Music
Music
In the most generalized sense, music is the organization of sound and silence; any definition less broad than that would risk exclusion of a diverse variety of musical practices. Across the range of types of music making, no matter the genre or type, music is a cultural practice that defines and is defined by the people who participate in it. By studying music, people can learn about cultures present and past and investigate how music intersects with issues of individual and cultural identity. Throughout its history and into the twenty-first century, what is usually called Western classical music—instrumental music, opera, and dance—coupled with Western music studies have formed and informed cultural conceptions of and representations of gender and sexuality by means of composition, performance, scholarship and listenership.
ANCIENT AND MEDIEVAL TIMES
Properly speaking, a history of gender and sexuality in Western music would start in ancient times, for musicians and historians throughout history have traced Western musical roots to ancient Greece and Rome. Whereas very little written music remains from this period, philosophies of music address music's correspondence to the harmony of the natural world, its value in education, and its ability to engage with emotion, whereas theoretical studies explain its foundation in the physical sciences. At the very core of Western music there exists a tension between science and expression—between objective and subjective approaches to music making—that makes Western music a fascinating entry into considerations of gender and sexuality. Whereas Western music is founded upon scientific principles of physics and harmonics, its dealings with emotional expressivity and subjectivity have been thought by some to corrupt its objectivity and feminize its stature among the other arts. Critiques of this feminization have, moreover, extended to those who create and practice music. Beginning with Plato (427 bce–347 bce) and Aristotle (384 bce–322 bce), philosophers and critics have debated this tension within the foundations of Western music but offered no clear resolution, such that the debate resurfaces generation after generation.
The first substantial body of written music dates from the medieval period and consists of monophonic chants with liturgical and nonliturgical religious texts by anonymous composers. Given the conservatism of the church and the limitations of education for women, men typically dominated music education and performance. For medieval women, however, a life devoted to religion, though lived primarily in seclusion, afforded educational and artistic opportunities unavailable to laypeople. Hildegard von Bingen, a twelfth-century Benedictine abbess, church reformer, mystic, author, and composer, wrote a number of chants and a morality play set to music, Ordo Virtutum (Ceremony of the virtues), that prove to be exceptions to the gender norms of the era as well as exceptional works within the body of medieval chant. Her intensely spiritual music centers on the female voice and a personal communion with God and the Virgin in a style that several historians have identified as possessing erotic (or homoerotic) overtones in its depiction of ecstasy. Representations of love, albeit worldly and not divine, also concerned composers of secular songs in the later Middle Ages, including Philippe de Vitry (1291–1361), Guillaume de Machaut (c. 1300–1377), and Guillaume Dufay (c. 1397–1474). These composers likewise pondered boundaries of sexuality and spirituality in polyphonic and polytextual genres that combined love songs, dance tunes, popular refrains, and even sacred hymns within single compositions in a manner that represented the contemporary fluidity between sacred and secular, aristocratic and popular, and courtly love and sex. Refrains and love songs also permeated sacred works as composers developed masses and motets around single melodic lines extracted from popular tunes.
THE RENAISSANCE AND THE SEVENTEENTH CENTURY
In the Renaissance (1350–1600) groups of amateur performers from among the aristocrats across Europe filled their leisure time with musical performance. The madrigal, the most popular of polyphonic genres, owed much of its attractiveness to texts that abound in double entendres and metaphoric treatment of sexual encounters. Many refer to death at the hand of a cruel lover, with death serving as a well-known and accepted metaphor for orgasm. Composers from Jacques Arcadelt (c. 1507–1568) to Orlando di Lasso (c. 1532–1594) and Claudio Monteverdi (1567–1643) wrote music that enacted these sexual encounters through modal allegory, word painting, chromaticism, and symbolic interaction between polyphonic voices. More difficult madrigal repertoire, however, fell to professional or semiprofessional singing groups, the most famous of which was the all-female concerto della donne, or the Three Ladies of Ferrara. The texture of three high female voices intricately intertwined held an erotic appeal that titillated audiences and inspired the foundation of similar ensembles across Italy. Secular music, however, was not the only genre to employ eroticism, for madrigal composers also wrote sacred works in which they often called upon similar poetic and musical imagery to depict mystical experiences of divine love.
The popularity of vocal music in the late Renaissance and an interest in the perceived union of music and theater in ancient times helped to foster the rise of opera in Italy and across Europe over the course of the late sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. The castrato—a male singer castrated before his voice changes so as to preserve its soprano range—effectively dominated opera up through the early eighteenth century. These men led operatic casts in the roles of heroic mythic and historical characters ranging from Orpheus to Julius Caesar. Their powerful soprano voices literally projected sound and figuratively projected a commanding masculinity for period audiences. Farinelli (Carlo Broschi; 1705–1782), the most famous castrato of the period, was not only a famous musician but also a highly sought-after sexual partner. Castrati's soprano voices also ideally suited them to the narratives involving gender confusion that were quite popular in seventeenth-century Venetian opera. Castrato masculinity, however, did not go unquestioned: French audiences, for example, shunned the castrato, deeming the voice (and perhaps the men who possessed it) to be unnatural.
Castrati were not the only ones to profit from the new popularity of opera, for these men shared the stage with many female singers (except in Rome where Catholic moral codes usually prohibited this interaction of the sexes). Throughout the seventeenth and well into the nineteenth century, dynastic musical families helped to further the careers of female performers and composers, many of whom entered into the business under the guidance of their fathers or family elders. Francesca Caccini (1587–c. 1640), daughter of the composer Giulio Caccini, performed as a vocalist in a family ensemble modeled on the concerto della donne and composed ballets and other works, serving as the highest paid musician in the service of the Florentine court at the start of the seventeenth century. Barbara Strozzi (1619–1677), an important female composer of the era, lived from childhood with the poet and librettist Giulio Strozzi (who may have been her father) and studied under such composers as Francesco Cavalli (1602–1676), eventually composing a number of important solo cantatas and other vocal works.
EIGHTEENTH CENTURY
Opera continued to find favor with eighteenth-century audiences, though over the course of the century comic opera and its women usurped the popularity of serious opera and the castrato. Memorable female roles from the comic stage include the servant Serpina in Giovanni Pergolesi's La serva padrona (The servant mistress) (1733), who uses her musical abilities to seduce her master, pretend to a class above her own, and achieve it. An archetypical soubrette (coquettish maid), the servant Serpina is, despite her station, the cleverest character in the opera. Other notable soubrettes include Susanna of The Marriage of Figaro (1786) and Despina of Così fan tutte (1790), from operas by Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756–1791). The former presents another convention of eighteenth-century comic opera—cross-dressing—in the character of Cherubino, the lovesick young man who lusts after his mistress (and every other woman in the opera). Played by women, pants roles such as Cherubino offered opera spectators a tantalizing hint of lesbian sexuality that modern audiences still find engaging.
The fact that instrumental music has not made an appearance in this entry until now should not imply that it did not exist, but only that opera typically usurped its popularity and that it primarily remained the purview of professionals and a select group of amateurs. This situation changed, however, over the course of the eighteenth century, as composers, performers, critics, and audiences began to pay more attention to and invest greater status in instrumental music—including sonatas, chamber works, and symphonies. Theoretical works addressed the new system of tonality and the imitative capabilities of instrumental music as scholars sought to award music a higher standing among the arts. Subscription concerts featuring (usually male) virtuoso composer-performers playing their own concerti and conducting their own large-scale symphonies gained a broad popularity that served to define these public genres along gender lines. Whereas certain women performers—Elisabeth Jacquet de la Guerre (c. 1664–1729), also a composer), and Therese Jansen (c. 1770–1843), for example—appeared in semi-public concerts, female performers were limited to harp, keyboard, or other instruments considered suitable for young ladies. Female keyboardists created a large demand for amateur works and helped to foster a lucrative market for the publication of compositions for women, from C. P. E. Bach's (1714–1788) Damensonaten (Sonatas for ladies) (1770) to accompanied keyboard sonatas in which (male) violinists or flautists played simple accompaniments for female keyboard soloists.
Composers modeled many popular amateur works on social dances of the period, for dance was a crucial component of eighteenth-century culture as well as an increasingly influential art form in its theatrical manifestations. Though music and dance have always been connected, developments in social and theatrical dance in the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries set the foundations for ballet as it is now known. In the late seventeenth century, professional and amateur dancers alike took part in spectacular productions of French theatrical dance composed of nonnarrative, virtuoso renditions of popular courtly dance. In social and theatrical dance of this period, men and women typically performed nearly equivalent choreographies such that on several occasions Louis XIV, the king of France (r. 1643–1715) famously performed female roles in drag. Over the course of the eighteenth century, however, choreographic reform introduced the narrative ballet d'action in which dancers employed gesture to tell stories. This new style of ballet, the near relative of the nineteenth-century grand ballet, employed many of the steps and positions of its seventeenth-century predecessor. However, because narrative ballet called for more obvious gender differentiation in choreography, the repertoire for male and female dancers diverged to privilege gendered stereotypes of comportment and capability.
NINETEENTH CENTURY
The great ballets of the nineteenth century—Giselle (1841), Coppélia (1870), and Swan Lake (1877)—employ such stereotypes, as choreographers and composers call for women dancers to be light, even languorous, and delicate, whereas male dancers execute high leaps and lifts that convey their masculinity. These gestures belong to a rigorous choreographic vocabulary that characterizes classical ballet, a vocabulary that is ultimately a symbol of control—of the dancer over his or her body, and of the dance over the dancer's body. Moreover, whereas early ballet was usually participatory—with many opéra-ballets ending in a general dance for audience and performers—ballet in the nineteenth century became an inherently visual genre, the male gaze intently focused on the female performing body.
Gender stereotypes also divided instrumental music in the nineteenth century, as critics widened the gap between public and private, professional and amateur, and hence male and female, music making. Once liberated from the patronage system, composition became a valued enterprise of genius, expression, and subjectivity typically dominated by male artists. As musicology developed over the course of the century, historians and critics privileged these genius composers and crafted narratives of musical development and evolution that resulted in the formation of a canon of male composers that, even in the early twenty-first century, continues to dominate concert repertoire. The nineteenth century was also an era for instrumental virtuosos, including Franz Liszt (1811–1886) and Niccolò Pagannini (1782–1840), who inspired female adulation that at times approached sexual frenzy. Few women pursued professional performance careers, and those who did, including Clara Schumann (1819–1896), benefited from the support of family members who were likewise involved in music instruction or composition. (Fanny Mendelssohn's [1805–1847] family, by contrast, prohibited her from performing in public.) In general, music making by young bourgeois women grew to fill an ever-larger role in the domestic sphere. The publication for amateur musicians of genres such as the lied and character piece was a lucrative business, though it could bring critical condemnation and accusations of effeminacy to composers, as was the case for Frédéric Chopin (1810–1849), whose nocturnes appealed to the female market. A handful of important female composers and performers, including Schumann and Amy Beach (1867–1944), however, did challenge gender norms by pursuing careers as performers and composers.
In what seems a contradiction of nineteenth-century gender norms, a host of powerful women appeared characterized on nineteenth-century operatic stages; however, they most often met their demise by the opera's end. Nineteenth-century dramatic opera brought a number of heroines to the stage and garnered fame for the female singers who executed these virtuoso roles. The title character of Georges Bizet's (1838–1875) Carmen (1875) is perhaps the most famous role in nineteenth-century opera—a highly sexualized femme fatale. Carmen is an Orientalist opera, casting anxieties about European (specifically French) gender and sexuality to a distant locale (Spain) and embodying them in the character of a gypsy woman. With arias including the famous habanera "L'amour est un oiseau rebelle" (Love is a rebellious bird), Bizet portrays Carmen as a powerful, seductive, lusty, and bodily woman who is a threat to morality and idealistic true love. Carmen thus represents the inverse of what was perceived acceptable for nineteenth-century women, and as such, dies at the opera's end. Death was the fate of many powerful opera heroines—Aïda, Tosca, Salome, Lulu—a fact that bears evidence to mounting anxieties with regard to women's place in society (recall the contrary domesticity of women's instrumental music in this same period). The canonical works to which these heroines belong have remained the staples of opera repertoires into the early twenty-first century.
TWENTIETH AND TWENTY-FIRST CENTURIES
Music of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries is perhaps less easy to define by sweeping trends. In the late-nineteenth century, composers explored more liberated representations of sex and sexuality in such works as the love duet from Richard Wagner's (1813–1883) Tristan und Isolde (1859) and Claude Debussy's (1862–1918) Prélude à l'après-midi d'un faune (Prelude to the afternoon of a faun) (1895). When these composers broke with the tonal language and excess of late-nineteenth-century Romanticism, a multitude of styles and schools arose. Serialism and twelve-tone music applied rigorous new systems of rational organization to music that intellectualized and perhaps masculinized the art. (It has been argued that Aaron Copland (1900–1990) turned to an academic atonal style when threatened by accusations regarding his homosexuality and perceived communist politics.) In the mid-1950s aleatory, or chance music, as pioneered by John Cage (1912–1992), challenged conceptions of what constituted music by incorporating non-musical sounds and determining composition and/or performance by operations of chance, processes that critics have identified as coded markers of Cage's homosexuality.
Just as gay and lesbian composers and performers gained greater visibility in the latter half of the twentieth century forming composer collectives and other associations, women, too, grew to have an increasingly important role in the contemporary music scene. Nadia Boulanger (1887–1979) trained many famous composers, including Copland; Yoko Ono (b. 1933) explored the divide between art and popular music in the mid-1960s; and Pauline Oliveros (b. 1932) structured improvisational works around a collective of women's voices. Women performers (on all instruments, not just those deemed suitable for women) also became an important part of modern concert life, though a gender imbalance still exists in major orchestras and the appointment of a female conductor is enough to make news headlines.
Whereas classical ballet remains popular, choreographic trends in modern dance of the twentieth and twenty-first centuries may be seen to free dancers from the strictures of classical ballet (not the least of which are pointe shoes), as it explores new vocabularies of choreography. Many of the early pioneers of modern dance were women—Martha Graham (1894–1991), Agnes de Mille (1905–1993), and Isadora Duncan (1877–1927), among others. The diverse currents of modern dance are as multiple as those of contemporary music, but among the notable developments are all-female or all-male dance troupes. The virtuoso Les Ballets Trockadero de Monte Carlo is an all-male troupe that performs parodies of classical ballets in drag. Matthew Bourne's (b. 1960) enormously successful Swan Lake features an all-male ballet corps in its retelling of the tale, in which a male swan represents deliverance for the tormented prince struggling with his desire for love.
The popularity of Bourne and other homosexual choreographers has called attention to the degree to which gay and lesbian performers and audience members are deeply involved in contemporary dance scenes. The same is true of opera, for music theater has historically been a location around which homosexual communities evolve. For example, opera queens—a particular contingent attracted to the diva and the opera in general—display ardent devotion to sopranos such as Maria Callas (1923–1977) and Joan Sutherland (b. 1926) and are among the most knowledgeable and passionate of opera audiences. Ballet and modern dance likewise maintain dedicated audiences made up of a number of gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender devotees.
In the late twentieth century, gender studies, queer studies, and feminist criticism each greatly influenced musicology and music theory, particularly with regard to issues of recuperation, representation, and queerness in music and music history. As a result many modern scholars make a practice of interrogating the canon and encouraging scholarship that considers music in its social context. The recuperation of female composers and performers typically involves a more general study of music making by women and the social constructs that surround music—educational opportunities, social factors, and institutional limitations. The influence of feminist theory has also led to the examination of musical portrayals of women in opera, ballet, and music theater, and even in pure instrumental music, by such scholars as Susan McClary, Suzanne G. Cusick, and Ruth A. Solie. Texted or choreographed representations of women offer images that enable critics to consider historical conceptions of gender—both male and female—by means of its musical manifestations. Gender characterizations also emerge in instrumental music, for example, in nineteenth-century terminology that referred to the musical themes in a sonata-allegro form as masculine and feminine and in the division of musical genres according to gender binaries.
Since the 1990s work in queer musicological studies has involved both recuperative and analytical strategies for examining the musical canon through the lens of alternative sexualities. Perhaps because of the perceived effeminacy of music, attitudes toward homosexuality in regard to the art have tended to oppress or erase its presence. Though music has throughout its history been very much influenced by gay and lesbian performers and composers, not to mention listeners, much of that history has until recently been closeted, as were many of the individuals who lived it. Among these men and women are such figures as Jean-Baptiste Lully (1632–1687), Franz Schubert (1797–1828), Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky (1840–1893), Wanda Landowska (1879–1959), and the aforementioned Copland, Cage, and Oliveros. Revisiting the biographies of such composers can fruitfully shed new light on their compositions. The queer musicologist Philip Brett has identified a complex of cryptography—including camp, Orientalism, and eroticism—by which composers and performers resisted the effacement of their own sexuality. Such studies may enable new interpretations of a range of canonical and noncanonical compositions. Other approaches to scholarship that have evolved out of queer studies involve the study of listener reception from a gay, lesbian, bisexual, or even transgender perspective, in what amounts to a queer reading of music.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Attinello, Paul. 1995. "Performance and/or Shame: A Mosaic of Gay (and Other) Perceptions." Repercussions 4(2): 97-130.
Blackmer, Corinne E., and Patricia Juliana Smith, eds. 1995. En Travesti: Women, Gender, Subversion, Opera. New York: Columbia University Press.
Bowers, Jane, and Judith Tick, eds. 1986. Women Making Music: The Western Art Tradition, 1150–1950. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
Brett, Philip. 1997. "Piano Four-Hands: Schubert and the Performances of Gay Male Desire." 19th-Century Music 21(2): 149-176.
Brett, Philip; Elizabeth Wood; and Gary C. Thomas, eds. 2006. Queering the Pitch: The New Gay and Lesbian Musicology. 2nd edition. New York: Routledge.
Citron, Marcia J. 1993. Gender and the Musical Canon. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Cusick, Suzanne G. 1994. "Feminist Theory, Music Theory, and the Mind/Body Problem." Perspectives of New Music 32(1): 8-27.
Cusick, Suzanne G. 1994. "Gender and the Cultural Work of a Classical Music Performance." Repercussions 3(1): 77-110.
Cusick, Suzanne G. 1999. "Gender, Musicology, and Feminism." In Rethinking Music, ed. Nicholas Cook and Mark Everist. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Dellamora, Richard, and Daniel Fischlin, eds. 1997. The Work of Opera: Genre, Nationhood, and Sexual Difference. New York: Columbia University Press.
Dunn, Leslie C., and Nancy A. Jones, eds. 1994. Embodied Voices: Representing Female Vocality in Western Culture. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Foster, Susan Leigh. 1996. Choreography and Narrative: Ballet's Staging of Story and Desire. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Gill, John. 1995. Queer Noises: Male and Female Homosexuality in Twentieth-Century Music. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Head, Matthew. 1995. "'Like Beauty Spots on the Face of a Man': Gender in 18th-Century North-German Discourse on Genre." Journal of Musicology 13(2): 143-167.
Holsinger, Bruce Wood. 1993. "The Flesh of the Voice: Embodiment and the Homoerotics of Devotion in the Music of Hildegard of Bingen (1098–1179)." Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 19(1): 92-125.
Kallberg, Jeffrey. 1996. Chopin at the Boundaries: Sex, History, and Musical Genre. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Koestenbaum, Wayne. 1993. The Queen's Throat: Opera, Homosexuality, and the Mystery of Desire. New York: Poseidon Press.
Kopelson, Kevin. 1996. Beethoven's Kiss: Pianism, Perversion, and the Mastery of Desire. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
Kramer, Lawrence. 1990. Music as Cultural Practice, 1800–1900. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kramer, Lawrence. 1997. After the Lovedeath: Sexual Violence and the Making of Culture. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Kramer, Lawrence, ed. 1993. "Schubert: Music, Sexuality, Culture." Spec. issue, 19th-Century Music 17(1).
Marshall, Kimberly, ed. 1993. Rediscovering the Muses: Women's Musical Traditions. Boston: Northeastern University Press.
Maus, Fred Everett. 1993. "Masculine Discourse in Music Theory." Perspectives of New Music 31(2): 264-293.
McClary, Susan. 1991. Feminine Endings: Music, Gender, and Sexuality. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
McClary, Susan. 1992. Georges Bizet: "Carmen." Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
McClatchie, Stephen. 1996. "Benjamin Britten, Owen Wingrave, and the Politics of the Closet; or, 'He Shall Be Straightened Out at Paramore.'" Cambridge Opera Journal 8(1): 59-75.
Metzer, David. 1997. "'Spurned Love': Eroticism and Abstraction in the Early Works of Aaron Copland." Journal of Musicology 15(4): 417-443.
Monson, Ingrid. 1997. "Music and the Anthropology of Gender and Cultural Identity." Women and Music: A Journal of Gender and Culture 1(1): 24-32.
Mordden, Ethan. 1984. Demented: The World of the Opera Diva. New York: Franklin Watts.
Morris, Mitchell. 1992. "On Gaily Reading Music." Repercussions 1(1): 48-64.
Neuls-Bates, Carol, ed. 1982. Women in Music: An Anthology of Source Readings from the Middle Ages to the Present. New York: Harper and Row. Rev. edition, Boston: Northeastern University Press.
Pendle, Karin, ed. 2001. Women and Music: A History. 2nd edition. Bloomington: University of Indiana Press.
Peraino, Judith A. 1992. "'Rip Her to Shreds': Women's Music According to a Butch-Femme Aesthetic." Repercussions 1(1): 19-47.
Robertson, Carol E. 1989. "Power and Gender in the Musical Experiences of Women." In Women and Music in Cross-Cultural Perspective, ed. Ellen Koskoff. Urbana: University of Illinois Press. (Orig. pub. 1987.)
Solie, Ruth A. 1992. "Whose Life? The Gendered Self in Schumann's Frauenliebe Songs." In Music and Text: Critical Inquiries, ed. Steven Paul Sher. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Solie, Ruth A., ed. 1993. Musicology and Difference: Gender and Sexuality in Music Scholarship. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Washabaugh, William, ed. 1998. The Passion of Music and Dance: Body, Gender, and Sexuality. Oxford: Berg.
Whitesell, Lloyd. 1994. "Men with a Past: Music and the 'Anxiety of Influence.'" 19th-Century Music 18(2): 152-167.
SARA GROSS
SARA WALSER
