Methodism

views updated

Methodism

There are more than twenty Methodist denominations in America that trace their origins directly to the movement begun in England by the Anglican priest John Wesley (1703–1791). Wesley was the dominant figure in establishing the beliefs, structure, and practices of American Methodism.

Methodism was organized in America in the 1760s, when immigrant laypeople from Ireland and England began to preach an evangelical message and formed Methodist societies and classes similar to those established by Wesley. At Christmas 1784 in Baltimore, Maryland, American Methodists, with Wesley's blessing, founded the Methodist Episcopal Church. It was the parent church of American Methodism. Several denominations trace their ancestry to the Methodist Episcopal Church, including the African Methodist Episcopal Church (1816), the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church (1821), the Methodist Protestant Church (1830), the Wesleyan Church (1843), the Methodist Episcopal Church, South (1845), the Free Methodist Church (1860), and the Christian Methodist Episcopal Church (1870). Three of these denominations, the African Methodist Episcopal Church, the African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, and the Christian Methodist Episcopal Church, have almost entirely African-American memberships. In 1939 the Methodist Episcopal Church, the Methodist Protestant Church, and the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, reunited to form the Methodist Church. In 1968 the Methodist Church united with the Evangelical United Brethren Church, a denomination with similar polity and theology, to become the United Methodist Church, at the time the largest Protestant denomination in the United States. The churches that are identified with the Holiness and Pentecostal movements in America also share the theological heritage of the Wesleyan/Methodist churches.

United Methodists share a similar connectional polity with the three African-American denominations. Each is divided into geographical annual conferences presided over by elected bishops who serve as their spiritual and administrative leaders. Bishops also perform the important task of appointing the clergy to their ministerial work. Bishops are assisted by episcopally appointed superintendents who advise the bishop and act as liaison between the annual conference and the local churches within its bounds. Each of these denominations has a general conference, with elected representatives from the annual conferences; the general conference meets every four years to set the official policies of the denomination. The structure and policies are set forth in the denomination's Book of Discipline as revised by the general conference.

From its earliest days American Methodism has considered three theological documents of major importance, although it has not always paid much attention to them. They include John Wesley's Explanatory Notes Upon the New Testament (first published in 1755), Wesley's Sermons on Several Occasions (a series of doctrinal sermons published in 1787–1788), and Articles of Religion, sent to America by Wesley in 1784. United Methodism has added The Confession of Faith of the Evangelical United Brethren Church (1963) to its collection of documents called Doctrinal Standards. In 1972 United Methodism also adopted a document titled Our Theological Task (revised in 1988), which sets forth a theological methodology using Scripture, tradition, reason, and experience as bases for understanding and practicing the Christian faith.

Worship is considered important in each of the Methodist denominations, especially the Sunday morning gathering of the congregation. Usually 30 to 40 percent of the membership attends Sunday morning worship. Although worship practices vary considerably among the churches in a denomination, the liturgies employed among Methodists tend to be less formal. The order for worship includes hymns, prayers, perhaps music by a choir, Scripture reading, offering, and a sermon, which is the centerpiece of worship. Two sacraments are observed: the baptism of infants and adults, and the Lord's Supper or Holy Communion.

Theological diversity characterizes the Methodist family, especially United Methodism, where theological controversy has been quite pronounced since the 1960s. One of the parties in this theological dispute has adopted a more liberal theological stance. It is represented by the Methodist Federation for Social Action, founded in 1907. The federation emphasizes a social action agenda, including the elimination of racism, boycotts of corporations that threaten the environment or exploit workers, and acceptance of the homosexual lifestyle. Their views are explicated in their newsletter Social Questions Bulletin. Another party, represented by the Good News Movement, founded in 1966, believes that the denomination has drifted too much toward liberalism and theological pluralism. They hold that the church must return to its evangelical roots, reaffirm the primacy and authority of the Bible, and continue its ban on ordaining homosexuals. In 1984 Good News launched its own Mission Society to correct what it judged to be the liberal agenda of the denomination's General Board of Global Ministries. Furthermore, the Good News leaders were instrumental in three theological documents that state Good News views: the Houston Declaration (1984), the DuPage Declaration (1990), and the Louisville Declaration (1990). Much of the disagreement between these two parties concerns the issue of whether the denomination should make evangelism or social action its priority. A large number of United Methodists stand between these two positions, believing that both should be emphases of the denomination.

Another recent theological development has been the rediscovery of the theology of John Wesley. The theologian/ecumenist Albert C. Outler (1908–1989) was the key figure calling attention to the substance and relevance of Wesley's thought for the second half of the twentieth century. Outler's leadership, the publication of the definitive new edition of Wesley's writings, The Works of John Wesley (thirty-five volumes when complete), and many books and articles on Wesley's theology have appeared regularly and continue to do so.

Most of the Methodist denominations are members of the World Methodist Council, founded in 1881, with offices at Lake Junaluska, North Carolina. The council sponsors a World Methodist Conference every five years, usually outside the United States. The largest Methodist bodies are also active members of other ecumenical organizations, including the National Council of Churches and the World Council of Churches. The African Methodist Episcopal, African Methodist Episcopal Zion, Christian Methodist Episcopal, and United Methodist denominations are engaged in a Pan-Methodist Movement, which seeks closer relationships and cooperation in common areas of ministry.

A number of critical tensions and controversies have been evident among Methodists in recent years. One of the more serious problems has been declining membership in the largest Methodist denomination.

United Methodism's falling membership, not unlike the drop in some other American Protestant bodies, has caused alarm. In response, some call for new programs of evangelism, the restructure and streamlining of the denomination to make its ministry more effective, and new programs and forms of worship to attract and involve children, youth, and young adults. Declining membership also puts stress on the sources of funding on which the churches rely to perpetuate their ministries.

The United Methodist Church has been at the forefront of a number of internal theological and structural conflicts. Although the racially divided structure created by the Methodist Church in 1939 was formally eliminated in 1968 in the union with the Evangelical United Brethren, much was still required to develop a racially inclusive church. Therefore it established the Commission on Religion and Race in 1968 to ensure racial inclusiveness. Since 1968 racial/ethnic caucuses have also been important forces in drafting legislation and ensuring representation in United Methodist denominational life.

The status and role of women has been another decisive area in Methodism. Laywomen have always been prominent in the life of Methodist congregations, but their role in leadership has been limited until recently. Beginning with the 1960s, women's role in the larger Methodist denominations has expanded. Women are now eligible for ordination in them, and growing numbers of women are voting members of the boards and committees of local churches, annual conferences, the general conference, and denominational agencies. In 1980 the United Methodist Church elected its first female bishop, Marjorie Matthews (1916–1986), and a significant number of women are currently pastors, superintendents, and bishops in the denomination. One noteworthy controversy related to the place of women in the church is the use of inclusive language, especially for God, in which references to God as masculine are eliminated in favor of gender-neutral language.

Other social issues generate controversy at the denominations' policymaking level, such as abortion, homosexuality, war and peace, economic and business matters, criminal justice including the death penalty, and international affairs.

Denomination1965197519851998
Source:yearbook of american and canadian churches.
United Methodist10,300,00010,031,0009,230,0008,549,000
African Methodist Episcopal1,166,0001,166,0002,210,0002,100,000
African Methodist Episcopal Zion770,0001,025,0001,134,001,036,000
Christian Methodist Episcopal444,000467,000719,000719,000

See alsoDenomination; Evangelical Christianity; Human Rights; Mainline Protestantism; Publishing, Religious.

Bibliography

Campbell, James T. Songs of Zion: The African MethodistEpiscopal Church in the United States and South Africa. 1995.

Frank, Thomas Edward. Polity, Practice, and the Missionof the United Methodist Church. 1997.

Heitzenrater, Richard P. Wesley and the People CalledMethodists. 1995.

Kirby, James E., Russell E. Richey, and Kenneth E. Rowe. The Methodist. 1998.

McEllhenney, John G. United Methodism in America: ACompact History. 1992.

Charles Yrigoyen, Jr.

More From encyclopedia.com