Woman Suffrage
WOMAN SUFFRAGE
When American women voted in the election of 1920, they did so for the first time as a constitutional right protected by the nineteenth amendment. The amendment's ratification marked the end of a long struggle that was bound up with both the shifting status of the ballot and the political development of a women's movement.
The struggle, which began formally at the women's rights convention at seneca falls, New York, in 1848, emerged when most states had already dropped their property qualifications for white male voters. "Resolved," averred elizabeth cady stanton, "that it is the duty of the women of this country to secure to themselves the sacred right to elective franchise." Yet in the context of the mid-nineteenth century the right to elective franchise still was not a national, constitutional issue. Moreover, voting embodied so powerful a symbol of personal autonomy that granting it to women was profoundly controversial. In fact, woman suffrage, as contemporaries called it, barely won the support of the delegates at Seneca Falls.
reconstruction transformed woman suffrage into a compelling constitutional issue. The second clause of the fourteenth amendment introduced the word "male" into the Constitution, and the fifteenth amendment, which prohibited abridging the voting rights of black males, was silent on the disfranchisement of females. Inasmuch as the two amendments seemed at once essential to the rights of freedmen and inimical to the cause of woman suffrage, the women's movement divided over their ratification.
The spacious terms of the first clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, however, sparked numerous challenges to women's disfranchisement. susan b. anthony created a dramatic test in the election of 1872 by registering and voting with fifteen other New York women, thereby violating a federal election statute, but her case did not reach the Supreme Court. The case that did was launched by Virginia Minor, who with her attorney-husband, Francis, sued the state of Missouri for restricting suffrage to males. The plaintiff's brief in minor v. happersett (1875) argued that women had been empowered to vote in federal elections from the inception of the Constitution, had actually voted for a time in New Jersey, and were simply reaffirmed in their right to vote by the terms of the Fourteenth Amendment. The disfranchisement of women, the brief asserted, was a bill of attainder, an infringement on freedom of speech, a form of involuntary servitude, and a violation not only of due process but of the constitutional guarantee that every state shall have a republican form of government. In a unanimous decision drafted by Chief Justice morrison r. waite, the Court ruled that suffrage was neither protected in the original text of the Constitution nor incorporated in the privileges and immunities of citizenship guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment.
By the 1890s, the drive for suffrage had stalled, despite the unification of the two wings of the women's movement. State-by-state campaigns yielded disappointing results, and after Minor a constitutional amendment was needed to ensure suffrage nationwide. Headway came with the bold campaigns of the Congressional Union (later called the Woman's party), an organization founded in 1913 by Alice Paul and Lucy Burns to replicate the militant tactics of English feminists. Picketing, arrests, and hunger strikes generated attention at a time when resistance to women voting was ebbing. Giving women the vote was regarded increasingly as a way of bringing their domestic concerns into the political arena and therefore as a potential instrument of Progressive reform. The final strategy for victory came from the lobbying efforts of Carrie Chapman Catt, president of the National American Woman Suffrage Association, who not only pulled a recalcitrant woodrow wilson into the suffrage camp but also capitalized on the temporary gratitude of the nation for the wartime service of its women.
Norma Basch
(1992)
(see also: Feminist Theory and Constitutional Law; Gender Rights; Progressive Constitutional Thought; Progressivism; Woman Suffrage Movement; Women in Constitutional History.)
Bibliography
Du Bois, Ellen Carol 1987 Outgrowing the Compact of the Fathers: Equal Rights, Woman Suffrage, and the United States Constitution, 1820–1878. Journal of American History 74:836–862.
Flexnor, Eleanor (1959) 1968 Century of Struggle: The Woman's Rights Movement in the United States. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
