Chinese Exclusion Act

views updated

Chinese Exclusion Act

United States 1882

Synopsis

The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first law passed in the United States that excluded a people of a specific ethnicity from immigrating to the country. It was the culmination of several decades' worth of agitation on the part of white workers in the United States, as well as violence directed against Chinese workers. The initial time period covered by the statute was 10 years; at the end of that time period, the law was renewed in 1892 for another 10 years, and in 1902 the law was made permanent. The act was not repealed until 1943, after China became an ally of the United States during World War II.

Timeline

  • 1863: The world's first subway opens, in London.
  • 1869: The first U.S. transcontinental railway is completed.
  • 1873: Typewriter is introduced.
  • 1876: Four-stroke cycle gas engine is introduced.
  • 1878: Thomas Edison develops a means of cheaply producing and transmitting electric current, which he succeeds in subdividing so as to make it adaptable to household use. The value of shares in gas companies plummets as news of his breakthrough reaches Wall Street.
  • 1881: In a shootout at the O.K. Corral outside Tombstone, Arizona, Wyatt, Virgil, and Morgan Earp, along with "Doc" Holliday, kill Billy Clanton, Frank McLowry, and Tom McLowry. This breaks up a gang headed by Clanton's brother Ike, who flees Tombstone. The towns-people, however, suspect the Earps and Holliday of murder. During the same year, Sheriff Pat Garrett shoots notorious criminal William Bonney, a.k.a. Billy the Kid, in Fort Sumner, New Mexico.
  • 1883: Brooklyn Bridge is completed.
  • 1883: Foundation of the League of Struggle for the Emancipation of Labor by Marxist political philosopher Georgi Valentinovich Plekhanov marks the formal start of Russia's labor movement. Change still lies far in the future for Russia, however: tellingly, Plekhanov launches the movement in Switzerland.
  • 1883: Life magazine begins publication.
  • 1885: Belgium's King Leopold II becomes sovereign of the so-called Congo Free State, which he will rule for a quarter-century virtually as his own private property. The region in Africa, given the name of Zaire in the 1970s (and Congo in 1997), becomes the site of staggering atrocities, including forced labor and genocide, at the hands of Leopold's minions.
  • 1889: Indian Territory in Oklahoma is opened to white settlement.
  • 1893: Henry Ford builds his first automobile.

Event and Its Context

The discovery of gold in California inspired not only American "49ers." Many Chinese peasants had been displaced by the Red Turban Rebellion, and they suffered under extremely high taxes levied by the Qing government to pay indemnities to Western imperialist powers as a result of the First Opium War (1843). This was coupled with hardships caused by the extensive flooding in the rich delta areas and resulted in large numbers of peasants being drawn to the promises held by Gam Saan (Gold Mountain) in the United States. The success achieved by early migrants who returned to their villages with the money they made in Hawaii and in the United States spurred more migration to America. Labor recruiters posted circulars in many villages in China, promising high wages. In 1860 a Chinese laborer who made $2 to $3 a month in China could make $30 a month working on the railroad in the United States, plus have clothing and housing provided by the American employers. This wage differential, and the other promised amenities, made immigration to the United States extremely attractive to struggling Chinese peasants.

Some Chinese peasants paid their own way to the United States, as they were able to gather enough money on their own or to borrow from family members or other villagers. A substantial number of Chinese men immigrated to the United States as contract laborers by borrowing money from a broker to cover the cost of transportation, and then paying off that loan plus interest out of earnings in the United States. There is little documentation that Chinese workers were kidnapped or coerced into immigration, so few Chinese immigrants could properly be labeled "coolies" (from the Chinese term Ku Li, meaning bonded servant), despite the popular depiction during this time of the typical Chinese laborer. The few who did come to the United States as bonded laborers were banned by law in 1862, in the midst of a war over slavery. In a pattern that would be repeated over and over with the Chinese, however, little distinction was made between bonded and free Chinese laborers; many Americans applied the divisive term to all Chinese workers.

Although some Chinese were initially warmly received in the United States, the increasing numbers of "Celestials" (one of the least objectionable names by which natives of China were known) engendered greater levels of hostility. By 1852 white miners were able to persuade the legislature of California to pass a law levying a tax of $3 per month on "foreign" miners who did not attempt to become citizens. (Chinese immigrants were prevented from applying for naturalization because of the 1790 law that limited those eligible for naturalized citizenship to "white" persons.) This foreign miners' tax remained in force until passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1870. Although this law was mainly aimed at protecting the civil rights of the newly freed African Americans, provisions also were made to prevent the imposition of discriminatory penalties, taxes, licenses, or other exactions, which were initially applied to the Chinese. By the time this occurred, however, the state of California had collected over $5 million through this tax, a sum representing over 25 percent of all state revenue. Most Chinese miners during this early time period worked for themselves in placer mines (the stereotypical mine claim in Gold Rush California), shoveling sand into pans or rockers and then washing it away, looking for the heavier gold particles. Like other miners, however, the Chinese were soon looking for other work as the surface mines quickly played out.

As this was happening, the impetus to construct railroads in California was growing stronger. In 1866 the Central Pacific Railroad began to recruit Chinese laborers to construct a rail line from Sacramento east. According to historian Alexander Saxton, the railroad kept some 10,000 Chinese men employed in boring and blasting the tunnels through the Sierra Nevada, as well as laying track across Nevada and much of Utah. Many of these Chinese laborers remained employed in railroad construction, because after joining the Union Pacific Railroad at Promontory Point in Utah, the Central Pacific built feeder lines north and south in California. Chinese workers who left the railroad construction industry often provided labor on California farms, which were moving from pastoral pursuits into cash crops; the Chinese provided the strong backs for clearing land, digging ditches, building dikes and irrigation systems, and harvesting crops. Chinese workers who could not find work in either of these two fields, or who chose not to, drifted into the cities in the West, where they often found jobs in industries being established in western cities, worked as domestics, or opened laundries. "Chinese laundries" are an American invention, as in patriarchal Chinese society, women were expected to perform household chores such as laundry. In the western portion of the United States, single men comprised a large portion of the population, and the entrepreneurial Chinese saw an opportunity to make money by providing a needed service. Chinese men provided this service because there were so few Chinese women in the United States; only one in every 13 Chinese immigrants was female. To ensure the return of prodigals, the Chinese government often kept wives and children at home to help sojourners resist the temptation to become permanent residents in the United States. Chinese custom at the time provided for the patrilineal division of property among all sons, who were in turn responsible for supporting their elderly parents. The immigration of Chinese females was further restricted in 1875, with the enactment of the Page Law that forbade the immigration of Chinese prostitutes. This effectively banned most Chinese females from immigration to the United States, as no effort was made to ascertain whether a particular Chinese female was a prostitute or not; it was simply assumed that all Chinese females who attempted to immigrate to the United States were prostitutes. This law, coupled with antimiscegenation laws that were passed by several states at about the same time, made it extremely difficult for the Chinese to marry and establish families in the United States. Many whites undoubtedly felt that allowing large numbers of Chinese to establish families in the country would encourage their permanent settlement, which they wished to avoid.

In the imaginations of many white Americans, Chinese workers replaced African American slaves on the lowest rung of humanity. Chinese workers were supposed to be living on a diet, consisting of rice and rats, that any self-respecting white man would reject. The imagery that Chinese workers could subsist on fewer rations than white workers remained a part of American labor ideology for an extended period of time. Samuel Gompers utilized this vision in a speech and article published in the American Federationist, entitled "Meat v. Rice," to plead the case for permanent Chinese exclusion in 1901. Chinese were also imagined as replacing African Americans as laborers in the cotton fields of the American South. At the Cotton States Exhibition held in Memphis in 1869, Cornelius Koopmanschap boasted that he could provide planters with all the labor they needed, directly from China, for as little as $10 or $12 dollars a month. Also in 1869, Chinese laborers were imported to North Adams, Massachusetts, to break a strike of shoemakers there; later in the century, African Americans would often be used for the same purpose. This brief contact with Chinese workers by a small portion of the white working class was kept alive by the daily and labor press and became the impetus for labor's support for the Chinese exclusion legislation when it was introduced. The Chinese worker was, in fact, excluded from consideration for membership from the Knights of Labor, the most egalitarian labor movement in the history of the United States to that point and an organization that readily admitted African Americans. Although the Chinese faced opposition from whites wherever they chose to try to make a living, the opposition was strongest where their numbers were the greatest—namely, in San Francisco, California.

In 1876 the mayor of San Francisco, Andrew Jackson Bryant (1823-1882), decided the time was propitious to settle the Chinese question. The presidential election that fall would be a close one, and the House and the Senate were split between the two parties. Both Democrats and Republicans would be looking for a political issue that could gain them votes. California political leaders quickly jumped on the bandwagon, and in the midst of an economic depression this issue became the leading issue in California politics. The problem with this development for California's white workers, however, was that other issues that concerned them, such as the enforcement of the eight-hour workday, were given short shrift by politicians in the state.

California politicians were not the only beneficiaries of this development, however. In San Francisco the Workingman's Party and its best-known demagogue, Denis Kearney, capitalized on much of the opposition to the Chinese. Kearney's dramatic oratorical style proved to be very popular in the nightly meetings held in empty lots near San Francisco's Chinatown. Kearney was regularly arrested for inciting violence (mainly against the Chinese); just as regularly he was acquitted. The Workingman's Party in California faded into obscurity after 1879, in part because the Democratic Party appropriated its biggest issue, the exclusion of Chinese.

The Democratic Party in California had been able to use the advocacy of the exclusion of Chinese to reestablish the party there, and this strategy was quickly utilized on the national level, as well. The appeal of the exclusion of the Chinese to workingmen, who found their status threatened by the increased importance of industrial capital, led many to abandon the Republican Party and vote Democratic because of this issue. This, of course, prompted many Republican politicians into the advocacy of Chinese exclusion and contributed to the abandonment of the advocacy of equal rights for former slaves.

Key Players

Gompers, Samuel (1850-1924): Gompers was the first president of the American Federation of Labor (1888-1924). Although Gompers himself was an immigrant (a Jew of Dutch parents, born in England), he advocated placing restrictions on all immigrants because he believed that their presence drove down the wages for American workers and immigrants already present in the country. Although unsuccessful in restricting immigration from Europe, Gompers contributed to the successful drive to continue the restriction on immigration from China.

Kearney, Denis (1847-1907): A native of County Cork, Ireland, Kearney rose to prominence in San Francisco in 1877 when he began addressing workers and the unemployed in vacant sand lots in the city during the depression. His speeches quickly devolved from denouncements of the power of monopolies, however, to denunciations of the Chinese. He began most speeches with the words, "The Chinese must go." Kearney helped found the Workingmen's Party (San Francisco, 1878), which was influential in helping form the new California constitution that year, although provisions denying Chinese certain civil liberties were later thrown out by the courts. The popularity of these anti-Chinese laws made the final passage of the Chinese Exclusion Act in 1882 much more palpable to politicians, however.

See also: American Federation of Labor.

Bibliography

Books

Chan, Sucheng, ed. Entry Denied: Exclusion and the Chinese Community in America, 1882-1943. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, 1991.

McClain, Charles, ed. Chinese Immigrants and American Law. New York: Garland Publishing, 1994.

Saxton, Alexander. The Indispensable Enemy: Labor and the Anti-Chinese Movement in California. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1995.

Takaki, Ronald. A Different Mirror: A History of Multicultural America. Boston: Little, Brown & Co., 1993.

—Gregory M. Miller

More From encyclopedia.com