New Balance Athletic Shoe, Inc.
New Balance Athletic Shoe, Inc.
Brighton Landing
20 Guest Street
Boston, Massachusetts 02135-2040
USA
Telephone: (800) 343-1395
Fax: (617) 787-9355
Web site: www.newbalance.com
NEW BALANCE THUNDERSTORM, STAIRS CAMPAIGN
OVERVIEW
Founded in 1906, the Boston-based company New Balance Athletic Shoe, Inc., had become the third-largest manufacturer of athletic shoes in the United States by 2003. Long catering to the serious athlete, New Balance prided itself on creating a quality product in a wide range of specialty sizes—a rarity in the athletic-footwear world. In 2002 New Balance launched two television commercials: "Thunderstorm" and "Stairs." Running under the larger, long-running "Achieve New Balance" umbrella campaign, both spots focused on products for female ath-letes—the former on women's running shoes and the latter on women's cross-training shoes. Both commercials were developed by New Balance's longtime ad agency, Messner, Vetere, Berger, McNamee, Schmetterer (MVBMS).
The commercials, a central feature of the company's $19 million marketing effort for 2002, premiered in March on several cable networks and continued throughout the year. They were aimed at 21- to 55-year-olds, a slightly broader demographic than New Balance's traditional target of 35- to 50-year-olds. The campaign also included magazine ads in such publications as Shape, Cooking Light, Condé Nast Traveler, Runner's World, and Fitness. A companion set of spots for men's running and cross-training shoes debuted at about the same time. John Donovan, New Balance's marketing services manager, explained to Chris Reidy of the Boston Globe that the commercials were about "how important exercise is for citizen athletes trying to balance the stresses of life."
Both spots were widely acclaimed by the advertising industry; "Stairs" was applauded for its dead-on depiction of what made a female athlete tick, and "Thunderstorm" won praise for its witty special effects. "Thunderstorm" was named one of the best commercials of 2002 by Adweek magazine.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT
For fiscal year 2003 New Balance's sales topped $910 million; they were down from $1.16 billion in 2001 but were enough to maintain the company's third-place rank, between Reebok and adidas. In a market dominated by Nike, New Balance had deliberately steered clear of high-profile advertising campaigns that targeted the urban-youth market by featuring superstar athletes and musicians. Additionally, New Balance's strongest category had always been running shoes, which made running a natural choice for its new television campaign.
New Balance had never advertised heavily on television. For years the company had preferred a more grassroots approach that allowed it to zero in on its best customers. To this end, most of its advertising budget went toward sports magazines and sponsorship of semiprofessional sporting events. Since 1989 New Balance had been a major sponsor of the Susan G. Komen Race for the Cure, a national event dedicated to raising funds to fight breast cancer, and since 1995 the company had been a major sponsor of the International Modern Pentathlon, an Olympic sport consisting of a single day of competition in five events: shooting, fencing, swimming, equestrian jumping, and running. The company's choice to sponsor these events highlighted its dedication to serving both female athletes and sports events that rewarded personal excellence.
TARGET MARKET
In a market dominated by youth, New Balance was a rarity: a footwear manufacturer that catered to middle-aged runners. "They have been after me for years to make more shoes for 14- to 15-year-olds. I don't want to do it," CEO Jim Davis told Daren Fonda of Time magazine. Unusual also was the fact that the company manufactured much of its product in the United States, years after most companies had outsourced that work to Asia. These factors worked to the company's advantage. Older consumers were very brand-loyal, and New Balance's U.S. facilities allowed the company to "respond more quickly to fashion cycles and requests from retail customers than overseas sneaker factories with long lead times," wrote Reidy in the Boston Globe.
Despite its satisfaction with its market niche, New Balance had always sought growth. By 2002 the company had enjoyed double-digit growth for several years, in part because of its acquisitions of Dunham boots, a "brown shoe" competitor to Timberland, and P.F. Flyers, a vintage brand with nostalgic appeal to baby boomers. In addition, New Balance "trail shoes" enjoyed a brief vogue among 20-somethings in the late 1990s, which further propelled sales figures. By 2001 the company's sales had topped $1 billion. But Davis, a runner himself who bought the company on the day of the Boston Marathon in 1972, had no intention to shift his main focus away from top-end athletic shoes. "We're going to continue to do what we know how to do, and we'll be gaining little bits of market share on an annual basis," he told Mark Sullivan of Sporting Goods Business.
In 2001 New Balance's $20 million advertising budget concentrated on television spots targeted at runners over the age of 45—a narrow demographic, but one easily reached through magazines such as Working Mother, Men's Journal, Prevention, and Outside. Though not as glitzy an approach as that of their competitors, targeting this niche made great business sense, according to New Balance marketing vice president Paul Heffernan. He told Hilary Cassidy of Brandweek, "We keep seeing studies that show the largest segment of the population is over 50, so we're spending some money there, and we don't think our competition is thinking about that group."
COMPETITION
New Balance also faced competition from industry leaders Nike and Reebok, mainstays adidas and Puma, and "boutique" brands such as Saucony and Brooks. In 2001 adidas announced plans to increase its marketing budget by 25 percent in a direct bid to leap over New Balance and take the number three spot behind Reebok. Adidas's ads highlighted a new technology called ClimaCool, which was used in its cross-training and basketball shoes to increase air circulation through the shoe.
In addition, adidas launched T-MAC, a new basketball shoe endorsed and named for Orlando Magic star Tracy McGrady. In response New Balance also introduced a new line of basketball shoes, endorsed by no one and aimed at the 15- to 21-year-old market. "Play to Live" was the tagline, and its grassroots "Hoop Troop" campaign included company appearances at local basketball courts to introduce the product directly to consumers. New Balance also sponsored the NBA's Hoop-It-Up tour, which featured 3-on-3 tournaments in 40 cities.
Whereas Nike dominated the field of high-tech shoe cushioning field with its tremendously popular Shox shoes, New Balance promoted its own Abzorb cushioning as the centerpiece of its superior technology. In 2004 adidas attempted to gain ground on New Balance with the $300 Adidas 1, which boasted a computer chip that automatically adjusted the shoe's cushioning level for maximized performance.
THE CHALLENGE OF FILMING IN ICELAND
New Balance's "Thunderstorm" spot was filmed in Iceland by director Agust Baldersson, though the storm that taunted the runner was computer-generated and on-site props consisted of rice and polystyrene. Real rain, in fact, preempted filming several times during the weeklong shoot. Fortunately, August in Iceland meant nearly 24 hours of daylight—plenty of time to get it right.
MARKETING STRATEGY
Unlike its primary competitors, Nike and Reebok, New Balance had long practiced an advertising strategy defined as "endorsed by no one," meaning it did not build marketing campaigns around top-name athletes. Likewise, "Thunderstorm" and "Stairs" were designed to appeal to goal-driven athletes who valued personal achievement over trendiness. "We don't want to be perceived as doing anything gimmicky," Stuart Babb, head of the company's running division, told Reidy of the Boston Globe.
New Balance's 2002 television spots deftly illustrated two modes of athletic perseverance with which its potential customers could identify. In "Thunderstorm" a runner made her way down a deserted highway as ominous storm clouds closed in on her. When the storm unleashed heavy rains, she took cover beneath a freeway overpass. As soon as she did, however, the rain stopped, taunting her with the suggestion that it was waiting for her to try to outrun it again. The voice-over asked, "What keeps you going?" and the tagline "Achieve New Balance" appeared. Shot in a similarly artistic black-and-white style, "Stairs" followed a woman as she ran up a stairway on a seaside cliff. At the top she rewarded herself with a treat—a single piece of chocolate. She continued again, down the stairs and up, to win another.
"'Conspicuous' is not in the New Balance dictionary; 'low profile' is," wrote Davis in an editorial for the Boston Globe. Indeed, not only were the athletes in these commercials "low profile" (they were exercising alone), but they also demonstrated discipline and fortitude, qualities that typified the ideal New Balance customer.
"New Balance sneakers are still basically known for their technical aspects, comfort, stability—and dowdi-ness," Fonda commented in Time. That did not seem to bother Davis. "If we hit on fashion, that's fine … but our shoes are really designed to run up hills." Indeed, New Balance's reputation for creating a quality product, particularly for people with hard-to-fit feet, had won it many influential customers, among them podiatrists, chiropractors, and serious runners. Nevertheless, market analyst Matt Powell told Natalie Zmuda of Footwear News, "I think the consumer still sees them as the noncorporate brand." That seemed to suit the company just fine. "Technical customers are consistent, even in difficult times, and that makes them more predictable," Nick Richino, global apparel operations manager for New Balance, explained to Rosemary Feitelberg of Women's Wear Daily.
OUTCOME
Writing in Fast Company, Randall Rothenberg named "Thunderstorm" the ad of the month for September 2002, calling it "gorgeous to look at" and praising its high production value, which he said brought to mind both The Wizard of Oz and the cult film Run, Lola, Run. Rothenberg also applauded the commercial's "subtle playfulness" as a refreshing antidote to the "humorlessness" of many athletic-shoe commercials aimed at women.
The "Achieve New Balance" campaign, of which the spots were a part, was revised in 2003 into the "N Is for Fit … N Is for Performance" campaign, which featured new print ads and television spots and emphasized the technical construction of New Balance shoes more than the previous years' advertising had. Also, subsequent campaigns focused on promoting New Balance's basketball shoes; despite Nike's dominance in that area, New Balance officials believed that it was a big enough market that the company could grab a slice of market share without a splashy star-driven campaign.
As Ann Davis, the company's executive vice president and the wife of CEO Jim Davis, told Katie Abel of Footwear News, the "spirit of perseverance has been one of the company's defining characteristics throughout the past 30 years." The commercials "Thunderstorm" and "Stairs" epitomized that spirit, which was verified by the attention the spots garnered from the advertising world. "New Balance chooses to celebrate everyday athletes who set their own performance goals," wrote Jim Davis in the Boston Globe. "We don't pay celebrities to sell our product. We believe our product sells itself."
FURTHER READING
Abel, Katie. "A Balancing Act: Jim and Anne Davis Have Always Had More on Their Minds, and Hearts, than Athletic Shoes." Footwear News, December 9, 2002, p. 44.
Cassidy, Hilary. "A Balanced Foothold." Brandweek, March 25, 2002, p. 19.
??????. "New Balance Ages Up." Brandweek, January 8,2001, p. 8.
Davis, Jim. "New Balance Maintains 'Low Profile.'" Boston Globe, February 10, 2002.
Dill, Mallorre. "Rain and Shine." Adweek, March 18, 2002.
Feitelberg, Rosemary. "Brands on the Move." Women's Wear Daily, April 5, 2001, p. 7.
Fonda, Daren. "Sole Survivor: Making Sneakers in America Is So Yesterday. How Can New Balance Do It—and Still Thrive?" Time, November 8, 2005, p. 48.
"On a Roll: Joyce Minkoff." Advertising Age, May 21, 2001, p. 29.
Reidy, Chris. "New Balance Dons High-Tech Addition to Keep Strong Position in Runners' Market." Boston Globe, October 23, 2001.
??????. "New Balance Plots Independent Strategy." Boston Globe, August 4, 2005.
??????. "No-Name Kid Dazzles in New Balance's Basketball-Sneaker Advertising Launch." Boston Globe, August 10, 2002.
??????. "TV Advertisements for New Balance Athletic Shoes Target Younger Audience." Boston Globe, March 1, 2002.
Rothenberg, Randall. "Ad of the Month: New Balance 'Thunderstorm.'" Fast Company, September 1, 2002.
Sullivan, Mark. "Marathon Man: Thirty Years after Buying New Balance, Jim Davis Is Still Running—All the Way Past the $1 Billion Mark." Sporting Goods Business, April, 2002, p. 36.
Zmuda, Natalie. "Rising Athletic Fortunes." Footwear News, May 17, 2004, p. 8.
Kathy Wilson Peacock
