Shaw, Artie
Shaw, Artie
(b. 23 May 1910 in New York City; d. 30 December 2004 in Newbury Park, California), prominent clarinetist and orchestra leader of the Swing Era.
Shaw was born Arthur Jacob Arshawsky on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, the only child of Harry Arshawsky and Sarah (Strauss) Arshawsky, Jewish immigrants from Russia and Austria, respectively. The parents ran a dressmaking business from their home until it went bankrupt, whereupon they moved to New Haven, Connecticut. The father tried several jobs and eventually abandoned his wife and son.
Vicious anti-Semitism by New York City schoolmates embittered the sensitive Shaw, and for three years his mother forced him to take piano lessons, which he hated and quickly forgot (but later relearned). As a Boy Scout he taught himself to play the ukulele. Inspired by vaudeville musicians, Shaw dropped out of high school when he was a freshman in order to master the alto saxophone. This allowed him to play professionally with minimal lessons. A voracious reader who later enrolled in college courses, he hoped to become a novelist.
Shaw was intense, acerbic, and a perfectionist in everything he did. In the mid-1920s, while playing shows and dances as far away as Cleveland, he shortened his name to Art Shaw, took up the clarinet and baritone sax, and began writing musical arrangements. In 1938 his first name became “Artie” when a recording executive observed that “Art Shaw” sounded like “a fast sneeze.”
On a whim he entered and won an essay contest about the upcoming 1929 National Air Races, the prize being a two-week trip to Hollywood, California. There Shaw witnessed Irving Aaronson and His Commanders dance band; two of its members, friends of his, convinced him to join the band when it moved on to Chicago. In Chicago, being the center of jazz music in the late 1920s, Shaw observed his first bona fide jazz players, with whom he jammed. He was heavily influenced by the trumpeter Louis Armstrong and the cornetist Bix Beiderbecke as well as—after the Commanders moved on to New York City—the piano man Willie “The Lion” Smith.
Shaw then made his first significant recordings with that band but also suffered a stiff fine after he ran over and killed a jaywalking pedestrian. During the early and mid-1930s Shaw performed as lead alto saxophonist and clarinetist on Bing Crosby’s and other radio shows, at dances, and on recordings for numerous jazz and “sweet” dance bands. He made records with the jazz giants Bunny Berigan and Red Norvo and the jazz singers Mildred Bailey, the Boswell Sisters, and Billie Holiday. About 1932 Shaw eloped with underage Jane Carns, a secretary whose father quickly had the marriage annulled.
Shaw’s grueling pace and determination to write a biography of the late Bix, who had recently succumbed to alcoholism, led him to retire from music in 1933 to a farm in Bucks County, Pennsylvania. He shared it with the nurse Margaret Allen, whom he later married and divorced. Shaw enjoyed life as a recluse, but his lack of writing skills soon convinced him to return to music, where he was still much in demand.
Impressed by classical composers, Shaw accepted an invitation to lead a jazz group in a unique “swing” concert by composing “Interlude in B-Flat” for clarinet, string quartet, and rhythm section (without piano)—an unprecedented combination inspired by Mozart and Brahms. Performing the piece at New York City’s Imperial Theater on 24 May 1936, Shaw moved the audience to thunderous applause.
This singular success led to an offer to form a permanent “little-band-built-around-a-string-quartet.” The first Art Shaw orchestra struggled among the popular bands that defined the Swing Era. So Shaw formed what he called the “loudest band in the whole goddamned world”—fourteen pieces of the standard brass, reeds, and rhythm for which he wrote the arrangements.
Even this version of the band, Art Shaw and His New Music of 1937–1938, failed to achieve success, leading Shaw to change its name to Artie Shaw and His Orchestra and add new swinging arrangements. The band performed on live radio twice weekly and in cut numerous records. The first one, Cole Porter’s “Begin the Beguine,” became a hit virtually overnight, making the Shaw band a national sensation.
The renowned black jazz singer Billie Holiday provided the band’s vocals for several months, but pervasive racial prejudice by customers during their travels led her to leave it. Shaw had utilized the African-American scat singer Leo Watson on records only, and he later persevered by integrating the trumpeter-vocalist greats Roy Eldridge and Oran “Hot Lips” Page into later touring bands but with the same result.
Shaw hired Helen Forrest, who proved a superb band singer, and in December 1938 brought in Georgie Auld on tenor sax and a sensational eighteen-year-old Buddy Rich on drums, elevating Jerry Gray to be his premier arranger. They transformed the band so much that impassioned swing fans saw Shaw as a challenge to the clarinetist bandleader Benny Goodman’s claim as “King of Swing.” Shaw adopted the title “King of the Clarinet,” and his band soon surpassed Goodman’s in Down Beat magazine’s poll as the top swing band.
Impressive to the experts, such as Richard Sudhalter later, was Shaw’s “uncanny control of the clarinet’s highest reaches,” and to Gunther Schuller, Shaw was “virtually incomparable in the beauty of his tone.” He experimented much more than Goodman did by eschewing pop melodies of the day in favor of more lasting evergreens from Broadway and Hollywood as epitomized in the melodies of the composers George Gershwin and Cole Porter.
Recording dates, cross-country road trips, and extended stays at ballrooms and hotels assured popular acclaim. The group made three movie shorts, appeared in the motion picture Dancing Coed (1939) with Lana Turner, and shared a weekly radio program with the comedian Robert Benchley. But the reckless behavior of exuberant jitterbug dancers and autograph hounds physically endangered Shaw, who dubbed his most obnoxious fans “morons,” which infuriated them. He also began to have health problems from the demanding pace.
Amid this chaos, Shaw one evening in November 1939 abruptly walked off the bandstand at a New York City hotel and disbanded. He went to Acapulco, Mexico, to rest, only to break his kneecap a month later rescuing a woman from the heavy surf. Shaw then returned to Los Angeles, married Lana Turner four days after her twentieth birthday in February 1940, and began planning another band, this one with a full string section.
The marriage soon failed, but the new band did not. With a melody Shaw had brought back from Mexico, “Frenesi,” he and William Grant Still, the leading black classical composer of the day, arranged it for a thirty-two-piece orchestra including a wind quartet (oboe, flute, bass clarinet, and horn). Recorded in March 1940, it achieved enormous success. The new Shaw band made another movie musical, Second Chorus (1940) with the dancer Fred Astaire and featuring Artie’s unique eight-minute “Concerto for Clarinet.” The film garnered him two Academy Award nominations—for Best Score and Best Song (“Love of My Life”). He concurrently showcased his Gramercy Five combo (plus himself), virtually unique in jazz for utilizing a harpsichord.
The restless Shaw disbanded before the year’s end, only to form his Symphonic Swing orchestra, arguably his best, in August 1941, motivated partly by his skyrocketing income taxes. Japan’s attack on Pearl Harbor during Shaw’s December 1941 gig near the Newport, Rhode Island, naval facility motivated him to give the band its notice and to join the navy. In March 1942 he married for the fourth time, to Elizabeth “Betty” Kern, the daughter of the composer Jerome Kern. They had one son and divorced after two years.
Becoming chief petty officer and bandmaster in April, Shaw personally convinced Undersecretary of the Navy James V. Forrestal to let him play his own brand of music for sailors in the war zone. Navy Band No. 105, the Rangers, played an exhausting schedule in intense heat aboard warships and on embattled islands in the South Pacific for more than a year, ending in October 1943. Shaw permanently lost the hearing in his left ear when two enemy bombs exploded near his foxhole on Guadalcanal. Fortunately, the injury did not impede his musical ability.
Suffering from severe “combat fatigue” that kept him under psychoanalysis for months, Shaw was discharged in March 1944 and gradually resumed his musical and marital activities. Late in 1944 he formed a stringless dance band with Ray Conniff as arranger; he would later add eleven violins and two French horns to excellent effect, also reviving his Gramercy Five. In October 1945 Shaw married the twenty-year-old movie starlet Ava Gardner. After this union collapsed, he wed the novelist Kathleen Winsor on 28 October 1946, divorcing her two years later. Neither marriage produced children.
Shaw’s good looks and fame largely accounted for his notorious marital record, the divorces being due to his musical genius, volatility, insistence on perfection, and passions for reading and writing (notably fiction shaped by his own life experiences). In the late 1940s and early 1950s he recorded classical music, flirted with “Third Stream” chamber ensembles at New York City’s Bop City, and led dance bands, recording with Mel Torme and the Mel-Tones. But his audience was shrinking due to changing musical tastes. He bought a farm in upstate New York, where he wrote a candid memoir, The Trouble with Cinderella: An Outline of Identity (1952).
Shaw’s seventh marriage, to the actress Doris Dowling on 16 June 1952, led to the birth of a son the next year, but divorce followed in 1956. In 1953 he reformed the Gramercy Five of young bebop-weaned musicians to perform and record “head” arrangements of familiar swing tunes. However, alienated by changing popular music trends, in 1954 Shaw quit music altogether, explaining that he wanted a life outside this all-consuming profession. He put down his clarinet for good.
Shaw turned to writing fiction, although his major extended novel based on his own life was never completed. He married the actress Evelyn Keyes in 1957 and moved with her to Spain for three years. They thereafter lived apart until the final divorce in 1985. Shaw published three novellas in 1965 as I Love You, I Hate You, Drop Dead! and six stories in 1989 as The Best of Intentions. He moved permanently to central California in 1973.
Although Shaw was musically inactive in his later years, his recordings continued to sell, and in 1962 RCA presented him with eight gold records (more than one million sold of each), with total sales exceeding forty-three million records. He occasionally appeared (but did not play) with a band he formed in 1983 under the direction of the clarinetist Dick Johnson to perform his most popular arrangements at dances and concerts. Shaw also lectured at colleges on big band swing, psychotherapy, and “Consecutive Monogamy and Ideal Divorce” from his self-proclaimed expertise on the subject.
Shaw’s legacy rests on his genius as musician. In 2004 he received a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award for his “creative contributions of outstanding artistic significance to the field of recording.” Late that year Shaw died of complications from diabetes; he was ninety-four. He is buried at Valley Oaks Memorial Park in Westlake Village, California.
Biographical information is in Vladimir Simosko, Artie Shaw: A Musical Biography and Discography (2000). Shaw’s autobiography, The Trouble with Cinderella: An Outline of Identity (1952), emphasizes the pre-1938 years, complemented by Shaw, “Artie Shaw’s Address to the IAJRC Convention, August 15, 1998,” International Association of Jazz Records Collectors Journal 32, no. 1 (Winter 1999): 9–19. The 1985 biographical film Artie Shaw: Time Is All You’ve Got won an Academy Award. Richard M. Sudhalter devotes two chapters to Shaw in Lost Chords: White Musicians and Their Contribution to Jazz, 1915–1945 (1999). Gunther Schuller assesses him critically in the context of the big bands in The Swing Era: The Development of Jazz, 1930–1945 (1989). Other essential sources include Chip Deffaa, “Artie Shaw: A Remembrance,” Mississippi Rag 32, no. 4 (Feb. 2005). An anticipatory obituary is John S. Wilson, “In the Royalty of Swing,” New York Times (31 Dec. 2004).
Clark G. Reynolds
