Wiretapping
WIRETAPPING
2008 Amendments to FISA
On July 10, 2008, President George W. Bush signed into law sweeping new amendments to the Foreign Intelligence Security Act, 50 USC § 1801 et seq., that the The New York Times referred to as “the biggest vamping of federal surveillance law in 30 years.” H.R. 6304, the FISA Amendments Act of 2008, was signed into law shortly after passing in the Senate by a vote of 69 to 28. The biggest and most divisive of its provisions was the granting of legal immunity for telecommunications providers (e.g., telephone companies) that had cooperated in the National Security Agency's (NSA) wiretapping program following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on the United States. The final bill ended nearly a year of debate in Congress over surveillance rules and the warrantless wiretapping program. In simplest terms, the measure provided for U.S. government agencies to intercept foreign telephone calls without court approval (“warrantless”). It also gave legal immunity (from lawsuits) to telephone companies who complied with requests pursuant to FISA. The immunity was both retroactive and prospective (for past and future cooperation).
Public disclosure of the warrantless wiretapping program was first made in late 2005 and ignited a fierce national debate over the balance of privacy and civil liberties against the need to protect the country against terrorist attacks. In the interim between public disclosure and the signing of the new amendments into law, approximately 40 lawsuits had been filed against telecommunications companies by groups and individuals. (In July 2007, a split panel of the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit vacated the judgment of a federal district court and ruled that plaintiffs challenging government spying under the National Security Agency (NSA) lacked legal standing to sue. The NSA operated a program providing for interception (monitoring, wiretapping) of communications involving any individuals with suspected ties to al Qaeda (a terrorist organization widely held as being a key player in attacks against the United States) without first getting a court-issued warrant. In February 2008, the U.S. Supreme Court denied review of the appellate court's decision. ACLU v. NSA, 493 F.3d 644; cert. den., No. 07-468, 553 U.S.—.)
FISA was established in 1978 following the Watergate scandal, to protect civil liberties against unwarranted government intrusion. It originally contained provisions prohibiting intentional electronic surveillance under the appearance of an official act, or the disclosure or use of information obtained by electronic surveillance, knowing that it was not authorized by statute. Wiretapping orders approved by secret orders under this prior version of the law were set to expire in August 2008 unless Congress acted.
The official amendments passed in the U.S. House of Representatives on June 20, 2008 by a vote of 293 to 129. A Senate vote was then delayed by filibuster efforts from Senators Russ Feingold (D-WI) and Chris Dodd (D-CT). Feingold argued that the bill threatened civil liberties, while Dodd called for an amendment to strike Title II (the immunity provisions), arguing that granting retroactive immunity
would undermine the rule of law. Dodd's amendment was rejected by a 66 to 32 vote.
Supporters of the final bill argued that it contained several safeguards to protect Americans' civil liberties, and had been reviewed by several inspectors general. Senator Christopher Bond (R-MO), a lead negotiator, told The New York Times reporters that there was nothing to fear in the bill “unless you have Al Qaeda on your speed dial.”
Support from key Democrats ensured passage of the final bill. Senator John D. Rockefeller IV(D-WV) agreed that modernizing FISA was necessary to provide intelligence officials with the necessary tools to deter attacks. E-mails, wireless telephones, and the Internet did not exist for consumers in 1978. But Rockefeller was quoted in The New York Times as stating that the plan “was made even more complicated by the president's decision, in the aftermath of Sep.11, 2001, to go outside of FISA rather than work with Congress to fix it.”
The 2008 amendments essentially rendered moot the lawsuits against such telecommunications giants as AT&T, Verizon, and others that conducted wiretaps at the Bush Administration's direction without court order. New provisions included a narrow review by district courts to determine whether the companies being sued received formal requests or directives from the administration to take part in the wiretapping. (The administration had acknowledged that such directives existed.) If such a finding is made, the lawsuits “shall be promptly dismissed,” the new amendments stated.
“The new amendments also expanded the government's authority to invoke emergency wiretapping procedures. The NSA would be allowed to seek court orders for broad groups of foreign targets, but a new seven-day period for direct wiretaps without a court order could be exercised in “exigent” circumstances where important government security information would be lost. The amendments also expanded the existing three-day emergency wiretaps of Americans to seven days, if the attorney general certified there was probable cause to believe the target was linked to terrorism.
Immediately following the signing of the bill into law, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) filed suit in federal district court, representing a coalition of attorneys, human rights activists, labor, and media organizations. The suit argued that the new law violated free speech and privacy under the First and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. Amnesty, et al., v. McConnell, U.S] District Court for the Southern District of New York, filed July 10, 2008.
