Americans with Disabilities Act
Americans with Disabilities Act
U.S. v. Georgia
Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), 42 U.S.C.A. § 12131 et seq., prohibits disabled persons from being denied the benefits of the "services, programs, or activities of a public entity, or to be subjected to discrimination by any such entity." A public entity includes any state or local government. Title II authorizes lawsuits by private citizens for money damages against public entities who violate Title II provisions. However, since the late 1990s the U.S. SUPREME COURT has issued decisions that have limited the ability to Congress to revoke state sovereign immunity and permit lawsuits under civil rights statutes for money damages. The Court shifted course in U.S. v. Georgia, __U.S.__, 126 S.Ct. 877, 163 L.Ed.2d 650 (2006), ruling that a Georgia state prison inmate who is paraplegic can pursue a Title II damages lawsuit against the state of Georgia for the conditions of his confinement.
Tony Goodman was confined to the Georgia State Prison at Reidsville. Goodman filed administrative complaints with the prison system and then filed a complaint in federal district court in which he challenged the conditions of his confinement. He named the State of Georgia and the Georgia Department of Corrections as defendants. He sought money damages and injunctive relief. In the list of allegations submitted to the court, Goodman claimed that he was confined almost 24 hours per day in his 12-by-3 foot cell. He could not turn his wheelchair around and he could not use toilet and shower facilities without assistance. Sometimes, he alleged, the guards denied him this assistance. He also alleged that he had injured himself many times when he tried to use the toilet or shower on his own and on several occasions he had been forced to sit in his own feces and urine. Other allegations included denial of physical therapy and medical treatment, and denial of access to almost all prison programs because of his disability.
The federal district court ruled that Goodman's allegations were vague and dismissed his complaint without allowing Goodman the chance to amend his pleadings and provide more detail. The judge dismissed the prisoner's Title II claims because the Supreme Court had ruled that states could not be sued for damages under Title II, as the law violated state sovereign immunity. Goodman appealed to the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals and at that point the United Sates government intervened on his behalf, arguing that in this case Title II had constitutionally abrogated the state's immunity. The court of appeals concluded that Goodman had alleged sufficient facts to support a civil rights lawsuit based on violations of the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishments Clause. The court ordered the district court to allow Goodman to amend his complaint relating to the conditions of his confinement. As to the Title II claims, the Eleventh Circuit upheld the district court, finding that these claims were barred by sovereign immunity. The Supreme Court agreed to hear the federal government's appeal to consider this sovereign immunity question.
The Court, in a unanimous decision, ruled that Title II validly abrogated state sovereign immunity when it created a private cause of action for damages against the states for conduct that actually violated the Fourteenth Amendment. Justice Antonin Scalia, writing for the Court, made clear that it was not reviewing the Eighth Amendment claims. The state had not contested the Eleventh Circuit ruling, so the Supreme Court would not consider the merits of those claims. However, Goodman had also argued that this same conduct also violated Title II. Justice Scalia found it plausible that the alleged deliberate refusal of prison officials to accommodate Goodman's disability-related mobility, hygiene, medical care and other prison programs constituted a denial of Title II discrimination. This was important because the Fourteenth Amendment's Due Process Clause incorporates the Eighth Amendment's Cruel and Unusual Punishment into its protections, making the Eighth Amendment applicable to state governments. Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment, which includes the Due Process Clause, the Equal Protection Clause, and the Privileges and Immunities Clauses, sets out these powerful substantive guarantees. Section 5 authorizes Congress to pass laws to enforce Section 1 and that power extends to the abrogation of state sovereign immunity.
Justice Scalia concluded that Title II created a private cause of action for damages against the state for acts that "actually" violate the Fourteenth Amendment. Prior Title II cases that refused to abrogate sovereign immunity dealt with actions that did not violate a person's constitutional rights. Therefore, Goodman was entitled to pursue the Title II cause of action as well as the Fourteenth/Eighth Amendment claim. The Court directed that the lawsuit be sent back to the district court, where Goodman could attempt to sort out these claims. Once he files an amended complaint the court can decide (1) which aspects of the state's alleged misconduct violated Title II, (2) which misconduct violated the Fourteenth Amendment, and (3) which misconduct violated Title II but not the Fourteenth Amendment. As to the third category, the lower courts would have to decide if the "purported abrogation of sovereign immunity as to that class of conduct is nevertheless valid."
