Archaeology

views updated

Archaeology

Tobacco has an extensive prehistoric past. Archaeologists have investigated several aspects of the prehistory of tobacco. Much of this research focuses on North and South American contexts, where evidence of the earliest documented use of tobacco can be found.

Methods

Archaeology depends upon material evidence left behind by past societies. Material evidence for tobacco can be divided into two types: direct and indirect. Direct evidence refers to physical remains of the tobacco plant in association with evidence of prehistoric human activity. Indirect evidence refers to material remains that are commonly associated with tobacco use in the absence of direct material evidence of the plant. While direct evidence is preferable, as it presents a much stronger case for past tobacco use, it is much rarer in the archaeological record. Accordingly, many archaeological studies have focused on indirect evidence.

The most common type of direct evidence archaeologists use to study tobacco use is macrobotanical remains, especially seeds. Tobacco seeds are distinctive and can be identified to species. Tobacco seeds are also extremely small in size and therefore difficult to recover archaeologically. Palynological analyses (the identification of plant pollen), while able to identify the presence of ancient tobacco, often cannot make a direct connection between tobacco and human use of the plant, since plants disperse pollen over a wide area. Phytolith analysis (the identification of mineral inclusions in plant cells) may have potential to identify prehistoric tobacco use, but this has been disputed (Adair 2000; Piperno 1988), and a systematic analysis of tobacco phytoliths from archaeological contexts has not yet been published. A final type of direct evidence with a high degree of accuracy in detecting ancient tobacco use is residue analysis, where techniques derived from analytical chemistry are used to detect the residues of compounds known to be present in tobacco but not in other plants, such as nicotine.

Indirect evidence consists of the material culture of tobacco use, the most common of which is the smoking pipe. Pipes have a long history and are commonly made of durable materials. There is, however, a wide variety of plants that could have been smoked prehistorically, even within societies known to have also smoked tobacco. The use of smoking pipes as indirect evidence of tobacco use is greatly strengthened when it proceeds in conjunction with residue analysis or other direct evidence. While other artifacts, such as tobacco pouches or snuff boxes, may also contribute to archaeological knowledge of tobacco use, these artifacts are generally of organic material and do not preserve in archaeological contexts in most situations.

Two other types of indirect evidence have been used by archaeologists. Iconographic representations of smoking, or of smoking pipes, can also provide circumstantial evidence for tobacco use; this type of evidence has been used for Mayan sites. A final type of indirect evidence is early ethnohistorical accounts of smoking. This is placed in the category of indirect evidence since, for the earliest accounts of tobacco use especially, it is often unclear exactly what plant the society being observed was using, as some observers were confused by what was to them a strange practice.

North and South America

Current evidence indicates an origin for tobacco use in South America. The oldest radiocarbon dates for tobacco seeds from that region are from Peru and range from 2500 to 1800 b.c.e. (Pearsall 1992). There is a substantial gap in both time and space between the earliest South American evidence and the earliest North American evidence. Early evidence from Mexico is generally lacking, and the geographic route by which tobacco smoking diffused northward is unknown. Small amounts of tobacco from Arizona date to as early as the fourth century b.c.e. (Adams and Toll; Winter 2000). Early evidence from Plains sites date to as early as 450 c.e. (Adair; Benn 1981). The earliest direct evidence from eastern North America comes from sites in the Midwest, dating to approximately 200 c.e.. Recent residue analysis shows that tobacco may have a longer history in eastern North America, as a small sample of pipes dating between 500 and 300 b.c.e. have tested positive for nicotine (Rafferty 2002).

Beyond North and South America

Old World dates for tobacco use post-date the European Age of Exploration during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Evidence purported to indicate a pre-Columbian diffusion of tobacco into the Old World is unsubstantiated. This evidence is based on residue of nicotine from Old World mummies (probably a result of contamination) and has been posited to prove that tobacco was brought to the Old World through early transatlantic trade, no other evidence of which has been substantiated. Tobacco was one of many New World plants that spread during the European expansion, and smoking pipes are material correlates of this spread. Initially it was common to find European-manufactured clay elbow pipes, but native-made pipes incorporating indigenous raw materials and iconography were soon developed wherever tobacco was used.

Large-scale importation of tobacco into Europe did not occur until the early 1600s. Old World direct evidence in the form of clay smoking pipes is found in a wide variety of European contexts dating to that period. First arriving in Africa with sixteenth-century Portuguese traders, tobacco soon spread throughout much of the continent, especially in East, West, and South Africa. Pottery smoking pipes have been found in post-Medieval contexts at the West African trade city of Timbuktu. Smoking pipes are common artifacts in late precolonial West Africa, such as eighteenth- and nineteenth-century examples from Ghana. Tobacco has been demonstrated by residue analysis to be at least one plant smoked in these West African examples. Tobacco also had a secondary introduction to Asia, by means of contact from Europeans. Tobacco was introduced into China via Japan and the Philippines during the later sixteenth century, and into Japan earlier that century through shipwrecks. While numerous indigenous Australian tobacco species indicate possible pre-seventeenth-century use by aboriginal populations, evidence for this is currently circumstantial.

Pipes

Archaeologists trace indirect evidence for tobacco back farthest in eastern North America. Tubular stone pipes from the Late Archaic Period (3000 b.c.e.–1000 b.c.e.) date to as early as 2000 b.c.e. (Lewis and Lewis 1961; Walthall 1980). Tubular smoking pipes, straight stone or clay tubes with the distal end open and proximal end constricted, were used throughout prehistory, but are most commonly associated with the Ohio River Valley from approximately 1000 b.c.e. to 200 c.e. The period from 200 to 1000 c.e. is dominated by platform pipes. These pipes feature a flat platform that contains the pipe bore, with a cylindrical bowl located in the center and perpendicular to the platform. Rarer and more elaborate were effigy forms where the bowl was replaced by an animal figure; bird of prey effigies dominated, but other woodland animals (wolf, bear, reptiles) were found. Prey animals (such as deer) are generally lacking.

Late prehistory, from approximately 1000 to 1500, in North America is characterized by elbow pipes. While elbow pipes had existed as minority styles in preceding eras, they became the most common form of smoking implement from the eleventh century onward. Diskshaped elbow pipes are included in this characterization. Figurine pipes are also important during later prehistory, especially during the Mississippian Period (c. 900–1500 c.e.). Mississippian pipes often include stylistic elements that relate to the constellation of motifs known as the Southeastern Ceremonial Complex. Evidence of tobacco's association with psychoactive plant remains and ceremonial artifacts points to its ritual importance during this period.

During the Contact Period (c. 1500–1600), some areas preferentially used native pipes rather than the increasingly available Euroamerican clay or pewter trade pipes. Other areas show a hiatus in native pipes followed by a resurgence (especially in effigy forms) during the 1600s, possibly some form of nativistic response to empower indigenous populations in the face of domination by European colonization. In addition, some areas saw a decrease in the use of durable materials, with perishable wooden pipes replacing clay or stone pipes.

The best-known Native American prehistoric pipes relate to the historically documented calumet ritual (Hart 1980). The calumet ritual was a widespread practice in the Plains and Eastern Woodlands where tobacco, smoked in stemmed pipes, was used to facilitate intergroup interactions through references to a shared cosmology. Calumet rituals may have arisen out of mourning rituals and adoption ceremonies in the Plains region, and the practice's ability to maintain peaceful interaction between potential enemies may have been in large part responsible for its spread in the early first millennium c.e.

Historic archaeology primarily deals with clay smoking pipes of European manufacture, or local versions thereof. Most archaeological discussions of historic smoking pipes are typological or chronological in focus. The use of pipe bore diameters as a chronological measure is a prime example. There have been regular and predictable changes in the size of historic pipe bores, and measuring a sample pipe stem's bore and comparing it to known and dated samples can provide a probable time period for that pipe's construction. Notable exceptions are recent studies of Middle Eastern and Australian contexts, which place pipes in an interpretive social context. Tobacco pipe studies in North America and in Europe have studied social class (e.g., use of pipes by lower versus upper classes), ethnicity (e.g., pipes incorporating ethnic symbols used in immigrant populations), cultural contact (e.g., smoking of tobacco during trade between Native Americans and Europeans to foster positive relations), working class ideology (e.g., pipes including labor slogans), and gender relations (e.g., traditionally male-made pipes made by women).

See Also Africa; Calumets; Middle East; Native Americans; Pipes; South and Central America; South Asia; South East Asia.

? SEAN M. RAFFERTY

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Binford, Lewis R. "A New Method of Calculating Dates from Kaolin Pipe Stem Samples." In Historical Archaeology: A Guide to Substantive and Theoretical Contributions. Edited by Robert L. Schuyler. Farmingdale, N.Y.: Baywood Publishing Company, 1978. Pp. 66–67.

Brown, Ian W. "The Calumet Ceremony in the Southeast and its Archaeological Manifestations." American Antiquity 54, no. 2 (1989): 311–333.

Goodman, Jordan. Tobacco in History: The Cultures of Dependence. London: Routledge, 1993.

Haberman, Thomas W. "Evidence of Aboriginal Tobaccos in Eastern North America." American Antiquity 49, no. 2 (1984): 268–287.

Hall, Robert L. "Calumet Ceremonialism, Mourning Ritual, and Mechanisms of Intertribal Trade." In Mirror and Metaphor: Material and Social Constructions of Reality. Edited by Daniel W. Ingersoll Jr. and Gordon Bronitsky. Lanham, Md.: University Press of America, 1987. Pp. 29–43.

Hays, Charles F. III. Proceedings of the 1989 Smoking Pipe Conference: Selected Papers. Rochester, N.Y.: Research Division of the Rochester Museum and Science Center, 1992.

Higgins, David A. "Clay Tobacco Pipes: A Valuable Commodity." International Journal of Nautical Archaeology 24, no. 1 (1995): 47–52.

Rafferty, Sean M. "Chemical Analysis of Early Woodland Period Smoking Pipe Residue." Journal of Archaeological Science 29, no. 8 (2002): 897–907.

Springer, James W. "An Ethnohistoric Study of the Smoking Complex in Eastern North America." Ethnohistory 28, no. 3 (1981): 217–235.

Winter, Joseph C., ed. Tobacco Use by Native North Americans: Sacred Smoke and Silent Killer. Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2000.

snuff a form of powdered tobacco, usually flavored, either sniffed into the nose or "dipped," packed between cheek and gum. Snuff was popular in the eighteenth century but had faded to obscurity by the twentieth century.

ethnohistory the study of the past or background of a particular ethnic group

radiocarbon dating a method of discovering the age of dead organic matter by measuring the presence of the carbon-14 isotope, which decays at a known rate. For example, scientists can date an ancient campsite by radiocarbon dating the charred firewood.

psychoactive having an effect on the mind of the user.

More From encyclopedia.com