Dalits
DALITS
DALITS The Rig Veda, which dates back at least to the second millennium before the common era, described the origins of the entire universe from the self-sacrifice of Purusha, the Cosmic Being, on the funeral pyre. From Purusha's body emerged the four categories of humans: from his mouth, the Brahman; from his arms the Rajanya, or Kshatriya; from his thighs the Vaishya; and from his feet the Shudra. These categories were subsequently referred to as var?s (colors), a term also used to categorize timber and precious stones.
During and after the sixth century b.c., Brahmans composed s?tras ("threads," brief Sanskrit prose aphorisms) and sh?stras (more elaborate Sanskrit verse instructions) regarding morally correct behavior (dharma). The s?tras and sh?stras saw the four var? divisions of society to be cosmically ordained, with Brahmans outranking the other three var?s. The var?a into which one was born was seen as a direct consequence of how one had performed one's morally correct behavior (dharma) in one's previous lives. The Dharma Sh?stra, attributed to the sage Manu, assigned occupations to each of the var?s. Brahmans were to study, teach, and perform sacrifices. Kshatriyas were to rule, wage war, sponsor sacrifices, and study. Vaishyas were to farm, breed cattle, trade, lend money, and study. The disadvantaged Shudras were to serve the three higher var?s
According to Manu, men of each var? were to marry women of the same var? Men of the three higher var?as were considered "twice-born"; their second birth ceremony (upanayana) was performed when they received the sacred thread (janeu) and could study the Vedic texts. Shudras, considered "once-born," were not permitted to undergo the second-birth ceremony, wear the sacred thread, study the Vedic texts, or marry according to the four highest forms of marriage. According to Manu's Dharma Sh?stra, Shudras were created to be the slaves of Brahmans; a Shudra who insulted a twice-born man with "gross invective" should have his tongue cut out; if a Shudra taught Brahmans their duty, the king should order hot oil to be poured into that Shudra's mouth and ears; Brahmans could confidently seize a Shudra's property; and a Brahman who killed a Shudra needed to perform only the same penance as if he had killed a cat or crow. Manu's Dharma Sh?stra predicted that a kingdom with a shortage of twice-born inhabitants and a surplus of Shudras would soon "entirely perish." The Bhagavad G?t? provided some comfort for Shudras. It stated that Shudras who faithfully fulfilled their assigned duties in this life could be reborn in higher var?s in their later lives. Furthermore, a Shudra who worshiped Lord Krishna with sufficient devotion (bhakti) in this life could at the end of this life be freed from the bonds of reincarnation.
The s?tras and sh?stras agreed that Shudras were the lowest of the four var?as. Nevertheless, Manu's Dharma Sh?stra identified groups that were even lower than Shudras. These lower groups included the offspring of the mixing or confusion of var?as (var?a samkara), that is, sexual activities between var?as. This mixing of var?as endangered society. According to Manu, these activities generated new birth groups (jatis) with their own names and occupations. One of the most offensive mixing of var?as occurred when a Shudra male impregnated a Brahman female. Manu labeled the offspring of such miscegenation a Chandala, considered to be the "lowest of men." According to Manu, Chandalas were to live apart from other people, never entering villages or towns after dark. They were to eat from broken dishes, carry out the corpses of unclaimed dead, execute criminals, and take for themselves the clothes, ornaments, and beds of the executed criminals. They should not look at an eating Brahman or touch a Brahman's sacrificial offerings.
Another offensive mixing of var?as occurred when a Brahman male impregnated a Shudra female. Manu labeled the offspring of their miscegenation a Nishada (also a "living corpse") who subsisted by killing fish. Lower than even a Chandala or a Nishada was an Antyavasayin, the offspring of a Chandala male impregnating a Nishada female. According to Manu, Antyavasayins were employed in burial grounds and were "despised" even by other groups excluded from the four var?as. By establishing morally reprehensible origins for such groups, Manu's Dharma Sh?stra provided justification for their rejection by much of society and their continuing disadvantages.
Manu's Dharma Sh?stra also listed occupations "reviled by the twice-born." These included managing horses and chariots, medical healing, doing things for women, trading, fishing, carpentry, hunting, snaring, working with leather, and drumming. Persons subsisting by these occupations were to live near burial grounds or in mountains or groves of trees. Brahmans were not to accept any food from outcastes or persons engaged in "reviled" occupations (although Brahmans could receive uncooked food from Shudras). Those among the twice-born who engaged in the most offensive behavior (e.g., drinking spirituous liquor) were to be branded as outcastes and left to wander over the face of the earth. Relatives were to perform their funeral rites and thereafter neither converse with them, nor marry them, nor share inheritance with them. Only after performing prescribed penances could such outcastes be restored to their former positions among their relatives.
One of the Jataka tales (a collection of stories in the Pali canon about Buddha's former births) described an occasion when the yet-to-be-Buddha was born as a Chandala in a Chandala village. When he went to the city as a young man, having learned to be a sweeper, he discovered that people called him a "vile outcaste" and that high-var?a women rinsed their eyes with perfumed water after seeing him. He discovered later, when he disguised himself as a Brahman, his inadvertent use of a Chandala form of speech revealed his true identity to a group of genuine Brahmans, who drove him away. In the epic Mah?bh?rata, during a devastating famine, the great Brahman seer Vishvamitra begged a Chandala to let him eat the dog meat hanging in the Chandala hamlet. In the end, with considerable reluctance, the Chandala gave the dog meat to Vishvamitra. In one well-known narrative, King Harishchandra, fulfilling his promise to a sage, donated his entire kingdom to the sage and left, with his wife and son, for a neighboring country. There a Chandala chief hired Harishchandra to collect the cremation-ground fees and burn the bodies brought for cremation. Harishchandra's subsequent profoundly moral behavior led to his restoration (with his wife and son) to his original kingdom.
Eyewitness Accounts of Disadvantaged Groups
Around 300 b.c. Seleucus Nicator, a general under Alexander the Great, sent an ambassador, Megasthenes, to attend Chandragupta Maurya's court in Pataliputra (present-day Patna). Although none of Megasthenes' writings have survived, in later years other Greeks cited him when reporting on the lands and peoples of South Asia. According to Megasthenes, no one in India had slaves, although a companion of Alexander the Great reported that slavery existed in the Indus River region.
At the beginning of the fifth century a.d., Fahsien, a Chinese Buddhist monk, traveled throughout northern India. In his journals he described Chandalas as fishermen and hunters who sold meat and were considered wicked. They lived apart from others. When they entered a city gate or marketplace, they struck a piece of wood so that people could avoid them. Two centuries later, another Chinese Buddhist monk, Hsieun Tsang, traveled throughout much of India. He reported that meat eating was forbidden. Those who ate meat were "despised." They lived outside the town walls and were seldom seen.
In the eleventh century, Alberuni, a Muslim from the court of Ghazni (in Afghanistan) who had traveled to India, wrote in Arabic his descriptions of the four-var?a system. Below the four var?as he described eight craft groups who lived outside the var?as' towns. Five of these craft groups freely intermarried but refused to marry three of the groups: shoemakers, weavers, and woolen-cloth thickeners. Below these eight craft groups came four groups considered "degraded outcastes" (among them Chandalas) who did "dirty work like the cleansing of the villages" and who were thought of as illegitimate children of a Shudra male and a Brahman female.
In the 1500s the Portuguese settling on India's southwestern coast labeled the local intra-marrying groups castas. Later the French and British modified this term, calling the groups "castes." In 1666 M. de Thevenot, a French traveler, reported that in Kerala, if a high caste Nair felt the breath of a Polea, the Nair considered himself polluted and was obliged to kill the Polea; otherwise the local ruler would put the Nair to death or sell him into slavery. Poleas, when working in the fields, called out "Po! Po!" to warn Nairs of their presence. Poleas could not enter towns. If they wanted to buy some commodity, they called it out and left money in a designated spot; a local merchant then left the commodity at the spot and collected the money.
More than a century later, a French Jesuit missionary, the Abbé J. A. Dubois, described Pariahs in South India as lower than Shudras and abhorred by other castes. Pariahs were village scavengers who cleaned the public latrines, swept the streets, and removed the rubbish. A Brahman had to purify himself by bathing if a Pariah's shadow fell on him. On the Kerala coast, many Pariahs were lifelong serfs of their landlords, who could sell them to other local landlords. Highest among the Pariahs were the Valluvas, who presided over Pariah marriages and other religious ceremonies. Valluvas married only other Valluvas. Among the slightly higher castes regarded as Shudras, the various cultivating castes looked down on, and refused to eat with, occupational castes who were "dependent on the public" such as barbers, washermen, and shoemakers.
The British Colonial Period
In 1871 and 1872, the British recorded their first all-India census, in which they noted respondents' castes and tribes and tried, often with difficulty, to place each group within the four-var?a framework. Shortly after the first census, government offices began receiving petitions from castes and caste groups claiming higher status than that ascribed to them in the census. For example, during the 1891 census in Madras presidency, Shanars (a "polluting" caste whose occupation was tapping the sap of palm trees) claimed to be Nadars of the Kshatriya var?a. The census commissioner rejected their claims. Ignoring the rejection, in 1897 fifteen Shanars entered a temple in Kamundi and worshiped the Goddess Meenakshi. The court case filed against the Shanars demanded financial payments to purify the "defiled" temple. The British courts at every level, including the Privy Council in London, ruled against the Shanars, resting their case on the fact that no Shanars had entered such a temple before.
The census revealed that significant portions of India's population were disadvantaged. They were referred to as depressed classes, backward castes, tribes, adivasis, adi-Hindus, and adi-Dravidas. They were also called by the English term "outcastes," even though few of them had been cast out by their relatives. They were also called by the English term "untouchables." However, except in a few South Indian locations, pollution by touching was seldom the issue. In most cases, higher castes felt polluted if they ate food cooked by those labeled "untouchables" or used eating or drinking utensils that had been used by them.
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, widely varying groups, including Christian missionaries, the ?rya Sam?j, the Servants of India Society, the Justice Party, the Theosophical Society, and the Self-Respect Movement, advocated various forms of uplift for disadvantaged groups. These included admission into temples, access to education and employment, representation on decision-making bodies, and the right to interdine and intermarry. Champions of uplift, though often disagreeing on strategies, included E. V. Ramaswamy Naicker (a non-Brahman from South India), Mohandas K. (Mahatma) Gandhi (a Vaishya from Gujarat), and Dr. Bhimrao R. Ambedkar (a Mahar "untouchable" from Maharashtra).
Reformers called on the British government to identify the disadvantaged groups in order to end their longstanding historical disabilities. J. H. Hutton, the census commissioner in 1931, instructed provincial superintendents to draw up lists of groups handicapped by their "degraded position in the Hindu social scheme." Criteria by which groups were identified varied from province to province but generally included such ritual disabilities as denial of admission to Hindu temples and higher castes' perceptions that members of these groups polluted higher castes. The Government of India Act of 1935 entitled the "degraded" groups to special electoral representation. In 1936 provincial governments prepared lists ("schedules") of local groups meeting the "degraded" criteria, and the official designations of these groups became "scheduled castes" (SCs) and "scheduled tribes" (STs).
Untouchability after India's Independence
Dr. Ambedkar was appointed chairman of the drafting committee for India's Constitution. Under his leadership the constitution initiated a policy of affirmative action referred to as "protective discrimination" or "compensatory discrimination." Article 17 declared that untouchability was abolished and any disability arising from untouchability was an offense "punishable in accordance with law." Article 15(2) guaranteed to all castes (including scheduled castes) access to public restaurants, wells, tanks, bathing ghats, and roads and places dedicated to the use of the general public. Article 15(4) declared that the state could make "special provision" for the advancement of scheduled castes and tribes. Articles 330 and 331 reserved seats in the national Parliament and the state assemblies for members of the scheduled castes and tribes. The percentages of seats in the legislative bodies were to match as nearly as possible the proportion of scheduled castes and tribes living in the represented territory. Article 325 declared that all voters—not just SCs and STs—could participate in the election of candidates for the SC and ST reserved seats. Article 335 reserved state-and central-government jobs for members of the scheduled castes and tribes. To address the guarantees in Article 16 of equal rights for all Indian citizens, the Constitution stipulated that these reservations of legislative seats and government jobs for SCs and STs would end after ten years. Over subsequent decades, Parliament periodically amended the Constitution to extend the SC and ST reservations for another ten years.
In 1960 the government of India published an all-India list of 405 scheduled castes and 225 scheduled tribes arranged in alphabetical order. According to this list, some castes were referred to by many different names, some castes were "scheduled" in certain localities but not in neighboring localities, and some castes (often referred to by different names) existed in India's different linguistic regions. In 1976 the government of India replaced its 1960 all-India list with an amended state-by-state list of 841 scheduled castes and 501 scheduled tribes. Some castes and tribes were still "scheduled" in certain localities but not in neighboring localities, and some castes and tribes were still referred to by various different names. When designations were unclear, India's Constitution stipulated that Parliament and the president were to make the final decisions regarding a group's "scheduled" or "nonscheduled" status. According to the published lists, scheduled castes formed about 17 percent of India's population, and scheduled tribes about 7.5 percent, for a total of 22.5 percent.
The Identification of "Dalits"
After the adoption of India's constitution, Dr. Ambedkar became increasingly disillusioned with trying to legislate significant changes for India's "untouchables." Following his failure to gain passage of the Hindu Code Bill in 1951, or to be elected to parliament in 1952, he turned to Buddhism as a solution to untouchability. In earlier writings he had argued that India's contemporary untouchables had once been Kshatriyas and Buddhists, whom hostile Brahmans had relegated to the bottom ranks of society. Convinced that Hinduism inherently incorporated caste discrimination, Ambedkar urged India's untouchables to abandon Hinduism and become Buddhists. In 1955, the year before he died, he himself converted to Buddhism. The millions of untouchables, many of them members of Ambedkar's Mahar caste, who followed his example were called neo-Buddhists. By becoming Buddhists, they sacrificed their legal benefits as members of the scheduled castes. They and other members of scheduled castes and tribes called themselves Dalits, a Marathi term for "oppressed," preferring this term to many demeaning alternatives such as "untouchables," "backward classes," or even to Gandhi's term harijan (children of God). Non-Hindu (e.g., Christian, Muslim) castes, who as such did not qualify as scheduled castes, also called themselves Dalits. Soon references were being made to Dalit activism and agitation as well as Dalit poetry, literature, drama, art, and film. Dalits' efforts to assert their rights sometimes met with deadly violence, as higher castes punished them for their assertiveness. Human rights groups became involved, and Dalit organizations appealed to the United Nations to include "caste" with its already established categories of race, color, and sex, to which all human rights applied.
The 1990s saw the appearance of candidates and political parties specifically representing SCs and other backward classes as defined in 1980 by the Mandal Commission. The appearance of these political parties generated reorientations of voting behavior (especially in the states of Bihar and Uttar Pradesh) and the election of candidates, parties, and ministries privileging the Dalits and other backward classes.
Joseph W. Elder
See alsoAmbedkar, B. R., and the Buddhist Dalits ; Caste System ; Mandal Commission Report ; Scheduled Tribes
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Asia Human Rights Watch. Broken People: Caste Violence against India's "Untouchables." New York: Human Rights Watch, 1999.
Buhler, Georg, trans. The Laws of Manu. Vol. 25 of The Sacred Books of the East, edited by F. Max Müller. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1886.
Dubois, Abbé J. A. Hindu Manners, Customs, and Ceremonies. Translated by Henry K. Beauchamp. 3rd ed. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1906.
Galanter, Marc. Competing Equalities: Law and the Backward Classes of India. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984.
Gomango, Giridhar, Constitutional Provisions for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. Mumbai: Himalaya Publishing House, 1992.
Government of India, Office of the Registrar General. Census of India, Paper No. 2, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes Arranged in Alphabetical Order. New Delhi: Publications Division, 1960.
Keer, Dhananjay. Dr. Ambedkar: Life and Mission. 2nd ed. Bombay: Popular Prakashan, 1962.
Wheeler, James T., and Michael Macmillan. European Travellers in India. Calcutta: Susil Gupta, 1956.
