Territory

views updated

TERRITORY

At the time of independence several states had extensive claims to territory on the western frontier. A dispute over whether such territories were to be administered by the claimant states or by and for the United States long delayed ratification of the articles of confederation. In 1780 Congress passed a resolution urging the states to cede their claims to the United States. The resolution contained three promises which became the basic principles of American constitutionalism as extended to the territories: that the territories would be "disposed of for the common benefit of the United States"; that they would be "settled and formed into distinct republican states"; and that they would eventually "become members of the federal union and have the same rights of sovereignty, freedom, and independence as the other states." After the cession was complete and the western boundary was settled by the Treaty of Paris (1783), Congress embodied these three principles in measures for the temporary government of the territories: the ordinance of 1784 and the northwest ordinance of 1787. The same principles were reaffirmed by the constitutional convention of 1787. Although some delegates advocated maintaining the western lands as a federal colony to be exploited and governed permanently by the existing states, the Constitution provided for the admission of new states on an equal basis with the original states.

The first acquisition of territory beyond the original borders of the nation was the louisiana purchase. After brief debate about the constitutional propriety of such territorial expansion, Congress proceeded to organize the Louisiana Territory following the model of the Northwest Ordinance. Exploration, purchase, and cession, as well as the conquests of the Mexican War, resulted in further territorial expansion.

Congress's power to make rules and regulations for the territories derives from the second clause of Article IV, section 3. In the first important case on territories to be decided by the Supreme Court, american insurance company v. canter (1828), Chief Justice john marshall suggested that the power to govern the territories was also implied in the power to acquire them through the use of the treaty power or the war powers. He added that, whatever its source, Congress's power over the territories was plenary, whether exercised directly or through a local legislature, and extended even to creation of territorial courts with jurisdiction beyond the judicial power of the United States.

In the early nineteenth century the question of slavery in the territories divided the country and sparked new controversy over the constitutional status of territories. Southerners maintained that the federal government held the territories in trust for the states and that Congress could not properly prohibit slavery in them, while northern Whigs such as abraham lincoln maintained that the territories were national possessions and failure to prohibit slavery in them would constitute a national endorsement of the institution. stephen a. douglas proposed to avoid the issue by leaving it to a vote of the settlers in each territory. Congress sought to allay sectional contention in the missouri compromise by permitting slavery in one part of the Louisiana Purchase while prohibiting it in the rest. In the compromise of 1850, Douglas's formula (which he called popular sovereignty) was adopted for the territory acquired in the Mexican War (except California). In dred scott v. sandford (1857) the Supreme Court held that Congress did not have the power to exclude slavery from the territories. The civil war, by eliminating the slavery issue, ended the sectional dispute over the status of territories.

By 1869 American territorial acquisition on the mainland of North America was complete. A new debate about the status of territories began when, at the end of the nineteenth century, the United States started to acquire overseas possessions, not a part of the continent and apparently not destined for statehood. The place of this "colonial empire" in the constitutional system was a subject of political dispute in the 1900 elections; but it was not resolved until the Supreme Court decided the insular cases. In these cases the Court formulated the doctrine of incorporation of territories, according to which territorial possessions do not become part of the United States until Congress, by some positive action, makes them so.

Territories may be either incorporated or unincorporated, and either organized or unorganized. The former refers to the degree of constitutional protection enjoyed by inhabitants and to Congress's ultimate intention to confer statehood or not; the latter refers to the provision Congress has made for government of the territory. There are now no incorporated territories, but there are both organized and unorganized unincorporated territories. In 1934 the special status of "commonwealth" was created for the Philippines, which became independent after world war ii; puerto rico and the Northern Marianas currently have commonwealth status and enjoy virtually complete internal self-government. After World War II the United States accepted a mandate over the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands. Authority over that territory was exercised by virtue of the united nations charter until the trusteeship ended in 1981.

Dennis J. Mahoney
(1986)

Bibliography

Bloom, John Porter, ed. 1973 The American Territorial System. Athens: Ohio University Press.

Liebowitz, A.H. 1979 United States Federalism: States and Territories. American University Law Review 28:449–482.

Perkins, Whitney T. 1962 Denial of Empire. Leyden, Netherlands: A. W. Sythoff.

More From encyclopedia.com