Powell, Baden
POWELL, BADEN
(b.. Stamford Hill, England, 22 August 1796; d. London, England, 11 June 1860)
physics.
Powell was the eldest son of Baden Powell of Langton, Kent. After private education he entered Oriel College, Oxford, in 1814 and graduated in 1817 with a first-class degree in mathematics. After ordination in 1820 he was curate at Midhurst, Sussex, and, from 1821 to 1827, vicar of Plumstead, Kent. The quality of his early researches in optics and radiant heat, which he performed at Plumstead, was recognized by his election as a fellow of the Royal Society in 1824 and by his appointment as Savilian professor of geometry at Oxford in 1827. He remained a prominent and respected figure at Oxford until 1854, when, despite the fact that he was to retain his chair until his death, he took up residence in London. He was married three times—in 1821, 1837, and 1846—and had fourteen children. One of his sons by his last marriage was Robert Baden-Powell, later Lord Baden-Powell of Gilwell, the founder of the scouting movement.
Most of Powell’s scientific research dates from the 1820’s and 1830’s. His best-known experiments were those on the heating effect produced beyond the red end of the solar spectrum (described in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society in 1825 and 1826). Powell used his experiments on the transmission of radiant heat and light through glass screens as the basis for some unusual speculations on the nature of radiation. According to Powell, all sources, whether luminous or not, emitted radiant heat of a kind that could be intercepted by a glass screen; but once a body became luminous, it began to exercise an additional and quite separate “heating power,” characterized by the ability to pass through glass.
Although in this way he associated at least a part of the heating effect with luminosity, Powell left his conjecture unexplained and certainly did not commit himself to John Leslie’s view that radiant heat and light had a common cause. Powell’s theory won little support and, as evidence of the identity of radiant heat and light accumulated in the 1830’s and 1840’s, it was ignored. Indeed, once J. D. Forbes had demonstrated the polarization of radiant heat in 1835 (an observation that Powell had failed to make in his experiments on polarization some five years earlier), Powell’s own conviction weakened and he became increasingly sympathetic to the view that radiant heat, like light, consisted of vibrations in an all-pervading ether.
Of Powell’s other experimental work, the most notable was the investigation of the dispersion of light (described in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society between 1835 and 1838), which he used to support the wave theory as treated by Cauchy.
Powell’s scientific reputation was not founded solely on his skill in original research. After 1830 he became even better known as a commentator on the work of others—for example, in the reports on the state of the study of radiant heat that he read to the British Association for the Advancement of Science in 1832, 1840, and 1854. As a public speaker he was noted for his lucidity and sedateness, and he was much in demand both as a lecturer on science and as a preacher. Powell wrote a number of elementary textbooks of mathematics, a popular History of Natural Philosophy (1834) for the Cabinet Cyclopaedia, and an exposition of the wave theory of light in 1841.
Throughout his life, but especially after 1850, Powell was involved in religious controversy. Opposed equally to the strict Sabbatarianism of the Evangelicals and to the Tractarians, he adopted a position on matters of doctrine similar to that later associated with the Broad Church movement. Like the Broad Churchmen, he maintained that the searching reexamination of traditional beliefs in the light of scientific knowledge did not endanger faith. Repeatedly he affirmed the irrelevance to Christian belief of the Old Testament (which he saw as little more than a Jewish parable) and argued, with Thomas Chalmers and against William Whewell, for the possibility of life on other planets. An admirer of Charles Lyell, Powell enthusiastically accepted the principle of the uniformity of nature and strongly criticized forms of natural theology that incorporated geological catastrophes and supposed suspensions of the normal laws of nature as evidence of divine intervention. Miracles, being deviations from uniformity, were inconceivable to Powell and merely reflected either the unreliability of the witness or man’s ignorance of the true laws of nature.
Although Powell presented his views on miracles most fully in his contribution to Essays and Reviews (1860), in which he elaborately distinguished the “external accessories” of Christianity (like miracles) from the “essential doctrines,” he had been no less committed to the principle of uniformity in the 1830’s, when such a position was unorthodox among theologians. It was entirely characteristic of Powell’s independence in Anglican circles (as also of his zeal for the principle of uniformity) that he was one of the first major theologians to treat Robert Chambers’ Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation (1844) sympathetically, as he did in his Essays on the Spirit of the Inductive Philosophy (1855). Like Chambers, he maintained that belief in the uniformity of nature could be the basis for a new natural theology that would yield a far grander conception of the Creator than the old.
Powell was also active in educational reform, and throughout his tenure of the Savilian chair he was a forthright spokesman for science at Oxford. As a member of the Royal Commission of Enquiry into Oxford University between 1850 and 1852, he urged the extension of science teaching at the university, against strong opposition; and he must take much credit for the modest reforms of the I850’s.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
I. Original Works. Powell’s most important researches are described in the following papers: “An Experimental Inquiry Into the Nature of Radiant Heating Effects From Terrestrial Sources’ in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society, 116 (1825), 187; 202; “An Account of Some Experiments Relating to the Passage of Radiant Heat Through Glass Screens,“ibid., 117 (1826), 372-382; “Researches Towards Establishing a Theory of the Dispersion of Light,” ibid., 126 (1835), 249-254; 127 (1836), 17-20; 128 (1837), 19-24; 129 (1838), 253-264, with supplement, 130 (1840), 157-160. He was also a frequent contributor to the Philosophical Magazine. His scientific and mathematical books, which were generally pitched at an elementary level, include: The Elements of Curves (Oxford, 1828); A Short Treatise on the Principles of the Differential and Integral Calculus, 2 vols. (Oxford, 1829-1830);An Elementary Treatise on the Geometry of Curves and Curved Surfaces (Oxford, 1830); A General and Elementary View of the Undulatory Theory, As Applied to the Dispersion of Light and Some Other Subjects (London, 1841). History of Natural Philosophy From the Earliest Periods to the Present Time (London, 1830) is popularization of a rather different kind. The most interesting of his publications on educational matters is The Present State and Future Prospects of Mathematical and Physical Studies in the University of Oxford(Oxford, 1832). Many of his theological views are expounded in The Connexion of Natural and Divine Truth (London, 1838), but the fullest treatments are his contribution to Essays and Reviews (London, 1860) and three sets of essays: Essays on the Spirit of the inductive Philosophy (London, 1855); Christianity Without Judaism (London, 1857); and The Order of Nature Considered in Reference to the Claims of Revelation (London, 1859).
II. Secondary Literature. The standard obituary of Powell is in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 21 (1861), 103-105, repr. in Proceedings of the Royal Society, 11 (1860-1862), xxvi-xxix. A detailed if uncritical account of Powell’s life and work appears in W. Tuckwell, Pre-Tractarian Oxford (London, 1909), 165-225; a thorough study has yet to be written. The critical unsigned article “Recent Latitudinarian Theology,” in Christian Remembrancer, 38 (I860), 388-427, is useful for an understanding of Powell as a theologian.
Robert Fox
