS Chemical Business Americas reported in December 2006 that P&G is the second largest color cosmetics maker with 20.5 percent of the mass color cosmetics market. Its two strongest masstige color cosmetics brands are Cover Girl (taking 18% of market) and Max Factor (taking 3% of the market).
Revlon
According to ICIS Chemical Business Americas, Revlon moved up to capture 20.7 percent of the color cosmetics mass market in 2006 (with the Revlon brand taking 15% and the Almay brand taking 5%). Revlon was founded in 1932, by the Revson brothers and a chemist who contributed the "L" to the Revlon name. Starting with a single product—a nail enamel that used pigments instead of dyes—Revlon offered women a rich-looking, opaque nail enamel in a wide variety of shades. Revlon market has segments include cosmetics, skin care, fragrance, and personal care. Revlon's products are offered at affordable prices and it sponsors events that raise awareness and money for women's health issues. In the 1990s Revlon revitalized its color cosmetics business. It introduced the first transfer resistant lipcolor which led to a full ColorStay Collection of transfer-resistant color cosmetic products. Revlon's color cosmetic brands include Revlon, ColorStay, New Complexion, Revlon Age Defying, Super Lustrous, Almay, and Ultima II.
Other companies with important roles within the industry include Del Laboratories, Inc., Johnson & Johnson, Noxell Corporation, Shiseido Cosmetics Ltd., and Unilever. Avon and Mary Kay are two companies with a direct sales distribution model for color cosmetics.
MATERIALS & SUPPLY CHAIN LOGISTICS
The materials used by manufacturers in the production of color cosmetics consist of the ingredients necessary to produce the cosmetics as well as the materials needed to package them. Color cosmetics packaging plays an important part in marketing makeup products. Packaging provides color cosmetics with a means of product differentiation.
As a whole, the toiletries industry spent $8.0 billion in 2002 on the total cost of materials needed to make all kinds of toiletries, including color cosmetics. Of this, $5.6 billion was spent on packaging and other materials, and $2.4 billion was spent on ingredients. In other words, this industry spends 70 percent on packaging, and only 30 percent on buying ingredients that go into the cosmetics themselves. Industry-wide expenditures for plastic containers including jars, tubes, tubs, and bottles were $1.2 billion in 2002, more than on any other single ingredient class.
Setting the issue of plastics aside, this section examines that portion of the $2.4 billion industry-wide purchases of ingredients that end up on the lips, eyes, face, nails, and cheeks. The review is based on Census data for the entire toilet products industry because informa-tion about materials consumed is provided only at the industry-wide level, not at the individual product class level. The primary categories of ingredients needed to make toiletries of all kinds are, from largest to smallest in terms of industry-wide spending, as follows:
- Perfume oil mixtures and blends, essential oils (natural), and perfume materials (synthetic organic)—representing 41 percent of ingredient spending
- Synthetic organic chemicals—representing 30 percent of ingredient spending
- Bulk surface active agents (surfactants)—representing 10 percent of ingredient spending
Perfumes are used in the production process to impart a pleasant aroma to both the product and the packaging. Together, perfume ingredients purchased for their pleasant aroma accounted for almost 40 percent—or $935 million—of total industry ingredient spending in 2002. When purchasing aromas, more than 50 percent of the $935 million—$522 million—went toward perfume oil mixtures and blends. The cost to purchase essential oils (natural) decreased 7 percent between 1997 and 2002, dipping from $174 million down to $161 million.
The cost for purchasing perfume materials (synthetic organic), however, almost quadrupled in the five-year period that ended in 2002, ballooning from $67 million to $252 million, an increase of 278 percent. Synthetic organic perfume materials are created primarily from chemical compounds obtained during petroleum distillation, a process which separates petroleum into fractions according to their boiling temperatures. The advantages of synthetics are substantial. The almost quadrupling of their use shows how rapidly they became pervasive as ingredients. For manufacturers, they make economic sense because they do not depend on plant material and plant harvest from year to year. The result is stable prices, consistent supply, and more than 2,000 odor profiles to chose from (instead of only 200 plant-derived profiles).
Synthetic organic chemicals represent 30 percent of the cost of the ingredients needed to make color cosmetics. They are the largest single class of ingredients consumed by the toiletries industry (not including the materials used to make the packaging). Synthetic organic chemicals are generally derived from petroleum products during its separation into fractions according to boiling ranges. In color cosmetics, organic chemicals are most important as preservatives integral to making products with a long shelf life. Consumers expect color cosmetics to last years. Examples are the parabens. Parabens include methyl, propyl, ethyl, and butyl. They provide broad spectrum anti-microbial protection to toiletries products. The U.S. toiletries industry almost tripled its use of synthetic organic chemicals between 1997 and 2002, mushrooming from purchases valued at $243 million to $721 million, an increase of 197 percent.
Surfactants are used to adjust the surface tension of a liquid or cream liquid to assist emulsifying in color cosmetics such as lip sticks and glosses, cream foundation, cream eye shadows, and cream blushes. Wetting agents that help products spread, surfactants are integral to making creamy color cosmetics that go on evenly and smoothly. The U.S. toiletries industry decreased spending on surfactants by 26 percent in the five-year period between 1997 and 2002, from $330 million to $243 billion.
DISTRIBUTION CHANNEL
Color cosmetic products exist side-by-side as both high-end products and low-end products. Product lines on either end of this spectrum are distributed through a distinct channel. Within the industry these channels co-exist because they serve different consumer segments. They are often referred to as the prestige channel and the masstige channel.
Prestige products are classified primarily based on price and are distributed via the department store channel. Masstige products are primarily lower-priced products distributed via a mass market distribution channel.
The department store distribution channel is a classic and large channel for prestige products. Prestige brand names were built through their exclusive availability in high-end department stores and this channel represents 40 percent of North American sales of cosmetics. This channel underwent a shakeup when Federated Department Stores acquired May Department Store Company. At the time the deal was finalized in August 2005, Federated owned 458 stores nationwide, mostly known as Bloomingdale's and Macy's, while May operated 491 department stores nationwide under the names Lord & Taylor and Marshall Field's, among others. In September 2006, the May Department Store nameplates were formally changed to Macy's. All prestige companies, or 40 percent of the color cosmetics industry, had to deal with department store consolidations. In effect, the Federated May consolidation was a merger of the two biggest distribution channels for prestige color cosmetics. An estimated 75 stores closed. Even with the department store distribution channel shake up, department stores account for 40 percent of sales within the color cosmetics industry.
The department store distribution channel for prestige products involves delivering the product via a company-trained beauty consultant. For instance, Estée Lauder has 40,000 beauty consultants that helped make Clinique—and later Bobbi Brown—a pillar of color cosmetics. Lauder renewed investment in training and educating its beauty consultants for one reason: consumers buy more under the auspices of a knowledgeable pro-fessional. Respondents to a recent Bobbi Brown survey indicated that a lesson with a makeup artist was one of the strongest influences on spending. It will remain so.
The department store channel offers makers a controlled environment, which they know generally equates to higher sales. Consumers also prefer the prestige channel since mistakes made in masstige product purchases can be cumulatively expensive. Many women may have a dozen or more products at home that were never used because colors were too bright, too gold, too orange, or all wrong. It is not uncommon for a woman to have a drawer that includes a Max Factor eye shadow (triple), a Revlon wet-dry shadow in lavender (single), and Oil of Olay midnight red lipstick—all used only once.
The mass market distribution channel is broadening in part because store loyalty is less prominent with masstige products than for prestige products. The mass market distribution channel grew to include a large variety of places to buy products. Lower-price products are sold through a throng of outlets: drugs stores such as CVS, Rite Aid, and Walgreens; food stores including Whole Foods and health food stores; mass merchandisers including KMart, Target, and Wal-Mart; and nontraditional Internet retailers. The broadened masstige channel includes warehouse club stores like Costco and Sam's Club. Popular Web sites that allow for online sales include cosmeticamerica.com and sephora.com.
In 2005 Lauder's internet operations contributed more than 30 percent to its U.S. sales surge. On that model, Lauder expanded e-commerce internationally by launching sites for Estée Lauder, Clinique, and M-A-C in the United Kingdom. Lauder has 17 single brand marketing sites, 11 with e-commerce capabilities. Because color cosmetics are fashion-trend focused, often just as a consumer finds a product color she prefers, it is discontinued and replaced with a trendier color. This has led to Web sites for discontinued color cosmetics. One example is cosmeticsandmore.com. The Urban Decay brand also has a website with one section for discontinued items called RIP. It explains that because its customers are cool and up on what is hip, it regularly introduces new colors and sells discontinued items on its Web site.
The mass market distribution channel is expanding. Cosmetics manufacturers actively courted a broader distribution channel using technologies including cable TV, cell phones, and podcasts. For instance, QVC, a direct sales cable network, is no longer perceived to be a sales channel for exclusively down market items. Philosophy—a prestige product sold at Macy's, Bloomingdale's, and Nordstrom—partnered with QVC eight years ago and is now the home shopping network's top beauty brand, edging out Bare Escentuals. QVC accounted for 48 percent of Philosophy's net wholesale volume of $120 to $150 million in 2006.
Bare Escentuals went to QVC in 1997. Bare Escentuals still relies on infomercials—not generally associated with the prestige air that matches its price points—to educate consumers about its crushed minerals, patents pending, and organic ingredients, making it easier for the consumer to part with $60 for 0.15 ounce of Rare Minerals Skin Revival Treatment, meant to be worn while sleeping for luminous skin. Even the pillar of prestige department store sales, Clinique, moved beyond TV and glossy magazines to health clubs, Weight Watchers magazine, and college campuses in order to reach a diverse audience.
KEY USERS
Users of color cosmetics are predominantly women of all ages. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) helps identify key users of color cosmetics by referring to the generally accepted uses of cosmetics, including color. The FDA defines cosmetics as "articles other than soap that are applied to the human body for cleansing, beautifying, promoting attractiveness, or altering the appearance." From this classic definition, it can be assumed that the key user is primarily a female with an interest in beautifying herself and promoting attractiveness; thus, use of color cosmetics may increase during activities involving dating, a process which often involves attractions.
The products purchased are dependent upon the financial circumstances of the consumers who buy them. Products purchased are also dependent upon the talent of the consumers who buy them. Some women do not need to purchase prestige products in order to utilize the services of a trained beauty consultant because they inherently know what works. Women with large, well-spaced eyes quickly learn to use eyeliner to highlight and draw attention to them. Women with narrow, closely-spaced eyes tend to stay away from eyeliner in order to highlight something else, perhaps luscious lips. Women learn early what their best feature is: lips, face, eyes, cheeks, or nails, and purchase products that work best for them. Barbra Streisand, for example, is well known not only for her voice, but for her striking nose and long manicured nails. She uses color cosmetic products to draw attention to one and away from the other.
ADJACENT MARKETS
The apparel industry is a market that is strongly adjacent to color cosmetics. The use of color cosmetics is strongly influenced by fashion trends. Changes in fashion impact sales of color cosmetics. For the most part, shifts in fashion tend to increase the sales of one type of cosmetic, say darkly colored lip sticks, while dampening demand for another such as bright blue eye shadow. Since most cosmetics manufacturers produce an impressive inventory of color cosmetics, they tend to be prepared for fashion shifts. The cosmetics industry also directly affects fashion trends and is, therefore, well-suited to plan ahead in order to take full advantage of sales opportunities that grow out of shifting fashions.
Knowledge, too, can impact the use of color cosmetics and is therefore an adjacent market. Knowledge about skin care products in particular influences cosmetics usage since skin care products are closely adjacent to the cosmetics industry. Books, tapes, and DVDs are available for the consumer to learn skin care and color cosmetics beauty lessons in her own living room. Ostensibly, this knowledge will save money and time.
The consumer who has made purchasing mistakes that became cumulatively expensive might well benefit from such books and tapes. Recent examples include Laura Mercier: The Flawless Face, a VHS tape that demonstrates expert applications of makeup and shares insider tricks. Another is Your Makeup: Simple Steps to Amazing Looks, a DVD by celebrity makeup artists who reveal their secrets.
Bobbi Brown has four best selling books. Her first book, Bobbi Brown Beauty: The Ultimate Beauty Resource (HarperStyle 1997) was a beauty guide for women of all ages. Her next book Bobbi Brown Teenage Beauty (Cliff Street Books 2000) was a New York Times Best Seller. Bobbie Brown Beauty Evolution (Harper Resource 2002) was for women of every age. Bobbi Brown Living Beauty (Springboard Press 2007) redefines beauty for women over 40. The books are successful at creating increased interest in the entire Bobbi Brown franchise.
RESEARCH & DEVELOPMENT
Color cosmetics are fashion-trend focused. Research and development activities must be ongoing because most products stay on the shelf less than four years. New products must be developed to meet the constant demand for a cycle of renewal. Color cosmetics R&D tends to focus on where the market growth is robust. In 2006 Lauder's research centered on developing advances in lip glosses, foundations, and mascaras. Not surprisingly, these segments correlate to robust product classes. Lip cosmetics, for example, grew at the rate of 157 percent in the five-year period between 1997 and 2002. The color cosmetics industry is competitive, and constantly changing due to scientific advancements in the ingredients used to make the products.
One such scientific advancement is related to pigments, which supply the color in color cosmetic products. R&D resulted in an innovation called borosilicate pigment technology that produces multi-dimensional pigments that make distinctive color-shifting effects available in color cosmetics. Borosilicate flakes are conducive to pearlescent pigment and can be fine-tuned for both transparency and sparkle. The flake pigment allows the unaided eye to discern colors particle-by-particle, which provides the multi-color effect. L'Oréal was among the first to introduce products utilizing this new innovation and signed Hollywood starlet Scarlett Johansson to promote its new line of color-changing cosmetics. The brand is known as HIP because it makes uses of special high intensity pigments. HIP was launched at U.S. chain, drug, and mass market outlets in February 2007. It is a comprehensive range of color cosmetics, including products for lips, face, cheeks, and eyes.
CURRENT TRENDS
In 2000 L'Oréal established its Institute for Ethnic Hair & Skin Research in Chicago, Illinois—the first and supposedly only research facility operated by a beauty company to conduct basic scientific research on the unique properties of the skin of people of African descent. In 2006 Lauder reinvigorated Prescriptives, a line designed around the customized color cosmetics concept. The Prescriptives line is uniquely positioned to appeal to women of diverse ethnic backgrounds. These are indications of trends in color cosmetics. Makers are formulating products to meet the needs of minorities including African American women and women of Hispanic origin.
Another trend involves the ever-expanding mass market distribution channel. Recognizing the effects of consolidation of the department store industry, and the trend toward more women buying from mass merchandisers, Lauder subsidiary BeautyBank created three new color cosmetics and skin care brands in 2004 for Kohl's, a discount chain with 750 stores in the United States. Lauder will retain ownership of the three brands. This represented Lauder's first foray into the low-end or mass market. One brand called Grassroots rolled out in 2006. Another is American Beauty for which actress Ashley Judd is the spokesmodel. All are available on Kohl's Web site.
TARGET MARKETS & SEGMENTATION
Cosmetics manufacturers target market segments that provide significant growth opportunities, such as lip cosmetics with its triple-digit growth or cream foundations with their highly loyal consumers. In color cosmetics, women over the age of 50 are a targeted segment along with ethnic groups with unique needs that have not been fully met.
Women over the age of 50 represent a market that has been traditionally underserved by the cosmetics industry, a fact that has been changing during the first years of the twenty-first century. ACNielsen estimates that female heads of households who are over age 45 account for nearly 70 percent of mass market color cosmetics purchases.
L'Oréal launched a cosmetics collection for women in their 50s and 60s with actress Diane Keaton as the spokes-model. Revlon kicked off its biggest launch in more than a decade—Vital Radiance. Vital Radiance is built on the premise that women who are 50 years old or older need to update their choice of color cosmetics as well as their application techniques to reflect the fact that their skin is changing—lines are appearing, color is diminishing, and lashes and eyebrows are becoming more sparse.
Ethnic and racial groups are also segments of the market that have been traditionally underserved by the cosmetics industry. These segments of the market are receiving increasing attention from cosmetics manufacturers. The fastest growing segments of the U.S. population by race and ethnicity are, in order of growth, Hispanics, Asian Americans, and African Americans. Together, these three segments of the population represented 24 percent of the population in 1990 and by 2005 they accounted for 31.5 percent of the population. This trend in demographics paints a picture of a population whose dominant skin tone is darkening. Color cosmetics for ethnic skin types are a product group designed for a growing market.
One problem that cosmetics manufacturers have encountered in their pursuit of new products for the ethnic market is the fact that chemists who are formulating new products often have little knowledge of the ethnic demographic. Upcoming formulations for black skin are predicted to include natural shea butters, plus cocoa and peanut oils because black skin is frequently dry and needs to be moisturized. Procter & Gamble's Cover Girl brand is targeting this market in glossy magazine advertisements and television commercials that feature beautiful African American singers Queen Latifah and Beyonce as spokes-models.
Mag Beauty Puig Fragrance and Personal Care Division NA maintains that paying attention to the buying preferences of Hispanic women helps them distribute Hispanic-oriented cosmetics under the Maja and Heno de Pravia brands, both strong sellers in many Latin American countries. Brand name recognition can drive sales that will open up the Hispanic market. Mag Beauty advertises its two brands heavily in Spanish language magazines.
The unmet needs of women over 50 and of ethnic minorities will drive future color cosmetics R&D. Successfully selling to these groups will contribute to the broadening of the distribution channel for color cosmetics.
RELATED ASSOCIATIONS & ORGANIZATIONS
Cosmetic, Toiletry and Fragrance Association, http://www.ctfa.org
The European Cosmetic Toiletry and Perfumery Association, http://www.colipa.com/site/index.cfm?SID=15588
Research Institute for Fragrance Materials, http://www.rifm.org
Synthetic Organic Chemicals Manufacturers Association, http://www.socma.com
BIBLIOGRAPHY
"Brief History of Beauty and Hygiene Products." Duke University. Available from ?http://scriptorium.lib.duke.edu/adaccess/cosmetics-history.html?.
"Chanel Makeup." Chanel. Available from ?http://www.chanel.com/mprod?.
"Color Cosmetics Glow." ICIS Chemical Business Americas. 18 December 2006, 1.
Darnay, Arsen J. and Joyce P. Simkin. Manufacturing & Distribution USA, 4th ed. Thomson Gale, 2006, Volume 1, 574-578.
"Facts for Features: Black History Month." U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census. 5 December 2006.
Guste, Constance. "Loyal Customers: Top 10 Consumer Brand Categories that Generate the Most Brand Loyalty." WWD. 28 September 2006, 18.
"Innovations in Lipstick Technology." Cosmetics & Toiletries Newsletter. 9 September 2003, Volume 118, Number 9.
Lazich, Robert S. Market Share Reporter 2007. Thomson Gale, 2007, Volume 1, 295-297.
"L'Oréal Paris Skincare." L'Oréal Paris. Available from ?http://www.lorealparisusa.com/cosmetics/lin-up?.
"A Market that Requires Attention." MMR. 24 April 2006, 1.
Monks, Richard. "Salon Patrons, Retail Shoppers Aren't Mutually Exclusive." Chain Drug Review. 11 September 2006, 69.
"Over 50 is No Longer Such a Bad Place to Be." MMR. 8 May 2006, 97.
"P&G Product Site Map." Procter & Gamble. Available from ?http://www.pg.com/product_card/brandoverview?.
Pitman, Simon. "Englehard Unveils Special Effects Technology for Color Cosmetics." Cosmetics Design.com. Available from ?http://www.cosmeticsdesign.com/news/printNewsBis.asp?id-65902?.
Schaefer, Katie. "The Road to More Effective Ethnic Skin Care." Cosmetics & Toiletries Magazine. February 2007, 88.
"Table 14. Resident Population, by Race, Hispanic Origin, and Age: 2000 to 2005." Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2007." December 2006, 15.
"Table 16. Resident Population by Race, Hispanic Origin Status, and Age—Projection: 2010 and 2015." Statistical Abstract of the United States: 2007." December 2006, 18.
"Toilet Preparation Manufacturing: 2002." 2002 Economic Census. U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of the Census. Available from ?http://www.census.gov/econ/census02/?.
"U.S. Personal Care and Household Products Digest." Citigroup Global Group and Smith Barney. 15 February 2005.
Walker, Rob. "Earth Cover: How a Cosmetics Company Replaced Romance with the Glow of Rationality." New York Times Magazine. 21 January 2007.
see also Cosmeceuticals, Sun Care Products
