Colic

views updated

Colic

For most parents, a human baby's crying is a particularly evocative signal, which compels them to seek and resolve the cause. Some babies, though, cry for prolonged amounts of time without apparent reason in the first three months after they are born, worrying their parents and leading many to seek expert help. In Western societies, this puzzling phenomenon has come to be known as colic. From a scientific viewpoint, both this word and the nature of the phenomenon that underlies it remain a source of controversy.


Defining and Measuring Colic

Part of the confusion in this area arises because the word colic has historical and etymological connotations. It comes from the Greek word kolikos, the adjectival form of kolon (the intestine), so that it is often used not just to refer to the behavior— crying—but to infer the presumed cause: gastrointestinal disturbance and pain. The eminent English pediatrician Ronald Illingworth, for instance, referred in 1985 to "pain that is obviously of intestinal origin" (p. 981). In fact, whether or not most babies who cry in this way have indigestion, and whether they are in pain, are both uncertain.

The second source of confusion is that, for obvious reasons, the clinical phenomenon is parental complaint about infant crying, rather than infant crying itself. Not surprisingly, factors such as parental inexperience have been found to increase the likelihood of clinical referral, throwing the spotlight onto parental, rather than infant, characteristics. This has raised issues about individual parents' vulnerability and tolerance, and about the extent to which colic as a distinct condition might be a Western, socially constructed, phenomenon.

One way to resolve this confusion is to define colic strictly in terms of a specific amount of infant crying. Morris Wessel and colleagues' (1954) Rule of Threes ("Fussing or crying lasting for a total of more than three hours per day and occurring on more than three days in any one week," p. 425) has been used in this way. From a research point of view, the advantage is that infants can be identified for study in a standard way. The disadvantage is that the definition is arbitrary; it is unlikely to help parents to be told that their baby does not have colic because he or she fails to meet this research criterion. Moreover, it implies the need to measure crying for a week without intervening, which many parents are reluctant to do.

Rather than employing a single definition, a workable alternative is to define colic broadly as prolonged, unexplained crying in a healthy one- to three-month-old baby, and the impact of this on parents. Information about the infant and parental parts of this phenomenon, within and between cultures, can then be sought in a systematic way. The alternative—of abandoning and replacing the word colic—has also been proposed, but it is so ingrained that this seems unlikely to work in practice.


Infant Crying and Its Impact in Western Cultures

Ronald Barr, Ian St. James-Roberts, and Maureen Keefe (2001) brought together our knowledge of infant crying and its impact on Western parents and clinical services. The principal findings can be summarized as follows:

  1. In general, Western infants cry about twice as much in the first three months as they do at later ages, with the amount of crying peaking at around five weeks of age (the infant crying peak). Around two hours of fussing and crying in twenty-four hours has been reported in U.S., Canadian, and English samples. Rather less has been reported in other European countries, but the reason for this is not yet clear. Infant crying at this age also clusters in the evening (the evening crying peak);
  2. As well as its greater amount, infant crying in the first three months has distinct qualitative features, which help to explain its impact on parents. These include the existence of bouts which occur unexpectedly and are prolonged, relatively intense to listen to, and difficult to soothe effectively;
  3. Parental complaints to clinicians about infant crying problems also peak during the first three months, while infants identified in this way share the same features as other infants, but often to a more extreme degree. This has led to the view that many infants identified as problem criers—and hence labelled as colic cases—are at the extreme end of the normal distribution of crying at this age, rather than having a clinical condition;
  4. Crying in the early months is a graded signal, which signals the degree of an infant's distress, but not precisely what is causing the crying (Gustafson, Wood, and Green 2000). It was previously believed that babies had different cry "types" (e.g., hunger, anger, pain) that allowed a sensitive parent to detect the causes of crying and to intervene to stop it. The unfortunate implication was that a baby who cried a lot had incompetent parents. Instead, it has become clear that "reading" the cause of crying from its sound is at best difficult and, in everyday circumstances, often impossible during the first three months. At this age, babies may cry intensely but the cry itself does not tell you what the problem is;
  5. Most babies grow out of their crying as they get older. Providing their parents can cope, follow-up studies have found that the infants are normal in their cognitive, social and emotional development, and sleep. However, a small minority do have long-term problems (Papousek and von Hofacker 1998). It is not yet clear whether these infants are different in what causes their crying, or in how their parents respond to and care for their babies over the long term.
  6. Women who are prone to depression can have their depression triggered by an objectively irritable newborn (Murray et al. 1996). This emphasizes the need to consider infant crying and colic in terms of parental and family vulnerability, rather than solely as an infant phenomenon.

Infant Crying and Its Impact in Non-Western Cultures

In his 1985 review, Illingworth identified a Punjabi word for infant colic, noting that it was recognized in India, where it was considered to be due to the evening gods. In contrast, many anecdotal accounts have suggested that babies in non-Western cultures hardly cry at all, and attribute this to the almost continuous holding, frequent breast-feeding, and rapid response to babies' cries in such cultures (referred to as proximal care). Overall, the empirical evidence from non-Western cultures is not adequate to resolve this issue. There is clear evidence of a difference in amounts infants cry inbetween African cultures which employ proximal, compared to more distal care (Hewlett et al. 2000). However, the study involved infants over three months of age, by which age colic is usually over, and crying has reduced, in Western infants. Other studies have certainly indicated that non-Western infants cry less in the first three months (Barr et al. 1991; Lee 2000), but this finding requires clarification and it is uncertain whether it reflects care differences or other factors. Attempts to introduce aspects of proximal care, such as supplementary carrying, into Western families have not produced reliable benefits (St. James-Roberts et al. 1995).

Since infants often do stop crying when responded to, it is reasonable to suppose that proximal care is associated with somewhat reduced crying, but whether or not it prevents the bouts of prolonged, unexplained, and "unsoothable" crying in one- to three-month-old infants that trouble Western parents is not yet known.

The Causes of Colic

Although most babies identified as colic cases probably have nothing wrong with them, organic disorders, including food intolerances, can give rise to crying in occasional cases. The best evidence-based estimate is that organic diseases as a whole are responsible for no more than 10 percent of cases where unexplained crying in one- to three-month-old infants is the presenting complaint (Gormally 2001).

There is growing evidence that intolerance of certain foods, especially cow's milk protein, can cause crying in some young babies. The mechanism is not certain, but it appears to be possible for the proteins to be passed via breast-feeding as well as bottle-fed milk or formula. However, reviews by a research pediatrician (Gormally 2001) and pediatric gastroenterologist (Treem 2001) have both concluded that food intolerance of this sort is rare. William Treem estimates that about 2 percent of infants overall are allergic to cow's milk protein, while only 1 in 10 infants taken to clinicians with problem crying have food intolerance. Only around 5 percent of infants diagnosed as having colic have gastroesophageal reflux (gastric acid refluxed into the esophagus). Treem also emphasizes that infants with feed-intolerance or gastrointestinal disorders can often be easily identified, by symptoms such as vomiting and diarrhea, blood in their stools, or a strong family history of atopy, asthma, or eczema.

A second possible cause of colic sometimes proposed is inadequate parenting. As noted above, it remains possible that Western approaches to baby-care as a whole may contribute to infant crying, although there is insufficient evidence to establish if this is the case. In principle, too, parental neglect can cause a baby to cry. However, recent evidence has made clear that many—probably most—Western babies who cry a lot do so in spite of highly sensitive and responsive parental care. Indeed, their parents have usually made extraordinary efforts to resolve the crying. The implication is that there is something about these babies that makes them cry despite care that does not cause crying in most babies.

The search for what this might be has focused on the so-called neurobehavioral shift believed to occur at around two months of age, whereby control over behavior moves from subcortical brain systems to the cerebral cortex. Evidence of this shift can be seen in the disappearance of newborn infant reflexes, such as the grasping reflex, and in the emergence of social smiling and more sophisticated perceptual and cognitive abilities. During this transition period, neurological regulation of behavior is believed to be poor, leading infants to be more or less overreactive, or poor at damping-down their crying once they have started (that is, at self-soothing). Several studies have found evidence that infants who cry a lot are highly reactive when undressed and challenged by handling and standard tests (e.g., White et al. 2000). The goal now is to understand the neurological and developmental processes involved, so that the reasons for the differences in reactivity between babies becomes clear. By understanding the types of stimulation which most provoke reactive behavior, it may also be possible to assist parents in how to minimize it.

Managing Crying in Oneto Three-Month-Old Infants

Many parents are accurate in their judgments of crying, but some may be influenced by their anxiety or expectations. Because the presenting complaint is usually parental concern about infant crying, accurate assessment of the crying is the first goal. Behavior diaries kept prospectively by parents are the method of choice, with detailed questionnaires and interviews being used where diaries are impossible. The resulting information can assist diagnosis and may provide parents with reassurance and insight.

Many parents link their baby's crying to digestive disturbances and are likely to want to change their method of infant feeding. As noted earlier, such disturbances are rare—evidence suggests no more than 2 percent of infants overall, and 10 percent of infants who are presented with crying problems, have gastrointestinal disorders, and these cases can usually be identified by their symptoms. Siobhán Gormally (2001) adds other symptoms of organic disorders for parents and physician to look out for, including a high pitched cry, lack of a time-of-day peak, failure to thrive or weight loss, a positive family history of migraine, maternal drug ingestion, and persistence of symptoms past four months of age. She stresses the importance of infant skin, eye, skeletal, neurological, gastrointestinal, and cardiovascular assessments, highlighting the need for parents to involve physicians in the decision process.

Where infants lack these symptoms, and are otherwise healthy and putting on weight normally, there is no evidence-based reason for assuming that their crying has a gastrointestinal cause, or for treating it with a change of feeding method or diet. In practice, clinicians differ in how readily they recommend a dietary change as a treatment for persistent crying. Where this is contemplated, the disadvantages need to be balanced against the possible gains. One is that breast-feeding is beneficial for young babies, whereas excluding cow's milk protein from a lactating mother's diet is likely to be trying for her and her family. A second is that research trials using dietary change to treat crying have seldom produced clear-cut advantages. Typically, some infants have improved somewhat, but continue to cry above normal levels, whereas other infants have not benefited at all. Other pitfalls include a high placebo rate–where babies seem to improve initially following any change—and the danger that an infant will be considered generally allergic or fragile by parents.

The alternative to dietary change is to use behavior management strategies to support parents and to help them to minimize the crying until it resolves. This approach follows from the evidence, cited earlier, that some parents are especially vulnerable to persistent infant crying, highlighting the need to consider this as a family, rather than infant, problem. Elements of this approach can include:

  • Viewing the first three months of infancy as a developmental transition, which all babies go through more or less smoothly.
  • Reassuring parents that it is normal to find crying aversive and discussing the dangers of abuse and shaken baby syndrome.
  • Examining the notion that crying means that there is something wrong with a baby of this age and introducing alternatives—such as the possibility that it signals a reactive or vigorous baby.
  • Discussing ways of containing and minimizing the crying, and highlighting positive features of the baby.
  • Considering the availability of supports and the development of strategies which allow parents to cope, take time out and "recharge their batteries."
  • Empowering parents and reframing the first three months as a challenge to be overcome, with positive consequences for themselves and their relationships with their babies.

Also implicit in this approach is the need for health services to find means of identifying and supporting the most vulnerable families, and to continue to monitor the infant, at least until the crying problems have resolved.

See also:Childcare; Childhood, Stages of: Infancy


Bibliography

barr, r. g.; konner, m.; baseman, r.; and adamson, l.(1991) "crying in kung san infants: a test of the cultural specificity hypothesis." developmental medicine and child neurology 33:601–610.

barr, r. g.; st. james-roberts, i.; and keefe, m. r., eds.(2001). new evidence on early infant crying: its origins, nature and management. skillman, nj: johnson and johnson pediatric institute round table series.

gormally, s. (2001) "clinical clues to organic etiologies ininfants with colic." in new evidence on early infant crying: its origins, nature and management, edited by r. g. barr, i. st. james-roberts, and m. r. keefe. skillman, nj: johnson and johnson pediatric institute round table series.

gustafson, g. e.; wood, r. m.; and green j. a. (2000)."can we hear the causes of infant crying?" in crying as a sign, a symptom, and a signal, ed. r. g. barr, b. hopkins, and j. a. green. london: mackeith press.

hewlett, b. s.; lamb, m.; leyendecker b.; andscholmerich, a. (2000). "internal working models, trust, and sharing among foragers." current anthropology 41:287–297.

illingworth, r. s. (1985). "infantile colic revisited."archives of disease in childhood 60:981–985.

lee, k. (2000). "crying patterns of korean infants in institutions." child: care, health and development 26:217–228.

murray, l.; stanley, c.; hooper, r.; king, f.; and fiori-cowley, a. (1996). "the role of infant factors in postnatal depression and mother-infant interaction." developmental medicine and child neurology 38:109–119.

papousek, m., and von hofacker, n. (1998). "persistentcrying in early infancy: a non-trivial condition of risk for the developing mother-infant relationship." child: care, health and development 24:395–424.

st. james-roberts, i.; hurry, j.; bowyer, j.; and barr, r. g.(1995). "supplementary carrying compared with advice to increase responsive parenting as interventions to prevent persistent infant crying." pediatrics 95:381–388.

treem,w. r. (2001). "assessing crying complaints: the interaction with gastroesophageal reflex and cow's milk protein intolerance." in new evidence on early infant crying: its origins, nature and management, edited by r. g. barr, i. st. james-roberts, and m. r. keefe. skillman, nj: johnson and johnson pediatric institute round table series.

wessel, m. a.; cobb, j. c.; jackson, e. b.; harris, g. s.; and detwiler, a. c. (1954). "paroxysmal fussing in infancy, sometimes called 'colic.'" pediatrics 14:421–433.

white, b. p.; gunnar, m. r.; larson, m. c.; donzella, b.; and barr, r. g. (2000). "behavioral and physiological responsivity, sleep, and patterns of daily cortisol production in infants with and without colic." child development 71:862–877.

ian st. james-roberts

More From encyclopedia.com