Wiretapping

views updated

Wiretapping

A form of electronic eavesdropping accomplished by seizing or overhearing communications by means of a concealed recording or listening device connected to the transmission line.

Government Tracks Foreign and Domestic Communications

In spring 2006, the facts came to light to suggest that the National Security Agency had amassed a massive database of domestic phone records totaling billions of calls within the U.S. Allegedly, the agency does not possess the content of the calls, but it does have records of when calls were made and to which numbers. President George W. Bush told the press, "We are not trolling through the personal lives of innocent Americans."

After the September 11th attacks in 2001, President Bush wanted to take action, and although he believed that the public would support measures that would help identify terrorists and prevent another attack, he kept the phone and Internet surveillance a secret from the public, although members of Congress from both parties were briefed on the plan.

In December 2005, the New York Times broke the story that the NSA had been monitoring the international phone calls and Internet messages of people inside the U.S. without obtaining warrants. Former NSA director General Michael Hayden, who at the time of writing was the likely candidate to take over leadership of the Central Intelligence Agency, had said in public statements that the NSA only monitored international calls, not domestic calls.

A senior Bush administration official who asked to remain anonymous was quoted in a Newsweek article as saying that the NSA's eavesdropping on international calls had, in fact, identified and foiled terrorist operations, although the official declined to be more specific.

Although legal experts have been quoted as saying that the government could collect a database of phone records without infringing the privacy of U.S. citizens, the three phone companies that cooperated with the NSA's request for records, BellSouth, Verizon, and AT&T, could be sued by their customers for violating the restrictions imposed by seemingly arcane communications laws. The NSA was allegedly banned from domestic spying in the 1970s in the wake of the Watergate scandal, when the story emerged that the government had been conducting domestic espionage activities such as opening the mail and tapping the phones of perceived enemies of the state.

Once the government has the phone records, the next step is to "data-mine" or look for patterns in the endless flow of electronic traffic that might identify a terrorist before he or she acts. However, data mining is a work in progress, and savvy terrorists may avoid phones for that reason, opting to hide messages on web sites, for example. With no record of any e-mail or phone call, the NSA has no way of intercepting such messages, which calls the value of wiretapping into question.

The NSA's activities since September 11, 2001, including eavesdropping on international calls and collecting records of domestic calls, could threaten citizens' rights to privacy. The risk of invading someone's privacy must be balanced with the probability that broad-based phone surveillance will result in the early capture of terrorists. The details as to whether the government monitors the personal phone and Internet communications of ordinary citizens who have not been convicted of a crime in the interest of national security remain uncertain.

Another layer of intrigue surfaced in 2006 when the Federal Bureau of Investigation admitted to seeking news reporters' phone records in order to investigate leaked information on such subjects as secret prisons in Europe and wiretapping of U.S. citizens' phones without a warrant.

Although some members of Congress defended the NSA's activities as an important aspect of national security, others said that they found the report of domestic surveillance disturbing, and 52 members of Congress asked the president to appoint a special counsel to investigate the matter.

The New York Times reported that the NSA may have eavesdropped on the international phone calls between U.S. residents and thousands of people overseas since September 11, 2001, and the Washington Post reported that almost all of the 5000 U.S. citizens who had been subject to eavesdropping had been cleared of any suspicion.

President Bush emphasized that domestic call-tracing was not the same as eavesdropping on calls while they are taking place. The administration has remained circumspect on the subject and has maintained that domestic calls are only being logged into a database and not monitored.

Statements from AT&T, Verizon, and Bell-South said that the companies had protected customers' privacy. The companies refrained from discussing details.

The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)launched campaigns in 20 states in May 2006 to attempt to stop the NSA from eavesdropping on calls and from acquiring information from phone companies. The Federal Communications Commission has said that it will not pursue complaints against the NSA at this time because it is unable to obtain classified material, and this lack of action prompted the ACLU to take the issue to the states.

Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales defended the data collection by citing a 1979 case heard by the U.S. Supreme Court, Smith v. Maryland 442 U.S. 735, 99 S.Ct. 2577, 61 L.Ed.2d 220, in which police officers installed a surveillance device at its central office in order to monitory the numbers called by a robbery suspect. Since the device was not installed at the person's home, his privacy was not violated, and since the numbers called appeared on a monthly phone bill, there should have been no expecta-tion of privacy with regard to the locations of the calls.

Gonzales was quoted in a Washington Post article as saying, "There is no reasonable expectation of privacy in those kinds of records," and his reference to the 1979 case hints that similar devices may be in use as part of the current NSA operation.

More From encyclopedia.com