Smoking

views updated

SMOKING

In the current social and political marginalization of the cigarette smoker, Americans may forget how tobacco and its use have shaped American leisure habits. Even in the precolonial period, in Native American culture, tobacco was central to the performance of shamanistic rituals, to religious and spiritual life, and to the social ceremonies of manhood initiation rites. It was linked to the fertility of both the land and of women and, as portrayed in countless Hollywood Westerns, it was at the heart of the calumet ritual, when a pipe was passed around a group to seal an agreement concerning political obligations or the exchange of goods. For European settlers, tobacco was a source of fascination, either because of its alleged properties in treating illnesses or for the individual pleasures it gave the newly initiated smoker. Within just a few decades, colonists had stopped trading directly for tobacco and had learned to cultivate it themselves. In 1612, John Rolfe (made famous through his marriage to Pocahontas) grew the first successful crop of tobacco in Jamestown, Virginia. By 1628, the colony was exporting 370,000 pounds of tobacco, and the seed was being planted all over the surrounding region.

Just as the new colonies were dependent on the export of tobacco, so, too, were its inhabitants on the act of smoking itself. Visitors to Virginia in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries frequently commented on the sight of whole communities smoking, with the majority following the lead of their northern European counterparts by using pipes. The great exception was the popularity of chewing tobacco, which required no special preparation. Users merely bit off the hard, tightly-pressed manufactured tobaccos of twist and plug, which were sold both for pipes and for grating into snuff. The great transformation in smoking practices would come with the arrival of the "Bright" leaf. Grown in the inland Piedmont region of Virginia and North Carolina, flue-cured Bright tobacco produced a lighter leaf with a less harsh and more pleasant taste, as well as a more aesthetically satisfying golden texture.

Initially, "gold leaf" tobaccos were used in pipe mixtures popular in the new urban centers of the nineteenth century. Paralleling the growth in popularity of the cigar, milder pipe tobaccos saw a resurgence in the literary-cum-philosophical "odes" to the weed led by such figures as Mark Twain. In a Victorian and largely bourgeois culture across the English-speaking world, countless pamphlets, books, poems, and periodical articles taught an expanding middle class about what the tobacco manufacturer Alfred Dunhill called "the gentle art of smoking." Various anecdotal "whiffs" and "pipefuls" were presented as amusing relief for busy city gentlemen who sought solace in their pipes, favorite armchairs, and metropolitan clubs. Smokers learned of the history, anthropology, ritual, literary heritage, production, manufacture, and pharmacology of tobacco, knowledge necessary if the mere smoker was to be transformed into a true connoisseur or "aficionado" of the "Lady Nicotine" or "Diva Nicotina." A man was said to be somehow lacking in character if he did not practice a particular smoking habit or possess his own "paraphernalia of smokiana," including pipes, cleaners, holders, spills, spittoons, ashtrays, pouches, storage jars, lights, smoking jackets, armchairs, hats, and slippers. Hierarchies of taste were established, which for cigars, stretched from Cuban brands at the very top, to cheap, U.S., mass-produced items associated with the urban "swell."

The Rise of Cigarettes

At the very bottom of this hierarchy in this semi-elite culture stood the new mass-produced cigarette, an item frowned upon by the connoisseur but which was to come to dominate the history of smoking. Handmade, expensive cigarettes had secured a small luxury market within the eastern cities from the 1850s, but cigarette manufacturing was to be revolutionized by the patenting of the Bonsack machine in 1880. The new invention could produce up to three hundred cigarettes a minute and was quickly put into use by the dynamo of the modern cigarette industry, James Buchanan "Buck" Duke, who set about transforming the tobacco industry in the 1880s. Through aggressive sales techniques Duke ruined, took over, and beat most of his rivals. In 1889, the greater portion of the cigarette industry merged to form the American Tobacco Company (ATC) with Duke firmly at its helm. The company was to hold a virtual monopoly on cigarette sales in the United States and enabled Duke to expand into Canada and Great Britain and become one of the pioneers of multinational capitalism when he formed the British American Tobacco with the Imperial Tobacco Company of Britain.

Opposition to the cigarette, though, came not only from a traditional, pipe- and cigar-smoking community, but also from the organized temperance movement. Early opposition came from Frances Willard's Women's Christian Temperance Union and later from such luminaries as Henry Ford and the health advocate and cereal producer Dr. John Harvey Kellogg. Most zealous of all was Lucy Page Gaston, the self-styled "extremist of extremists" (Tate, p. 62). In 1899 she created the Anti-Cigarette League of America, an organization that eschewed the education and reform of the sinful smoker and advocated instead outright prohibition. The Anti-Cigarette League's medico-moral rhetoric, which connected smoking with a whole range of degenerative vices and illnesses, proved popular among Anglo-Saxon Protestants, who associated cigarettes with immigrants and urban delinquent youth. By 1901, the league had 300,000 members and, by the outbreak of World War I, the movement had succeeded in outlawing cigarettes in thirteen states, with bills in six others pending (virtually every state had already banned the sale of cigarettes to minors).

Defeat for the movement began with the American entry into the war in 1917 as the government, the army, and newspapers all patriotically recognized the palliative effects of smoking for soldiers. Even former antitobacco groups such as the YMCA, the Red Cross, and the Salvation Army defected to the other side and distributed cigarettes to the troops on the front lines and in hospitals. The war also enabled other cigarette manufacturers to break into the market, helped by the Supreme Court decision to break up the ATC in 1911 under the provisions of the Sherman Antitrust Act (1890). For instance, R. J. Reynold's Camel brand, introduced in 1913, was able to achieve a sales figure of 20 billion cigarettes in 1920, following a government supply order and a successful marketing campaign. Cigarettes were a comfort to the troops in the trenches but also a far more practical method of smoking on the battlefield than the cumbersome pipe. In recognition of its morale-boosting qualities, a soldier's ballad urged men to smile in the face of death with "a Lucifer to light your fag," while, most famously, General Pershing stated, "You ask me what we need to win this war. I answer tobacco as much as bullets" (Klein, p. 135). The cigarette emerged triumphant from the war, a position that was easily sustained as it became the leading legal narcotic during the Prohibition era. In 1919, cigarettes surpassed pipe tobacco in the actual amount of leaf consumed, and, by 1922, they over-took chewing tobacco as well.

The interwar years witnessed the spread of the cigarette among both sexes and every social group, backed by a popular commercial culture that portrayed smoking as the norm rather than the exception. While those smoking "new women" of the pre–World War I period had to experience such reactions as a 1908 New York law prohibiting female smoking in public, the flappers and college women of the 1920s witnessed much less resistance. By 1929, women were estimated to consume 14 billion cigarettes, or 12 percent of total consumption. Advertisers were quick to take advantage of this new smoking trend, and Philip Morris introduced its Marlboro brand in 1925, to target the emerging female market. However, more often, advertisers recognized that women were far more likely to smoke the same brands as men; therefore, Chesterfield, in 1926, urged women "to blow some my way" and Lucky Strike, in 1928, suggested they "Reach for a Lucky instead of a Sweet." Certainly, advertising was of some influence—and manufacturers were prepared to pay around 20 percent and more of the total cost of the product on promotion—but women, men, and youths often just followed the lead offered by peers, parents, and popular culture.

Most spectacular of all was the portrayal of smoking in Hollywood. Films featuring such stars as Clara Bow, Louise Brooks, Tallulah Bankhead, Marlene Dietrich, and Mae West glamorized the cigarette while, later, Edward G Robinson, James Cagney, Spencer Tracy, Gary Cooper, and especially Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall raised the image of the cigarette to iconic status, ensuring it would never lose its sophisticated and loftily independent connotations. And for young couples watching Paul Henreid light two cigarettes at once for himself and Bette Davis in Now Voyager (1942), the association with courtship and seduction was clearly established.

Smoking Is Linked to Health Problems

When Ernst L. Wynder first published a link between smoking with lung cancer in 1950, it was clear that his findings would be a shock to both America's smokers and its powerful manufacturers. By this time, between 44 and 47 percent of the nation smoked, with the figure much higher for adult, urban males. Many smokers simply refused to accept the evidence, their arguments bolstered by the refutations offered by the tobacco companies and by advertisements that showed medical doctors endorsing the benefits and pleasures of the cigarette. The 1964 Report of the Surgeon General, however, made the link far more indisputable, and, from then on, an average of 2 million smokers gave up the habit every year. By 1978, the overall smoking rate had fallen to 33 percent. These figures, though, are hardly as great as one might expect, even taking into account the role of physical addiction. While many might have given up smoking, many others have also started, and while smokers have regularly—and unsuccessfully—taken cigarette companies to court since as early as 1954, it is clear that others have simply ignored the evidence against their habit.

Approximately 60 million smoking-related deaths have occurred across the developed world since 1950, and it is estimated that around 400,000 people die from smoking every year in the United States, not only from lung cancer, but also heart disease, bronchitis, emphysema, pneumonia, vascular disease, and cancers of the mouth, throat, bladder, kidneys, pancreas, and stomach. Moreover, of those who have quit, the overwhelming number have been professional, affluent men, making smoking today a health problem increasingly associated with women and poverty. And whereas the average U.S. smoker got through twenty-two cigarettes a day in 1954, this had increased to thirty by 1978 (although rates subsequently fell to around twenty in 2000), suggesting that the quitting rate was higher among those who smoked less and that more cigarettes were being smoked by those who still smoked, most of whom had increasingly moved to lighter or filtered brands.

Of perhaps equal importance, therefore, in changing smoking habits has not been the negative evidence against smoking but the positive images of life being promoted by an increasingly health-conscious society. In addition, the comparatively ready acceptance of the dangers of environmental (or "second-hand") tobacco smoke has resulted in a still ongoing series of legislative efforts against smoking in public. California has led the way, but its proscriptions against smokers are now being followed by other states. This has led many to suggest that the smoker is being portrayed as a hero of resistance to the health faddists, with his or her marginalization creating a counterculture figure demonized by an affluent, nonsmoking majority. But such romantic narratives are hardly the full story, since powerful images produced by a commercial popular culture ensure that smoking remains as "cool" as it was in the days of Bogart and Bacall. A survey of the most successful Hollywood films found that films in 1995 featured four times as much smoking as in 1990 and that three times as many smoking characters were portrayed as "rebellious." The deep-rooted nature of America's smoking culture, stretching back centuries, implies the current hostility to smoking may only be temporary. There remains a demand for tobacco and cigarettes that is unlikely to be overturned by either regulation or prohibition. In the increasing rates of smoking among today's youth, and in the poor quitting rates among the poor and the disenfranchised, smoking is already witnessing a minor revival.

See also: Prohibition and Temperance; Recreational Drug Use

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Brandt, Allen. "The Cigarette, Risk, and American Culture." Daedalus 119 (1990): 155–176.

Goodman, Jordan. Tobacco in History: Cultures of Dependence. London: Routledge, 1993.

Hilton, Matthew. Smoking in British Popular Culture, 1800–2000. Manchester, U.K.: Manchester University Press, 2000.

Klein, Richard. Cigarettes Are Sublime. London: Picador Books, 1995.

Kluger, Richard. Ashes to Ashes. New York: Vintage Books, 1997.

Sobel, Robert. They Satisfy: The Cigarette in American Life. New York: Anchor Press/Doubleday, 1978.

Tate, Cassandra. Cigarette Wars: The Triumph of "The Little White Slaver." New York: Oxford University Press, 1999.

Matthew Hilton

More From encyclopedia.com