Deluxe Corporation

views updated

Deluxe Corporation

1080 West Company Road F
P.O. Box 64399
St. Paul, Minnesota 55164-0399
U.S.A.
(612) 483-7111
Fax: (612) 481-4163

Public Company
Incorporated: 1920 as DeLuxe Check Printers, Inc.
Employees: 17,400
Sales: $1.53 billion
Stock Exchanges: New York
SICs: 2759 Commercial Printing Nee; 2782 Blankbooks & Looseleaf Binders; 3953 Marking Devices; 2761 Manifold Business Forms

A shining example of a company built upon the right idea at the right time, Deluxe Corporation is the largest supplier of checks, deposit slips, and other financial documents in the United States, holding over 50 percent market share in a $1.9 billion industry. Since its 1987 purchase of Current, Inc., it has also become the nation’s foremost direct-mail marketer of greeting cards and related products. The company’s long and enviable track record has in large part mirrored the evolution of American banking and financial services technology, from the relatively simple boom-and-bust 1920s through the complex decades of the 1950s and 1960s, when electronic automation revolutionized the industry, to the current rise of electronic funds transfer (EFT). As recently as 1985, check printing accounted for 96 percent of Deluxe’s sales. However, under the leadership of CEO Harold Haverty, this figure was lowered to 69 percent by 1989 through an expanded focus on such product-services as processing software, account verification, ATM cards, sales development, business and health care forms, and the specialty products offered through Current. For many analysts, the diversification was long overdue, particularly given repeated predictions that checks would soon be obsolete; yet, 54 consecutive years of sales increases, regular returns on equity of 25-30 percent, and the continuing viability of the personal check, have proved the company right in its slow and judicious move away from its original market.

The foundation for Deluxe was laid in 1905 when William Roy Hotchkiss purchased a small Wisconsin newspaper named The Barron County Shield. Well acquainted with the printing business since boyhood, Hotchkiss thought he had found his niche, particularly after he became publisher and co-owner of the more prestigious Dunn County News of Menomonie in 1908. For the next five years Hotchkiss oversaw the development of this paper into the largest and most respected weekly in the state. A protracted illness, however, forced his early retirement from the newspaper business and his relocation to the more congenial climate of southern California. His entrepreneurial drive still intact, Hotchkiss decided to raise chickens but failed, despite conceiving the idea of selling pre-cut chickens to grocery stores.

In 1915 Hotchkiss returned to the Midwest and settled in St. Paul, vowing, according to company annals, “to do one thing and one thing only, but do it better, faster and more economically than anyone else.” Recalling his printing days and a special assignment of printing bank checks for a friend, Hotchkiss decided to claim the creation and marketing of personalized checks as his business. The distinctive feature of his checks would be quality imprinting of information unique to each customer. Hotchkiss borrowed $300 to secure the necessary equipment and a small office in the People’s Bank Building in downtown St. Paul. In the two months of operations for 1915 the eager salesman attracted $23 in orders against $293 in expenses. Despite such unpromising numbers, the company would soon find success. As Terry Blake wrote in A History of the Deluxe Corporation, 1915-1990, several factors favored Hotchkiss’s enterprise, particularly the printer’s choice of location. The Minneapolis/St. Paul area, already densely populated with financial institutions, was destined to become a major national banking center—and therefore a major check clearinghouse—through Minneapolis’s selection as the site of the Federal Reserve Bank of the Ninth District. Equally important was Hotchkiss’s timing. In 1915 approximately five billion checks were being written by American businesses each year. This immense market was being served by various printing houses, none of which was more than regionally dominant, particularly noteworthy for its service, or even remotely prepared to foster new business in a virtually untapped domain: individual consumers.

Hotchkiss’s early marketing of his company’s services consisted of mail-order brochures sent to all regions of Minnesota. His first customers were healthy outstate banks, with less deposits than the Twin Cities banks but also far fewer check-printing competitors. In 1916 Hotchkiss succeeded in tapping the metropolitan market with contracts from both the People’s Bank and the Western State Bank of St. Paul. Sales for his first full year of business reached $4,173. This same year Hotchkiss welcomed printer Einer Swanson as a business partner. Swanson replaced Hotchkiss as chief salesman and may also have been responsible for determining the company’s name. The new arrangement allowed Hotchkiss, an instinctive inventor, the freedom to design and develop new machinery to enhance printing quality, speed delivery time, and save money. By 1918 the company’s sales had soared to $18,961 and Hotchkiss issued his first catalog. The following year, as sales more than doubled, the company relocated to its first, full-sized plant. In 1920 Swanson and Hotchkiss incorporated as DeLuxe Check Printers, Inc. and became equal partners.

Growth during the 1920s was phenomenal because of both timing and the special imprint of Hotchkiss’s vision. From the beginning he had decided that his business would emphasize quality and service. Service, for him, became synonymous with speed; he instituted the still standing company goal of 48-hour turnaround on any order, or “in one day, out the next.” As the Federal Reserve established new banking districts, Deluxe, as soon as it was able, moved in to claim its share of the check business. First came Chicago, then Kansas City, then Cleveland, then New York. By the end of the decade, sales and net income had risen to $579,000 and $42,000, respectively.

Perhaps more indicative of the company’s long-term prospects were Hotchkiss’s unique advancements in check products and printing technology during the 1920s. In 1922 he developed one of the first small pocket checks—nicknamed the LH, or “Little Handy”—to complement the larger, end-register-style business check. The initial market for this new check was to be the wise and discerning consumer. As catalog copy from this era declared, “The Individualized Check today is considered almost as necessary in leading social and business circles as the calling or business card. It marks the user as a man of distinction and discrimination.” Yet, as Blake pointed out, “Hotchkiss had no definite strategy for marketing the personalized Handy checks. Bankers, too, were skeptical of the horizontal register and deemed Hotchkiss’s invention a fad. As a result, the LH, destined to become the most successful product in Deluxe’s history, remained an obscure novelty for a number of years.” Hotchkiss realized more immediate profits from a series of important, speed-enhancing inventions, which included the Hotchkiss Imprinting Press (HIP), patented in 1925; a two-way perforator, perfected the same year; and the Hotchkiss Lithograph Press (HLP), patented in 1928.

With the stock market crash in 1929 came an end to a free-spending era. From 1920 to 1929, Deluxe saw sales increase by an average of 32.3 percent annually. By comparison, from 1930 to 1939, sales increased only 55 percent for the entire ten-year span. After suffering its only full-year loss in 1932, the company began to rebound as newly elected President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s sweeping reforms for the banking industry took hold. A potentially devastating period was transformed and, like F.D.R., Deluxe hastened the transformation with a revolutionary new sales program. The program was guided not by Hotchkiss but by George McSweeney, a former Deluxe paper supplier hired by the company in 1932 expressly for the task of building a sales force and boosting revenue. McSweeney emphasized personalized attention over catalog promotions and worked closely with bankers in developing personalized check programs. Viewing Deluxe as a service—rather than product-oriented—business, he sought ways to aid financial institutions in boosting their own incomes. Promoting small checking accounts for individual customers, all of whom represented potential loan clients, became a mutual goal and the LH the mutually agreed upon tool to attract these customers. McSweeney also directed his sales force to refocus attention on serving rural banks; by 1939, this segment had grown to represent 58 percent of Deluxe’s annual revenue. Finally, McSweeney instilled in his sales force a “guidance and counsel” approach. With the passing of the Social Security Act in 1935 came an opportunity for McSweeney and his representatives to thoroughly research the law and then educate their banking customers. “To McSweeney,” writes Blake, “it was important for Deluxe to establish itself as a leader, and Deluxe’s impressive anticipation of an industry-altering event like Social Security set a precedent the company has always followed.”

In 1940 Deluxe saw sales surpass $1 million. A year later, McSweeney became company president at his own request. LH orders had multiplied from 1,000 in 1938 to 100,000 and would continue to grow exponentially. With World War II and the ration banking program which necessitated new ration checks, sales also jumped dramatically. A new service-monitoring system was instituted by production superintendent Joe Rose in 1948. Within a year, two-day delivery fulfillment advanced from 75 percent to nearly 90 percent. The advent of the teletype-setter and new plant construction in Chicago, Kansas City, and St. Paul capped the decade.

During the 1950s, overall sales rose by 275 percent. Much of the company’s growth could be attributed to the widespread popularity of the LH. Equally important was Deluxe’s national coverage of the commercial banking industry. By 1960 it had contracted for a portion of sales with 99 percent of the country’s commercial banks. Meanwhile, Deluxe’s largest competitor, New York-based Todd Company, was struggling to hold market share after a corporate takeover. With ten plants strategically spread across the United States to better serve its customers, Deluxe could boast sales of $24 million and anticipate a bright future, with steadily rising numbers for total domestic checks written, which now numbered nearly 13 billion. Furthermore, many bankers now accorded Deluxe special status as an industry leader. This was particularly true after Deluxe’s fundamental involvement with the development of magnetic ink character recognition (MICR), which after years of back-and-forth negotiations between the American Bankers Association, leading high-tech companies, and check printers, was now becoming the industry norm.

With McSweeney’s death in 1962 and the continuing maturation of MICR technology came numerous changes for the company. McS weeney’s successor, Joe Rose, was faced with dire predictions that a checkless society would be a reality by 1970. Deluxe’s recourse was to embrace MICR for all types of document processing and to launch a New Products Research Division. By 1967, sales for the three-year-old division from loan coupon books, process control documents, and deposit/withdrawal slips topped $1 million. Deluxe underwent another difficult, though ultimately beneficial, change in 1965 when it went public after pressure from various estates who complained of the artificially low trading prices for their stock. This same year, Rose satisfactorily settled another potential setback when the U.S. Post Office announced new coding and presorting regulations. A major user of the public mails, Deluxe could ill afford increased expenses or undue delays caused by the new regulations. Consequently, Rose met directly with the deputy postmaster general and obtained permission to establish his own in-plant post offices where mail could be easily sorted and sent to save the company and the local post offices both time and money. Rose closed the 1960s with more than $85 million in sales.

Despite serious inflation during the 1970s which caused production costs to rise, Deluxe performed well. By 1979 sales had risen to $366 million and net income to $39 million. This was especially impressive after considering the large capital expenditures involved in new plant openings, which arose at the pace of three per year. A considerable amount of new equipment, including minicomputers and the Deluxe Encoder Printer (DEP), also made their debut during this decade. Under Gene Olson, who became president in 1976 and CEO in 1978, Deluxe acceded to critics on Wall Street—long wary of the company’s dependency on essentially one product—and cautiously diversified into pre-inked endorsement stamps.

Growth continued unabated during the 1980s; by 1988 sales had surpassed $1 billion. Among the new products that kept Deluxe firmly in place as a financial products market leader were three-on-a-page, computer-form business checks, pegboard checks, and money market related documents. Although the financial industry suffered repeatedly by failures of large-sized banks, such developments actually increased Deluxe’s competitiveness, for as the institutions failed, numerous small check printers ceased business as well. By 1989, less than ten full-service printers remained. In one sense, however, such events were singularly frightening, for few could anticipate the future of banking. Harold Haverty, elected president in 1983 and CEO in 1986, wrestled anew with the problem of diversification (analysts for Forbes had twice predicted the company’s downfall, due to its traditionally cautious acquisition policy). In part to satisfy the analysts, but also to increase its presence as a provider of wide business services, Deluxe purchased Chex Systems, John A. Pratt and Associates, and Colwell Systems, consequently entering such new fields as account verification, marketing services, and direct-mail supply to the dental and medical industry. In 1986 Deluxe purchased A. O. Smith Data Systems and instantly became a leader in the burgeoning EFT industry. In 1987 the company purchased Current, which it now touts as “the nation’s largest direct mail marketer of greeting cards and consumer specialty products.”

Doubts about the company and its future have largely ceased. As reported by Ignatius Chithelen for Forbes, “Deluxe’s new businesses have grown to the point where they now account for 35 percent of Deluxe’s revenues and an estimated 25 percent of its operating income.” In fiscal 1991, the Data Systems Division (responsible now not only for EFT, but also electronic benefit transfer, point-of-sale retail, and automated clearing house processing) reported 12 percent sales growth. The Business Systems Division (responsible for short-run business forms for small businesses) experienced 11 percent growth. Deluxe Check Printers, as evidenced by the company’s recent name change, has now become a contributing unit to, rather than the centerpiece of, the corporation. “What happens if checkbooks eventually go the way of the buggy whip and the vacuum tube?” asked Reed Abelson, a Forbes forecaster. “Deluxe,” he decided, “seems to be well prepared.” Nonetheless, checks continue to be cashed and Deluxe reigns as the market leader in service (99.56 percent error-free delivery, 97.2 percent on-time delivery).

Principal Subsidiaries

ChexSystems, Inc.; Current, Inc.; Deluxe Data Systems, Inc.; Electronic Transaction Corp.; Nelco, Inc.

Further Reading

Zemke, Ron, and Dick Schaaf, “Deluxe Corporation,” The Service Edge: 101 Companies That Profit from Customer Care, New York: New American Library, 1989; Blake, Terry, A History of Deluxe Corporation, 1915-1990, St. Paul: Deluxe Corporation, 1990; Barthel, Matt, “To Bolster Checks, Deluxe Buys Authorization Service,” American Banker, January 4, 1991, p. 3; Chithelen, Ignatius, “Printing Money,” Forbes, March 18, 1991, p. 116; Sawaya, Zina, “The Underpaid: Relative Pain (Harold Haverty),” Forbes, May 27, 1991, p. 222; Abelson, Reed, “The Check Is in the (Electronic) Mail,” Forbes, January 6, 1992, p. 99; Kutler, Jeffrey, “3 ACH Operators Band Together,” American Banker, April 20, 1992, p. 3; “Company Profile,” July 1992, St. Paul: Deluxe Corporation.

—Jay P. Pederson

More From encyclopedia.com