Maupertuis, Pierre Louis Moreau De

views updated

MAUPERTUIS, PIERRE LOUIS MOREAU DE

(b. St. Malo, France, 28 September 1698; d. Basel, Switzerland, 27 July, 1759),

mathematics, mechanics, natural philosophy, life sciences. For the original article on Maupertuis see DSB, vol. 9.

Maupertuis was an original and eclectic thinker whose contributions to the science of the eighteenth century ranged widely across fields and genres. He was at the center of scientific activity from the 1730s through most of the 1750s, first in Paris and then in Berlin. His career was fraught with controversies and contradictions, bitterness and triumph. Expending considerable effort in forging a public reputation, initially as a mathematician, then more broadly as a man of letters and a philosopher, he ventured into the speculative areas of life science and metaphysics as well as mathematics and mechanics. He was a favorite of princes and duchesses, and a friend of some of the best mathematicians and philosophers of his day. His major scientific work falls into the following categories: geodesy (the shape of Earth), rational mechanics (principle of least action), and life science (reproduction and heredity). In addition, he wrote on mathematics, cosmology, metaphysics and the philosophy of language. When the original DSB article was written, very little research on Maupertuis had made use of unpublished sources (especially letters), or sources held in archives outside of Paris, and as a result, Maupertuis’s published works had not been linked to their historical and cultural context. This update offers a revised perspective on the scientific work of this Enlightenment figure. For a full account of Maupertuis’s career, institutional position, scientific correspondence, and works, see Terrall (2002), which has full references to unpublished archival material.

Maupertuis has been remembered, in the history of science and in physics and biology textbooks (Glass, 1959; Guéroult, 1934; and Brunet, 1938) for certain of his ideas that gained significance through some relation, genealogical or not, to more modern concepts such as evolution or the dynamical principle of least action. Though his reputation as a brilliant innovator was largely eclipsed by the end of the eighteenth century, in part because of Voltaire’s witty attacks, in his day Maupertuis was a major player in the European scientific and literary worlds. The social location of science and philosophy in these worlds, where hierarchical power relations coexisted with the cosmopolitan and egalitarian ideals of the republic of letters, informed the articulation of Maupertuis’s ideas, the self-conscious presentation of these ideas to his contemporaries, and the reactions they provoked.

Defense of Newtonian Theory . Although Newton’s mathematics was well known in France around the turn of the eighteenth century, Maupertuis was one of the first French mathematicians to defend the Newtonian theory of gravitation. He traveled to London in 1728, where he made social contact with Newtonian mathematicians and physicists, and other members of the Royal Society. This trip, however, was not in any substantive way the source of his Newtonianism. His own work on attraction, especially the mathematical application of gravitation theory to the vexed problem of the shape of the Earth, dates from somewhat later, after his mathematical studies with Johann Bernoulli in Basel. Bernoulli was anything but a Newtonian. He objected strenuously to empty space and action-at-a-distance, and he considered Continental mathematics, in the Leibnizian tradition, far superior to that of the English. His importance for Maupertuis’s mathematical career, documented in their extensive correspondence, cannot be overestimated.

Little did Bernoulli suspect, while he painstakingly reviewed Maupertuis’s mathematical problem solutions, that his protégé would subsequently become famous as a pioneering French Newtonian. In fact, Maupertuis

solidified his position in the Paris Academy of Sciences in the early 1730s with a series of papers applying Leibnizian analysis to problems from Newton’s Principia. He made a conscious choice to work on controversial material, but he did not initially present it as a defense of Newton. His work in geodesy came directly out of this Leibnizian-Newtonian mathematics, because the shape of Earth was a problem Newton had discussed in some detail. Having established his credibility in the academy on the basis of mathematics, Maupertuis published a comparison of Cartesian and Newtonian cosmologies for a non-specialist audience. This book, Discours sur les figures des astres (1732), brought the theory of universal attraction to the attention of a literary audience in France well before Voltaire wrote his Letters on the English (1738). Indeed, Voltaire admired Maupertuis’s book and turned to the mathematician for clarification of Newtonian physics.

Geodetic Expedition . In 1736 Maupertuis led a high-profile expedition mounted by the academy to make astronomical and geodetical measurements in the Arctic. This expedition, the product of a dispute about measuring and calculating techniques with implications for the Newtonian theory of gravitation, gave Maupertuis the opportunity to expand his reputation outward from the specialist environment of the academy and the mathematics community to the genteel literary public. On his return from Lapland, he was hailed as a hero by the social elite, who appreciated the exotic combination of Arctic travel and mathematical acumen. He was also lionized by Voltaire and his allies, because the Lapland results supported Newton’s mathematical deduction that Earth must be slightly flattened at the poles. The Paris Observatory astronomers, headed by Jacques Cassini, were less enthusiastic about the new measurements, which called into question their own measurements of the Paris meridian. Cassini objected to Maupertuis’s astronomical practices and to his use of mathematics; although the Paris meridian measurements seemed to imply an elongated Earth, this was strictly an empirical matter and had nothing to do with Cartesian mechanics. (There was no Cartesian explanation for an elongated Earth.) Although the conflict was complicated by Cassini’s hostility toward universal gravitation, this was not essentially a dispute about cosmology. Nevertheless, because of the unmistakable Newtonian overtones of the flattened Earth, the Lapland expedition brought related cosmological and philosophical issues into the public eye.

Berlin Academy and Principle of Least Action . By 1740, Maupertuis’s expedition account had made him famous throughout Europe. Frederick II, the new king of Prussia, attempted to woo him to Berlin to revitalize the Prussian Academy of Sciences. Disillusioned about the prospects for a viable academy in Berlin after an initial visit in 1740 to 1741, when Frederick was at war in Silesia, Maupertuis ultimately succumbed to the Prussian monarch’s flattering attentions. He moved to Berlin in 1745 as president of the Academy of Sciences and as a key player in the lively intellectual life of the court at Potsdam, where several French philosophers and writers had taken refuge from censorship at home. Maupertuis governed the Berlin Academy autocratically, modeling his administrative style on that of the Prussian king. He was genuinely interested in enhancing the reputation of Berlin as a home for serious scientific and philosophical endeavors, and he worked hard to attract foreign scholars to Berlin—a project that met with only mixed success.

Shortly before moving to Berlin, Maupertuis introduced the principle of least action to the Paris Academy, in a paper about the refraction and reflection of light. He framed it as a mathematical version of the metaphysical economy principle that nature acts as simply as possible: “Whenever there is any change in nature, the quantity of action necessary for this change is the smallest possible” (1756, Vol. 4, p. 36). In Berlin, unlike Paris, the academy devoted official attention to speculative philosophy, or metaphysics (one of the academy’s classes was devoted to this subject, explicitly excluded from the Paris Academy). Maupertuis’s first paper in Berlin derived the principle of least action for mechanics (including static equilibrium) from a metaphysical economy principle. Because it was both a unifying principle and a mathematical expression of final causes, he not only brought together different problem areas in physics (optics, mechanics, and statics), but also made his principle the cornerstone of a proof for the existence of God. Maupertuis used the Berlin Academy to promote his rational mechanics, based on this extremum principle. He found an exceptionally able and willing ally in Leonhard Euler, who applied the variational calculus to problems outlined by Maupertuis in less rigorous form. Maupertuis revisited his metaphysical-mechanical principle in several publications, most extensively in Essai de cosmologie (1750), where he made mathematical physics the cornerstone of a rationalist theology that found evidence for God in the most universal principles and offered an alternative to natural theology based on admiration of the details of divine design.

Theory of Generation . Maupertuis was also well known for his theory of generation. In Vénus physique (1745, an expanded version of a short anonymous work published the previous year), he gathered evidence from microscopy, anatomy, animal breeding, and everyday experience to argue for an epigenetic theory of fetal development. In this model, male and female seminal fluids, made up of heterogeneous corpuscles derived from the different parts of the parents’ bodies, combine to form germs, the particles are driven by their own teleological instincts or affinities for each other. These active properties allow for many possible outcomes within certain parameters, and they locate the capability to produce order in organic matter itself. Maupertuis used chemical affinities, forces of a different order than mechanical forces of impact, to describe organic forces. Strong affinities between those elements “appropriate for forming traits similar to those of the individual parent” account for resemblances between parents and offspring (1980, p. 139).

Maupertuis refined his notion of the forces responsible for organization in Système de la nature (1751). The focus here shifted from arguments about preexistence and epigenesis to a fuller justification of a dynamic conception of matter. Chemistry retained its analogical role as the counterpoint to mechanical reductionism, but in spite of their selectivity and flexibility, affinities could not fully explain organic form and function. “We must have recourse to some principle of intelligence, to something similar to what we call desire, aversion, memory” (Maupertuis, 1756, Vol. 2, p. 147). Desire and aversion operate as forces analogous to the affinities that propel, unite, and separate chemical substances; memory links each organic element to its corresponding part in the parent organism. Every element “retains a kind of memory (souvenir) of its previous situation and will resume it whenever it can, in order to form the same part in the fetus” (Vol. 2, p. 158).

Though his position in Berlin did give him a high profile, Maupertuis was frustrated in his efforts to transform the Prussian academy to his own specifications. He became increasingly combative and embittered about the situation in Berlin. In the 1750s his health deteriorated as he suffered recurrent bouts of debilitating fever and lung disease. He engaged in a bitter and rather pointless controversy with a former friend, Samuel König, about the authorship of the principle of least action. (For a full account of the institutional and intellectual ramifications of this dispute, see Terrall, 2002, Chap. 9.) Voltaire also turned against him in this period, due not so much to philosophical differences as to personal resentment and competition for favor with the Prussian king. It was often said, in the 1750s and subsequently, that Maupertuis’s poor health was due to his contretemps with Voltaire. This was certainly not the case. He continued in this period to produce new work, especially on generation and inheritance, and to re-edit older texts for new editions. His final contribution to the Berlin Academy journal in 1756 reprised his metaphysical mechanics in the context of a discussion of epistemology and the necessity of the laws of motion. He left Berlin for France for the final time in 1756, on the eve of the Seven Years’ War, and spent the last three years of his life (1756–1759) caught between allegiance to France, his native land, and to Frederick, his most illustrious patron. He died at the home of Johann Bernoulli in Basel on his way back to Berlin in 1759.

SUPPLEMENTARY BIBLIOGRAPHY

WORKS BY MAUPERTUIS

Vénus physique: suivi de La lettre sur le progres des sciences. Edited by Patrick Tort. Paris: Aubier-Montagne, 1980.

Oeuvres de Mr. de Maupertuis. 4 Vols. Lyon, France : J.M. Bruyset, 1756.

OTHER SOURCES

Beeson, David. Maupertuis: An Intellectual Biography. Oxford: Voltaire Foundation, 1992.

Brunet, Pierre. Étude historique sur la principe de la moindre action. Paris: Hermann, 1938.

Glass, Bentley, William Straus, and Owsei Temkin, eds. Forerunners of Darwin, 1745–1859. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1959.

Greenberg, John. The Problem of the Earth’s Shape from Newton to Clairaut. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1995.

Guéroult, Michel. Dynamique et métaphysique leibniziennes. Paris: Les belles lettres, 1934.

Hoffheimer, Michael. “Maupertuis and the Eighteenth-Century Critique of Preexistence.” Journal of the History of Biology 15 (1982): 119–144.

Terrall, Mary. The Man Who Flattened the Earth: Maupertuis and the Sciences in the Enlightenment. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2002.

Mary Terrall

More From encyclopedia.com