Chauliac, Guy De
Chauliac, Guy De
(b. Chauliac, Auvergne, France, ca. 1290; d. in or near Lyons, France, ca. 1367–1370),
medicine.
Guy’s family were of the peasant class, and he was aided in his studies by the lords of Mercoeur. He studied medicine first at Toulouse, then at Montpellier, and finally in Bologna. It was at Bologna that he perfected his knowledge of anatomy under the guidance of his master Nicolaus Bertrucius (Bertruccio), and his description of Bertrucius’ teaching methods has often been quoted. After leaving Bologna, Guy traveled to Paris before taking up residence in Lyons, where he was appointed canon of St. Just. He was later appointed a canon of Rheims and of Mende. At this period the popes resided in Avignon, and Guy became private physician to Clement VI (1342–1352), Innocent VI (1352–1362), and Urban V (1362–1370). His service to the popes was valued enough to earn him an appointment as a papal clerk (capellanus). While serving at Avignon, Guy made the acquaintance of Petrarch.
In his works Guy calls himself “cyrurgicus magister in medicine,” and he received his master’s degree in medicine (equivalent to the M.D. of Bologna) from Montpellier. He was one of the most influential surgeons of the fourteenth century; in fact, some nineteenth-century medical historians went so far as to rank him second only to Hippocrates in his influence on surgery. His chief work was the Inventorium sive collectorium in parse chirurgiciali medicine, which is usually referred to by its shorter title of Chirurgia or sometimes Chirurgia magna. Guy completed it in 1363 and dedicated it to his colleagues at Montpellier, Bologna, Paris, and Avignon, places where he had either practiced medicine or been a student. The seven parts or books that make up the Chirurgia passed through numerous editions and served at least until the seventeenth century as the standard work on the subject. The book or parts of it were translated early from Latin into Provençal, French, English, Italian, Dutch, and Hebrew. The prologue (“Capitulum singulare”) is an invaluable essay on general facts that Guy thought every surgeon should know about liberal arts, diet, surgical instruments, and the manner of conducting an operation. It also included a brief history of medicine and surgery in the form of notes on earlier physicians and surgeons and is the source of much information about Guy himself.
Guy regarded his book as a collection of the best medical ideas of his time, and he modestly stated that only a few things were original with him. E. Nicaise, the editor of the standard scholarly edition of the work, found that of some 3,300 quotations made by Guy, no fewer than 1,400 were from Arab writers and 1,100 from ancient authors. All told, some 100 different writers were cited or quoted. Galen led the list with 890 different citations, but frequent references were also made to Hippocrates, Aristotle, Al-R?z? (Rhazes), Abul Kasim (Albucasis), Ibn S?n? (Avicenna), Ibn Rushd (Averroës), and many other Arab or classical writers. Chauliac also mentioned and assessed his contemporaries. He thought highly of William of Saliceto but little of Lanfranchi, and he ridiculed John of Gaddesden.
Chauliac urged surgeons to study anatomy and went so far as to say that surgeons who were ignorant of anatomy carved the human body in the same way that a blind man carved wood. In spite of his emphasis on anatomy, his section (Tractatus I) on the subject is the weakest part of his book; Guy shows little real understanding, even though he had undoubtedly assisted at dissections and carried out postmortem examinations. His work may be said to reflect more the teacher than the scientist and is more didactic than scientific; he probably accurately represents the state of medical knowledge at his time.
His work is a mine of information on all kinds of things. In his section on carbuncles, abscesses, tumors, and so forth, Guy also included buboes in the armpits. He then went on to describe the plagues of 1348 and 1360 at Avignon. He pointed out the prevalence of plague in Asia and Europe, indicated the differences between the pneumonic and bubonic types, and then revealed himself to be a man of his time by blaming the disease on the Jews—who, he said, wished to poison the world—or on certain conjunctions of the planets. He did, however, recognize the contagious nature of the plague and recommended purification of the air, as well as venesection and a good diet for the afflicted.
Much of the historical controversy on the place of Guy de Chauliac in the history of medicine has raged over the question of his views on infection. In many standard histories of medicine, Guy is accused of believing that pus (laudable pus) was a necessary part of the healing process. He is also accused of practicing meddlesome medicine by prescribing all sorts of salves, plasters, and so forth instead of depending upon the healing powers of nature. This labeling of Guy as a medical reactionary has in part been discounted by historians such as Jordan Haller, who are extremely critical of the standard treatments of Guy’s medical attitudes.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
I. Original Works. Chauliac’s original MS has long been lost, and so has the archetype of the translation that was made into French. There are, however, several versions dating from the last quarter of the fifteenth century, as well as fragments, commentaries, and abridgments. The first published ed. was a French one, De la pratique de cyrurgie, collated with the Latin text by Nicolas Panis (Lyons, 1478). The first Latin ed. was published at Venice in 1498. An Italian trans. appeared at Venice in 1480; a Dutch trans. at Antwerp in 1500; and Catalan and Spanish trans. at Barcelona in 1492. Most of these went through several eds. An English ed. published in 1541 has not survived, although Robert Coplan’s trans. of the Chirurgia parva, dating from 1541–1542, is still extant. This Chirurgia parva, although often ascribed to Chauliac, is simply a rather poor compendium of some parts of the Chirurgia magna. Guy also wrote a treatise on astrology, Practica astrolabii (De astronomia), dedicated to Clement VI, and two other works that are now lost, De ruptura, a treatise on hernia, and De subtilianti diaeta, a treatise on cataract with a regimen for the patient. The best ed. is that of E. Nicaise, which is a trans. into modern French under the title La grande chirurgie (Paris, 1890). There is an English trans. of Tractatus III, On Wounds and Fractures, by W. A. Brennan (Chicago, 1923). See also The Middle English Translation of Guy de Chauliac’s Anatomy, Björn Wallner, ed. (Lund, Sweden, 1964).
II. Secondary Literature. George Sarton, Introduction to the History of Science, III (Baltimore, 1948), 1690–1694, summarizes much of the information about Guy and includes a discussion of various eds. of his work. Also valuable is E. Gurlt, Geschichte der Chirurgie, 3 vols. (Berlin, 1898), 11, 77–107. See also Leo Zimmerman and Ilza Veith, Great Ideas in the History of Surgery (Baltimore, 1961), pp. 149–157; and Vern L. Bullough, The Development of Medicine as a Profession (Basel, 1966), pp. 64–65, 93–95. A good summary article on whether Guy was or was not a medical reactionary is Jordan Haller, “Guy de Chauliac and His Chirurgia magna,” in Surgery, 55 (1964), 337–343.
Vern L. Bullough
