Euthanasia

views updated

Euthanasia

Definition

The American Medical Association (AMA) defines euthanasia in its Code of Ethics as “the administration of a lethal agent by another person to a patient for the purpose of relieving the patient's intolerable and incurable suffering.” The English word euthanasia comes from the Greek and means “a good death” or “dying well.”

It is important to note that the AMA definition excludes assisted suicide , which is sometimes called physician-assisted suicide. In physician-assisted suicide, the doctor provides the patient with the means of death (commonly an overdose of morphine or a similar drug) but the patient administers the drug. Euthanasia administered directly by a physician is illegal in all 50 states; physician-assisted suicide is illegal in all except Oregon as of 2008.

Euthanasia must also be distinguished from pain relief (palliation) that may shorten the patient's life when the primary intention of administering the drug is to ease the patient's pain rather than to hasten death. The U.S. Supreme Court has underscored the importance of the principle of double effect in the context of relieving pain at the end of life. The principle of double effect means that an action that is primarily intended to have a beneficial effect (to relieve pain in this case) is permitted, even though a secondary effect that is harmful (an earlier death in this case) is likely. Thus, a doctor who administers high doses of opioids to ease a patient's pain at the end of life is legally protected by the doctrine of double effect: Provided palliation was the primary reason for giving the drugs rather than to shorten the patient's life.

Description

Historical background

Euthanasia appears to have been accepted in the ancient world, and it was possibly abused. Some historians of medicine think that the Hippocratic Oath contains a clause forbidding euthanasia because there was a need to limit its practice. The oath states, “I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect.” The combination of the Hippocratic tradition with the ethical traditions of Judaism and Christianity regarding the value of human life helps to explain why euthanasia was forbidden by law from the time of the late Roman Empire through the modern period.

It should be noted that one reason for the prohibition of euthanasia (as well as of suicide) was the traditional desire to protect the relationship between the individual person and the larger community (family, nation, or religious community). Both ancient philosophy and scriptural teachings conceived of persons and their communities as existing in relation to each other. Individuals grow into mature adults through relationships to others and, thus, cannot dispose of their own life as if they are isolated being without any obligation to the larger community. At the same time the community is composed of individuals, all of whose lives are valuable; it does not have the right to define some of those individuals as unworthy of life.

One way of understanding why the modern euthanasia movement emerged when it did—at the end of the eighteenth century through the middle of the nineteenth—was that the older balance between individuals and the larger society began to break down. Some people began to think of themselves as superior individuals who should not be bound by the rules that governed the less well educated or less intelligent. Such philosophers as Voltaire and David Hume, for example, saw no reason why people should not be allowed to commit suicide, for example, as a protest against conventional morality. In addition, advances in medicine—specifically, the discovery of reliable and relatively safe anesthetics in the 1840s—helped to make euthanasia seem feasible as a way of ending the pain of terminal illness.

The third factor was Charles Darwin's theory of evolution and its extension to human society in the 1860s and 1870s. Francis Galton (1822–1911), a half-cousin of Charles Darwin, was the inventor of the

Types of euthanasia

As of 2008, euthanasia was usually described as either active or passive and as either voluntary or involuntary. Active euthanasia is what is described in the AMA definition, namely, taking deliberate steps to end someone's life. Passive euthanasia is defined as withdrawing or withholding medical treatment in order to let a terminal illness take its course and end the patient's life. Some people would understand a “do not resuscitate” order or the withdrawal of life support as forms of passive euthanasia.

Voluntary euthanasia refers to the patient's personal decision that action be taken to end his or her life or that life-saving treatments be stopped. In involuntary euthanasia, the patient's life is ended, whether passively or actively, without his or her knowledge or consent.

Viewpoints

Current debate

Public policy debates about euthanasia in both the United States and Europe have intensified in the 1980s, partly as a result of several controversial court cases related to passive euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. The state of Oregon legalized physician-assisted suicide in 1994, and several well-known books were published about self-administered euthanasia. Arguments in favor of euthanasia are usually based on one or more of the following points:

  • Individuals should be allowed complete control over their own life without interference by the government or any other institution. One man who took his own life in 2007 described himself as “a prisoner of the medical-industrial complex” who was exercising his “freedom to choose death.”
  • Euthanasia provides a means for harvesting valuable organs for transplantation.
  • It offers an end to the patient's suffering.
  • It relieves the emotional strain on the patient's family. This argument was used by a Canadian father who killed his 12-year-old daughter with carbon monoxide poisoning in 1993. The father claimed that his daughter's cerebral palsy was painful and that he killed her out of love, even though she apparently enjoyed outings and attended a nearby school.

The AMA statement on euthanasia includes several arguments against it:

  • Euthanasia violates the physician's role as healer.
  • It would be difficult or impossible to control and it could “pose serious societal risks.” This argument has been taken up by the disability-rights movement, many of whose members fear that they could be euthanized by others who have arbitrarily decided that their lives are “not worth living.” A disabled lawyer has written of her public debate with Peter Singer, a philosopher who favors the euthanasia of babies with severe disabilities. She points out that “the public in general, and physicians in particular, tend to underestimate the quality of life of disabled people, compared with our own assessments of our lives.”
  • Euthanasia could be extended to incompetent patients and those who are otherwise vulnerable (unconscious, under anesthesia, etc.). Although the AMA statement does not explicitly mention psychological vulnerability, other writers have noted that the distinction between voluntary euthanasia and involuntary euthanasia is unclear. There have been several publicized cases of persons in the United States being pressured to commit assisted suicide who may not have genuinely wanted to die. One of the better-known instances is that of Myrna Lebov, who was ill with multiple sclerosis and finally took a lethal mix of drugs at her husband's urging. The husband, who was eventually tried for manslaughter, noted in his diary, “I will say: I have fallen prey to the tyranny of a victim. [She is] sucking my life out of me like a vampire and nobody cares.” Other instances have been noted in Europe, particularly in the Netherlands,

Other arguments against euthanasia that are not mentioned in the AMA's statement are:

  • The possibility of using euthanasia for financial benefit, for example, by relatives desiring to save money that would otherwise be spent on a dying family member's health care. Others have pointed out that the constantly rising costs of health care could also be used to justify euthanizing people who are regarded on the basis of age, poverty, disability, or some other basis as so-called burdens to society.
  • The abuse of involuntary euthanasia to obtain organs for transplantation. In March 2008, a doctor in California was accused of hastening a patient's death in order to harvest his organs.
  • The destruction of trust between patients and doctors. Some writers have pointed out that people might be afraid to seek treatment for severe illness if they knew that euthanasia were legal and that their doctors could decide to kill them without penalty. This trend seems to be occurring in the Netherlands, where euthanasia was decriminalized in 2002. Even though as of 2008 Dutch law states that euthanasia must be voluntary and that the patient must request it over a period of time, an American doctor who has studied that Dutch system estimated that even before the 2002 law, several thousand patients were euthanized in the Netherlands each year without their consent.
  • The availability of effective pain management. Many patients who are terminally ill do not want to die as much as they simply want the pain to stop. It is, therefore possible to relieve pain at the end of life without resorting to euthanasia.
  • Religious reasons for opposition. Many religious beliefs affirm that God is the giver of life, that life is itself good and precious in his sight, and that no human being should be defined by other humans as unworthy or undeserving of life.

The AMA statement on euthanasia concludes with the following summary of the contemporary physician's ethical obligation to all patients: “Instead of engaging in euthanasia, physicians must aggressively respond to the needs of patients at the end of life. Patients should not be abandoned once it is determined that cure is impossible. Patients near the end of life must continue to receive emotional support, comfort care, adequate pain control, respect for patient autonomy, and good communication.”

KEY TERMS

Assisted suicide —A form of self-inflicted death in which a person voluntarily brings about his or her own death with the help of another, usually a physician, relative, or friend. Assisted suicide is sometimes called physician-assisted death (PAD).

Ethicist —A person who studies and writes about moral principles and questions involving good and evil or human duties and obligations.

Euthanasia —The act of putting a person (or animal) to death painlessly or allowing death to occur by withholding medical services, usually because of a painful and incurable disease; also called mercy killing.

Palliation —Easing the pain of disease when cure is impossible.

Principle of double effect —An ethical principle that holds that an act that causes harm may be morally permissible if the harm is a side effect of promoting a good purpose. In the context of euthanasia, the principle of double effect would justify a doctor's giving high doses of painkilling drugs to ease the pain of a terminally ill patient (the good purpose) even though the patient might die sooner as a result (the harm).

Resources

BOOKS

Beers, Mark H., and Thomas V. Jones. Merck Manual of Geriatrics, 3rd ed., Chapter 14, “Legal and Ethical Issues.” Whitehouse Station, NJ: Merck, 2005.

Dowbiggin, Ian Robert. A Concise History of Euthanasia: Life, Death, God, and Medicine. Lanham, MD: Rowan and Littlefield, 2005.

Fremgen, Bonnie F. Medical Law and Ethics, 2nd ed. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall, 2006.

PERIODICALS

American Academy of Hospice and Palliative Medicine. “Position Statement on Physician-Assisted Death.” Journal of Pain and Palliative Care Pharmacotherapy 21 (April 2007): 55–57.

Delury, George. “George Delury's Suicide Note.” Santa Barbara Newsroom June 14, 2007 [cited March 10, 2008]. http://www.santabarbaranewsroom.com/news/general/george-delurys-suicide-note.html.

Johnson, Harriet McBryde. “Unspeakable Conversations.” New York Times Magazine February 16, 2003 [cited March 11, 2008]. http://www.utilitarian.net/singer/about/20030216.htm.

Simon, Dan, and Paul Vercammen. “Doctor Accused of Hastening Death for Patient's Organs.” CNN.com March 5, 2008 [cited March 11, 2008]. http://www.cnn.com/2008/CRIME/03/03/transplant.trial/index.html#cnnSTCText.

OTHER

Euthanasia. American Medical Association (AMA) Code of Ethics 2005 [cited March 10, 2008]. http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/category/8458.html.

Zwiebel, Chaim Dovid. “The Diary of George Delury.” Jewish Law [cited March 11, 2008]. http://www.jlaw.com/Commentary/diary.html.

ORGANIZATIONS

American Association of Pastoral Counselors (AAPC), 9504-A Lee Highway, Fairfax, VA, 22031, (703) 385-6967, (703) 352-7725, [email protected], http://www.aapc.org/index.cfm.

American Medical Association (AMA), 515 N. State Street, Chicago, IL, 60610, (800) 621-8335, http://www.ama-assn.org/.

Dignitas (Swiss assisted suicide group), Postfach 9, Forch, Switzerland, CH 8127, +41 44 980 44 59, +41 44 980 14 21, [email protected], http://www.dignitas.ch/.

Final Exit Network (choice in dying group), PO Box 965005, Marietta, GA, 30066, (800) 524-EXIT, http://www.finalexitnetwork.org/.

Not Dead Yet (NDY; disabilities activist group), 7521 Madison Street, Forest Park, IL, 60130, (708) 209-1500, (708) 209-1735, [email protected], http://notdeadyetnewscommentary.blogspot.com/.

The President's Council on Bioethics, 1425 New York Ave. NW, Suite C100, Washington, DC, 20005, (202) 296-4669, [email protected], http://www.bioethics.gov/.

Rebecca J. Frey Ph.D.

More From encyclopedia.com