Agent Orange
Agent Orange
Agent Orange defoliation damage
Agent Orange is a defoliant that kills plants and causes the leaves to fall off the dying plants. The name was a code devised by the U.S. military during the development of the chemical mixture. The name arose from the orange band that marked the containers storing the defoliant.
Agent Orange was an equal mixture of two chemicals; 2, 4–D (2, 4, dichlorophenoxyl acetic acid) and 2, 4, 5–T (2, 4, 5-trichlorophenoxy acetic acid). Another compound designated TCDD (2, 3, 7, 8-tetrachlorodibenzo-para-dioxin) is a by-product of the manufacturing process and remains as a contaminant of the Agent Orange mixture. It is this dioxin contaminant that has proven to be damaging to human health.
Agent Orange was devised in the 1940s, but became infamous during the 1960s in the Vietnam War. The dispersal of a massive amount of Agent Orange throughout the tropical jungles of Vietnam (an estimated 19 million gallons were dispersed) was intended to deprive the Viet Cong of jungle cover in which they hid.
Agent Orange defoliation damage
By 1971, the use of Agent Orange in Vietnam had ended. However, the damage caused to the vegetation of the region by the spraying of Agent Orange is still visible in 2006. Agent Orange applications affected foliage of a diversity of tropical ecosystems of Vietnam, but the most severe damage occurred in the mangrove forest of coastal areas. About 306,280 acres (1,240 km2) of the coastal mangrove forest of South Vietnam was sprayed at least once. This area comprised about 40% of the South Vietnamese coastal mangrove ecosystem.
The spraying killed extensive stands of the dominant mangrove species, Rhizophora apiculata. Barren, badly eroded coastal habitat remained, which had devastating effects on the local economy. The harvesting of dead mangroves for fuel would sustain fewer people than the living forest once did, according to a 1970 report commissioned by the United States National Academy of Sciences, because the supply of mangrove wood was not being renewed. Unless a vigorous replanting program was undertaken, the report warned of a future economic loss when the dead mangroves were harvested.
The destruction of mature seed-bearing trees has made regeneration of mangroves slow and sporadic. Weed species have become dominant. Indeed, the Academy of Sciences has estimated that full recovery of the mangrove forest might take 100 years or more.
Agent Orange was sprayed over 14 million acres of inland tropical forest. A single spray treatment killed about 10% of the tall trees comprising the forest canopy. Defoliation of the trees was much more extensive, but many of the defoliated trees continued to live. Smaller shrubs, protected from the herbicide by the high canopy, comprised the majority of vegetation in sprayed areas. The total loss of commercially useful timber caused by the military application of herbicide in South Vietnam is estimated to be 26–61 million cubic yards (20–47 million m3). In areas that were sprayed repeatedly, the valuable tree species were replaced by a few resistant, commercially unimportant trees (such as Irvingia malayana and Parinari anna-mense ), along with tussock grass and bamboo. In the dry season, the stands of grass easily catch fire, and if burned repeatedly, the land is less likely to return quickly to forest. It will take many decades before the tropical forest recovers and attains its former productivity.
Because Agent Orange herbicide remains in the soil for some time, there is concern that these residues might inhibit the growth of crops and other plants. Soil bacteria break down the herbicides into smaller molecules, but complete decomposition takes years to occur. Studies performed 15 years after the spraying in South Vietnam still found degradation products of Agent Orange in the soil. These byproducts, which can be toxic, can be passed through the food web. How much Agent Orange actually reached the soil is subject to question. A large proportion of the herbicide falling onto the forest was trapped by the canopy. Few drops reached the soil directly, but much of the herbicide was eventually delivered to the forest floor by a rain of dead foliage and woody tissue. In open areas, much more of the application reached the soil directly. The contaminant TCDD is quite persistent in soil, with a half-life of three years. (In that period of time, one half of the dioxin originally applied would still be present in the soil.) In studies conducted in the United States, samples of inland soil and sediment from mangrove areas treated with herbicide still had substantial levels of TCDD after ten years. An indirect effect of the Agent Orange spraying is the poor fertility of soil in many areas, due to erosion following the destruction of soil-binding vegetation.
Reduction of animal habitat
As the rich, biodiverse, tropical forests disappeared, so did habitat for indigenous animals. Uniform grassland has poor habitat diversity compared to the complex, multi-layered tropical forest. As a result, the number of bird and mammal species living in sprayed areas declined dramatically. Most of the forest animals are adapted to living in a specific habitat and are unable to survive in the post-herbicide grassland. Wild boar, wild goat, water buffalo, tiger,
KEY TERMS
Exposure dose— The quantity of a chemical that an organism receives from the environment through inhalation, ingestion, and/or contact with the skin.
Toxicity— The extent to which a substance is poisonous.
and various species of deer became less common once the cover and food resources of the forest were removed. Domestic animals such as water buffalo, zebu, pigs, chickens, and ducks were also reported to become ill after the spraying of Agent Orange.
The defoliation and destruction of the mangrove forests had other consequences to wildlife. The number of coastal birds declined dramatically, since their habitat had vanished. Fish and crustacean populations also suffered, since their former breeding and nursery habitats in the web of channels winding beneath the mangrove trees were destroyed. Additionally, the wartime spraying of mangrove forest is thought to have contributed to the post-war decline in South Vietnam’s offshore fishery.
Possible human health threat
Agent Orange has unquestionably been a disaster for the ecology of Vietnam. But evidence also suggests that the defoliant, and in particular the TCCD dioxin component, is a health threat to soldiers who were exposed to Agent Orange during their tour of duty in Vietnam. Tests using animals have identified TCCD as the cause of a wide variety of maladies. In the mid-1990s, the “Pointman” project was begun in New Jersey, which scientifically assessed select veterans in order to ascertain if their exposure to Agent Orange had damaged them. The project is ongoing. In the meantime, veterans’ organizations continue to lobby for financial compensation for the suffering they feel has been inflicted on some soldiers by Agent Orange.
Since the late 1970s, hundreds of lawsuits have been filed against the manufacturers of Agent Orange (Dow Chemical, Monsanto, Hercules Inc., Diamond Shamrock Chemicals, Uniroyal, Thompson Chemical) by individual veterans and groups of veterans, seeking compensation for illnesses allegedly caused by the defoliant. Eventually the claims were consolidated into one lawsuit. While the link between Agent Orange and the veterans’ illness failed to be established, an award of $180 million was made.
In 2003, the Supreme Court ruled that the blanket settlement did not bar furture claims against the manfacturers of the chemical. A lawsuit brought by one veteran is ongoing as of 2006.
See also Immune system; Poisons and toxins.
Resources
BOOKS
Griffiths, Philip J. Agent Orange: Collateral Damage in Vietnam. New York: Trolley, 2003.
Institute of Medicine. Veterans and Agent Orange 2004: Update 2004. Washington: National Academies Press, 2005.
Parker, James N., and Philip M. Parker. Agent Orange: A Medical Dictionary, Bibliography, and Annotated Research Guide to Internet References. San Diego: Icon Health Publications, 2003.
Brian Hoyle
