Civil Disobedience
Civil Disobedience
Essay
Date: 1849
Source: Thoreau, Henry David. "Civil Disobedience" in Blackwood, R. T. and A. L. Herma, eds. Problems in Philosophy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1975.
About the Author: Henry David Thoreau was a naturalist and writer who lived in Massachusetts in the mid-nineteenth century. His writings, especially the book Walden and the essay Civil Disobedience, had little influence during his lifetime but became world-famous during the twentieth century.
INTRODUCTION
Henry David Thoreau (1817–1862) was an essay-ist and naturalist who lived in Concord, Massachusetts. He was a member of an informal group of New England thinkers known as Transcendentalists, who shared a belief that the life of the spirit went beyond or transcended the truths available from science or organized religion. He wrote a number of books and essays, including, most famously, Walden (1854) and the essay "Civil Disobedience."
In 1842, Thoreau began to refuse paying his poll tax. The poll tax was an annual sum demanded of every adult Massachusetts male between the ages of twenty and seventy. Thoreau's intention was straightforward: he was an ardent Abolitionist or opponent of slavery, and, as he explains in "Civil Disobedience," wished to dissociate himself from any government that either actively enabled slavery or acquiesced in its existence.
In May, 1846, the United States went to war with Mexico. The result of the war was the forced cession by Mexico to the United States of about half its territory, an area including the present-day states of Arizona, California, Nevada, and New Mexico—almost a quarter of the United States' present area. (Mexico was forced to accept $15,000,000 for the territory, about $300,000,000 in 2005 dollars.) The war was viewed by some Americans, including virtually all Abolitionists, as aggressive and unjust. Thoreau mentions the Mexican War several times in "Civil Disobedience" as an exemplary reason for refusing to cooperate with government.
By 1846, when the Mexican War began, the Concord tax collector had been asking Thoreau to pay his poll tax for years. Two months after the start of the war, however, he accosted Thoreau in the street and asked again for the money. Thoreau refused to pay and was escorted politely to the town jail, where he was imprisoned for refusal to pay the tax.
Thoreau was not the first Transcendentalist to be jailed for refusal to pay the poll tax: Bronson Alcott (1799–1888) and Charles Lane (1800–1870) had both been arrested in 1842 for Abolitionism-inspired tax resistance. In both cases, a third party paid off their debt against the protestor's will, rather than allow a town scandal to occur. In Thoreau's case, too, an anonymous third party—probably an aunt—paid the tax. He was released after spending only one night in jail. Thoreau was annoyed by this outcome, since he had wished his imprisonment to be longer in order to have greater political impact.
In 1848, he gave a public lecture based on his experiences and on his philosophy of resistance to the State. The next year, an essay version of the lecture was published under the title "Resistance to Civil Government." The phrase "civil disobedience," which is today a basic term of the political vocabulary, was never actually used by Thoreau, but was attached to the essay when it was published in book form four years after his death. The identity of the editor who devised the famous phrase is not known.
PRIMARY SOURCE
Unjust laws exist: shall we be content to obey them, or shall we endeavor to amend them, and obey them until we have succeeded, or shall we transgress them at once? Men generally, under such a government as this, think that they ought to wait until they have persuaded the majority to alter them. They think that, if they should resist, the remedy would be worse than the evil. But it is the fault of the government itself that the remedy is worse than the evil. It makes it worse. Why is it not more apt to anticipate and provide for reform? Why does it not cherish its wise minority? Why does it cry and resist before it is hurt? Why does it not encourage its citizens to be on the alert to point out its faults, and do better than it would have them? Why does it always crucify Christ, and excommunicate Copernicus and Luther, and pronounce Washington and Franklin rebels?
One would think, that a deliberate and practical denial of its authority was the only offence never contemplated by government; else, why has it not assigned its definite, its suitable and proportionate penalty? If a man who has no property refuses but once to earn nine shillings for the State, he is put in prison for a period unlimited by any law that I know, and determined only by the discretion of those who placed him there; but if he should steal ninety times nine shillings from the State, he is soon permitted to go at large again.
If the injustice is part of the necessary friction of the machine of government, let it go, let it go: perchance it will wear smooth—certainly the machine will wear out. If the injustice has a spring, or a pulley, or a rope, or a crank, exclusively for itself, then perhaps you may consider whether the remedy will not be worse than the evil; but if it is of such a nature that it requires you to be the agent of injustice to another, then I say, break the law. Let your life be a counter friction to stop the machine. What I have to do is to see, at any rate, that I do not lend myself to the wrong which I condemn.
As for adopting the ways in which the State has provided for remedying the evil, I know not of such ways. They take too much time, and a man's life will be gone. I have other affairs to attend to. I came into this world, not chiefly to make this a good place to lie in, but to live in it, be it good or bad. A man has not everything to do, but something; and because he cannot do everything, it is not necessary that he should do something wrong. It is not my business to be petitioning the Governor or the Legislature any more than it is theirs to petition me; and if they should not hear my petition, what should I do then? But in this case the State has provided no way: its very Constitution is the evil. This may seem to be harsh and stubborn and unconciliatory; but it is to treat with the utmost kindness and consideration the only spirit that can appreciate or deserves it. So is all change for the better, like birth and death, which convulse the body.
I do not hesitate to say, that those who call themselves Abolitionists should at once effectually withdraw their support, both in person and property, from the government of Massachusetts, and not wait till they constitute a majority of one, before they suffer the right to prevail through them. I think that it is enough if they have God on their side, without waiting for that other one. Moreover, any man more right than his neighbors constitutes a majority of one already.
SIGNIFICANCE
The number of persons who have been moved to political action partly by Thoreau's essay is in the many thousands or possibly millions, and includes a number of world-famous activists. Indian independence leader Mahatma Gandhi (1869–1948) read "Civil Disobedience" in 1906, when he was living in South Africa and fighting racist laws in that country. He often cited it as basic to his own theory of nonviolent resistance, which eventually won India its independence from the British Empire in 1947. Thoreau himself, it should be noted, was not a pacifist; although he does not advocate violence in "Civil Disobedience," in later essays he approved of violent resistance against slavery.
Emma Goldman and Martin Buber both cited Thoreau's essay as a key influence. An unnamed member of the Danish resistance to Nazi occupation during World War II later wrote, "Thoreau's 'Civil Disobedience' stood for me, and for my first leader in the resistance movement, as a shining light with which we could examine the policy of complete passivity which our government had ordered for the whole Danish population … I lent Thoreau's books to friends, told them about him, and our circle grew. Railroads, bridges, and factories that worked for the Germans were blown up" (quoted by Thoreau scholar Lawrence Rosenwald). Martin Luther King (1929–1968), leader of the American movement for civil rights and racial equality in the 1950s and 1960s, read Thoreau as a young man in college and in his autobiography said that "I remembered how, as a college student, I had been moved when I first read this work. I became convinced that what we were preparing to do in Montgomery was related to what Thoreau had expressed. We were simply saying to the white community, 'We can no longer lend our cooperation to an evil system.'" "Civil Disobedience" is also cited today by the war-tax resistance movement, which refuses to pay taxes to governments that are waging wars the protestors consider unjust.
Thoreau's influence on the modern world has been great in other areas as well. He has profoundly shaped the environmental movement, for example, through such works as Walden and the essay "Walking." Thoreau is one of the few philosophers of the nineteenth century who is read today not only by students and scholars but by millions of ordinary people who are moved—often to action—by what he had to say.
FURTHER RESOURCES
Books
Harding, Walter. The Days of Henry Thoreau: A Biography. New York: Dover, 1962.
Periodicals
Hendrick, G. "The Influence of Thoreau's 'Civil Disobedience' on Gandhi's Satyagraha." The New England Quarterly. 29,4(1956): 462-71.
Herr, William A. "Thoreau: A Civil Disobedient?" Ethics. 85,1(1974): 87-9.
Web sites
Oxford University Press. "The Theory, Practice, and Influence of Thoreau's Civil Disobedience." August 7, 2003. <http://www.wellesley.edu/Peace/Rosenwald/thoreau.html> (accessed May 15, 2006).
