Monroe, James
Monroe, James
Born April 28, 1758 (Westmoreland County, Virginia)
Died July 4, 1831 (New York, New York)
Diplomat, governor, U.S. president
James Monroe was the first of the early prominent U.S. leaders to deliberately choose public service as his career. Spanning forty-three years, Monroe's career included the roles of state legislator, governor, foreign diplomat, U.S. secretary of state, U.S. secretary of war, and U.S. president.
Young James
James Monroe was born on April 28, 1758, the first of four children born to Colonel Spence Monroe and Elizabeth Jones Monroe. James was tutored at home before entering a private school at twelve years of age. He entered the College of William and Mary at the age of sixteen. After two years, his studies were interrupted when he decided to join the Continental Army, to fight for American independence. The American Revolution (1775–83) had begun, and James wanted to help his country break free from British rule.
"The American continents, by the free and independent condition which they have assumed and maintain, are henceforth not to be considered as subjects for future colonization by any European powers."
From the Monroe Doctrine
Monroe saw action in New York at Harlem and White Plains. He was wounded at the Battle of Trenton in New Jersey, and after recovering he went on to battle in Pennsylvania at Brandywine (September 1777), Germantown (October 1777), and Monmouth (June 1778).
Monroe left the Continental Army in 1780 with a high commendation from the commander in chief, General George Washington (1732–1799; see entry in volume 2). Washington would go on to become the first president of the United States. That same year Monroe began law studies under Virginia governor Thomas Jefferson (1743–1826; see entry in volume 1), whom he met in 1778 while serving in the army.
Continental Congress, 1783–86
Monroe's public service career began in 1782 when he won a seat in the Virginia legislative assembly, the House of Delegates. The next year, the assembly named him a delegate to the Continental Congress, America's national legislative body. He served in this position from December 1783 to November 1786. As a Virginia delegate to Congress, Monroe took a strong interest in three major issues confronting the new nation: regulation of trade, the Old Northwest, and navigation of the Mississippi River.
Under the Articles of Confederation, the nation's first constitution, the national government had no power to regulate trade among the states or with other countries. To remain competitive in trade, states imposed taxes on each other: import taxes on goods coming into the state and export taxes on goods being shipped out of the state. The states also made individual trade agreements with foreign countries. The situation caused confusion and bickering among the states. Monroe advocated giving control of trade to a central authority, the national government. He proposed that the national government collect import and export taxes and then pay out this money to the states. This was one of the few times when Monroe supported a strong centralized government. However, no immediate action was taken on this matter.
As a Virginian, Monroe took a strong interest in the future of the Old Northwest. In 1784, Virginia had ceded (given up) its claims on land in the Old Northwest to Congress, with the understanding that Congress would manage the land for the good of all the states. James Madison (1751–1836; see entry in volume 2) had written the cession plan. Monroe was concerned about how these western lands would be dealt with. The Old Northwest included land north of the Ohio River to Canada and west of the Appalachian Mountains to the Mississippi River.
During the 1784 summer recess of Congress, Monroe made an extended tour of the Old Northwest. He wanted to learn about the British forts in the area; relations between the Native Americans and the whites who had settled there; and the general lay of the land, soil, and water. Monroe encouraged Congress to set up committees to consider dividing the region into several territories and plan for a temporary form of government for them.
Navigation of the Mississippi River was Monroe's third main interest while he was serving in the Continental Congress. Spain held claim to the Mississippi and to the port at New Orleans. Monroe joined with other Virginia delegates to demand free navigation of the Mississippi for American frontier farmers.
Brief return to private life
While serving in the Continental Congress, twenty-seven-year-old Monroe courted seventeen-year-old Elizabeth Kortright (1768–1830), daughter of a wealthy New York merchant. They married in New York on February 16, 1786. When Monroe's term in Congress ended, in November 1786, he and Elizabeth moved back to Virginia. Their first child, Eliza, was born in December. The family lived in Fredericksburg, in Spotsylvania County, from late 1786 until 1789. The Monroes had two more children. Their son, James Spence, was born in May 1799; he died while still a toddler on September 28, 1800. A second daughter, Maria Hester, was born in 1803.
In Fredericksburg, Monroe began a private law practice and was again elected to serve in the Virginia Assembly. However, in 1787, much to his dismay, he was not elected to the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia that began in late May. The purpose of the convention was to revise the Articles of Confederation, the nation's first constitution, but the delegates instead wrote an entirely new constitution. Monroe's friend, James Madison, one of the delegates from Virginia, was the chief author of the new constitution, which significantly strengthened the federal government.
Virginia ratifying convention of 1788
In 1788, Monroe represented Spotsylvania County at the Virginia convention to consider ratification of the new constitution. Madison knew Monroe was not in favor of a strong central government but thought Monroe would vote to ratify the Constitution. However, Monroe joined with fellow Virginia statesmen Patrick Henry (1736–1799) and George Mason (1725–1792) in opposing ratification. Monroe's specific complaints about the Constitution were as follows: (1) It provided no adequate check on exercise of power by the executive (president); (2) it would lead to serious power struggles between national and state governments; and (3) it put no limit on the president's term. Another objection many delegates expressed was that the new constitution did not contain a bill of rights (basic liberties considered fundamental to citizens).
Upset that the majority of Virginia delegates voted in favor of ratifying the Constitution, Henry tried to prevent Madison from winning a seat in the U.S. House of Representatives of the newly established U.S. Congress. He convinced Monroe to run against Madison in the district that included Spotsylvania County. However, much to Henry's dismay, Madison was victorious. Monroe and Madison, having avoided personal attacks during the campaign, remained friends.
U.S. senator
Although Monroe lost his bid for the House, he found himself in the U.S. Senate in 1790. The Virginia legislature appointed Richard Henry Lee (1732–1794) and William Grayson (1736–1790) as the state's first two U.S. senators, but Grayson died soon after his appointment. The legislature selected Monroe to fill the vacant Senate slot. He took his seat in the Senate on December 6, 1790, and held the position until May 1794.
During this period, Monroe was one of the fiercest opponents of the policies of President Washington's administration. Washington and his top advisors favored strengthening the federal government over the state governments. Monroe especially opposed the financial measures introduced by Secretary of the Treasury Alexander Hamilton (1755–1804; see entry in volume 1).
Federalists and Republicans
Gradually, America's early leaders split into two political camps. Those favoring a strong central or federal government were known as Federalists. Federalists tended to believe that highly educated Americans would run the government best; this generally meant people who were wealthy enough to afford the privilege of education. Federalists did not believe that the common people could make good decisions on government matters. Washington, Hamilton, and John Adams (1735–1826; see entry in volume 1), Washington's vice president, were considered Federalists.
Friendship of Three Virginians
James Monroe and Thomas Jefferson admired each other's intellect and commitment to American independence. They began a friendship in 1778 that would last until Jefferson's death in 1826. Jefferson, the older statesman, supported and counseled Monroe on many occasions during Monroe's long career of public service. He was the key influence in Monroe's political career.
James Madison, a close friend of Jefferson and later the fourth U.S. president, also became a friend of Monroe's after Jefferson introduced the two in 1784. Although Madison left the Continental Congress in 1783, just when Monroe was arriving, they frequently sought advice from each other on matters related to the new nation. Many years later, Monroe would serve in President Madison's administration. Except for brief interruptions over political matters, Monroe and Madison remained lifelong friends.
Americans aligning with Monroe, Madison, and then secretary of state Thomas Jefferson were known as Republicans (later called Democratic-Republicans). Although Madison had been the primary author of the Constitution, which strengthened the federal government, he did not believe the Constitution gave Congress authority to establish a national bank, one of the financial measures recommended by Hamilton. Republicans of the 1790s believed that the executive branch was quickly becoming too powerful. The term "Republican" comes from the word "republic"; a republic is a government run for and by consent of the people. Republicans trusted the common people, ordinary citizens, to make decisions on how the government should be run.
Minister in France
In his Neutrality Proclamation of 1793, President Washington declared the United States a neutral country. This meant that the United States would not favor either France or Britain in the battles these two enemies continued to fight. Washington knew America could not afford to fight another war. However, America's neutrality was not respected. Both the British and the French seized U.S. commercial ships, and the British "impressed" American seamen. Impressment meant capturing seamen and forcing them to work on British vessels. The U.S. public was outraged.
Given his forthright opposition to many of President Washington's ideas, Monroe was surprised when Washington selected him as minister to France. Monroe, a Republican, was commissioned for the job on May 28, 1794. American statesman John Jay (1745–1829; see entry in volume 1), a Federalist, was the minister to Britain. Republicans such as Monroe favored good relations with France, a country that had helped the United States defeat Britain in the American Revolution. Republicans still considered Britain the enemy and were strongly pro-French. Federalists desired improved trade relations with Britain; they were pro-British and anti-French. Because of Monroe's pro-French feelings, Washington hoped Monroe could have success in negotiating with the French.
The biggest barrier to improved U.S.-French relations was the Jay Treaty, an agreement between America and Britain that Jay negotiated in late 1794. The treaty improved U.S. trade with Britain, but it did not require the British to stop their practice of impressment, Americans' biggest concern. Nevertheless, a Federalist-dominated Congress approved the Jay Treaty in June 1795. Republicans were outraged and so was France. The French believed the United States should honor its Treaty of Alliance of 1778 and support France against Britain. The French had not expected the United States to improve its relations with Britain, but that is exactly what the Jay Treaty did. France was exceedingly upset with the United States from the moment the treaty was signed, and Monroe openly said he regretted that Congress had approved the treaty. The Washington administration was angry with Monroe for not downplaying the importance of the Jay Treaty; President Washington had expected him to soothe French misgivings. Believing Monroe mishandled the entire situation, Washington removed him from the minister post on August 22, 1796.
Return to Virginia
Monroe traveled across the Atlantic in the spring of 1797 and spent the rest of the year writing A View of the Conduct of the Executive, which strongly criticized Washington and Jay. It was published in December 1797. Although Monroe's opinion of Washington and Jay softened over time, Washington never forgave his fellow Virginian for the words contained in the publication.
Within two years, Monroe reentered public office. He was elected governor of Virginia in 1799. The governor's term of office was only one year, but Monroe was elected for three straight years. In November 1799, Monroe moved his main home from Fredericksburg to Albemarle County, Virginia, to property called Highland, later Ash Lawn-Highland. This home was near the homes of his friends Jefferson and Madison.
Louisiana Purchase diplomatic victory
Thomas Jefferson became the third U.S. president in 1801. Jefferson learned that same year that Spain had ceded its rights to a huge expanse of land then known as Louisiana. By the Treaty of San Ildefonso, Spain had handed over this land to France. Louisiana encompassed approximately 800,000 square miles, stretching from the mouth of the Mississippi River at New Orleans northwest all the way to Canada and west to the Rocky Mountains. For the United States, having powerful France as a next-door neighbor on the western frontier was a threatening prospect. Having France in control of New Orleans and navigation on the Mississippi River was intolerable.
Determined to settle the situation peacefully, President Jefferson sent Monroe back to France with instructions to aid the American minister already in France, Robert R. Livingston (1746–1813). Jefferson wanted them to try to purchase the port of New Orleans from the French. Congress had allotted $2 million for the purchase of New Orleans. On April 12, 1803, Monroe joined Livingston in Paris; Livingston was already in negotiation with the French. To the amazement of the two Americans, France offered to sell the United States all of Louisiana. After negotiations over price, Monroe, Livingston, and the French settled on $15 million. They signed a treaty of agreement on May 2, 1803, and hoped Congress would approve the additional $13 million. Congress readily approved the purchase on October 20, and the United States took over the region—which came to be called the Louisiana Purchase—on December 20, 1803. This purchase was the largest land deal the world had ever known; it doubled the size of the United States. President Jefferson, Monroe, and Livingston were astonished and ecstatic.
Difficult missions to Britain and Spain, 1804 –7
By early 1804, the British were still seizing U.S. ships and impressing American seamen. President Jefferson, pleased with Monroe's success in France, dispatched him to Britain in April. Britain was not receptive to negotiators, so Jefferson sent Monroe to Spain in the fall to help Charles Pinckney (1757–1824) with negotiations to acquire the Floridas. Monroe and Pinckney were in constant communication with Spanish minister Don Pedro Cevallos from January to May 1805. Again negotiations led nowhere, so Monroe returned to his residence in London and resumed talks with Britain. At last, in the fall of 1806, serious negotiations with Britain began. The United States signed a treaty in December 1806 for improved relations with Britain. Because of the long time required for communication across the Atlantic, President Jefferson received the treaty on March 15, 1807. The treaty had two fundamental flaws: It made no provision against the impressment of American seamen, and it secured no promise of payment for losses Americans had incurred in the seizure of their goods and vessels. Dismayed with Monroe's treaty, Jefferson never presented it to the Senate for ratification; he simply terminated negotiations without any agreement. He then replaced Monroe and Monroe returned to the United States.
Monroe's failed missions to Spain and Britain were not due to any lack of intelligence or expertise on his part. These missions were doomed from the start, because Spain was not ready to give up the Floridas and Britain had no intention of giving up the practice of seizing U.S. vessels and seamen. Within a few years, the United States would be at war with Britain. However, Monroe was embarrassed and angry that Jefferson and Madison had refused to take his negotiated treaty to the Senate. He felt slighted by his two old friends.
Ill-fated run at the presidency
In 1808, a few old Virginia Democratic-Republicans talked Monroe into opposing Madison in his run for the presidential nomination. Monroe's candidacy went nowhere. Madison went on to become the Democratic-Republican presidential nominee and the fourth president of the United States. Monroe's family life served to cheer him. On October 17, 1808, his oldest daughter, Eliza, married Judge George Hay (1765–1830). Hay, twenty years older than Eliza, was a well-known lawyer and a political activist in Virginia. Hay and Monroe would become close friends. As Monroe regrouped from his diplomatic difficulties and renewed his political career, Hay became a close adviser.
In the spring of 1810, Monroe was elected for the third time to the Virginia House of Delegates. By the end of 1810, he was again elected as governor of Virginia. Monroe served only part of his term as governor, from January until November 1811. President Madison, fully aware of Monroe's political and diplomatic talents and holding no ill feelings toward him, asked him to join his administration as secretary of state. Monroe relished the opportunity and gladly accepted the assignment. He would hold the position until 1817.
Secretary of state, secretary of war
On June 18, 1812, the United States declared war on Britain. The start of the war went so badly for the United States that the secretary of war, Dr. William Eustis (1753–1825), left his Cabinet position. President Madison asked Monroe to temporarily serve as both the secretary of state and secretary of war. Soon, General John Armstrong (1758–1842) took over the war secretary's position. In August 1814, the battle reached Washington, D.C. Convinced the British would never march on the nation's capital city, Armstrong had not dispatched troops to defend it. On August 22, Monroe informed President Madison that he believed the capital was in direct danger. On August 24, the British marched into Washington and burned the public buildings, including the Capitol and the president's mansion.
Dismissing Armstrong immediately, President Madison asked Monroe to again take charge of the War Department. Monroe at once infused vigor into the military operations. His hopes were bolstered when Fort McHenry at Baltimore held firm against a British advance. Monroe was enthusiastic, determined, and confident of public support. By the end of 1814, peace was at hand.
President
In 1816, Monroe was elected the fifth president of the United States. He received 183 electoral votes, defeating Federalist candidate Rufus King (1755–1827) of New York, who received only 34. Monroe was inaugurated on March 4, 1817. That same year, he participated in laying the cornerstone for the University of Virginia. Former president Jefferson founded the university, but both Monroe and Madison aided in the plans. In 1820, Monroe was reelected to a second term. By then, the Federalist Party no longer existed. Monroe received every electoral vote except one cast by a New Hampshire elector for Monroe's secretary of state, John Quincy Adams (1767–1848). The Monroe presidential years are known as the Era of Good Feelings. The eight years proved very positive for the young nation.
The first major event of the eight-year Monroe administration was the Seminole War of 1817–18. Members of the Seminole living in Spanish-held Florida made frequent raids into southern Georgia, stealing property and terrorizing Americans. General Andrew Jackson (1767–1845; see entry in volume 1) and his troops crossed into Florida, subdued the Native Americans, and seized territory. By 1819, the Spanish realized they could not hold Florida and ceded it to the United States.
In 1818, Missouri applied for admission to the union as a slave state (a state that allows slavery in contrast to free states that make slavery illegal), setting off a bitter controversy over the expansion of slavery in America. In 1820, Congress agreed on the Missouri Compromise, which remained in effect for thirty years. Missouri was admitted as a slave state, but slavery was prohibited in the region of the Louisiana Purchase north of the southern boundary of Missouri, except in the state of Missouri itself which could allow slavery.
On December 2, 1823, Monroe delivered a message to Congress that became a lasting legacy of his administration. The three main points of the message, later known as the Monroe Doctrine, set directions for U.S. foreign policy throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Monroe stated that there was to be no further European colonization in the Western Hemisphere, chiefly meaning Mexico, Central America, and South America; that the United States would stay out of the political affairs of European nations; and that he expected European governments not to meddle in the affairs of governments in the Western Hemisphere.
Last years
Monroe retired from the presidency in 1825 and moved to his estate, "Oak Hill," near Leesburg, Virginia. His last act of public service came in 1829, when he served as president of the Virginia convention to revise the state constitution. Madison joined him as a member of the convention. Monroe's wife died in 1830, and he moved to his daughter Maria's residence in New York City. Monroe died at Maria's home on July 4, 1831.
For More Information
Books
Ammon, Harry. James Monroe: The Quest for National Identity. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1971. Reprint, Charlottesville: University Press of Virginia, 1990.
Dangerfield, George. The Era of Good Feelings. New York: Harcourt, Brace, 1952.
Gilman, Daniel C. James Monroe: In His Relations to the Public Service during Half a Century, 1776 to 1826. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin and Company, 1883.
Kelley, Brent. James Monroe: American Statesman. Philadelphia: Chelsea House, 2001.
Levy, Debbie. James Monroe. Minneapolis: Lerner Publications, 2005.
Web Sites
"James Monroe (1817–1825)." American Presidents.http://www.americanpresident.org/history/jamesmonroe/ (accessed on June 14, 2005).
James Monroe Foundation.http://www.monroefoundation.org/ (accessed on August 17, 2005).
James Monroe's Ash Lawn–Highland.http://www.ashlawnhighland.org/ (accessed on August 17, 2005).
