Dean Witter, Discover & Co.

views updated

Dean Witter, Discover & Co.

Two World Trade Center
New York, New York 10048
(212) 3922222
Fax: (212) 3927562

Public Company
Employees: 27,000
Sales: $4.5 billion
Stock Exchanges: New York San Francisco
SICs: 6211 Securities Brokers and Dealers; 7389 Business
Services Not Elsewhere Classified

Dean Witter, Discover & Co. is engaged in providing securities brokerage and credit card services. The company is a leading U.S. provider of brokerage services for individuals, electronic transaction processing services, and consumer financing. The company is also the largest credit card issuer in the nation with 29 million accounts issued through its Discover credit card.

Dean Witter, Discover & Co. was formed in 1993. Prior to becoming a public company, Dean Witter was operating as a subsidiary of retail giant Sears, Roebuck & Co. Sears purchased Dean Witter in 1981 for about $600 million as part of its strategy to diversify out of the retail industry. At the time, Dean Witterthen an investmentonly business named Dean Witter Reynoldswas the fifth largest brokerage house in the United States. Sears planned to make Dean Witter the nucleus of what would become a national financial services network.

The original Dean Witter brokerage house was founded in 1924 by Dean Witter, his brother Guy, and cousin Jean. The trio started Dean Witter & Co. as a West Coast securities firm dealing in municipal and corporate bonds. They set up shop in San Francisco and, in 1928, purchased a seat on the San Francisco Stock Exchange; that exchange was later incorporated into the Pacific Stock Exchange. The company enjoyed immense success during the explosive bull market of the 1920s. In 1929, in fact, Dean Witter opened a New York office and purchased a seat on the New York Stock Exchange.

Dean Witter survived the Depressionera securities industry shakeout and even managed to post profits every year during the 1930s and into the 1940s. The company also became known as an innovator on Wall Street. For example, Dean Witter was one of the first securities firms to establish an account executive training program. The company grew rapidly during the 1950s and 1960s, establishing itself as a major U.S. brokerage house. Dean Witter died in 1969, and, the following year, Guy Witter retired, passing the top position to Jean Witters son, William M. Witter, who became CEO of the operation. The company was taken public in 1972 with an offering of 1.5 million shares on the NYSE. In 1977, Dean Witter purchased InterCapital Inc., an investment management firm with $200 million in assets.

At the same time that Dean Witter was rising to prominence on Wall Street, another company was making its mark on the securities brokerage business. Reynolds & Co. was started in 1931 by Richard S. Reynolds Jr., Thomas F. Stanley, and Charles H. Babcock, all members of the Reynolds family. That company also went public in the early 1970s, becoming Reynolds Securities. In 1978, Reynolds and Witter joined forces in what was then the largest merger in the history of the U.S. securities industry and would remain the largest merger to date going into 1995. Both firms were industry leaders and neither had posted a loss since they had opened their doors. The resultant company, Dean Witter Reynolds, was the fifth largest broker in the United States.

By the late 1970s, Sears, the largest retailer in the world, was facing several challenges. Its retail store operations were increasingly under fire from new competitors, particularly from discount retailers and upscale department store chains. Likewise, its wellknown catalog division was threatened by a new breed of specialty catalog retailers. In short, Sears retailing strategy had become obsolete and the company was floundering. In an effort to overcome its problems, Sears experimented with a variety of fixes. During the early 1980s, for example, it decided to diversify into new businesses, including financial services. Toward that end, Sears acquired Dean Witter Reynolds in 1981.

Sears hoped that Dean Witter would provide the foundation for a giant financial services networkthe Sears Financial Services Groupthat would be offered to consumers through the companys extensive chain of retail stores. The network would provide Sears customers with an easy way to purchase mutual funds, stocks, and insurance, and even allow them to obtain financing for homes and other purchases. To head Dean Witter, Sears chose Philip J. Purcell, a strategic planner at the Sears Chicago headquarters. Purcell moved to New York to run the operation from Dean Witters office.

Sears decided early that Dean Witter should make a major shift in its strategy. Instead of serving both the retail and institutional sectors, it would shift its focus to the former, the individual consumer. Purcell believed that market would fuel growth in the financial services industry in the coming decade, and he felt that Sears offered the infrastructure to reach that group. Thus, the strategy was relatively synergistic: Sears would create a sort of financial services supermarket aimed at the broad middle consumer market. A combination of heavy foot traffic and general goodwill toward Sears would lead millions to entrust their money with Dean Witter and its affiliates. A lot of people dont trust brokers, but they do trust Sears, explained John Fallon, a Dean Witter account executive, in the December 14, 1987 Crains Chicago Business.

Many critics regarded Searss scheme as simplistic and illusory. Do consumers really want to buy socks and stocks under the same roof? they quipped. Similarly, stockholders wondered why Sears was involving itself with financial services, when its core business was being assaulted by WalMart and other aggressive contenders. In response, Sears cited its success with Allstate, an insurance company that it had started in 1931. Sears enjoyed success with that operation and hoped to replay those gains with broader financial offerings. In addition to Dean Witter, in fact, Sears purchased Coldwell Banker, a provider of mortgage and brokerage services. Sears aimed to achieve a synergy between Allstate, Coldwell, and Dean Witter that would allow the three to benefit from their complementary offerings.

During the early 1980s, Sears used its retail store network to open new Dean Witter and Coldwell Banker offices in areas of the country in which they had been nonexistent or poorly represented. After establishing a base in the local Sears store, satellite offices were spun off in surrounding neighborhoods. Sears invested millions of dollars into the Dean Witter operation during the early 1980s, opening 280 new offices between 1981 and 1986. Indeed, in 1983, Sears announced its intent to at least double Dean Witters chain of 350 outlets during the 1980s and to establish it as a leading securities firm for individual investors. Sears initiated similar growth plans for Coldwell Banker as well.

However, Searss aggressive efforts to turn its financial services division into a star performer had achieved lackluster results by the mid1980s. Critics of the strategy sounded off after the stock market crash of 1987, which seemed to expose weaknesses in the division. Indeed, after focusing on building Dean Witters retail sales, the financial services division was facing the possibility of a longterm bear market during which retail sales growth would undoubtedly wane. Worse yet, Dean Witters position in the traditional investment banking and underwriting sectors had deteriorated rapidly since 1981. Many of its top executives and managers had jumped ship after the transition to retailing. Not surprisingly, Dean Witters rank in the corporate debt and equity underwriting market had slipped from tenth to 15th, and investment banking accounted for less than ten percent of Witters revenues by 1987.

Sears financial group posted a loss of $37 million in 1987 on sales of about $3.5 billion, while Sears earned $1.35 billion from $44 billion in sales during that year. Nevertheless, some contended that Dean Witters performance was not as bad as it seemed. In fact, the overall financial services operations had posted healthy profits of $80 million just one year earlier. Furthermore, much of the 1987 loss was attributable to the Discover Card, a credit card introduced the year before by Sears, which sought to enter the growing $200 billion industry. Sears had invested $200 million into the project during 1986, with the expectation of losing money in the short term.

Discover Card had been set up as a division of Dean Witter, which was still under Purcells direction. The main appeal of the card for consumers was that it was free; most other cards at the time charged annual fees ranging from $10 to $50. In addition, the card offered cashback bonuses and interestfree cash advances. The card was distinguished from Visa and Mastercard in that Sears controlled its brand image, features, service level, and pricing. Even though many retailers were initially slow to accept the card, within two years the card boasted more than 22 million subscribers and was accepted at 740,000 merchant outlets.

Discovers growth dropped off significantly during the late 1980s as credit card competition intensified. According to some analysts, Discovers profitability failed to live up to Searss original expectations, and the concept received a generally lukewarm reception from the Visa/Mastercarddominated credit card market. Nevertheless, Sears poured more than $1 billion into the project, and Discover turned its first profit in 1988. Discovers account base continued to increase past 25 million by the early 1990s as the total number of dispensed cards topped 40 million. In fact, Discover became the largest single issuer of general purpose credit cards. Its profitability remained well below that of many of its peers, but its sheer size allowed Discover to generate earnings of about $174 million annually by 1991.

Like Discover, Dean Witters other operations experienced some challenges during the late 1980s. Although Dean Witter had nearly doubled in size between 1981 and 1989, it appeared as though Sears had failed to achieve the financial services synergy for which it had hoped. Sears announced plans to close about 200 of Dean Witters 650 outlets, primarily those located in its department stores. Viewed as a failed attempt to capitalize on the individual financial services market, the barely profitable Dean Witter was frowned upon by frustrated Sears stockholders. In the early 1990s, however, the fortune of Dean Witter and its Discover Card began to turn.

Falling interest rates in the early 1990s sent many investors scurrying to the stock market in search of higher returns. As a result, Dean Witters sales skyrocketed. Much of its gains were attributable to Dean Witters emphasis on mutual funds. The company had begun investing heavily in its mutual fund offerings in the early 1980s, speculating that the funds would become the investment vehicle of choice for its target market. That strategy began to pay off in the early 1990s. Importantly, Dean Witter introduced a new family of proprietary funds (funds managed inhouse) in 1992, giving it a steady stream of cash in the form of management fees as well as upfront fees charged to enter the funds. As cash began to pour in, Witters mutual fund assets increased to more than $50 billion by 1992.

To the surprise of its critics, Dean Witter staged a major comeback in the early 1990s. In 1990, Witter posted profits of $109 million while the average Wall Street brokerage house saw a loss of $162. In 1991, moreover, net income from Dean Witter and its Discover division rose to $171 million and $173 million, respectively, as combined sales soared to a record $3.35 billion. Then, in 1992, total net income surpassed $400 million from revenues of $3.7 billion. Although Witters securities operations were enjoying healthy gains, its success was also the result of big advancements by Discover, which was finally beginning to bear fruit.

As its financial services division posted solid gains during the early 1990s, the performance of Searss core retail operations waned. By 1992, the mismanaged retail giant was suffering under a massive $38 billion debt load. In an effort to pare its debt and refocus its energies on its core business, Sears announced its intentions to sell its financial services operations. Although they were going to lose their deeppocketed parent, many Dean Witter managers welcomed the decision to spinoff the operation. Indeed, some of them felt that the Sears name wasnt helping their image; in 1992, Sears posted the worst performance in its 108year history, a staggering $3.9 billion loss.

On February 22, 1993, Sears spun off 20 percent of Dean Witter and Discover into an independent, publicly traded company called Dean Witter, Discover & Co. The remaining 80 percent was spun off on June 30, 1993. During its first year of operation, Dean Witter Discover revenues rose more than 20 percent to $4.6 billion as net income reached $600 million. Moreover, the companys stock soared. Gains continued in 1994 as both credit card and securities operations continued to advance, causing many of Witters competitors to adopt the operating strategies that they had once ridiculed. Going into the mid1990s, Dean Witter, Discover & Co. remained the largest credit card issuer in the United States, was the third largest broker, and offered a variety of related financial and transaction processing services. In 1994, moreover, the company started a new credit card, Prime Option, aimed at the Mastercard/Visa segment of the market.

Principal Subsidiaries

Dean Witter Reynolds Inc.; NOVUS Credit Services Inc.

Further Reading

Beldky, Gary, and Robert Reed, Dean Witter Woes Spur Retrenchment, Crains Chicago Business, December 14, 1987, p. 1.

Elstrom, Peter J. W., Whats Next for SplitUp Sears: Discover Loses Muscle in Card Battle, Crains Chicago Business, October 5, 1992.

Gleason, Mark, Consumers Discovered Gold with Sears Bold Credit Card, Cincinnati Business Courier, October 12, 1992, p. 12.

Herr, Jeff, Job Growth on Track Despite Sears Moves, Arizona Business Gazette, October 1, 1992, p. 1.

Lefton, Terry, Amid Rate, Fee and Rebate Squabbles, Sears Finds it Costs to Discover, Brandweek, November 9, 1992, p. 34.

Parker, Marcia, Debt, Credit Rating Crucial at Dean Witter, Crains New York Business, October 5, 1992, p. 1.

Roberts, William L., Dean Witter, Discover Spinoff May Become Major Competitor, Philadelphia Business Journal, February 1, 1993, p. 3.

Robinson, David, Dean Witters Retail Focus is Finally Paying Off, Buffalo News, September 20, 1992.

Waldstein, Peter D., Sears Stores Cut Financial Outlets, Crams Chicago Business, March 13, 1989, p. 1.

Willis, Gerri, Dean Witter Laughs Last, Crains New York Business, February 7, 1994, p. 1.

Zonana, Victor F., Trying to Become Financial Supermarket, Los Angeles Times, September 30, 1992, p. Dl.

Dave Mote

About this article

Dean Witter, Discover & Co.

Updated About content Print Article