Nautical Archaeology
Nautical Archaeology
Techniques for underwater surveyance, retrieval, and analysis
The development of nautical archaeology
Other uses of nautical archaeology
Recent techniques of nautical excavation
Nautical archaeology is the branch of archaeology (the study of the past by investigating what people left behind) concerned with the excavation, identification, and study of the remains of sunken sites such as ships and cities. The techniques used in nautical archaeology can be applied to the study of submerged ports, lost cities, sacrificial wells, and other underwater sites.
The ocean conceals a vast number of unexplored, and potentially valuable, archaeological sites. However, the technology needed to explore these sites was not perfected until the mid-twentieth century. With the development of scuba gear, underwater transport, and other underwater devices, archaeologists have improved their ability to survey and retrieve objects underwater.
The artifacts, or archaeological finds, removed from the ocean have enriched scientific understanding of the history of boat building and navigation, as well as broadened human knowledge of everyday life on land. Because of the lower oxygen content of cold water, objects preserved in the ocean deteriorate much less rapidly than they do on land. A 1,000-year-old shipwreck still might contain the wooden implements and food used to cook the sailors’ last meal, as well as the clothes they wore to dinner. The chances of finding such objects preserved on land would be extremely slim.
However, not all objects that sink into the ocean are preserved. If an object sinks near shore, it stands a chance of being shattered against the rocks or of being picked up by a curious diver. The movement of large waves can destroy even an object that sinks to depths of up to 50 ft (15 m). In addition, organisms inhabiting the lower regions of the sea such as teredos (ship worms) can bore through the object. In a process known as encrustation, barnacles and coral can grow in a thick layer over the object, also causing it to deteriorate.
Techniques for underwater surveyance, retrieval, and analysis
Before objects can be removed from a shipwreck, the diver must map their precise location in relation both to the other objects and to the surrounding ocean terrain. Because the average diver can move through the water at a rate of only 0.5 mph (1 km/h), apparatus have been developed to speed up surveyance. A diver may ride in a hydrodynamic cradle, a flat metal one-diver bobsled with a window in front, which can be maneuvered to lower depths. A team of two divers may ride in a towvane, a top-shaped vessel with Plexiglas® observation windows and hydrodynamic steering, similar to a diving bell. Or they may descend in a cubmarine, a small electrical battery-powered vessel steered by water jets that can submerge to depths of 164–197 ft (50–60 m).
At great ocean depths or in areas with poor visibility other devices may be employed. Sonar may be used to determine the location of large or encrusted objects by calculating the time it takes echoes to bounce off them. Underwater cameras may be towed by the boat to take pictures of a site in water with good visibility.
The method used to remove the objects will depend on their size and fragility. Ordinary objects may be brought up in plastic or net bags. Heavy objects may be lifted with chains and pulleys or with balloon-like air bags. These bags contain a small amount of compressed air that enables them to expand and rise to the surface as the water pressure decreases.
To determine the age of these objects, archaeologists had to develop new strategies. Pottery phases and stratigraphy (the analysis of the origin, distribution, and succession of layers or strata of earth) can be used to date objects found on land. However, neither technique works reliably for objects found in the sea, where water may distort the shape of a jar or may carry away rocks and silt from the scene of the wreck. Instead, archaeologists use anchors (and sometimes ship nails) to determine the age of a shipwreck. Like pottery, anchors were produced in different sizes and shapes and made of different kinds of materials (such as stone or iron) that conform to historical phases. Archaeologists use these features to assign the shipwreck a date.
The development of nautical archaeology
In the first century AD, two large Roman ships sank to the bottom of Lake Nemi, southwest of Rome, Italy. Rumored to be carrying treasure, and lying at the relatively shallow depth of 49–75 ft (15–23 m), they were not entirely forgotten. In 1446, at the request of a church official, Italian architect and theorist Leon Battista Alberti (1404–1472), assisted by divers, attempted to tow one of the ships to shore but succeeded only in raising a large statue. In 1556, a diver wearing a primitive diving apparatus consisting of a wooden hood and crystal face plate visited the site. He returned with a description of the ships, claiming that the decks were paved with red brick. In the late nineteenth century, antiquities dealer Eliseo Borghi began to remove objects from the vessel and sell them at high prices to the Italian government, but the government soon halted Borghi’s financial venture. It was not until 1928 that Italian dictator Benito Mussolini, intrigued by rumors of the buried treasure, decided to raise the ships by draining the lake, partially by means of an old Roman overflow tunnel. Four years later, the water level had been lowered more than 70 ft (229.5 m), and the ships were raised, cleaned, and moved to a museum. No treasure was found, but the ships themselves were a spectacular find: they contained heated baths, private cabins, and paved mosaic decks. Both ships were destroyed during World War II.
The first large-scale salvage of a shipwreck was carried out by the Greek Navy in 1900. In about 80 BC, a Roman vessel carrying a cargo of Greek amphorae (two-handled storage jars) sank to a depth of 197 ft (60 m) near the island of Antikythera, between Crete and southern Greece. Divers worked under extremely dangerous conditions to excavate the wreck. Laboring in storm-tossed seas, and able to remain submerged for only five minutes at a time, the divers nevertheless brought up a number of valuable objects. These objects included a statute by the Greek sculptor Lycippus and an early astronomical computer.
The first systematic archaeological excavation of a shipwreck was carried out in 1952 under the direction of French researcher, ecologist, and explorer Jacques-Yves Cousteau (1910–1997) and Fre´de´ric Dumas. The French team excavated a Roman amphora carrier that had sunk in the second century BC at Grand Congloué, near Marseilles. To assist in surveying the wreck, they decided to employ underwater photographic equipment. They also used a method known as an airlift to bring the amphorae to the surface. In this method, unbroken amphorae were filled with air, causing them to rise to the top of the water. To clear off debris from the wreck, the team used a vacuum pump attached to the ship.
Photojournalist Peter Throckmorton and archaeologist George Bass employed underwater photography and precise methods of surveyance to excavate the Gelidonya wreck off the coast of Turkey. In about 1200 BC, a trade vessel loaded with more than a ton of metal hit rocks and sank to the bottom of the sea on its journey to Phoenicia (modern-day Syria, Lebanon, and Israel). Explorers worked at a depth of 90 ft (27 m). They pinpointed the location of each object before bringing it to the surface. Heavy objects were raised with a winch and borne to the surface by air bags.
Between 1961 and 1964, Bass led the first excavation to be conducted completely underwater. Divers explored a wreck located off the coast of Turkey. Not far from the island of Yassi Ada, a seventh-century Byzantine amphora carrier lay buried in the sand, its wooden structure partially devoured by teredos. Rescuers excavated the ship by using bicycle spokes to keep the fragile wood from breaking off and drifting away until their work could be completed. To give them a better picture of the site, they built a metal scaffold overhead, complete with photographic towers that were 16-ft (5-m) high. The undamaged part of the ship was salvaged and completely reassembled on land.
All of the wrecks discussed above were excavated in the Mediterranean Sea. Many wrecks have been excavated in other parts of the world—for example, China. In 1973, a shipwreck was discovered off the coast of Quanzhou in east China. Its cargo contained pottery and fragrant wood. Dated to 1277, the ship is one of the earliest examples of Chinese nautical design. Examination of the wreck brought to light a new fact about Chinese ship construction. Chinese ships were not flat-bottomed, as formerly believed, but rather V-shaped, with a keel that tapered inward.
Whole-ship retrieval
Early excavations succeeded in raising only the contents of shipwrecks or portions of the ships. Recent excavations have focused on raising the entire ship, with its contents intact.
One such project was carried out under the leadership of Anders Franze´n, with the support of the Swedish government. In the seventeenth century, Swedish king Gustavus II Adolph (ruled from 1611 to 1632) decided to improve Sweden’s military capability by building a powerful naval fleet. The pride of this fleet was the Vasa, an enormous 1,400-ton vessel that was set to depart on its first voyage from Stockholm Harbor. No sooner had it set out from port than it sank, within full view of the king.
Franze´n believed that the ship lay at the bottom of the coldwater harbor in an excellent state of preservation. He made several attempts to locate the vessel— one with sonar—all of which failed. Then he made a lucky discovery. He came across a letter from the Swedish Parliament to the king that described the ship’s exact location.
Various plans to raise the vessel were discussed. Rescuers decided that the safest plan would be to run cables through tunnels dug by divers beneath the ship. The divers would then swim through the tunnels with the cables and attach them to pontoons on either side of the ship. The pontoons would be filled with water until their decks were even with the water’s surface. When the water was pumped out of the pontoons, the Vasa would begin to rise from the bottom of the harbor.
This plan was tried and it worked. The process was repeated several times, and the Vasa was pumped out of the water. A floating hall was built around it. Enshrined in the hall, and still containing its centuries-old cargo, the Vasa was floated to a museum site, where it remains on view today. Among the items found inside the ship were casks containing the sailors’ original food and ale, implements for daily use, and twelve skeletons, many of them with their clothing still on, undisturbed down to the coins in their pockets.
In the 1980s, another remarkable vessel was raised from the sea. This time researchers worked to rescue a sixteenth-century naval vessel, the Mary Rose. In a tragedy strikingly similar to that which befell the Vasa, King Henry VIII watched from Southsea Castle as the pride of his fleet sank with its crew of 700 men on its way to battle in France. Historian and archaeologist Alexander McKee believed that the Mary Rose was preserved in a deep bed of silt. He decided to raise the ship by attaching cables to a floating crane that lifted the ship out of the water. The ship was, then, continuously sprayed with water to keep it from drying out until it could be safely moved to shore. Medical equipment, pocket sundials, fishing gear, and leftover food from the ship broadened knowledge of daily life in the sixteenth century.
Other uses of nautical archaeology
Techniques used in nautical archaeology have been applied to other kinds of underwater archaeology. Submerged ports and lost cities are also subjects of research. Excavated by a team from the United States in 1960, the enormous Port of Caesarea was built by King Herod of Judaea in the first century BC to improve commerce with foreign merchants. Destroyed by an earthquake, the port still remains visible underwater. To construct the port, enormous stone blocks were lowered into the water to form a foundation for the 5-mi (8 km) long pier built on top, which included a large curved wall with towers and arched shelters for the merchants.
Destroyed by an earthquake in 1692, Port Royal was a flourishing center of commerce in the Caribbean. After the earthquake, the port sank to a distance of 65 ft (20 m) below sea level. A field school established to study the site has employed seventeenth-century maps to explore the submerged city and port.
The Maya are a Central American people who built an extensive civilization that flourished until the arrival of the Spaniards in the sixteenth century. The natural wells found in the limestone Yucatan Peninsula provided the Maya with a source of drinking water, but some wells were also the site of human sacrifice. In the early twentieth century, attracted by the prospect of finding treasure in the sacred wells, American archaeologist Edward Herbert Thompson (1860–1935) purchased one of them for $70. To excavate the well, he employed the highly unsystematic method of lifting objects out with a bucket. When this method proved unsatisfactory, Thompson dove down into the murky well with two Greek sponge divers, but the extremely low level of visibility thwarted any hope of finding the treasure. Thompson’s mission did, however, bring to light a number of important archaeological finds— headdresses, wooden spears, and fabric-that would have otherwise perished had they been left to deteriorate on land.
More than one-half century later, the National Institute of Anthropology and History made its own
Key Terms
Amphora (plural: amphorae)— A tall, graceful, two-handled jar with a narrow neck used to store wine, grain, etc., in classical times.
Artifact— An artificially made object that has been shaped and fashioned for human use.
Teredo— A kind of mollusk with a wormlike body, which burrows through wood and other materials on ships.
attempt to excavate the sacrificial well. This time, the water was chemically treated and filtered so that rescuers could see to a depth of 15.5 ft (5 m). The two-and-a-half-month excavation project produced other exciting finds. These finds included carved wooden stools, stone jaguars and serpents, and human remains.
Recent techniques of nautical excavation
To search for objects underwater, nautical archaeologists now employ robots and improved sonar technology. These methods were employed to excavate the Titanic, a supposedly indestructible ocean vessel than sank in 1912. To search for the Titanic, an American-French team employed three robots: Alvin, Angus, and Argo. Alvin was a midget submarine that could descend to the 13-ft (4 m) depth where the ship lay buried. The photographic craft Angus and the television camera craft Argo assisted in pinpointing the location of the Titanic.
During the Titanic mission, the French researchers used a new kind of sonar known as side-scanning sonar. Ordinary sonar surveys a narrow field that must be carefully mapped out in advance. Side-scanning sonar eliminates this drawback, by picking up signals at a diagonal.
Resources
BOOKS
Ashmore, Wendy, and Robert J. Sharer. Discovering Our Past: A Brief Introduction to Archaeology. 3rd ed. Mountain View, CA: Mayfield Publishing, 2000.
Bass, George F., ed. Beneath the Seven Seas: Adventures with the Institute of Nautical Archaeology. London, UK: Thames & Hudson, 2005.
Finamore, Daniel, ed. Maritime History as World History. Salem, MA: Peabody Essex Museum; and Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, 2004.
Marx, Robert F. Treasure Lost at Sea: Diving to the World’s Great Shipwrecks. Buffalo, NY: Firefly Books, 2004.
McGrail, Sean. Boats of the World: From the Stone Age to Medieval Times. Oxford, UK, and New York: Oxford University Press, 2002.
Throckmorton, Peter, ed. The Sea Remembers: Shipwrecks and Archaeology from Homer’s Greece to the Rediscovery of the Titanic. New York: Smithmark, 1991.
PERIODICALS
Gibbins, D. “Shipwrecks and Maritime Archaeology.” Archaeology Prospection 9, no. 2 (2002): 279-291.
Christine Molinari
