Richard II

views updated

Richard II

by William Shakespeare

THE LITERARY WORK

A play set in England in the late fourteenth century; written and first performed c. 1595; published c. 1597.

SYNOPSIS

Richard II, the king of England from 1377 to 1399, is overthrown and replaced by his cousin Bolingbroke, who becomes King Henry IV.

Events in History at the Time the Play Takes Place

The Play in Focus

Events in History at the Time the Play Was Written

For More Information

With the exceptions of King John and Henry VIII, Shakespeare’s English history plays dramatize the century-long story of the Wars of the Roses, the conflict between the two royal houses of Lancaster and York that dominated English politics during the fifteenth century. Shakespeare composed the plays in an order different from that in which the actual events occurred, so that The Tragedy of King Richard II (known simply as Richard II), though written near the middle of the sequence, relates the background from which the struggle arose. The Wars of the Roses were of particular interest in Shakespeare’s time, not least because they had been ended by Henry VII, the grandfather of the reigning monarch, Queen Elizabeth. Like Shakespeare’s other history plays, Richard II addresses questions of increasingly urgent importance, since the childless Queen Elizabeth, now in her sixties, remained without a clear successor. These questions relate to the nature of monarchy and, above all, to what makes a monarch legitimate. Richard II balances Richard’s tyrannical behavior with his unquestionable title to the throne, and Bolingbroke’s effective leadership with his lawless usurpation.

Events in History at the Time the Play Takes Place

The legacy of Edward III

Richard II was only ten years old when he ascended to the throne in 1377, succeeding his grandfather, Edward III, who reigned from 1327 to 1377. Richard’s father, Edward the Black Prince, the oldest of Edward III’s seven sons, had died of illness the year before. The health of both Edwards was broken by years of rigorous campaigning in France, where, starting in the 1330s, Edward III had initiated the conflict that would become known as the Hundred Years’ War. The war was not going well for England when Richard succeeded to the throne. Early English successes in the 1340s and 1350s (such as the Black Prince’s victory at Poitiers in 1356) had given way to a French military revival starting in 1369, a resurgence that came as both Edward III and his son declined in health.

Under these difficult circumstances, influence in the government had increasingly fallen to the next oldest of Edward III’s surviving sons, John of Gaunt. Fearing that Gaunt might try to usurp the throne, after Edward III’s death the nobles demanded that Richard be confirmed as rightful heir. The unpopular Gaunt’s influence, however,

THE PEASANTS’ REVOLT

As part of Edward III’s legacy, Richard inherited mounting social and religious tensions within the kingdom, In June 1381, just a few years after ascending to the throne, Richard faced the only real outbreak of social unrest in medieval English history. For decades since the outbreak of the plague (the Black Death) in 1349, the reduced population had made labor scarce and had thus driven up wages, improving the lot of free peasants, artisans, and serfs. Noble landowners had quickly responded by enacting the Statute of Labourers in 1351, which attempted to impose a maximum wage on the free peasants and artisans. The serfs, peasants whose labor was not paid but exacted by the nobles under the feudal system, now found themselves forced to work under the same customary conditions in a market in which the real value of their labor had doubled or tripled. Unrest, which had mounted during Edward III’s final years, crested in 1380 when Richard’s council enacted a poll tax of a shilling a head (about ten days’ wages) in order to pay for the expensive and mismanaged war with France. This flat tax penalized the poor, who rose up against the landowning nobles and against the Catholic Church, which was also a major landowner and thus controlled any serfs who were tenants on its land.

Led by Wat Tyler, a peasant, and John Ball, a rebellious priest, peasants and serfs throughout southeast England attacked the manor houses of the nobles, the offices of lawyers and judges (where documents attesting to the legal status of serfs were kept), and religious edifices. Moving to London, they attacked John of Gaunt’s palace, among others, and trapped Richard in the Tower of London. As the uprising spread throughout England, on his counselors’ advice the 14-year-old king met the rebels. Young Richard promised them pardons as well as freedom for the serfs—promises that neither he nor his counselors had any intention of keeping. At a subsequent meeting between Richard and Wat Tyler, the rebel leader was stabbed and killed by the Lord Mayor of London; most of the other leaders were rounded up and hanged. Unrest continued to fester in repeated minor outbreaks throughout the reign. Though the events in Richard II take place nearly two decades after the Peasants’ Revolt, Shakespeare alludes to Richard’s unpopularity, having him comment bitterly on Bolingbroke’s calculated “courtship to the common people / How he did seem to dive into their hearts / With humble and familiar courtesy” (Shakespeare, Richard II, 1.4.24-26).

continued after Richard’s accession, despite Gaunt’s being excluded from the ruling council set up to run the government during Richard’s minority. Richard’s other uncles were also excluded from the council, for similar reasons. Appointed by Parliament, the council represented the interests of the English nobles, which often conflicted with those of the monarch. Control of England now depended on control of its young king, and thus from the beginning of his reign Richard found himself caught between his ambitious uncles and Parliament’s wary nobles.

The Lords Appellant

As he grew older Richard sought greater independence in exercising power. He began to select his own advisors, and starting in 1383 Parliament objected repeatedly to what it regarded as the mismanagement of Richard’s government. Richard, in turn, struggled to build up his own following. By 1386 the opposition centered on one of Richard’s uncles, Thomas Woodstock, duke of Gloucester, a younger brother of John of Gaunt. (John himself, who had mediated between the king and his critics in the past, was away attempting to enforce a hereditary claim to territory in Spain.) Gloucester found allies in Gaunt’s son Henry Bolingbroke (also spelled Bullingbrook), earl of Derby; Thomas Mowbray, earl of Nottingham; and two other earls, Warwick and Arundel. Together, these five made up the Lords Appellant, or “accusing lords.” Thus, disgruntled members of the royal family allied with nobles against the king and his new advisors. After defeating the king’s favorite in a skirmish at Radcot Bridge, the Lords Appellant dominated Parliament (the so-called Merciless Parliament of 1388), carrying out a year-long purge of the king’s supporters.

Gloucester, Mowbray, and Bolingbroke

For two years Richard kept a low profile, but in May 1389 he declared himself of an age to rule with full independence. Gaunt returned from Spain later that year, and with his uncle’s presence as a buffer Richard enjoyed nearly eight years of relatively stable and peaceful rule. His first wife, Anne of Bohemia, died in 1394, and two years later the 29-year-old Richard cemented a peace with France by marrying Princess Isabella, the 7-year-old daughter of the French king.

During this time of unprecedented harmony, however, Richard was quietly building up a second alliance of favored advisors. These included Sir John Bushy, Sir Henry Green, Sir William Bagot: the “caterpillars” of Shakespeare’s play, an extended metaphorical reference to their parasitical existence in the “garden” that is England (Richard II, 3.4.43, 46). Richard had pardoned the five Lords Appellant, but, under circumstances that remain unknown, in 1397 he arrested three of them: his uncle Gloucester, and the earls of Warwick and Arundel. The three were convicted of treason; Warwick was sentenced to exile and Arundel to death. Gloucester, who was being held in a castle under Mowbray’s charge, mysteriously died while a prisoner. It is not known whether Richard ordered his death or whether Mowbray acted on his own—willingly or unwillingly—or whether Gloucester died of poor treatment or even simply of natural causes. In Richard II, Richard’s guilt is unstated but assumed.

Soon after Gloucester’s death, Mowbray seems to have warned Bolingbroke—the other surviving appellant—that the king might revoke their pardons. Bolingbroke then turned to his father, John of Gaunt, and on Gaunt’s advice accused Mowbray of treason in plotting against the king. Later, he added charges of murdering Gloucester and misappropriating funds meant for the war. (It is at this point that Shakespeare’s play opens.) Mowbray denied the charges and demanded trial-by-combat, as was his right under the feudal system. Richard ordered the trial to take place, but stopped it at the last minute, instead banishing the two disputants—for ten years in Bolingbroke’s case and for life in Mowbray’s. Before Bolingbroke’s departure, Richard reduced his exile to six years.

Bolingbroke’s Lancastrian inheritance

At the same time that the struggle between Mowbray and Bolingbroke was taking place, Richard undertook a series of harsh financial measures designed to increase his royal treasury and support his sumptuous court, the extravagance of which exceeded that of his predecessors. Most notably, he won from Parliament a lifetime grant of all customs duties on wool and leather (England’s largest trade items). Also, as recorded by Shakespeare’s major historical source, Raphael Holinshed, Richard forced wealthy subjects to sign “blank charters”—I.O.U.s essentially—for him to fill in at will. Elsewhere Holinshed describes Richard as “prodigall, ambitious, and much given to the pleasure of the body,” qualities that would lead to the king’s downfall (Holinshed in Bullough, p. 408). After Gaunt’s death in 1399, Richard overstepped himself by illegally seizing the vast estate Gaunt had possessed as duke of Lancaster. He then made the further tactical error of traveling to Ireland to put down a rebellion

FACTORING IN THE ENGLISH PARLIAMENT

Richard II necessarily concerned himself with Parliament during his reign. Coming into being from 1272-1377, the English Parliament had crystallized into two separate bodies by the time he ascended the throne. The two divisions were not yet called “houses” of Parliament but already the king had to obtain the consent of the “lords” to conduct war, and already the “commons” rather than the lords had become the branch that represented the community. Over the next 50 years, procedures would solidify, parliamentary rights would achieve recognition, and Parliament would become a forum in which to air and decide major issues affecting the realm. Usually assembling annually in Westminster Palace, Parliament was held for varying lengths of time over the years. In 1376 Parliament lasted for ten weeks while during Richard’s reign it sometimes ran even longer. Its two bodies would discuss the king’s affairs, grant the taxes needed to conduct them, and consider remedies for grievances that plagued the kingdom. The commons consisted of more than 250 elected representatives, not all of them residing in the areas they represented. The lords included about 100 members, nearly half of them ecclesiastics (bishops and archbishops) and the rest laymen (earls, dukes, and, thanks to Richard, marquises and barons). During his reign, Richard broadened the class of lords by his actions in relation to two of its subdivisions. The title of “baron” existed before then, but first landholding and later heredity determined who took the title. In 1387 Richard introduced a major change by ignoring these qualifications and promoting a steward of his household—John Beauchamp of Holt—to baron. Beauchamp was a fervent loyalist to Richard, whose reign by this time was fraught with the tension that manifests itself in Shakespeare’s play. Richard’s subjects therefore interpreted Beauchamp’s entitlement as a political act. If the new baron was elated, he would not remain so for long; his fortunes ultimately plummeted. In 1388, the year Parliament purged the kingdom of Richard’s supporters, its leaders would have Beauchamp beheaded. For the moment, though, Beauchamp could enjoy his new status, even if it enflamed others in the realm. So incendiary was this act of the king’s, says one historian, that it may be the reason for his unpopularity: “Richard’s ill repute probably attached to this method of preferment [entitling a baron], as it did to marquis,” a title Richard introduced in 1385, when he made Robert de Vere England’s first marquis.

(Brown in Davies, p. 115).

of Irish leaders against their English overlords, having quelled a similar revolt in 1394 and deeming it necessary now to consolidate the earlier victory. As one scholar puts it, this move was “reasonable policy, fatally timed,” for Boling-broke took advantage of Richard’s absence to return and claim his Lancastrian inheritance (Saccio, p. 28). Many of the nobles, fearful that the confiscation of one estate left their own vulnerable to similar treatment, rallied to support Bolingbroke. By the time Richard hesitantly returned from Ireland, Bolingbroke was in a strong position—but it is still uncertain whether (as he maintained) he wanted merely to claim the inheritance that was rightfully his or whether he already had it in mind to depose Richard and take his place.

Richard’s deposition and death

Lured by deceit into an ambush by Bolingbroke’s ally, Northumberland, Richard was captured and taken to the Tower of London in August 1399. (Shakespeare omits the ambush, making the king’s opponents more honorable and Richard more the agent of his own destruction.) On September 30 Parliament deposed Richard, and on October 13 Bolingbroke was crowned as Henry IV.

In January 1400 a few of the former king’s supporters attempted to murder Bolingbroke and restore Richard to the throne, but the plot was easily foiled and the conspirators captured. Sometime in February Richard died in his cell at Pomfret Castle. One account has him starving to death; another (which Shakespeare followed) has him assassinated in order to secure Bolingbroke’s place on the throne.

The Play in Focus

Plot summary

The play opens with King Richard and his uncle, John of Gaunt, in Richard’s throne room, preparing to hear the accusations of Gaunt’s son Bolingbroke against Thomas Mowbray, duke of Norfolk, and to hear Mowbray’s defense. The two appear and, amid elaborate and courtly speeches from both, Bolingbroke accuses Mowbray of treason, misappropriation of royal funds, and of complicity in the death of Thomas Woodstock, duke of Gloucester, Gaunt’s younger brother and thus also Richard’s uncle. Mowbray denies the charges, but with a studied ambiguity that leaves open the possibility that he in fact arranged the slaying on Richard’s orders.

Bolingbroke has issued, and Mowbray accepted, a challenge to decide the truth of the accusations in a trial-by-combat—the “chivalrous design of knightly trial” dictated by feudal custom (Richard II, 1.1.81). Richard forbids the trial-by-combat, tries ineffectually to reconcile the two, then reverses himself and declares a date for the tournament. As the highly ceremonial event is about to occur, however, Richard again reverses himself and brings it to a halt. Instead he has decided to banish both Bolingbroke and Mowbray, the former for ten years and the latter for life. After Gaunt expresses his grief at his son’s exile, Richard commutes the sentence to six years. Gaunt and Bolingbroke bid each other farewell; Richard complains to his favorites that Bolingbroke curries favor with the common people, “As were our England in reversion his, / And he our subjects’ next degree of hope” (Richard II, 1.4.35-36). Richard also reveals his plans to “farm our royal realm” in order to finance a planned war in Ireland and—upon hearing that John of Gaunt is ill—to appropriate his uncle’s huge fortune (Richard II, 1.4.45).

Act 2 opens with the sick Gaunt and his younger brother the duke of York expressing grief over Richard’s refusal to accept their “wholesome counsel,” though Gaunt hopes that the advice of a dying man may make a greater impression on their headstrong young nephew (Richard II, 2.1.2). Gaunt then launches into one of the most famous speeches in Shakepeare’s plays, an apostrophe in which he expresses his love for England and his outrage that Richard should spoil and ruin it for his own profit:

This royal throne of kings, this sceptred isle,
This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars
This other Eden, demi-paradise …
This happy breed of men, this little world,
This precious stone set in the silver sea …
This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this
England …
Is now leased out, I die pronouncing it,
Like to a tenement or pelting farm.
               (Richard II, 2.1.40-60)

THE WARS OF THE ROSES

While the Wars of the Roses (1455-85) were not fought until half a century after Richard II’s deposition, the dynastic struggle of which they were the culmination in fact began with Bolingbroke’s rebellion. Because of the illegitimate way in which Bolingbroke had come to power, his Lancastrian descendants never enjoyed real security on the throne. In 1455 Bolingbroke’s grandson, Henry VI, was challenged by Richard, duke of York—who was also descended from Edward III. Both sides won victories, but in the end both also exhausted their supply of male heirs, many of whom died in combat. The sons of Richard, duke of York, became Edward IV and Richard III, the latter of whom was defeated in 1485 at the Battle of Bosworth by the Welsh-descended Henry Tudor. As King Henry VII, Henry Tudor married a York and could claim to have ended the Wars of the Roses by uniting the two houses, both of which were branches of the powerful Plantagenet family.

Richard enters, and Gaunt reproaches him in similar terms, calling him “Landlord of England … not king” and openly accusing him of spilling royal blood in the murder of Gloucester (Richard II, 2.1.113). Gaunt exits, and only a few lines later Northumberland, a noble, enters with news of Gaunt’s death. Richard immediately announces to York his intention of seizing Gaunt’s estate. York, now “the last of noble Edward’s sons,” laments both the spilling of Gloucester’s blood and the improper confiscation of Bolingbroke’s “charters and customary rights” (Richard II, 2.1.171, 196). They exit, but Northumberland remains with Ross and Willoughby, two other nobles, and they discuss Gaunt’s death. Northumberland reveals that he has news of Bolingbroke’s impending arrival and proposes that they join him in order to “shake off our slavish yoke” and “redeem from pawn our blemished crown” (Richard II, 2.1.291). Ross and Willoughby agree, and the three conspirators exit.

Two of Richard’s favorites, Bushy and Bagot, comfort Queen Isabella, who feels sorrow at Richard’s absence in Ireland and expresses a sense of foreboding. Green, another royal favorite, enters and announces that Bolingbroke has landed at Ravenspur in northern England, where Northumberland and other nobles have flocked to his cause. York enters and worries that he is too old and weak to defend the king’s interests. Indecisive, he is split between his two kinsmen, between his duty to Richard and his conscience, which tells him that the king has deeply wronged Bolingbroke. Duty prevails, barely, and York goes off to prepare a defense at Berkley Castle until Richard can return. As Bolingbroke, Northumberland, and the other rebels approach the castle, York comes out to meet them and challenges Bolingbroke’s action as treason against the king. Bolingbroke defends himself by invoking his customary rights of inheritance. York caves in, inviting Bolingbroke into the castle.

Act 3 opens with the entrance of Bolingbroke, York, Northumberland, and other nobles, with Bushy and Green in tow as prisoners awaiting execution; the queen is at York’s manor house, and Bolingbroke asks him to treat her well. The scene shifts to Richard, who has arrived from Ireland, and two of his few remaining supporters: his cousin Aumerle, son and heir to York, and the Bishop of Carlisle. In this long scene, the play’s structural center, Richard alternates between joyful confidence and utter despair. Three times he plucks up his courage, and three times news of Bolingbroke’s progress sends him crashing down again. The center of his confidence is the medieval conviction that, as he puts it, “The breath of worldly men cannot depose / The deputy elected by the Lord” (Richard II, 3.2.56-57). Yet this belief in the divine right of kings crumbles before his own inability to act, to take command, to be a king in deed as well as in name. He gives up when his supporters are still ready to fight, sitting down while they remain standing:

For God’s sake let us sit upon the ground
And tell sad stories of the death of kings,
How some have been deposed, some slain in war,
Some haunted by the ghosts they have deposed,
Some poisoned by their wives, some sleeping killed,
All murdered. For within the hollow crown
That rounds the mortal temples of a king
Keeps Death his court.…
               (Richard II, 3.2.155-62)

The scene ends as Richard tells Aumerle to send his followers away.

In the next scene Bolingbroke, York, and Northumberland arrive at Flint Castle, where (as Northumberland says, significantly omitting the royal title of king) “Richard … hath hid his head” Richard II, 3.3.6). Bolingbroke professes his continued allegiance to the king—with the condition that Richard end Bolingbroke’s exile and restore his inheritance. Otherwise, he threatens, blood will rain “from the wounds of slaughtered Englishmen” (Richard II, 3.3.44). With a flourish of trumpets, Richard enters with Carlisle and Aumerle, immediately upbraiding Northumberland for not bowing in the royal presence. But he agrees to Bolingbroke’s terms. In fact, in submitting he goes further than asked and ironically, it seems, suggests his own deposition: “What must the king do now? Must he submit? / The king shall do it. Must he be deposed? / The king shall be contented. Must he lose / The name of king? A God’s name let it go” (Richard II, 3.3.143-46). A few lines later he asks, “What says King Bolingbroke? Will his majesty / Give Richard leave to live till Richard die?” (Richard II, 3.3.173-74). Bolingbroke, however, kneels before Richard, before leaving to escort him to London. In a brief scene, the queen overhears a gardener telling a servant of Bolingbroke’s capture of the king. The gardener compares England to a garden that has been badly kept, overgrown with weeds and crawling with caterpillars (the king’s flattering favorites), but the weeds have now been “plucked up root and all by Bolingbroke” (Richard II, 3.4.52).

Act 4 consists of a single long scene, set in Parliament, in which Richard’s erstwhile supporters (Aumerle and Bagot, primarily) blame each other for Gloucester’s death; Bolingbroke hears of Mowbray’s death; York, in Richard’s name, invites Bolingbroke to take the throne; Richard appears, is formally deposed, and is sent to the Tower. In vain, Aumerle and the Abbott of Westminster hatch an abortive plot to restore him. The scene climaxes with the deposition, in which Richard physically hands the crown to Bolingbroke. Afterward, Richard gazes on his own reflection, asking “Was this the face / Which like the sun did make beholders wink?” before shattering a mirror (Richard II, 4.1.282-83).

Act 5 begins with Richard and the queen meeting as he is being taken to the Tower. Northumberland enters with the news that Bolingbroke has changed his mind: Richard is to go not to the Tower but to Pomfret Castle, deep in Lancastrian lands in the north. The queen will return to France. Richard and the queen bid each other farewell tenderly. York discovers his son Aumerle’s part in the plot to restore Richard and goes to warn Bolingbroke; Aumerle arrives before him and begs Bolingbroke’s forgiveness. Against York’s advice, but in deference to the duchess of York’s pleas for her son’s life, Bolingbroke agrees. Exton, a noble, is told by a servant that Bolingbroke has wished Richard dead. Exton declares, “I am the king’s friend, and will rid his foe” (Richard II, 5.4.11).

Alone in his cell at Pomfret Castle, Richard reflects on his solitude, considering the thoughts with which he might “people this little world” in which he now finds himself (Richard II, 5.5.9). He seems to recognize some degree of complicity in his own passiveness: “I wasted time and now doth time waste me” (Richard II, 5.5.49). He is visited by a groom who wants no more than “to look upon [his] sometime royal master’s face” but who tells him that his horse Barbary was ridden by Bolingbroke on coronation day without a sign of discomfort at having a new master (Richard II, 5.5.75). As the keeper arrives with Richard’s food, Richard warns the groom to leave. When the keeper says that Exton has ordered him not to taste the food (for poison), Richard beats him, as Exton and four murderers rush in. Roused to action, Richard kills two of the murderers before Exton strikes him down. With his last words, Richard curses Exton and commends his own soul to heaven. In a brief final scene, Bolingbroke banishes Exton, yet admits that he wished Richard dead and acknowledges his own guilt.

The idea of England as a nation

Two centuries separated Shakespeare from the events of Richard II, and during those years England was transformed from a medieval feudal society into a modern nation-state. As the critic E. M. W. Tillyard has noted, Shakespeare uses stylized motifs throughout the play in order to lend it a “medieval feel” that would seem authentic to his audience: death as a monarch holding court, in Richard’s speech quoted above, for example, or the highly ritualized ceremonial challenges traded by Mowbray and Bolingbroke in Act 1. Knights, chivalric ritual, references to the Crusades, stately ceremonial speeches (especially in Act 1)—in Tillyard’s words, the effect of such elements is “just like a medieval illumination” (Tillyard in Newlin, p. 36). Richard himself, Tillyard observes, is “the last king of the old medieval order,” the last of those in the direct line of undisputed succession descended from William the Conqueror (Tillyard in Newlin p. 32). In his struggles with those who would limit his power, the historical Richard relied more than his predecessors on the medieval concept that kings rule by divine right; Shakespeare repeatedly has his Richard invoke the same principle. Bolingbroke, the usurper, represents the new order, a world in which a king in some sense would have to earn his title rather than rely solely and exclusively on the divine sanction of his birth. As a character, he anticipates the later plays in the history cycle, moving away from what Tillyard calls “the essential medievalism of Richard II” (Tillyard in Newlin, p. 37).

POETRY AND RICHARD II

Richard II was reportedly a poet himself, though not an accomplished one, and he is known to have patronized the great poets of his age, most notably Geoffrey Chaucer (who also died in 1400). On a visit to England in 1395, the French chronicler Jean Froissart presented Richard with a book of poems in French, which Richard spoke fluently. An inscription on Richard’s tomb even compares him to the Greek poet Homer, leading some to speculate that the king must indeed have been a poet. Shakespeare may have had these facts in mind when creating his own character for the medieval king, a character that critics praised as the most poetic of his tragic figures before Hamlet (1600-1601).

The medieval world conspicuously lacked the idea of national identity; to modern historians it is precisely in his use of this idea in the play that Shakespeare imposes an Elizabethan outlook on its medieval picture. In the feudal world there was no national identity as such. Feudal allegiances were based on service to a liege lord, not on any notion of duty to one’s king or country. The idea of “country” in this sense did not exist, for England in Richard II’s day was a loose web of feudal obligations, only some of which were to the king. As duke of Lancaster, for example, John of Gaunt held an absolute authority in his duchy that superseded even the king’s. Gaunt’s famous apostrophe to England is Elizabethan, not medieval, in its conception of England as a tight little “fortress,” a “happy breed of men,” a “little world” protected by the “moat defensive” of the Channel and the North Atlantic (Richard II, 2.1.45, 48). Such ideas had arisen only after the dramatic failure of the Spanish Armada in 1588, which had occurred a mere seven years before the play was written (and was intended by the Spanish king to secure Elizabeth’s deposition). An Englishman of the fourteenth century was not primarily an Englishman—he was above all a Yorkshireman, or a Cornishman, or a Kentishman.

Even the Hundred Years’ War, in which historians have often seen national feeling beginning to take shape, was waged for feudal reasons (such as the English kings’ inherited claims to French land), not for anything we would recognize as national interest. Down to Edward III’s time, in fact, English kings spoke French, which was part of their Norman heritage. Gaunt’s view of England in the play arises from historical circumstances particular to Elizabeth’s day, in which Protestant England saw itself as a new Israel, surrounded by and heroically resisting powerful Catholic enemies. Yet Shakespeare’s importation of Elizabethan national sentiment into the feudal world of his history plays has been highly influential in shaping our view of the past. As historian E. R. Lander has suggested, it was in this Elizabethan context that “Shakespeare invented the long popular tradition of a nation in arms behind the king” (Lander, p. 54).

Sources and literary context

As for all of his history plays, Shakespeare’s most important source for Richard II was Raphael Holinshed’s popular Chronicles of England, Scotlande and Irelande (published in 1577, with a second edition in 1587). Other sources included the medieval French chronicler Jean Froissart (available in an English translation by Lord Berners in 1523-25); the early Tudor historian Edward Hall, author of an influential work entitled The Union of the Two Noble and Illustre Famelies of Lancastre and York (1542; enlarged 1548, 1550); and Samuel Daniel’s The First Fowre Bookes of the Civile Warres (an epic poem on the Wars of the Roses published starting in 1595). Though Shakespeare generally follows Holinshed’s account closely, he also departs from it to serve his dramatic purposes. He invents or adapts some events and characters, compresses sequences that took place over days into single scenes, and heightens some events while omitting others. The most obvious departure from Holinshed is the part of the queen. In Holinshed, Richard’s actual queen, Isabella of France, was about ten years old at the time of his deposition, but Shakespeare follows Daniel in portraying her as a mature Women. The royal couple’s scenes together, and the love the queen expresses for her king, help Shakespeare develop Richard’s character from the arbitrary tyrant of the first half of the play into the more sympathetic and morally aware figure of the second half. Of events that Shakespeare compresses, the most obvious example is Act 2 Scene 1, in which Gaunt gives his famous apostrophe to England, exits, and is revealed to have died only a few lines later; Richard seizes his estate; and Bolingbroke is said to be already on his way to contest the seizure.

The popularity of Richard II and works such as Daniel’s show that the conflict between the Lancasters and Yorks could be shaped into story that would grip Elizabethan (and later) audiences. Revealingly, the white (York) or red (Lancaster) rose was only one of several heraldic symbols associated with each house, and the association was not a standard literary device until Henry VII invented the Tudor double rose (white and red) to symbolize his uniting of the two houses. Shakespeare popularized the association, which soon became a fixture of English literature, but the name “Wars of the Roses” did not come into general use until the nineteenth century.

Events in History at the Time the Play Was Written

Elizabeth and Richard II

Parallels between Elizabeth I and Richard II occurred to the queen’s contemporaries strikingly early in her long reign, which lasted from 1558 until her death in 1603. Like Richard, the queen was known for surrounding herself with trusted favorites. In 1578, she apparently rebuked one of these advisors, Sir Francis Knollys, who had given her advice that (for an unknown reason) she did not like. In a letter of January 9, Knollys responded that he refused to “play the partes of King Richard the Second’s men” by offering only flattery (Newlin, p. 14). Ten years later, another courtier, Henry, Lord Hunsworth, wrote in similar circumstances that he “was never one of Richard II’s men” (Newlin, p. 14). Then in July 1597, almost two years after the earliest productions of Richard II, one of Elizabeth’s courtiers, Sir Walter Raleigh, wrote to another, Sir Robert Cecil, about a third courtier, the earl of Essex:

I acquaynted … [Essex] with your letter to mee & your kynd acceptance of your enterteynemente, hee was also wonderful merry att ye consait of Richard the 2. I hope it shall never alter, & whereof I shalbe most gladd of as the trew way to all our good, quiett & advancement, and most of all for her sake whose affaires shall therby fynd better progression. (Raleigh in Newlin, p. 14)

The gist of this enigmatic reference seems to be a humorous comparison (or “consait,” conceit) between Richard and Elizabeth—and that, like Richard’s, Elizabeth’s courtiers knew how to flatter in order to secure their own “good, quiett & advancement.” The “enterteynemente” may have been a private performance of Shakespeare’s play.

Censorship and rebellion

Such parallels were no doubt behind the censorship, in all printed versions of the play produced during Elizabeth’s lifetime, of the long deposition scene (Act 4). Unlike Richard’s, Elizabeth’s title to the throne was quite shaky. Her most famous rival, Mary Queen of Scots, had been executed in 1587; like Bolingbroke, Mary was a cousin of the monarch and was close (next, in Mary’s case) in line of succession. While it seems that in performances the deposition scene was retained, the deposing of a monarch was considered too volatile a subject for portrayal in the printed version.

The parallels between the two monarchs were vividly illustrated by events in February 1601, when the earl of Essex (who had fallen from favor) rebelled in an attempt to depose the queen and seize the throne himself. Significantly, his best claim to legitimacy was his descent from the same duke of Gloucester that Richard II was supposed to have had murdered. On the evening before the rebellion, the earl and his supporters commissioned a special performance of Richard II at the Globe theater, probably in the hope that Londoners would support Elizabeth’s deposition as they did that of the play’s Richard. The rebellion was quickly crushed, and the performance was used as evidence at Essex’s trial. Shakespeare and his colleagues did not suffer as a result; on the contrary, on the day before Essex’s execution, they performed in front of the queen. However, later that year Elizabeth was heard to remark, “I am Richard II, know ye not that?” (Newlin, p. 15).

Reception

In the same conversation, the queen referred to Richard II as having been performed 40 times “in open streets and houses” (Newlin, p. 16). While no records survive, if this refers to the original production, it was an exceptionally long run for an Elizabethan play. Regardless, it is known from contemporary references that Richard II was one of Shakespeare’s most successful plays in original production, as it has remained ever since. It was printed in three quartos in 1597 and 1598; in the latter year the author Francis Meres, surveying the state of literature in England, called it “foremost among the tragedies of the day” (Meres in Shewring, p. 24). (The term “quarto” designates not only the size of a volume—the standard paper is folded twice instead of once [folio]—but also, in Shakespeare’s case, designates the plays [18] published in his lifetime.) Six passages (including three excerpts from Gaunt’s apostrophe) were anthologized in the popular collection England’s Parnassus (1600). The deposition scene was not printed until the Fourth Quarto of 1608, five years after Elizabeth’s death.

—Colin Wells

For More Information

Bullough, Geoffrey, ed. Narrative and Dramatic Sources of Shakespeare. Vol. 3. New York: Columbia University Press, 1960.

Davies, R. G., and J. H. Denton, eds. The English Parliament in the Middle Ages. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1981.

Lander, J. R. Conflict and Stability in Fifteenth Century England. London: Hutchinson, 1977.

Lockyer, Roger. Tudor & Stuart Britain 1471-1714. Harlow, England: Longman, 1964.

McKisack, May. The Fourteenth Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1959.

Moseley, C. W. R. D. Shakespeare’s History Plays: Richard II to Henry IV, The Making of a King. London: Penguin, 1988.

Muir, Kenneth. The Sources of Shakespeare’s Plays. London: Methuen, 1977.

Newlin, Jeanne T., ed. Richard II: Critical Essays. New York: Garland, 1984.

Saccio, Peter. Shakespeare’s English Kings. New York: Oxford University Press, 1977.

Saul, Nigel. Richard II. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997.

Shakespeare, William. King Richard II. Ed. Andrew Gurr. New Cambridge Shakespeare. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1984.

Shewring, Margaret. King Richard II Shakespeare in Performance Series. New York: Manchester University Press, 1996.

More From encyclopedia.com