New Deal

views updated

New Deal

As the Great Depression deepened in the months following the 1929 stock market crash, foreign and domestic consumption of all types of American tobacco declined, causing prices to plummet. The average price of flue-cured tobacco (the most important variety because of its use by American cigarette manufacturers), which had not dropped below 20 cents per pound from 1920 to 1927, plunged to 8.4 cents by 1931. Revenues for tobacco growers in 1932 were down to only 40 percent of the average received during the 1920s. After 1932, any further slump in prices would have spelled economic ruin for most producers in the tobacco-growing states.

During the 1932 presidential campaign, Franklin Roosevelt endorsed a remedy called the domestic allotment plan. Heavily promoted by the agricultural economist Milburn L. Wilson, the proposal called for the government to pay growers of certain crops to reduce production voluntarily. Farmers would not only benefit from checks financed by a tax on processors, but also from price gains on the crops they did produce. Wilson also desired active grower participation in the programs. Farmers would vote in referenda for acceptance of the programs and help oversee implementation by choosing producer committees to ensure compliance and resolve disputes.

After winning the election, Roosevelt worked with Congress to establish the Agricultural Adjustment Administration (AAA)—the New Deal agency established by the Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1933 to administer the production control programs largely based on Wilson's allotment plan. New Dealers modified the programs over the years in reaction to farmer discontent, judicial decisions, and political influences. The result was four distinct tobacco programs for the 1933, 1934–1935, 1936–1937, and 1938–1939 periods, respectively.

In 1933 the AAA negotiated a marketing agreement with buyers to boost prices. After a requisite number of farmers agreed to reduce their 1934 planted acreage up to 30 percent in exchange for government payments, buyers consented to pay at least 17 cents per pound for flue-cured tobacco. The first tobacco program was a success, as evidenced by the fact that growers in North Carolina (the largest flue-cured tobacco state) received over $85 million for their crop compared to only $35 million in 1932.

The programs changed over the next two years as a majority of farmers rallied behind an effort to compel participation. The fact that a minority of growers did not participate but still benefited greatly from the increased prices on fully planted acreage angered many cooperating producers. Their pressure on the president and Congress resulted in the Kerr-Smith Tobacco Act of 1934. Under this law, producers were assigned a quota based on past production. Tobacco sold over a farmer's limit would have a prohibitive tax placed on it, thus creating a disincentive to overproduce. Meanwhile, the AAA continued payments to growers in exchange for reduced planting.

After the shock wore off from the Supreme Court's January 1936 ruling in the Hoosac Mills case (declaring the unconstitutionality of the AAA's production control contracts and processing taxes), Roosevelt supported an important expedient—the Soil Conservation and Domestic Allotment Act (SCDAA). Growers would now be paid from the Treasury for planting less "soil-depleting" crops, including tobacco, and planting more "soil-building" crops such as grasses and legumes. The goal was to achieve production control indirectly under the auspices of soil conservation. Because Congress repealed the Kerr-Smith Act after the high court's decision, the SCDAA was a completely voluntary program. It was only marginally effective in reducing surpluses; payments were less than under the first AAA Act, and many growers increased their planted acreage.

With a friendlier pro-New Deal Court in place, Congress passed the Agricultural Adjustment Act of 1938. Building on the existing soil conservation legislation, marketing quotas were added during high-surplus periods, subject to a two-thirds approval vote by the growers. This law governed the tobacco programs until World War II.

By the end of the 1930s, the AAA successfully helped American tobacco farmers weather the storm of the Depression. It enabled growers to better adjust supply to demand while maintaining prices at the 1920s average level. In North Carolina, growers' incomes tripled while land values doubled for farms holding a tobacco allotment. Tenants and sharecroppers in tobacco-growing areas were not as adversely affected by AAA policies as those in the cotton regions, due mainly to the relatively larger labor requirements for raising tobacco. While many cotton regions suffered a tremendous drop in nontenured laborers, North Carolina, for example, experienced only a 10-percent decline in tenants.

In creating the first farm subsidies programs in American history, the AAA helped most tobacco farmers avert economic calamity. The New Deal for tobacco was generally a successful holding operation until the prosperous World War II years. It also had a lasting impact on the nation's tobacco growers. The government's relationship with tobacco producers has never been the same, as farm subsidy programs have become part of America's political economy.

See Also Politics; Sharecroppers; United States Agriculture.

? KEITH VOLANTO

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Badger, Anthony J. Prosperity Road: The New Deal, Tobacco, and North Carolina. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1980.

Rowe, Harold B. Tobacco under the AAA. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution, 1935.

Rowley, William D. M. L. Wilson and the Campaign for the Domestic Allotment. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1970.

flue-cured tobacco also called Bright Leaf, a variety of leaf tobacco dried (or cured) in air-tight barns using artificial heat. Heat is distributed through a network of pipes, or flues, near the barn floor.

referendum an election where voters choose between policies or actions rather than between candidates; for the electorate to vote directly on a law or tax rather than indirectly through representatives.

soil conservation the husbandry of the land; making careful use of soils to prevent erosion and maintain fertility and value.

marketing quota the amount of cured leaf tobacco (usually expressed in pounds) that a tobacco grower may produce and sell in a given year. The United States Department of Agriculture began setting marketing quotas for tobacco in 1933.

More From encyclopedia.com

About this article

New Deal

Updated About encyclopedia.com content Print Article

Related Content