Religion
Religion
The course of history has been influenced significantly by man's pursuit of wealth through trade, and to an even greater extent by religion. The link between these two spheres of human activity has had such a profound effect on the evolution of civilization. Certainly, trade has facilitated the spread of religion. Today the Christian church celebrates hundreds of religious leaders who spread the Gospel throughout the Mediterranean in the first, second, and third centuries after Christ. Perhaps less well known is the subtler, but no less important, role of Christian merchants during the same period. While taking wine, grain, olive oil, and precious metals to all corners of the Roman Empire, merchant ships were also carrying Christians who shared their beliefs with their trading partners.
Arab conquests in northern Africa and the Middle East in the seventh and eighth centuries were crucial to the spread of Islam. In the following centuries Arab merchants played a key role in the mass conversion of tribes south of the Sahara Desert and along the East African coast. Their adherence to strict rules of exchange built long-term relationships based on trust, lowered transaction costs for all market participants, and contributed to the emergence of thriving commercial centers from Spain to China. As Arab merchants sailed across the Indian Ocean and made inroads through Africa, a trading network linking the sub-Saharan regions of Africa, India, and the Muslim world developed and expanded. Market integration and religious conversion went hand in hand: it did not take long for local authorities to realize that it would be beneficial to replace their traditional ways of doing business with a common Islamic commercial legal system. There was very little resistance from the local merchant class, and the new system was accepted as legitimate. A basic tenet of economics is that markets function much more effectively in an environment with well-established property rights, and the Islamic system assured honest market participants that cheating would be effectively punished. Islamic rulers often created privileges for the mercantile class. These attitudes help explain the initial rapid economic growth of Arab-dominated parts of the world. In contrast, economies in Christian Europe, where merchants were looked down upon, stagnated for most of the Dark and Middle Ages.
As Islam spread to the Atlantic regions to the west and to Pacific regions to the east, so did a culture of locally centralized political, religious, and commercial authority. This system appealed particularly to leaders in regions that bordered on conquered lands. Converting to the new religion enabled them to consolidate military and spiritual power while at the same time increasing economic activity and accumulating wealth. The Islamic empire that arose in the gold-rich Mali region of West Africa, whose military might was matched by its economic prosperity, is an example of this type of interconnection between religion and trade.
In the Islamic system the special interests of mercantile elites were served at the expense of the peasant class, and so eventually it proved to be counterproductive. Maintaining higher agricultural taxes in order to subsidize trade led to stagnant agricultural productivity. During the Middle Ages countries such as England lagged behind the Arab world in per capita income, but they incorporated institutional arrangements that allowed the agricultural sector to prosper. By the end of the eighteenth century England was producing a surplus of food that allowed resources to be redistributed, and the era of industrialization to emerge.
Christianity and Islam fought over Iberia for almost eight centuries (between 711 and 1492 c.e.). After victories in Europe, Spain and Portugal took the war to Southeast Asia. The new battleground was not chosen random-ly—the spice trade in that region was one of the most profitable enterprises of the time. As trade between the West and Southeast Asia expanded and intensified, so too did proselytism. Many people in the region readily abandoned the religious traditions of their forefathers. Because local beliefs linked wealth with spiritual power, the wealthy European and Arab merchants served as examples of the superiority of Christianity and Islam over pagan religions.
During the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries America experienced a religious conversion on a scale not seen since the days of Constantine the Great and Charlemagne. God was as powerful a motive as gold for the colonization of the continent. Jesuits and other religious orders established missions from California to Patagonia, and for more than two centuries the growth of trade and the spread of Christianity went hand in hand. Because the evangelizing efforts of the Roman Catholic Church were supported by the Hapsburg dynasty, priests and merchants pursued their goals in more or less mutually beneficial ways.
The economic prosperity derived from trade with the New World led Spanish emperors to grant the Jesuits special privileges over a vast territory in what is today Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay, and Uruguay. Spain even allowed the establishment of the semiautonomous Guarani society that was based on primitive Christian principles.
Religion has provided powerful justification for some trade practices and against others. Consider the story of Ham, which is included in both the Holy Bible and the Koran. Both Arabs and Western Europeans to justify slavery used a perverse interpretation. On the other hand, biblical teachings also sent many Christians to the frontlines of the fight against the slave trade; indeed, it was religion-inspired efforts that led to the abolition of slavery in the British Empire in 1833 and in the United States in 1865.
The link between religion and trade also provides at least a partial explanation for today's economic superiority of the West. Most pre-Christian peoples worshiped nature, severely limiting the extent to which societies could transform and utilize the environment. Constraints on economic activity were significantly relaxed as the Western world embraced the Judean belief in one God who created nature to serve the needs of human beings. With the processes of centralization of power and responsibility around the see of Rome, institutionalized religion became an obstacle to capitalistic enterprise. As the papacy started to lose its grip on economic life in Europe in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries, commercial communities in the Mediterranean prospered. During the sixteenth century the West experienced a period of religious and political reformation. Christendom began to shift away from the ideal of monastic asceticism and towards the notion that believers could fulfill their calling through participation in worldly activities. The events of this period eventually resulted in the rise of more secular attitudes toward work and investment, and destroyed many of the remaining barriers for the entrepreneurial class.
Did the Protestant Reformation give birth to the so-called "spirit of capitalism?" Max Weber and his followers think that it did. Or was is that once life was no longer dominated by a single religious institution, those already possessed by that spirit were empowered to circumvent some of the traditional constraints? This issue has been hotly debated by social scientists over the last century. One thing is sure, however—religious endorsement of investment and profit seeking, together with technological improvements in the production and transportation of goods, has played a major role in the development of global trade practices.
SEE ALSO Books; Conquistadors; Ethnic Groups, Africans; Ethnic Groups, Gujaratis; Ethnic Groups; Huguenots; Ethnic Groups; Jews.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Alexandrin, Glen, and Zech, Charles E. "Ancient Futures: Papal and Buddhist Economics." International Journal of Social Economics 26, no. 10/11 (1999): 1344–1353.
Bennett, John C.; Bowen, Howard R.; Brown, William A., Jr.; and Oxnam, G. Bromley. Christian Values and Economic Life. New York: Harper and Brothers, 1954.
Essid, Yassine. A Critique of the Origins of Islamic Economic Thought. Boston: Brill Academic, 1995.
Johnston, Carol. "A Christian Critique of Economics." Buddhist–Christian Studies 22 (2002): 17–29.
Price, Betsey. "Economics, Ethics and Religion: Jewish, Christian and Muslim Economic Thought." Economic Journal London 113, no. 485 (February 2003): F206–F207.
Stapleford, John E. Bulls, Bears, and Golden Calves: Applying Christian Ethics in Economics. Downers Grove, IL: Intervarsity Press, 2002.
Stone, Thomas. "Morality as the Enemy of Equality: Law, Economy, and Moral Responsibility in the Early Mormon Church." Journal of Socioeconomics 29, no. 1 (2000): 57–71.
Tawney, R. H. Religion and the Rise of Capitalism. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction, 1998.
Waterman, A. M. C. Revolution, Economics and Religion: Christian Political Economy, 1798–1833. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1991.
Weber, Max. The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism. [1905]. New York: Penguin, 2002.
Alex Tokarev
Graham Lemke
